Michelle Duggar admits she doesn’t know if she’s pregnant again

michelle1
People Magazine has an interview this week with the Duggars, the famous family in Arkansas that stars on a reality show with now their 19 kids. The Duggars have been dealing with so much after their youngest daughter, Josie, was born last September by emergency C-Section at only 25 weeks old and weighing just 1 lb. 6 oz. Little Josie was in the NICU unit in a hospital in Little Rock for four months. She went home briefly in April, only to have to return two days later following a medical crisis. Josie’s youngest sister, Jordyn-Grace Makiya, was also born in December just one year prior.

jimbob
The Duggars are outspoken about the fact that they don’t use birth control, never will, and will let God decide how many children to give them. In their half hour reality show, which airs on TLC once a week, they are always calm and collected to a degree that can seem delusional. The family is devoutly religious and nothing seems to bother them, but they admitted to People that Josie’s premature birth and medical condition were the hardest thing they’ve ever had to deal with, and that they were fighting, crying and praying that she would pull through.

One thing that really stuck out for me in this story was an anecdote by Michelle about how she tried to assert her authority over a medical test for Josie. She almost convinced her husband and the doctors not to allow a scary MRI for the infant, only to back down and eventually give her approval. Michelle also didn’t rule out another pregnancy, of course, and admitted that she’s not sure if she’s pregnant again. Michelle Duggar is a 43 year old grandmother and has 19 children from the age of five months to 22 years.

Here’s some of what the Duggars told People, and I really feel for them after reading what they’ve been through:

While doctors try to determine why Josie, born three months prematurely, is now struggling to digest normally, the couple are just grateful for their littlest girl’s continued survival. We’ve never walked through anything like this,” Michelle says. Agrees Jim Bob: “the first 72 hours in the NICU rock your world. This is like surviving a hurricane…

This has tested our marriage and family relationships. It tests the foundation of your soul. Our prayer is that we stay close,” Jim Bob says. “We have totally felt overwhelmed – we didn’t know if Josie was going to live or die or what kind of problems she would have. It’s tough to accept all these things.” And under these conditions, even the most serene couple can start to clash. “When you are under pressure, you have the tendency to be quick to anger and become self-centered,” Jim Bob admits. “We try to have a loving response instead of a sharp one.”

But it isn’t always easy. The couple find themselves struggling over how to make the right decision for their baby’s well being – and they don’t always see eye to eye. When Josie was scheduled to have an MRI as part of an optional study, Michelle worried the loudness of the machines would cause her baby further stress. Jim Bob thought the test was a good idea in order to see how Josie’s brain was developing – until Michelle woke up in the middle of the night, panicked and convinced the test should not proceed. “Jim Bob and I talked about it,” Michelle says. “He said we should pray about it, and then it would be up to me.” In the end, Michelle allowed the test – but it was halted when Josie became too upset by the entire process – much as Michelle had feared.

[When Josie had to return to the hospital after her vitals dropped] “I was terrified. I was thinking. ‘My baby is going to die. I am losing her now.’ I held her skin-to-skin in the ambulance, trying to warm her,” says Michele. “I was crying out to the Lord for her life because I didn’t know what was going on.”

After a frantic race back to the hospital, Josie has stabilized, growing to an impressive 6 lb. 9 oz. But complex questions remain about her condition. Unable to normally digest her feedings, Josie needs enemas ever six hours and constant staff assistance. Ligaments that should keep her stomach in place are weak or nonexistent; portions of her intestines are similarly mobile. Doctors next plan on a surgery to repair three hernias; they may also try to anchor certain organs in place…

As for whether Jim Bob and Michelle will continue to procreate… the couple say they are ready and willing to have more kids – perhaps sooner rather than later. “I don’t know… it’s possible,” Michelle says simpley, when asked if she might already be pregnant. As Jim Bob explains, he and Michelle remain ready to face any challenge – including the public criticism that could accompany yet another pregnancy: “We trust God with our lives, our children, our future. Let’s pass this test. Let’s have the right response.”

[From People Magazine, May 31, 2010]
josie

In April, we ran a story in which the mother of a premature baby criticized the Duggars for both allowing cameras around fragile Josie and acting so nonchalant about her condition. In terms of how eerily mellow they are, the Duggars believe that God controls everything, and that He makes the decisions for them. A lot of people feel that way, and while I can’t personally relate I admire how the Duggars go through life without looking like a damn thing stresses them out. Whether that’s ignorant or wiser than the rest of us is a matter of perspective I guess.

They should really give it a rest, though, and realize that it’s not healthy for Michelle or any potential offspring if she continues to have children. Even if God is calling the shots, I don’t get the idea that it’s ok to have as many kids as you want, even if that puts people’s lives at risk. It’s probably all in the Bible, right? I never could figure that thing out. Maybe it’s easier when you pick and chose passages to take at face value. At least Josie is hanging in there and we hope that things look up for that little one soon. She certainly has plenty of people who love her and are pulling for her.

michelle2

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

155 Responses to “Michelle Duggar admits she doesn’t know if she’s pregnant again”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Fluffy Kitten Tail says:

    I mean, come on. Enough is enough. These people need to send her uterus into retirement!

    There gets to be a point (like 17 children ago) where this is not normal.

  2. Maritza says:

    Enough is enough, no more babies please! Take care of the ones you have and just be grateful they are all normal. The older she gets the bigger chances of having a baby with Downs syndrome.

    • Deirdre says:

      People with Down Syndrome are some of the most amazing people I’ve ever met. Not to mention the odds go up only slightly. Women in their 20’s with their first pregnancy can have a child with down syndrome.

      • Stella says:

        No one should push their luck in that way for the almighty dollar. Our taxes pay jimboob’s lifelong healthcare deal…the one he got from holding some dumb congressional position or two back in the day. Thanks a lot, Jimbrah and creepy babytalking mom.

  3. Leek says:

    I feel so bad for their kids.

    I have a friend who is a devout Christian and she is one of the best people I know, however, it can be very frustrating to talk to her because she complains about life not being what she wants it to be because God just hasn’t made it happen for her yet. She just doesn’t realize God gave her a brain with individual thoughts to go out in the world and makes things happen for herself. When things go bad it’s God’s fault, when things are great it’s God’s will, when an ugly guy approaches her why did God do that when she’s not in the mood. That’s the catch though, if God sent the ugly guy maybe she’s supposed to give him a chance, but instead she picks and chooses what works for her and pushes all the blame on God.

    I have said enough. I’ll be living life blaming others for my mistakes now. Cheers!

  4. malina says:

    I don’t know what kind of church they belong to, cause actually Catholic Church teaches those about to marry about natural ways of controling birth (which means not to have sex when you’re ovulating). Fallible I know, but as much as every other birth control I guess.
    My point is Catholich Church doesn’t try to convince people they should let God decide about number of children they will have, at least not to this point. It just seems a little fanatic to me, what they are doing. But whatever works…

  5. dre says:

    Whos to say how many is enough and what is normal?
    When did we become God?

    This is a wonderful family, so dont judge!

  6. Dorothy says:

    Yes, it is awful what they are going through, I can’t imagine going through something like that with my children.

    But just the fact that she sould be pregnant again?! What??!! This is so f*cking crazy it kinda makes me sick. Maybe God is working on some other world problems and is not thinking about Jim Bob and Michelle’s sex life, so maybe they can start thinking for themselves.

  7. malina says:

    @ Leek – that’s just a wrong Christian attitude. I don’t think this is what’s being Christian is supposed to be about but people have been altering the original faith for what suits them best ever since and that’s just sad.

  8. crash2GO2 says:

    Josie’s condition sounds dire. 🙁

  9. Jaxx says:

    I understand giving control of your life to God but come on Duggars, He also gave you a brain. Michelle’s body is obviously crying out for a long rest after this last baby. If they don’t believe in birth control can’t they ABSTAIN for a very long while so Michelle can recover completely from the last one? Doesn’t Josie need and deserve all their attention for a very long time rather than ANOTHER new born coming along?

