Miley Cyrus: I ‘made history’ at the VMAs, but you’re all ‘over thinking’ it

Miley Cyrus

The tongue is back! Did you notice that we took a bit of a breather yesterday from the wall-to-wall Miley Cyrus coverage? In the meantime, the media frenzy surrounding the twerking seen ’round the world didn’t stop (and it won’t stop) because Miley was classy enough to flip off the paps on Labor Day. In addition, Vanity Fair chose to hilariously spoof Liam Hemsworth’s reaction to the VMAs and (in the process) basically call him a battery-powered robot. Finally, Dr. Laura Schlessinger has slammed Miley asa disgusting little pig” as well as “a little miss piece of crap,” which is pretty rich coming from a woman that posed topless in her 20s. I won’t link the photos because — let’s face it — I love you guys. Nobody wants to see Dr. Laura’s knockers.

Rest assured though that Miley has inspired global-bound twerkout classes that promise to burn upwards of 500 calories per hour. If nothing else, we can all keep our girlish figures amidst this Cyrus frenzy in the lead up to the release of Bangerz in October.

Now Miley has given her first official interview since the VMA madness, and her sense of entitlement remains relatively unrivaled even within the realm of former child stars. This sense of arrogance is what disturbs me the most about Miley’s recent behavior. It’s not enough for her to beg for attention. She also has to insist that she’s living everyone’s dream because we’re all jealous of her childhood empire that she built all by herself (nevermind Disney’s instrumental involvement). Indeed, Miley fully views herself as an indispensible mover and shaker. In that spirit, she has told MTV that she fully intended to “make history” by grinding against Robin Thicke’s crotch. As such, she willingly compares herself to Madonna rolling around in a wedding dress in 1984 and Britney Spears dancing with a snake in 2001 (and for that matter, Britney shaking it in a nude bodysuit in 2000).

The delusions certainly run deep here. On the other hand, Miley does deliver confirmation about whether or not Robin Thicke was possibly conflicted over their act; and if she’s speaking the truth, then Robin was completely on board:

Miley Cyrus

Miley & Robin’s joint goal at the VMAs: “Me and Robin [Thicke,] the whole time said, ‘You know we’re about to make history right now.'”

Miley is amused: “What’s amazing is I think now, we’re three days later and people are still talking about it. They’re over thinking it. You’re thinking about it more than I thought about it when I did it. Like, I didn’t even think about it ’cause that’s just me.”

She’s not worried at all: “I don’t pay attention to the negative because I’ve seen this play out so many times. How many times have we seen this play out in pop music? Madonna’s done it. Britney’s done it. Every VMA performance, that’s what you’re looking for; you’re wanting to make history.”

[From MTV]

Sigh. This would have been a much better argument if Miley would have specified that she wanted to make a splash in “pop-culture history,” “music history” or even merely “MTV history.” Instead, she makes it sound like she broke down the Berlin wall or was the first woman to walk on the moon. Instead, Miley merely shook her booty. Enough said.

I also have to admit to finding Miley’s supposed ambivalence to all of our “over thinking” to be quite amusing considering that her own manager, Larry Rudolph, admitted that Miley was absolutely thrilled with the collective reaction to her gross twerking. Girlfriend has loved every second of this fallout, and she’s thinking about it just as much as the rest of us have been for well over a week.

Here are some pictures of Miley over the weekend at a photoshoot. Naturally, her booty was hanging out because girlfriend can’t be tamed.

Miley Cyrus

Miley Cyrus

Miley Cyrus

Screenshot courtesy of MTV. Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet and WENN

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

172 Responses to “Miley Cyrus: I ‘made history’ at the VMAs, but you’re all ‘over thinking’ it”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Neelyo says:

    Someday she’s going to realize how disposable she is to show business and it won’t be pretty.

  2. lady_luck says:

    What the hell is wrong with her?? She is actually becoming repulsive and repugnant in looks, actions and behaviour.

    • Marjalane says:

      I think she’s got a screw loose. There’s something very manic about her behavior- and as with all the other kid stars, all the people who should be encouraging her to take it down a notch, are on the payroll. Her mother thinks her act is awesome!