    The thing I fear is that she is going to roll the dice one time too many and leave 19 children without a mother. I guess they would just say that’s God’s will but to me that is just insane.

    I do admire these people, they really practice what they preach and walk the walk all the way. Their children are truly lovely and they are clearly a close and loving family but enough is enough.

  10. lem says:

    i don’t feel sorry for them. i feel sorry for the children, but not the parents. they’re adults, they go to doctors, they are aware of the risks they are taking. they knew that giving birth at age 43 (with baby #19), the chances of a complication of this severity were great and they did it anyhow. i have no sympathy for how hard it has made their life because they did this willfully and knowingly.

  11. lway says:

    That baby is very tiny and very cute but this couple has to invest in condoms or something.

    It’s not normal for people to have 19 children in this day and age.

    @ CB – I think, after like the 5th child, you’ve mastered it. That’s why they don’t look stressed.

  12. YT says:

    I thought having lots of children was more of a political and social thing than a religious thing. More babies equal more soldiers and farm workers. The rich tend to have fewer babies so their wealth will not be divided too much with inheritances. Some people just like having lots of babies. More power to them, but no need to bring God into it.

    I cannot believe she might be pregnant again. What happened to common sense? Maybe God did not give them any.

  13. nj says:

    I am a Roman Catholic. These people make us all look stupid. You can be Catholic and not be a stupid zealot moron churning out kids.
    I think its the height of conceit to believe God “blesses” us with kids anyway. I believe in His miracles, but I do not believe He is personally blessing them (or anyone) with offspring. God does not decide to give babies to drug addicts, young teens, sexual abuse victims, and savage animals. He does not choose to deprive the couple who want a child so badly but cannot conceive. It’s biology. We get all caught up , but the miracle is in the relationship you develop with your child over time. But these people are apparently not interested in doing that, as they shove each kid off on the others. THAT is a sin, in my book. And having another baby while this last one is clinging to life is unconscionable.

  14. Jackson says:

    Is God making them have sex? Keep it zipped once in awhile, dude.

  15. QB says:

    I feel so bad for all of their girls , they are force to be mothers of their other siblings while her mother is pregnant or taking care of the newborn.

    Free the Duggar girls!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    PS: The reason they are not stresse out is because they have an army of baby sitters in the form of their daughters.

  16. Duggars=Disgusting says:

    If Josie dies, God forbid, will they stop? That baby is far from out of the woods and it breaks my heart what she’s facing? How can Michelle not know if she’s pregnant? She’s been pregnant over 20 times (counting the miscarriages) – one would think she’d know by now. These “parents” make me sick. I don’t feel sorry for any of them but the little ones and definitely Josie. And I bet when it comes down to it, Michelle won’t let the surgery happen to repair Josie’s tummy.

  17. Whatever says:

    These people are sickening. This isn’t about accepting children as God sends them. People who do that won’t force wean babies at 5 months old to bring back fertility. It’s more like a sick race to see how many they can have before her uterus falls out in the aisle at the grocery store.

    I agree with the preemie mom who criticized them. Pimping out a sick baby on a TV show is ok but an MRI is not. Wrong, Michelle. I bet cameras and a TV crew are just as stressful for a sick little girl who needs peace and quiet to heal. They are NO different than Jon and Kate, pimping out their kids on TV to fill mom and dad’s bank account. Gross.

  18. LindyLou says:

    You’d think that Mama Duggar would be slapping that peen away after the last kid. Jeez, don’t they think that maybe Josie’s struggle to live is a “sign” that maybe they should take a break?? I don’t know…..just my two cents.

  19. Kitten says:

    Ugh, I am more disturbed by the fact that these old folks are still “doing it”.

  20. bros says:

    these people are ridiculous. I love that they think god decides everything, but really, its the doctors keeping their premee 25 week old baby alive with medical science. If it were up to god, I don’t think they would have 19 children at this point.

    I agree Whatever-wtf? the crew is somehow quieter and less stressful on a sick infant than an MRI? these people ARE gross.

  21. Kelaa Khaa says:

    Jim bob needs a new hair style.

  22. lucy2 says:

    nj, I really like your post.

    It sounds like little Josie is doing better, but still has a lot of health problems. To me, that would be a sign to stop having more babies and focus on her (and the other kids). That premie mother made some excellent observations before.
    It seems like her body barely has a chance to start to recover before the next child is on the way, and as she gets up there in years, it does seem very dangerous, for both mother and child. If you want to believe each child is a blessing from God, great, but then take care of those blessings! And as others have said, God gave you a brain, use it.

    I always still wonder a bit, if the TV cameras and magazines all went away, if they would really continue having more.

  23. Lem says:

    the commenter’s here at CB are hands down, most open commenter’s across the gossip webs.
    But too harsh with her..

    Duggar’s commitment to their beliefs (which btw aren’t my beliefs) is kind of inspiring to me. they really do practice what they preach.

  24. EEE says:

    regardless of what your religous beliefs may be, what they are doing to their children is WRONG. These ‘parents’ cannot possibly provide the love, support and guidence that their other 19 children (or whatever the rediculous number is) DESERVE. what’s even more concerning is that they rely on their children to become assistant caregivers to the new babies, which is not fair! I also find it disgusting that poor Josie’s health struggles are all happening while she has a TV camera in her face. These 2 are disgusting.

  25. Leek says:

    @Malina — I agree you with you as well. I guess my point is this is what happens when religion is put into the wrong hands. Sometimes instead of hurting others they just hurt themselves.

    I saw the Duggars on Say Yes to the Dress and totally thought Jim Bob or whatever his name is is a closet homosexual.

  26. Ellen Smith says:

    Of course they want Josie to get well – so they can pass her off to an older sibling to care for her. Michelle and Jim Bob have never nurtured or cared for their children – they screw, make babies, and hand them off to their older siblings. If NFL football teams had their “passing” record, they’d all win the Super Bowl.

  27. meme says:

    these people are fucking insane and i feel sorry for their children.

  28. a_elise says:

    They are NOT catholic! They are members of a movement called “quiver” which accepts as many children as god will give them. Although Catholics know a lot about “natural family planning” they do not believe that the most amount of children possible is always the best decision. And if you use NFP correctly, (as in, you must take your temperature…down there, daily, test your vaginal fluids with your finger, nasty stuff I would really rather not do when a pill does the same thing…) it still is very good. There are only a couple of days in a woman’s cycle when she can get pregnant. Meaning, JB and Michelle must be doing it a.) carefully planned or b.) all the time. *shudder*

    anyways, this “quiver” business is ridiculous. it should be illegal.

  29. Samantha says:

    Michelle was worried about the noise from an MRI machine?? Really?

    Mind boggling. She brought that fragile baby home to a house full of noisy out of control kids and she’s worried about an MRI machine stressing Josie.

    I tell you, these people are nuts.

  30. irishserra says:

    @CB: Perhaps the lack of stress is due to all of the sex. ;o)

  31. Scarlet Vixen says:

    Wow, I agree so completely with so much of what’s already been said that I don’t know if I can contribute anything. Except maybe…JIM BOB–LEAVE THE POOR WOMAN ALONE!

    I come from a religious family, and believe that God does have a hand in our lives. But I also believe he gave us free will. I also kinda understand the Duggars’ belief that “God will tell them when they should stop.” But maybe they’re just not listening very well! I think that perhaps the difficulties Michelle had in her pregnancy with Josie, and the sad health struggles baby Josie are now facing are clear ‘signs’ that Michelle’s body is wearing out and they need to stop having children and take care of the ones they already have. But that’s just me. Hasn’t anyone ever told these two that just because you CAN doesn’t always mean you SHOULD?

  32. Kelaa Khaa says:

    Leek, this idea has crossed my mind as well and I kind of wonder if he had so many kids to prove that he isn’t.

  33. susanne says:

    If the Duggars were going the all natural, let it happen route, god’s will and all that, she wouldn’t be pregnant three months after giving birth…
    She’s obviously weaning the babies very young, and switching to formula to get fertility back. Nursing is “god’s” (I say nature’s) way of letting a baby get what it needs and giving mama’s body time to recover before another pregnancy.
    I think they’re whacked.

  34. Toby says:

    Her uterus has probably just committed suicide.

    Does anyone have any concept of the environmental footprint uncontrolled reproduction like this has? Good God, woman, the children you are having now have dreadful health problems and require enourmous resources to bring to just normal health. Bish please! You are just being selfish now

  35. Susan says:

    I am a Christian and I have talked with other Christian women about this “quiver” thing. Most think it’s wonderful. I on the other hand think it’s gross. It’s wierd to me. Like someone else said – they are either having sex like every day (ewwww) or they are “planning” their sex around Michelle’s cycle to get pg.

    I will say – I have watched the show and Michelle comes across surprisingly down to earth and smart. Also, they taped one of her last ob visits and her dr said that MOST mothers who have multiple births like this back to back – have health problems, their bladder drops, etc. She said Michelle showed NONE of that. Almost seemed like there was some “divine intervention” going on. I mean I’ve had two kids and I’m 42 – my body changed bigtime after my 2nd. Michelle just seems to be a baby machine.

    I do agree they need to just ABSTAIN. Atleast until their last baby gets better. Honestly – I would not even want to have sex if my child was that sick, in the hospital, etc. I wouldn’t be in the mood whatsoever. So, yeah, that is kinda creepy.

    I do admire their “blind faith”. Even though it does make them appear delusional. That is the type of faith God wants us to have. I have not mastered that for sure – I worry about everything.

    If you watch the show you will see their kids live a VERY sheltered life. All home schooled, no secular music, etc. I don’t think they watch tv either. Somebody made a joke about how they were doing this show but didn’t watch tv. They said they do the show to glorify God — and they do talk about their faith.

  36. alysan says:

    This piece was so well written. Thank you for not taking jabs at these people OR painting them as saints. Either would have been easy.

  37. Cowbelle says:

    Scarlet Vixen = “…just because you CAN doesn’t always mean you SHOULD?”

    VERY true. I’ve BTDT – I miscarried twice but thank God went on to have a healthy baby. My dr told me I could try for another one because I obviously could carry to term. I told my dr that exact thing – just because I can doesn’t mean I should.

  38. filthycute says:

    God doesn’t tell her to keep opening her damn legs. Give it a rest, you old wh*re!

  39. Kolby says:

    It would be one thing if they really were just letting nature take its course, but they’re not. They start actively trying to conceive another baby once their most recently born child reaches a certain age – I think it’s six months. So, they aren’t actually leaving anything in God’s hands. They’re doing their damndest to have as many kids as possible before the Menopause Fairy pays Michelle a visit.

  40. Taya says:

    It does not matter if Michelle is pregnant again or not. She will just pawn off her sick preemie to one of the older girls anyway. This woman may have the babies, but she is in no way their mother. Michelle’s older daughters are the true moms of that house.

  41. Jennifer says:

    Kitten: you’re grossed out by people in their *40s* having sex????? Guess what? People much older than that have sex! Sheesh. 40 isn’t dead, you’ll find that out someday if you’re lucky.

    But the Duggars? They’re sick for having all these babies. And yes it is intentional and not just oh la la la whatever God wants, we don’t do anything different.

    And by the way, she ALWAYS knows if she’s pregnant or not, so her “I don’t know” answer can be safely translated to “yes, we just haven’t announced it yet.” They announce their pregnancies on Good Morning America, not to People magazine.

  42. tar says:

    I am sorry for what they are going through. However the irony of their hypocracy is not lost on me.

    They say they don’t use birth control because they want to leave it in the hands of God whether or not they have more children.

    Yet they accept the extraordinary measures taken to keep this child alive. A child, who without modern medical intervention, would not have survived. Isn’t that taking it out of God’s hands then?

    You can’t have it both ways people.

  43. Raven says:

    A normal 45 year old woman would have difficulty becoming pregnant now. But it sounds like they spend every possible minute having sex while dumping the other household responsibilities on the older children, mostly the girls. Maybe they could back off a bit and take care of the family they have.

  44. me says:

    true some women have a hard time conceiving and it definitely can be considered a miracle when it happens. but when a healthy woman conceives, it’s not really a “miracle”. it’s the body doing what the body was made to do, imo.

    nj said it best with “the miracle is in the relationship you develop with your child over time.” as a mother of the most wonderful boy on the face of the planet, iawtc!!!

    and for the love/safety/sanity of the rest of the children already here (and the wife who has to conceive), keep it in your pants man! give it a rest. ABSTAIN!!!

  45. Bella says:

    Let just call it for what it is, Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar are nothing more then sex addicts. They are too irresponsible and ignorant to use contraception but too hypocritical to stop having sex like two cats in heat so it results to multiple conceptions. Also, as some of the other posters already mentioned, the reason they don’t look tired from raising 19 kids is because the are not the ones that take care of them, the children basically raise one another while mom and dad are humping like rabbits in the bedroom.

    I am not religious what-so-ever and I do not belive in God but even I am offended that they keep using their religion to justify their uncontrollable need for sex.

  46. Ashley says:

    The baby being this sick, in my opinion, is God’s way of saying stop it! Unless God strikes her barren she wll not stop, and it is so so sad. I feel bad for the little one who will no doubt have medical problems her entire life, I feel sorry for the elder ones who have to buddy up with the younger ones and therefore have missed out on their own childhood. I feel sorry for those girls who are being trained to be housewives and nothing more, and I hate that they dismiss evolution as if science is all one big lie.
    Jesus Christ, I bet if they saw a dinasaur bone and the scientific data to back up the age on it they’d go into seizures.
    The fact that TLC glamorizes this family and gives them a show only feeds the monster that is the Duggar family, and it is out of control and needs to stop.
    Just my opinion.

  47. WTF?!? says:

    What, God frowns on home pregnancy tests, too?
    These people are disgusting, and anyone who believes that they are not receiving public assistance and charity to fund their twisted pastime is daft.
    If she is pregnant, the doc should remove all her lady parts when he delivers her next ego-booster.

  48. Keen says:

    yes they are part of the “Quiverfull” movement, but another big reason they came to that decision what that after they had their first child, she had a miscarriage and her doctor told her it was b/c she was on the Pill when they conceived. She truly believes that it is her fault that that baby died and now does not use any birth control so that if she were to have another miscarriage she would just have to give it up to God and assume it was his will, not something she had done.

    I know a lot of people don’t “get” them and while that would definitely not be my choice, parents often get extreme when it comes to their children. Regardless of what you think about the whole autism/no vaccine movement, most people can acknowledge that it is a pretty extreme view, but when you’re a parent and you’re doing what you think is best for your kids and your family, then that’s what you do.

  49. Susan says:

    Alot of people have criticized them for making the older girls raise the younger children/newborns. But, in all honesty…..they all seem very happy. Maybe it’s an act for the cameras – but the older girls seem truly laid back and happy.

  50. M says:

    Well I feel like, on the one hand they are good parents who can physically and mentally control all their kids. Not too mention their kids dont run amok and cause chaos. However, I don’t know why they would want to risk having another baby so soon after Josie’s condition. What if the same thing happens again?

  51. Karen says:

    These people really disgust me, I don’t care what they think their god wants them to do. They should start actually being parents and raising their children instead of neurotically obsessing over making more; it makes me wonder if they have some sort of mental illness.

  52. FIONA says:

    these people disgust me.

  53. sara says:

    They claim to be debt-free and financially secure (thanks to whopping fees paid for their show), so are they paying for all this medical care themselves? Allowing an insurance company to pick up the tab would conflict with their God-Will-Provide schtick.

    I estimate the medical care for this kid who should never have been born and will endure a lifetime of serious care and problems is around $400,000 to $600,000 so far. Who’s paying for it?

  54. Susan says:

    @M. — I agree. If I had a child literally on death’s door in the hospital – I would NOT be having (unprotected) sex and thus risking doing that to another little baby. I don’t get that. Just say no Michelle!