      • Nevarmore says:

        She needs a room next to Amanda.

      • gg says:

        I think amphetamines are fueling this behavior. She’s already claimed “people are impressed with me because I only sleep 45 minutes a day”. While I’m sure that’s an exaggeration, looking at her manic state onstage that night makes me think of DRUGS.

    • MoxyLady007 says:

      I liked her. I defended her. And now she is making me look like an asshole

      • Sloane Wyatt says:

        MoxyLady007

        Pat yourself on the back for possessing a flexible, growing spirit. The ability to change your mind is a gift to be cultivated because it gives you never ending possibilities.

      • Rachel says:

        You are not alone Moxylady. I’ve always been a defender, but now she’s managed to turn me against her. And, even though I fear what karma will do to me, every time I see a picture of her with her damn tongue out, I want to see her trip and bite it off. There. I said it.

        Also, twerking classes promising to burn 500 calories per hour? You can burn upwards of 1000 calories per hour in my spinning class AND keep your self respect.

      • Kitten Mittens says:

        Rachel
        My spin class was my first thought too.
        Moxy
        Right there with you. The young girl growing up and hitting phases like we all did argument backfired. She has enough money to do nothing for forever. She should take the hint if this is how she wants to contribute to society.

      • Yup, Me says:

        I thought this article was really interesting on this matter. Miley should read it. Particularly this statement: “Miley’s recent MTV VMA’s performance was a master class in how to become an unintentional comedy masterpiece.”

        http://m.xojane.com/issues/the-origins-of-twerking

      • Kath says:

        Same here. Dammit.

        However, I can’t understand the “poor innocent Robin Thicke” angle. It is clear from the video that he walks over to a (designated) spot on the stage and sticks his crotch out, waiting for Miley to come and ‘twerk’ on him. Bleugh.

      • Pirouette says:

        Yup, Me, thanks for posting that article. The author offers a more complex examination of a seemingly ridiculous situation.

    • Lil says:

      She’s just a very good stripper that’s it

  3. Lindy79 says:

    Her examples made history while still doing some level of performance and showing how women can perform and own the stage. She made history by humiliating herself and dancing/singing badly while being culturally insulting, as many have pointed out.

    If that’s what she wanted then job done.

    • Jenny says:

      +1,000,000
      ‘Nuff said

    • NM9005 says:

      And they made history without being racist. They just displayed their sexuality to make their point. Although, Madonna did make quite the uproar and she is ‘disgusting’ to this day.

      I guess Cyrus did achieve her goal though. Because (not despite) the embarassment, she dominated headlines, her singles are doing well and she is going into VMA history. She doesn’t even need to work on her PR and performance skills because she’s slaying with a racist embarassing performance.

      She’s not ‘just being Miley’ imo, it was calculated, she had a goal. Don’t tell us we’re the ones overthinking it when her VMA performance was supposed to make history =/

      I just know that if Cyrus is going to be ridiculed over and over again, she’s going to pull the ‘I’m a serious artist’ card because she sells well.

      • Kyle says:

        Its very disturbing that no one has explained to her why her performance was like a ministrel show. She needs to watch it or she will end up in whatever McDonalds Vanilla Ice now works at.

    • GoodNamesAllTaken says:

      I agree. Her performance was embarrassing because it was so bad. It also happened to be vulgar and inappropriate on a lot of levels, but mostly it was just bad singing and dancing with frequent awkward pauses for that ridiculous tongue. Ugh, I cringed for her.

    • Eleonor says:

      Agreed.
      And I thought Michael K nailed it when he described her performance as “the drunk girl at the party, who doesn’t know anyone, and embarass herself”

      • Jo 'Mama' Besser says:

        You know how there’s always a drunken aunt who tries to prove that she’s still ‘with it’ and gets inappropriately flirtatious with the younger generation’s friends and promises that she won’t squeal to that sourpuss of the kid’s mother that she won’t adhere to her buzzkill policing and thinks that when she sneaks the kids into the club they’ll actually want to party with her and truly expects that they’ll take her up on her offers of fun in the big city because her scene is so free and you know that suburban conformity just distasteful to her because of it’s prescribed roles of phallus gazing, patriarchal…and she was named Groupie Of The Quarter 1986 by Wastrel Magazine and how when she was young everyone was sticking it to the man by blurring the lines and both men and women wore makeup and…um…hegemony…and she has so many stories about Lee Iacocca and Laurie Anderson and that one time she was doing blow with Grace Jones and got bitch-slapped by her for monopolizing Philip Treacy’s time and then tells some tales about her short-lived romances with Yahoo Serious and Nik Kershaw and she was the one who thought up the line ‘You’re twisting my melon, man’ for the Happy Mondays and reminds the kids that her glory days were far more glorious than what this bunch will look upon as their own glory days by default so she’s taken it upon herself to end the epidemic of blandness thrust upon the world and will kindly educate the kids about how to be true rebels and sits in delusion not questioning why none of these kids has accepted her friend invites but she secretly wants the suburban paradise and would drop her current hell in a second if she could make the third marriage work and maybe that guy will want kids and puts on a free-spirited disposition (to which she attributes the breakdown of said marriages because it was so parochial) and she’s just too much of an individual and ‘too real’ for clearly delineated relationship statuses and that’s why she can really connect with young people and can’t admit that she’s not the person that she says she is under that facade and isn’t one of those ladies who actively chooses to be single and/or invite a child into her family and she’s always a bridesmaid just can’t take it anymore when she’s interrogated about giving someone grandchildren and the picket fence is just a lie and more merlot, please?

        Miley, this is your life in twenty years.

      • TheyPromisedMeBeer says:

        Jo Mama, that was amazing.

      • MK says:

        Substitute merlot with vodka and it’s pretty much Lilo’s life story.

    • whipmyhair says:

      I just rewatched the “performance” (i wasn’t able to get through the whole thing before); and I have something nice to say!

      Miley was wearing sneakers. Which i heartily approve of. I’m not a fan of women doing permanent damage to their bodies to look sexy. I’m also a big fan of practical shoes,which seals the deal for me.

      And to prove this was on topic… Britney wore sneakers when she performed in 2000(?) the year she wore the nude sparkly number.

    • erika says:

      she made ‘history’ by giving a really shi***ty performance?

      i really don’t have an issue w/ the twerking/tongue/part, i mean, i’m 41, ive seen a lot of crap on tv….what I thought was….it was just a BAD performance.

      she can’t dance great, can’t sing great – so all she did was shock us, and that’s why we talk about the performance.

      seriously? my BFF’s in jr high used to guzzle sugar sticks/soda/pizza and starburst at slumber parties and still manage to dance/jam out better than miley.

      she shocked. she didn’t ‘perform’

  4. TherapyCranes says:

    She didn’t “make history” for being controversial and ground breaking.. She’s getting so much attention for being a disgusting embarrassment. When I watched that video I was embarrassed for her. Seriously. Girl needs to learn the difference.

    • brin says:

      But then she would overthink it like the rest of us.

    • janie says:

      She didn’t make history for her mess on stage, she’s delusional. I notice Robin Thicke hasn’t been bragging about making history, it was an epic fail. This girl needs help & how her strutting around nearly naked she thinks is ground breaking is beyond me. She’s going to fall, and fall hard. Grow up little girl!

    • Arock says:

      She made history because the entire watching public was doing it threw their fingers after the face palm. Bravo Miley, you made the entertainment industry shudder- history indeed.

    • Liv says:

      This happens when you don’t have good friends who tell you the truth and your family is a mess. Poor girl. She will wake up one day and her world will fall apart.

      I can’t believe that she believes what she talks. She just can’t compare her performance with Madonna or Britney! She basically didn’t sing!

      • Ginger says:

        Exactly! I wish someone would have told her that latex get up was SO unflattering! She’s young and has a great body but that outfit made her look terrible! And even if someone mentioned she probably said screw you and wore it anyway. That wouldn’t surprise me in the least. Madonna and Britney looked sexy and beautiful in their time.

  5. jessica says:

    I am still traumatized by that disgusting display at the VMA’s…and now of course, she’s got some single called Wrecking Ball getting massive airplay. the song itself is not bad but you put anyone with that voice box she is using to sing the song and they would sound just the same. talentless and now she will be shoved in our faces. such is the music industry today.