  55. mmf says:

    What the hell are they thinking?
    Keep in you pants man.
    That man would’ve been cut off after about five kids.
    How can they possibly give attention to all the children?
    They can’t.
    Big counseling bills are in their future for the children who are all messed up.

  56. Susan says:

    Found this on their website………As a family project the Duggars built a 7000 sq. ft. home debt free! Both Jim Bob and Michelle are licensed real estate agents.They often host and facilitate the Jim Sammon’s Financial Freedom Seminar. Jim Bob served in the Arkansas House of Representatives from 1999 to 2003 and was a candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2002.

  57. Bella Mama says:

    i would never choose their lifestyle. ever.

    that said, i can’t hate on them. they seem to be good people, practice what they preach, arent on welfare and asking for handouts. the children seem happy and loved.

    so, yeah, wouldnt live it, but absolutely dont fault them for it.

  58. Gia says:

    Personally, I think old Jim Bob is slipping Michelle happy pills. That’s why she looks so laid back. Btw, religion is for people who don’t want to think or make decisions for themselves. If things don’t work out, blame it on God.

  59. GatsbyGal says:

    I think he should let his wife have some fucking rest. Keep the snake in his tank, so to speak. Just because she’s not pregnant doesn’t mean they have to bump uglies. Then again, don’t they not believe in medicine? Does that mean she can’t take even advil for period cramps? Hell, I’d be pregnant all the time too in that case.

  60. anon says:

    i wanted to go on about too many babies, how can they pay them proper attention.. but i’ll let the other comments stand. Reading this was very hard since we had a scare with our newborn (thankfully just a scare and screw up on test results!) but for 3 days we had no answers and were afraid she’d not come home with us. I TOTALLY empathize and this changes my view of them.. goes to show walk a mile adage really means something.
    They seem like kind people which is so hard to find nowadays. So I will shut up about my gripes on birth control.. they aren’t on the dole and the kids seem happy and cared for.

    But the premature birth could well be b/c of her AGE! it is a factor in older moms. You;d think she’d see this experience as so hellish she’d think twice about another one… sigh

  61. TG says:

    I agree with about everyone on here. How can they even be having sex when they are going thru something like this? Don’t they spend their hours thinking and worrying and taking care of their other “precious” children? I guess since they don’t do a darn thing or worry about Josie they can have all the sec they want.

    Wish people would boycott TLC and that stupid show and all the other stupid family shows they have on there. I don’t watch TLC for that reason.

  62. Iggles says:

    @ Bella Mama:
    that said, i can’t hate on them. they seem to be good people, practice what they preach, arent on welfare and asking for handouts. the children seem happy and loved.

    Jim Bob served 1 term as a state senator. As a result he and his entire family get FREE health care for life.

    Who’s paying for their daughter’s $500,000+ hospital bills. The taxpayers of Arkansas.

    How is that ANY DIFFERENT then welfare??

  63. girl says:

    I can understand why she might not know she is pregnant. It is called lactation amenorhea (sp?).

    I do believe she is pumping for Josie and for some women, that is enough to delay a return of fertility. (It isn’t always though and for those who use it as a method to avoid pregnance, there are pretty strict guildlines for it). Some women will return to fertility much sooner than others despite nursing so it has much to do with how baby receives their nutrition/comfort nursing (pacifier vs. non-nutritive sucking at the breast) etc.

    I never ovulated sooner than 8 months or so following child birth. I also ecologically breastfeed (it is an actual term, it means no pacifiers, no supplimental bottles, etc.)

    As for her family size, I don’t see why people are so up in arms about it. Is there some solid evidence that they are hurting anyone?

    This is just as bad as conservatives bashing same sex parents of perfectly happy children. The logic is the same.

  64. Chico says:

    Good point Iggles. And, Arkansas is one of the poorest states in the nation. That pisses me off. As a resident of California, we were paying for Octomom’s procreation catastrophe. I just think there should be a cap here. After the 4th kid, they should have to pay for everything else. There’s no way taxpayers should be on the hook for someone’s irresponsible decicion to singlehandly overpopulate the planet.

  65. Taya says:

    girl:
    ”As for her family size, I don’t see why people are so up in arms about it. Is there some solid evidence that they are hurting anyone?”

    It is not the family size that people do not like, it is the fact that she pawns off her babies to her older daughters and also that she is probably pregnant again even though she has a very sick preemie to take care of. Let’s be honest people, the older girls are gonna end up taking care of Mama Duggars preemie while she is pumping Pa Duggar for more babies.If she wants a big family fine, but do not have your older girls raise it for you.

  66. Susan says:

    Btw, religion is for people who don’t want to think or make decisions for themselves

    Whoa – that’s a loaded statement right there. Christians think and make decisions every day (I know – I am one) – we just also CHOOSE to believe in God/Christ. Yes, when things don’t go our way – we sometimes question God. But, that’s where faith comes in. It’s not easy – but it also doesn’t mean we’re walking around with blinders on.

  67. Naye in VA says:

    @ iggles

    Um insurance??

    IDK anybody who had a baby with the privelege of the taxpayers money unless they had medicaid and i dont believe they have medicaid. Any they must be paying a GRIP for insuracne with 19 kids to bet they have a lot of coverage as well

    also, everybody says she pawns the kids off to the other girls, so what does that mean she sits on her but and naps all day? she has nothing really to do with the raising of her kids because her other kids help out? what about all the celebs who have one kid and have a ful-time nanny, even when they are at home.

    are the other girls being forced to help? are they not allowed any private time or outside time? or have they just been given responsiblities like most other teenagers?

  68. Bopa says:

    Personally I think this whole situation is based solely on Jim Bob’s choices in life. I don’t think she has a choice in anything including how many things pass out of her uterus. I remember watching the wedding dress show that the Duggars went on and remembered how forceful Jim Bob was about deciding what type of dress she could wear. Even to the point of dictating that no one could be in the dressing room with her while she was changing clothes. As if the ladies that work there will be lusting over her. I think he’s a controlling person. Ultimately she could chose to get a divorce but I don’t see that happening.

  69. Hautie says:

    The odd thing is that neither one of their (Michelle/Jim Bob) families are involved in their “quiver” thing.

    I saw one of the shows were Michelle’s sister came for a visit. She made it clear that no one in their immediate family understood why Michelle kept turning out babies.

    Then there was Jim Bob’s father, on his death bed, telling Jim Bob to stop with all the babies. That it was time to let Michelle have a break. At least for her health. Jim Bob completely blew the advice off.

    I believe Michelle had the baby early cause she had became diabetic during the pregnancy. (I can’t think of the correct medical term for it) She was diagnose, put on bed rest and suddenly had the baby early.

    What I have wonder about most… is how exactly are the girls in that family suppose to find a spouse.

    When they are not allowed out of the house to socialize.

    Even going to Church, is in their own home. Jim Bob doesn’t even belong to a local Church in town. He does his own preaching to the family. In their house.

    Those poor girls are going to end up in arranged marriages to 50 year olds.

  70. MommaQ says:

    They are not Catholic they are Bible believing Christians. Quiverfull minded persons attend many different churches, with the most common being Baptist. It is not a religion, it is a group of persons trying to follow the Bible to the best of their ability each and every day.

  71. Susan says:

    I don’t see him as controlling. He comes across as very nice on the show too. They are believable.

    He does control his children’s environment (as any good parent should try to do). They don’t watch tv (which lets face it – there is a LOT of crap on tv these days – nothing like I Love Lucy or the Andy Griffith Show for sure-negative news every day), no secular music (again – a LOT of crap out there – I have a 12 year old daughter and cringe at some of the songs she likes), all home schooled (nothing wrong with that imho).

    He’s just trying to live a Godly life and raise Godly children. Liberal America thinks Christians are ignorant and backwards. But, I don’t see any of his teenagers doing dope or ending up pg. His oldest got married (probably BOTH virgins and they probably waited until their wedding night) and they seem happy too.

    Maybe we’re all just jealous?

  72. original kate says:

    i don’t want to hear any more about this woman’s god-fearing vagina, or their icky sex life, or the christian army they call their children.

  73. gen says:

    This family (the parents) make me sick.
    I’m entitled to my opinion.

  74. Jeri says:

    As respects their sex life, obviously a little restraint is called for. That is just common sense, I believe God and us humble beings can agree on that.

    Are their children prepared by them to spend all their days having sex & children once married. (I know one or or more are married already.)

    They seem like cult members that drank the kool-aide.

  75. GatsbyGal says:

    @Susan – I’m not jealous of their sheltered, ignorant life.

  76. Jo 'Mama' Besser says:

    What ‘sign’ are they looking for? Clearly having their last baby almost die wasn’t enough, so are they holding out for having 26 motherless kids, or are they waiting for the unthinkable to happen to signal to them that they should’ve stopped at the last one. I don’t mean to sound cruel, but it looks as if we’re far beyond the point where ‘it’s not hurting anybody’. Somebody needs a real advocate, and some should never be in short supply of free kicks in the crotch at bedtime.

  77. Ursaline says:

    If 43 is too old for sex, then Madonna must have one foot in the grave. She’d probably consider them “fightin’ words”.

  78. Kim says:

    Get spayed you selfish piece of crap!!! They are mental. Their poor kids/ built in babysitters.

  79. Kim says:

    He is a moron with no self esteem and thinks impregnating his wife (with no brain of her own) multiple times makes him masculine. No God favors a man and woman who bear children just for the sake of bearing them. If they love children so much why arent they adopting? They are selfish – pure and simple.

  80. sarts says:

    get her spayed
    get him neutered

  81. Kim says:

    The funniestthing is i think the Duggars think they are the worlds best parents when in fact they are the WORST! The parents pawns off the younger siblings on the older ones to be fed, bathed, etc etc. Weve seen it on the show and the older kids have expressed wishing they could do things like other kids and not be raising babies! These parents are abusive in a sense of taking away their kids childhoods by making them raise the younger siblings. They claim oh we dont make them -they like to do it. BS and everyone knows it. Weve heard it straight form the kids mouths for goodness sake. Why social services hasnt stepped in on this family for abuse i have no idea. YOu dont have to be beaten to be abused. Parents forcing older kids to raise younger kids against their will is emotionally abusive. These parents are scum! Raising all these babies they chose to have is their job not their other kids job.

  82. Bonfire Beach says:

    I want to know when they find time to have sex all the time. I only have one kid and work full time and I don’t have enough time for sex!

  83. Lukie says:

    It is her “clown car” uterus. She can do with it what she wants.

    With that said…

    If I had a tribe of children and the last one was still kind of touch and go, I would make it a point NOT to get pregnant for a while. This baby is going to need a lot of hands on attention and IMHO, another baby would just be a distraction….

  84. Anastasia says:

    There’s no way they can have a close relationship with every one of those kids and spend the amount of time with them that they’d have to to build that close relationship.

    It’s not a family, it’s a breeding machine.

    They even follow this rule that they must be abstinent x number of days after a boy is born and x number of days after a girl is born (it’s a longer period of time after a boy).

    That number of days has come and gone for this last baby. There are blogs with women who are obsessed with this couple, especially with Michelle, and they actually posted on that 40th day that she and Jim Bob could start having sex again and that there would be a pregnancy announcement at any time.

    I think it’s kinda weird and hypocritical that they are so big on “modesty” when it comes to cleavage or words that are said, etc, but the world knows all about this couple’s sex life. And Michelle herself said her daughters “watch her cycle like hawks” so her daughters know exactly when she’s ovulating, when her period is due, etc.

    That’s just WEIRD and obsessive, y’all! There’s seriously something wrong with this family. Even the biggest live and let live religious types don’t have this many damn kids.

    And yeah, if they believe in signs from God, Josie should have been a sign that God is saying “hey cut it out.”

  85. TG says:

    @Lem – I didn’t catch your comment the first time. I hope you are joking. With your reasoning one could say they admire the Taliban for discrimminating against women and trying to repress them – at least they are following their beliefs.

  86. juliana says:

    I would have much more respect for this couple if they had adopted or fostered some of 19 these children.

    And the Duggars belong to the Quiverfull movement?
    I believe that is the same religion that Rusty and Andrea Yates were involved in, and we know how that turned out.

  87. TG says:

    @Anastasia – WTF? Her kids know when she is ovulating? Is that true? Disgusting to say the least.

    People are defending the work these kids do as responsibility but it is slavery and not right. There is a big difference in giving a child chores and pawning your offspring off on them. I was raised in a large family 11 kids and we were raised in a crazy religion that created all kinds of stress. My parents made us do all the chores and they had more animals than they could afford or that allowed time for us to care for them properly and it was devastating on to me not to have that freedom. I still struggle with it today to a certain extent. Having that kind of responsibility of managing the life of another can be too much for a child, esp. when the parents should be managing it themselves and having the kids help out here and there but not restricting their freedom.

  88. TaylorB says:

    I personally think that she is making a reproductive CHOICE, and women have that right in ALL directions (be it adoption, abortion, or birthing a baseball team) to do so.

    Would I make the same choice? HELL NO!

  89. Trillion says:

    All kinds of people do all kinds of crazy things, believing it’s “God’s Will”. It doesn’t really mean anything, does it.

  90. Whatever says:

    I believe that is the same religion that Rusty and Andrea Yates were involved in, and we know how that turned out.

    Funny you should mention this. Jim Bob really reminds me of Rusty, same look and same blank expression. Also, both did the church at home thing. Weird.

  91. Jackie says:

    I wonder if the baby was born premature because of the something the hospital did to Michelle when she had to go there for some emergency problem she had. It was a gallbladder or something. It seems too coincidental that she had that baby prematurely within a few days after she had that problem. The hospital/doctor probably did something to her that caused it to happen, but they probably gave them a big chunk of money not to tell anyone.

    As far as having all the kids; its their business if they want to have them. I don’t even have any kids and I’m not religious either, but families like theirs are rare nowadays, and as long as they are taken care of its nobody’s business but their own. They do support them no matter if everyone agrees with how they do it or not.

  92. Robin says:

    THIS IS CRAZY!!!! Why doesn’t child protective services step in and have this woman FIXED LIKE A STRAY CAT!!!!! As a mother of a preemie myself HOW can you possibly think of having another baby when you still have a sick one that needs you in the NICU!!!!! Horrible people. Her older daughters are the real parents in this situation, NOT MICHELLE AND JIM BOB

  93. Ruffian9 says:

    Susan: We’re JEALOUS??? Um, no. Are you serious? There nothing in your statement that reflects anything I would want for myself or my children.

    Also, Duggars, I believe that God is in favor of abstinence.

  94. Ana says:

    Maybe they should ease up on sex until the baby gets better.

  95. MissyA says:

    Very well written article, CB.

  96. Samantha says:

    I kind of think that’s the point. It isn’t normal, but they are not going for normal. They are going to Godly, which is different according to how each individual interprets it.

    The Bible does say that those who follow God should be in the world, but not of the world. Some take that to mean that Christians should stand out and be different, so maybe that’s what they are going for.

  97. Samantha says:

    Robin:

    Child Protective Services????? Seriously??? They have enough to do dealing with parents who are ACTUALLY NEGLECTFUL OR ABUSIVE!!! These children are very well cared for, and seem to be happy with their lives. Who are we to say that it isn’t right just because there are so many? They have plenty of space and enough food to go around. The kids are always clean and well-groomed. There is no reason CPS would ever be interested in this family!

  98. Granger says:

    Sorry, Susan, but I can’t even imagine being jealous of this family. I wasn’t raised in a home that forbade me from watching t.v., listening to music, dancing, or having friends outside the church, and I turned out just fine, thank you.

    Because I had what the Duggar kids don’t — parents who allowed me the freedom to be the person I wanted to be, the knowledge to experience life responsibly, and the confidence to go out and take control of my own future. Those kids are so controlled and micro-managed, they don’t even know what life is! And I wouldn’t wish that kind of existence on anyone.