  6. Assistant Rachel says:

    Oh please!

  7. Tessa says:

    Britney and Madonna’s performances showcased showmanship and incredible dancing talent, along with being provocative and sexy. Miley’s was just a back alley striptease on national television. How does she not recognize this?

    • LDB says:

      Unfortunately she clearly thinks she is on their level and she couldn’t be farther from the truth. kinda insulting to both Madonna and Brittany really.

    • socalgal says:

      Yeah, it’s a bit much to describe Madonnas VMA performance a either dancing or showmanship. Brittany yes. Madonna no way. In fact I recall people saying round about the same things about Madonna that you are saying about Miley.

      • moot says:

        Yeah, I was one of those who thought Madonna was more marketing savvy than talent. Still do. Never thought she could sing or dance. I don’t care if she did train with Alvin Ailey—it wasn’t long enough and she’s only mediocre as a professional dancer. Every time I’ve seen her (even back in her hey day) I can watch her clicking through the moves in her head as she’s performing. She’s the most un-natural dancer I’ve ever heard people praise as an exceptional dancer. Definitely a cheerleader, though.

  8. Gretchen says:

    Oh my god Miley, you’re UNDER-thinking it so just sit down, shut up and let the grown-ups explain: it’s not just about the overt sexuality, it’s about the racism and appropriation inherent in the performance. Someone close to her, please spell it out!!

  9. Willa says:

    Eyeroll for the millionth time. Gag.

  10. Lulu86 says:

    silly delusional girl.

  11. Ladylupton says:

    Love you too, Bedhead. Thanks for not showing us Dr. Laura’s boobs.

    Miley’s become bafflingly ridiculous. It must be drugs.

  12. Mika says:

    Billy Ray Cyrus, you need to tie that ho to a tree

    • Jo 'Mama' Besser says:

      It worked in One Hundred Years Of Solitude and that book is one of the most amazing collection of words (in any context) that I had had the pleasure to encounter, so you’re on to something.

  13. Mo says:

    “They’re over thinking it. You’re thinking about it more than I thought about it when I did it.” Clearly.

  14. Merritt says:

    She is awful. She can’t twerk correctly. The dancers she hired were not twerking correctly. She is spoiled brat whose sense of entitlement is ridiculous. She has no self awareness of her white privilege. If her performance made any type of history, it is only because it was an embarrassing pile of racist crap.

    • Jinx says:

      Exactly. I was about to post:
      Let’s skip to the “bottom” line. Miley can’t actually twerk. If you’re going to “culturally assimilate,” at least do it correctly. Y’all should go to YouTube and search ‘best twerking.’ You’ll see what I mean.

    • Mindy says:

      A blogger pointed out something pretty nasty. Miley, a slender girl (commonly associated with attractiveness) had her ass out. A black woman who was quite large (deemed in society to be comical, not hot) had her ass out. Three slender black women (with slender but curvy body types) had large bears strapped to their backs hiding their asses………….even as they performed a dance that requires ass movement.

      It seems her management didnt want the unflattering comparisons made. Her with her flat ass ‘twerking’ badly and attractive black women twerking right. So instead we get a woman who is culturally treated as a clown because of her size. No competition for our delicate little dandelion.

    • Mindy says:

      A blogger pointed out something pretty nasty. Miley, a slender girl (commonly associated with attractiveness) had her ass out. A black woman who was quite large (deemed in society to be comical, not hot) had her ass out. Three slender black women (with slender but curvy body types) had large bears strapped to their backs hiding their asses………….even as they performed a dance that requires ass movement.

      It seems her management didnt want the unflattering comparisons made. Her with her flat ass ‘twerking’ badly and attractive black women twerking right. So instead we get a woman who is culturally treated as a clown because of her size. No competition for our delicate little dandelion.

  15. lucy2 says:

    Whatever they lacked in vocals, Madonna and Britney at least put on an entertaining show with some hint of talent. Miley’s “performance” was awkward and embarrassing, which is why all anyone talks about it is how it was so trashy.