  99. daisyfly says:

    Yes, Michelle Duggar is making a choice, albeit a choice she feel she HAS to make due to her faith, and I will fight to the end to ensure that she always has that right.

    However, what about the rights of her children? The ones already here? Don’t they deserve to be kids and not built in help? They didn’t ask their mother to have 20 kids; they didn’t ask to be born period. When Josie finally comes home, she’s going to need constant care, and that care isn’t going to come at the hands of her mother. It’s going to come at the hands of her sisters. It’s subjugating these girls to a subservient life that demeans them and devalues them as girls, as people, as children.

  100. Carol says:

    Previous Quote: And if you use NFP correctly, (as in, you must take your temperature…down there, daily, test your vaginal fluids with your finger, nasty stuff I would really rather not do when a pill does the same thing…)

    I’ve been practicing NFP for years, and this information is not correct.

  101. L says:

    @Susan There’s a strong difference from not allowing your children to watch television/songs that you think are crap, and having a full out BAN of all of it. No TV at all. No non-christian music at ALL. They wouldn’t be able to watch I love lucy or andy griffin.

    And please don’t get me started on the lackluster ‘education’ these kids get. How 2 parents who never went to college can provide good homeschooling for kids in K-12 in one room is beyond me. Never mind the fact that when you watch the show they have their schedule set up so they never wake up before noon. I’ll take my solid education over that crap any day.

    Being godly and raising good christian children isn’t about sticking your head in the sand and shutting out the world. At that point, you should just join a cultish compound and don’t bother going out in public.

  102. MsTriste says:

    She may not know if she’s pregnant because she may be perimenopausal now, one of the first signs of which is irregular periods.

  103. mtngirl says:

    Funny stuff, I guess after spending the last 22 plus years being pregnant and/or getting ready for the next one Mrs. Duggar would have no clue if she is pregnant or not. When her uterus drops out, tears through the wall, and scoots away very quickly she will know. In the meantime she’s got lots of children having children, they could populate their own country, err, I mean planet.

  104. asiont says:

    this is sick

  105. Aspie says:

    I am a big fan of the show and was very supportive of this family but now it’s disappointing to see how they’re handling everything in regards to poor little Josie. They really need to abstain from sex until Josie gets better. They do not need to bring another child into this world right now because Josie really needs them. I also now feel bad for their daughters because they don’t seem to get out and socialize much and instead are stuck babysitting so much for their siblings. It’s not fair to place such a heavy babysitting burden upon them. I hope Jim Bob and Michelle can ease up a bit and let their girls get out and socialize more as well as realize that it’s time to slow down on procreating and focus on Josie more instead.

  106. paranel says:

    These people make me sick. Is there anything they won’t do for fame ? They need to be put away. How are they different than Octo mom?

  107. PowerZoo says:

    Please…….these two people reproduce like rabbits…when our first child was born he was very ill and while he was in and out of the hospital for the first year of his life WE DID NOT REPRODUCE, WE DID NOT USE BIRTH CONTROL, but we did have the COMMON SENSE to know that our strength and time needed to go towards helping our child who was ILL. GOD also gives you a brain and the wisdom to know when to KEEP YOUR LEGS CLOSED!

  108. a_elise says:

    @carol: I didn’t mean “a pill does the same thing” in the literal sense because I know the pill changes your hormones. I was referring to both methods similar intention of preventing pregnancy.

    if you were referring to the NFP method, or if anyone else is confused:

    http://familydoctor.org/online/famdocen/home/women/contraceptive/126.html

  109. faye says:

    Jesus. I guess God doesnt want women to say “no” every once in awhile to sex? How fucking sad.

  110. Jamie says:

    I will say, I live in North west Arkansas. I’ve seen the family around town, And I drive by Josh’s car-lot weekly. North west Arkansas is VERY religious, And everyone is VERY laid-back and mellow. Also, here, It is very normal for mothers in their 20’s to have 5 children. The duggars are not that un-usual.

  111. original kate says:

    @robin –

    to suggest that CPS should step in and “fix michelle like a stray cat” is the most ridiculous comment on this thread. she has a right to her own body, and the government has no right forcing any woman to be sterilized. and also? CPS has to deal with children who are actually abused. you know, molested, starved, beaten or worse. i think the duggars are creepy as hell and they need to stop breeding like rabbits but i don’t think their children are abused.

  112. Gabby says:

    What does the husband do for a living? Beside the obvious. How do they pay for their food? utilities? Do they own their own business? Just wondering.

  113. ViktoryGin says:

    The one thing that always irks me about Christianity, and by extension most patriarchal organized relgions, is that they seem to demand your complacency and that you evacuate your ability to think and discriminate. Not because the ego and the mind is an obstruction to ascension as postulatd by the Buddhists (matriarchal), but because there is this implicit, tacit inclincation to try to disempower their followers. I beieve that one has to trust in the natural process of things as we humans are not omniscent, but to give up the power to make sense of your surroundings and the ability to reason is irresponsible and daft.

    @ Kolby

    “It would be one thing if they really were just letting nature take its course, but they’re not. They start actively trying to conceive another baby once their most recently born child reaches a certain age – I think it’s six months. So, they aren’t actually leaving anything in God’s hands.”

    I completely echo your sentiment. There is obviously some biological manipulation going on here. That’s fine, but they need to stop plugging God as if He’s solely responsible.

  114. Melissa says:

    common they are both in it for the money…she wants to hit it for baby number 20. But seriously religious or not. She should start taking care of the children they have and not let the older children do it for them. She has a premature baby and lots of other toddlers. i know with two im always want to show my love to both of them equally, how the heck does she do it with 19. I find it a little ridiculous!!!

  115. John says:

    Am I the only person reminded of Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life when I see the Duggars? At least she can’t keep having kids indefinitely, menopause approaches.

  116. ruth says:

    Michelle Duggar could be a sex therapist.

  117. Lynda says:

    zi don’t know how a couple could have anything other than mechanical sex (vs. intimacy) when dealing with a very ill child, age, stress of every day life, etc., etc. Can’t her husband hold it back a little? Or is he “told” he HAS to have sex by his God? Where is his compassion for his wife? Michelle impresses me that she couldn’t say sh@t if she had a mouthful.

  118. girl says:

    @Momma Q “They are not Catholic they are Bible believing Christians.”

    Are you implying that Catholics aren’t Christians? Because you are quite wrong.

    I forget who mentioned it but there are several different methods of NFP. Marquette, STM, Creighton Model, etc.

    It really find it funny that people are so judgemental of this family but when there is a family that is unconventional in a more liberal way, they would fight tooth and nail to tell conservatives how wrong they are and say they are being too judgemental.

  119. Jag says:

    Agreed, they could definitely abstain from sex for a while, and that’s not invasive birth control. Nowhere in the Bible does it say they have to have sex all the time, or if it does, I missed that part. lol

    It sounds like Josie has some sort of rare condition that the doctors haven’t figured out yet. They need to be looking at episodes of Medical Mysteries and the like, or better yet, get that baby an excellent rheumatologist to examine her. It sounds genetic, possibly enzyme?, but I can’t remember the names of anything that it would be close to. Definitely in a similar vein of Marfan’s with loose joints and tendons, but involving other parts of the body.

  120. Mairead says:

    As if God has nothing better to do than micromanage this eejit’s uterus!

  121. Get your own life and stop sniffing Michelle's uterus says:

    You know what amazes me? That there are people commenting on this post who would fight tooth and nail for a woman’s “right to choose” yet when Michelle and Bob CHOOSE to have this many children, the very same people have a problem with it. Is it because she chooses not to kill her children that bothers you or is it because her life doesn’t reflect yours? I am really curious since you all seem to think you know what is the right number of children to have? Someone please let me in on that secret too. What is the right number of children?

  122. crash2GO2 says:

    Go #121. Except for your handle, your post is great.

    @ViktoryGin: Who ever said Christians have given up the ability to think critically? Have you ever read any C.S. Lewis?

    To be fair: Can you point me in the direction of any astrologists that are true critical thinkers?

  123. Whiskey says:

    This conversation ended two days ago, so I am a little late here, but I think its weird that everyone defends/supports the Duggars but loathe and condemn that Octomom person. Its the same thing.

  124. emmajulie says:

    she might be pregnant AGAIN???WTF??? she is very, very, very, very disturbed. josie was born ONE YEAR after the last one. by mother nature and her brilliance, if a woman is breastfeeding, she CANNOT get pregnant within the next year. want to know why? do you? because before baby formula was around and we were cavemen/women, a woman would not be able to care for baby after baby (not considering multiple births here which in the past were typically twins….maybe triplets…no IVF back then..mulitple births were very rare) that were too close in age. but by the time the child is a little over two years old, that child can walk, feed itself (basically), might be potty trained (debatable). so if a woman is breastfeeding for about a year, her body will get back in fertile mode after that and then nine months later after that year of breastfeeding, she could have another baby so they’re two years apart. and the two year old is a little self sufficient so the mother can now concentrate on the newborn (and run after the two year old). michelle is OBVIOUSLY weening the babies off very soon (if she even breastfeeds at all) and is purposefully getting pregnant again. stop having sex with jimbob right after your baby is born! it’s not healthy for her own body or the new fetus. and she’s 43! her body is a wreck. the reason josie has been born with so many issues and was a premie is because michelle’s body CANNOT do it anymore. her body is done with childbearing. she is actually messing with mother nature and mother nature is going to kick her ass. next time, i wonder if a pregnancy won’t kill or hurt michelle. they are playing with fire. literally.

  125. mitz says:

    I read all the comments on here but no one seems to get that Michelle might be suffering from severe PTSD from that miscarriage. I don’t think its drugs, I’ve acually counselled many clients with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, which makes you catatonic and very dulled in your ability to critically think and analyze. Clearly, her husband doesn’t care about her well-being and they’re too stupid to understand that now because her issues were left untreated, she is passign on secondary PTSD to her kids.

    I also hate to be the bearer of bad news but seeing as I work in social work and have seen kids like these, it appears they are being groomed for sexual abuse.

  126. Mary says:

    I agree with reading a lot of the comments here.It is not fair to the other children to parent their younger sisters and brothers & to do heavy house chores & help cook meals.That is child abuse and Child labor!. Child Labor is another form of child abuse.Refraining children from freedom and enjoying childhood. I feel sorry for the older children that they do not have no freedom to them self. The children are not allowed to leave their home to be with their own friends?.Their friends have to come to their home.That is not fair to the older Duggar kids.I betcha any money that the Duggar kids are not happy kids in real life.They act out on TV but behind the scene’s, the other kids are probably stress!..And what is this family gathering meetings that the kids have to have in the home?.If the husband really loves his wife & really cares about her health,he would get fixed. Michelle could die,(getting pregnant yearly & not giving her body a chance to go back into shape could cause sever health issues or death).Having all these children seems that the parents are looking for attention,(fame and fortune). I mean,talk about having the older kids parenting their younger sisters and brothers. The parents are not giving each child the equal amount of attention.Their are over 100 different written bibles and not proven evidence if the bible is accurate. So I believe both Duggar parents are using religion as of excuse.Its attention they’re striving for and fame and fortune.Its not the children they really care because if they really do,they wouldn’t have so many kids. A couple to show love and affection – not have the older kids parent the younger sisters and brothers. That is child abuse right there & child labor by having them cook – clean constantly and refrain them from freedom outside their home. I am surely not jealous.I’m hurt for the children & disgusted by the parents that they have so many children to use for attention. Shame on you Jim Bob!! Shame on your Michelle!! You are a poor excuse for parents!!

  127. Momof4 says:

    They are some sick people.They need to stop having sex and take care of there kids and stop making the older ones do it.You would think all the problems with Josie would open there eyes.When you watch the show she is always passing them off so she can take care of the baby what about the other younger one they need attention also.You two are a poor parents grow you butts up your are not two teenagers and take care of the ones you have.

  128. kristyt1393 says:

    What ever happened to children are our future? All we know is what we read and what we see. so do we really know what’s going on in the Duggar home. There are so many people out there that are quick to judge without knowing the persons they judge. I’m not saying they are right but look at all they have done for themselves and others. To be honest I don’t know them personal and probably never will but what I can do is see past what other people see. Now can you?

  129. DStadtherr says:

    That entire article is a fabrication. None of that took place. I read the article. This information is complete BS.

  130. Alexia says:

    This is RIDICULOUS. I think TLC needs to stop filming the Duggars. Period. If they stop getting attention, I think they’ll just go into the woodwork and stop having kids.

    What’s going to happen if she IS pregnant again?

    If God does grant them another child, will He take Michelle away from them in return?

    I really hope the Duggar children will branch out and NOT follow in their parents’ footsteps.

  131. Summer says:

    Gosh I hope she’s not with # 20. I hope she talking abour some one eals maybe a friend or Josh and, Anna and not her self. Goodness

  132. Pamela Luckenbach says:

    Oh you missinformed people. There are a lot of people out there intentionally trying to have children,and can’t. There are no medical reasons,and doctors are caonfused by it. Some people go as far as to go to doctors,and get medication for it. Haven’t you noticed that there are more sextuplets being born.
    What about Nadia Suleman? There are worse issues out there. She is not married. Has three sets of twins. She saves so they can implant the rest of the fertilzed eggs. So she gives birth to octuplets.
    This couple is married. The Bible does say to be fruitful,and multiply. It doesn’t put a number on how many.

  133. Grace says:

    Someone said Michelle seems intellegent? I totally disagree, she seems quite ignorant actually. She never says anything important or intellegent if you think about it. Nor does Jim Bob.
    I totally feel sorry for the kids, but you can bet your bootie that half of them will find out there is a “real world” out there and not grow up the way mommy and daddy expect. They will rebel when they find there are teen lives and something called fun! Bet we will see one of them on “I’m Pregnant AND”..
    Truly ashame if she is pregnant again she almost lost poor little Josie. This women is far from intellegent!

  134. Grace says:

    Found this! Thank GOD!

    VIDEO: Michelle Duggar Announces ‘Someone’s Expecting!’VIDEO: Michelle Duggar Announces ‘Someone’s Expecting!’
    ——————————————————————————–
    Posted on Sep 15, 2010 @ 06:15AM print it send it

    http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid16157557001/bctid609569434001
    Michelle Duggar made a bombshell announcement on the latest episode of her show, stunning all 19 of her children as they were gathered together. “Someone’s expecting!” Michelle revealed to the family.

    Watch the video on RadarOnline.com

    The news that Michelle is pregnant with her 20th child would be a surprise to the family, but not something unexpected. She has spoken out on recent episodes of wanting to have another child if “it is God’s plan.”

    “But it’s not us,” she revealed with a big laugh to the family that was quietly standing around her! Michelle announced that Jon Boyle, a production assistant, and his wife were expecting their first child. The family all clapped and cheered, maybe a little relieved that Michelle and Jim Bob weren’t having their 20th child yet.

  135. DH says:

    No one tells you how to run your family so I dont think you should comment on how they should run theirs. If they want to have more kids let them have them. I only have 2 and that is enough for me but like my mother always told me “each to their own”. They provide for their kids and I can tell you they have the most well behaved children. No one is telling you to stop having kids! Some families with 2-3 kids dont have their house under control like they do! I really enjoy watching their show so please keep filming.

  136. leesha says:

    Who cares what this woman does with her vagina. It is her body she has the right to have how many kids she wants. People need a life and stop worrying about the Duggars. Damn and the religious bashing is a shame how dare someone bash someone on their religion. I’m not a saint but i believe in my father God and Jesus Christ.