  16. j.eyre says:

    As someone on the radio pointed out yesterday, it’s always best to let someone else proclaim that you have made history.

    You may want to get some longer shots, Miley darling, your ignorance is showing.

  17. DanaG says:

    People are talking about it but only how awful and pathetic she was no one is saying the song is good or she danced well. She really is an idiot and she is going to fall flat on her face. She and Justin Beiber should date….

  18. Lio says:

    Why does she always have a wedgie??

    • Belle Epoch says:

      Ha ha! I noticed that too. It must be really uncomfortable and hemmorhoid-inducing.

      My son asked why she had “liquid butt” in the VMA the booty shorts. They were so tight they were pulling her butt cheeks apart. Wish I hadn’t seen that photo!

  19. Penny says:

    I guess outrageous is the new black…I mean tasteless outrageous since celebs having been shocking us with exhibition that makes the everyday man blush

  20. elkiddo says:

    I couldn’t decide who’s worse, she or Bieber.

    • Princess Lizabeth says:

      +1

    • Jen says:

      As much as Miley humiliates herself, she doesn’t seem disrespectful towards other people. She doesn’t spit off balconies or pee in buckets like Bieber. She at least seems to behave with some manners in every day life.

    • Annie says:

      They’re both obnoxious, but so far Miley has stayed out of trouble.

  21. emmie_a says:

    It’s total BS that her & Robin knowing they were going to make history… for what??? Going on stage and *singing*?? Right. Because that has never been done before.

    Has anyone watched the video of her interview?? She is seriously on something. Besides her delusions, she is talking so incredibly fast. She needs help. Although at this point I can’t stand her and I sort of enjoy her making a huge ass of herself and thinking that she’s made it. Ha!

    • Anthea says:

      Yes, I’d agree. I think she’s thick in the throes of an MDMA/Coke honeymoon. It’s quite upsetting to watch.

  22. tifzlan says:

    I am the first to say that Miley is a talentless, classless hack but this Laura Schlessinger person sounds like the actual pig. Hypocritical to boot, too.

    Anyway, it’s hilarious to me that she would compare her performance to what Britney did in 2000. Yes, Britney shocked audiences at the time but on the flip side, her performance was entertaining, well-choreographed and extremely well-executed. Britney didn’t have to grind up on some other person to make headlines. She didn’t do it JUST to shock and make headlines. She did it by dancing her amazing body off and hitting all her cues. Same with her I’m A Slave 4 U performance. Britney has always been and will always be a better performer and entertainer than Miley is. Also, Britney was actually in shape and had a butt to shake. Sorry, but i don’t consider Miley to have a good looking body at all, beyond the flat abs (which admittedly, i do not have and desperately want).

    And that’s why Britney’s performance is actually an important and iconic moment of music/VMA history. Miley’s? It’s just controversial, but nothing worth remembering in the long run. Next year, someone else is gonna do something even more bombastic than this and we’ll be talking about that for two weeks before we all move on with life. Which is what is happening to Miley.

    • Nicka says:

      +1000

      Yes, thank you for pointing that out, tifzlan! Miley is, and never will be, Britney or Madonna level. While her performance was, at best, a satirical response to her Disney upbringing and image, and at worst, was a true showing of her trashy, lack of talent, delusions of grandeur self. Who am I kidding, if she didn’t think about it before doing it, then there is no way it was intended to be any type of satire.

      Britney, oh man, Britney’s body and performances are everything Miley WISHES she could be. Britney’s booty is the booty you try and twerk with, not the paper-flat thing Miley calls her “down south rump” (seriously, look at her twitter bio).

      I can’t wait until this all blows over and Miley can go back to being ignored. Or better yet, she can finally make The Backyard Sessions album that should have been made, instead of this trashy junk she thinks is going to revolutionize the world.

      Also, can I just state, that I would gladly give my left arm to have Britney’s body circa 2000-2001? Good Lawd! That girl definitely had it going on!

    • Kimbob says:

      Totally agree. I guess what “impresses” me most is the fact that what Miley did @ VMA’s required NO TALENT WHATSOEVER…just a pair of misguided balls, that’s all.