  137. Jacquie says:

    I think it is interesting that following the show, the “Bringing My Baby Home” show comes on, following “Baby Story”. The couples on these shows struggle with the children that they bring in the world, with perhaps only two or three. I feel bad because it makes them probably feel inadequate as parents. Even though they look so controlled on the show, I just wonder how real it is off the camera’s eye. But, however, the Duggers’ are always going on some family outing. I am just confused on the amount of people in the house, the house is always perfect. My house ALWAYS in place. However, it takes me alot of time and my 3 kids are 19, 20 and the oldest, 23, who is the only one that lives on her own. She has her daughter, which I might add, CAN DO NO WRONG IN EYES, LOL. I have always took pride in the fact that I trained them in such a way to keep the house, as some say, looking like a museum. But is not easy. I don’t believe that their life is as it is portrayed on the show. The older chilren need time “OFF”. I don’t believe it is correct and it is unfair for them. The parents never, that I saw give them thank them for their hard work. I think that its important that a child feels appreciated. So that being said, Michelle and Jim Bob should stop and show the children some love and affection. It isn’t my place to comment on what they should have done. They can’t change that, but they can change what happens in the future. I hope Josie gets better. My heart goes out to her and all the rest of the children.

  138. june says:

    if michele is prenant again before the baby got out of hospital. did her c section heal befor he was there again omg

  139. Helene says:

    Wow! I don’t understand why everyone is so judgmental of this good family. They aren’t breaking any of the ten commandments by having so many children. I am a mother, and I wish that I could spend just one day with Michelle Duggar. She is an inspiration to me. As far as people feeling like the older girls are raising the little ones, they are just learning to become good mothers. The children all seem to be well adjusted, happy, intelligent, and well educated for being home schooled. Mom is obviously doing something right. The fact that they are having sex is what God asks of each Christian couple in the re-affirmation of their marriage covenant. Just because they have a lot of children doesn’t mean that they are having sex all of the time. I believe there is a biblical verse that says “Do not judge, lest you be judged”. I don’t think the Duggars are judgmental of others. They are simply doing what they feel God is asking of them. It could be called selfishness to only have 1 or 2 children, but nobody puts people down for that. And ultimately fertile couples who choose to only have 1 or 2 kids because they don’t want to be strapped financially, could be called selfish. I certainly am not going to pass judgment on anyone for their choice in family size. I just think that the Duggars are an amazing family, who are walking in God’s path, whether they had 1 child, or have 30. They aren’t asking for sympathy from anyone, and aren’t complaining. If all children were raised in the same type of environment as the Duggars, I would guess that our prisons wouldn’t be very full. They are all blessings upon this earth.

  140. GGK says:

    It seems to me that for people who constantly put down Christians calling them intolerant, you people are the least tolerant of all! What does it matter to you how many children they have? Where is your tolerance for these people? Because it is not a lifestyle choice you would make, you harshly judge and condemn them! Hypocrites!

  141. Aerin says:

    I am catholic too, but at the same time to quote my husband “God created rain as well but when it starts raining…he puts on rubbers”

  142. Heather says:

    Michelle was told by her doctor’s after Josie was born that, if she got pregnant again she would most likely deliver prematurely. So prematurely, that the baby would probably not survive.

    Deliberately having babies, knowing this information from the doctor’s; they are making the decision to put a helpless child through alot of pain and suffering if born prematurely. IF the baby is even born at a viable age. Otherwise, they give birth to a baby that cannot survive. A stillborn. That will be on your conscience, Michelle and Jim-Bob. Forever…

    Certainly you two are smart enough to realize that. You have no right to play around with a helpless human life. You would now be playing Russian Roulette, if you conceived again.

  143. Toni says:

    Why is everyone so judgemental on the Duggars. How is what they do affecting you??? They don’t live on welfare and they have no debt. They are raising their children to be reponsible, hard working, respectful, and good christian people. I think a lot of people could take lessons on how to raise children. You may only want 1 or 2 children and they may want to have as many as possible……It has no affect on your life so get on with it!!

  144. karilee Resto says:

    So I really have to ask this of the people commenting. Have any of you actually read the bible? Especially the Old Testament where you have Abraham and Sarah having a kid at like 100 or some where in that ball park? Or what about the number of children that Adam and Eve had? It is said that Eve probably bared 50+ Children! Google it and you will find that it is true. And where do the 12 tribes of Israel come from? From a man that had that many children.

    All I am saying is first of all, we don’t know how many children someone bares is natural to God. Second of all, these people are the best parents anyone could have. Third of all, these people are looking to God which is the best place to look. So maybe you ought to think on these things. Cause you are judging when you shouldn’t. How many of you if we knew your personal lives would have something that seemed unnatural to the rest of us? How many of you have divorces or never get married before making families? Cause these people and I myself would find that unnatural. So please think before you criticize someone.

  145. amanda says:

    she needs to get her tubes tied or something

  146. Maggiemay says:

    I love how they walk out on there faith. Although I do think its strange how they have all these rules like not showing skin. No wonder they have so many kids! The parents are so covered by the time its night they just throw there clothes off and go at it! But they need Birth Control or something. I think that she needs to be grateful for her 19 HEALTHY kids! She has been blessed and needs to just sit back and smell the roses. Stop having kids before Mamma Duggar or a baby dies.

  147. Lori says:

    Have these people even heard of birth control there are couples that can’t have their own children it’s like there rubbing there nose in it enough is enough already.

  148. Krista says:

    I think that if they choose to keep having kids, then that’s their business. They live completely debt free, so it’s not like they’re a burden on anyone. They aren’t overfilling classrooms because they homeschool. So why should we care if they want to fill their home with kids? Every time she says she’s expecting again, the kids are excited so obviously this isn’t a hardship on them. More power to them. At least they’re raising great kids with solid values. Much more than I can say about most people with only 1 or 2 kids, who are growing up to be bullies or spoiled brats or divas or future felons.

  149. layla says:

    I do agree with the comments that point out how great the kids are. However, I just don’t think it’s fair to use the older children as babysitters. They should be out enjoying their teenage years, not cooking, cleaning and caring for little ones.
    And if the cameras weren’t around would the Duggars still be having babies? I think not, this has become big business for them and the more kids they have the more money they stand to make.

  150. kristy says:

    My son has heart disease and is in need of a heart transplant hes had many MRI’s of his heart. The machine isnt really that loud. shame on her!! an we arenot having anymore kids! To risky to have another heart baby!! i also have a daughter an she is healthy then we had our son .. he has major heart problems

  151. momof4 says:

    Well I dont mean to be rude but if you dont like what they are doing… then turn the channel. There is no need to run them down or be so rude. They are using “their” money to support the family not yours. Calling Michelle nasty names… gee that dont seem right either. It is a free country (thank goodness ) and they can raise their children the way they see fit. When the kids become old enough to leave the nest it will be their choice to decide how they want to live their lives. At least they aren’t letting their kids run the streets, do drugs & have babies at 13. And they “WATCH” their children.I dont see them sticking them in front of a tv. They have Bible studies with their children.Sure it may not be everyones way of life but it seems to work just fine for them. Can’t tell you how many parents I know who let their kids run wild just so they don’t have to be bothered. Not saying everyone. But you know there a lot of them out there. So lets just be happy that they take care of their own, live debt free and dont ask you for anything. Lets just be kind. Try it you might just like it.

  152. Libby says:

    For Michelle to even attempt to have any more children is a risk that she may leave her children motherless. It is selfish beyond belief for her to even consider getting pregnant again. How is she going to provide for Josie, who is obviously fragile and needs constant care as well as another newborn? What about the other school age children in the house that still need a mother’s and not a sibling’s nurturing?

  153. kk92 says:

    OMG!!! really, did yall carry them? did yall deliver them? do yall have to raise and support them? no so shut up and grow up, what they do in there lives has nothing to do with yall and it isnt your choice, people have been having kids since the beginning, do you think they had BC then? no they didnt, if they were ment to have alot of kids they did if they wernt then they didnt, apparently it was gods will for them to have these kids wether she was on BC or not she would have ended up pregnant cuz thats what GOD!! wanted, so give it a rest really.