      Britney had talent…ability. I don’t see ability or talent in what Miley’s doing, as ANYONE, absolutely ANYONE can get up on stage & act like a fool, squawk into the mike, and amateurishly shake their ass just as Miley did.

  23. Miss so and so says:

    She needs a spanking and to be grounded… you act out like a child you get treated like one.

  24. Adrien says:

    Yes, of course. A cautionary tale for future generations. Soon, students will be able to study the importance of her VMA performance along with the Milli Vanilli fiasco and Sisqo’s Thong Song.

  25. Susei says:

    You cannot compare a 20 year-old ex-Disney victim to a normal 20 year-old woman. Of course she is not grown up and acts crazy in public. We´re just all too normal and old to understand this s*itty behaviour.

    It´s obviously that Robin was on board. He´s a douchebag and both wanted/ needed the PR. The “performance” was going around the world. Win win situation.

    • emmie_a says:

      Robin didn’t need the PR. He’s talented and has done just fine on his own. Miley, on the other hand, is lacking in the talent department and is absolutely desperate for attention, good or bad.

    • Kim says:

      Whether he needs it or not, Robin was 100% in the know and on board with the performance.

      Miley got exactly what she wanted – more attention than anyone else at the awards. Bad press is great press in the industry! Look at the most popular people/shows right now: Kartrashians, Fake Housewives, Teen porn moms.

      Sadly most people pay more attention to train wrecks than talent. Miley doesnt care that all the attention is bad – its attention period. This new breed of “celebrity” loves attention in any form and will sell their souls to get it: sex tapes, gyrate with a teddy bear, etc.

      • emmie_a says:

        How do you know that Robin was 100% in the know/on board with her performance? If anyone actually cared about Miley or her career they would have told her to tone it down because she looked like a total raging idiot, which isn’t cool, as the audience’s reaction told her. And as much as she plays it down, she can’t be enjoying her peers laughing and rolling their eyes at her. She’s a complete joke.

  26. mkyarwood says:

    Newsflash, Miley: You have not made history. In fact, you can’t seem to come up with an image of your own. You blatantly ripped off PEACHES and combined her feminist values with Rihanna’s basic style and some T Boz. Fail, my friend. You’re not the only girl who can tell people she masturbates /shrug

  27. pao la says:

    History Miley?? HISTORY?!
    I can’t wait for her to stop doing coke and gain 20 pounds so at least she’ll cover her ass.

  28. eliza says:

    How exactly did she make history? I am a bit fuzzy on that!

  29. aquarius64 says:

    Everyone here is saying the same thing that other people on other blogs have said: she made history by making a fool of herself. There’s also been the collective eyeroll on the Britney/Madonna comparisons.

    No matter how big of a game she talks, Miley and her team are NOT happy about the results of her VMA mess. Sure the CD and the singles are selling well, but what about after October 8th? Will the respected music critics like” Bangerz” for its music quality, or will they bash it and state those who ordered it in advance were robbed of $14? Will the CD and individual songs be recognized by the Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences, the people behind the Grammys? That’s the true measure of success. This interview is continued damage control; team Cyrus is afraid of long-term repercussions from Twerk-gate. Some comments on blogs suggest Miley’s performance was drug-fueled and/or a symptom of emotional problems. This “self-assured” stance Miley makes in the interview is supposed to counter that perception. They are afraid Miley will be seen not as a serious artist but a joke at best or a psych evaluation waiting to happen at worst.

    P.S. – If the criticism really doesn’t bother you, you don’t flip the bird at the paps or lash out at your critics on your Twitter page.

  30. Mia 4S says:

    Put your tongue back in your mouth Hanna Montana, my neighbor’s pug has more class.

    The insecurity in this one is painful. It’s a desperate act.

  31. jenyking says:

    c’riously, this ho needs rehab

  32. Annie says:

    She still doesn’t understand that she looked like an idiot. She was controversial because she was vulgar AND embarrassing. Nobody enjoyed watching her. Madonna and Britney never looked like idiots. They were controversial BUT sexy. Whatever they were attempting to do, they succeeded. People liked it. Even when Britney had a bad performance she just didn’t know the choreography, but she didn’t look stupid or ridiculous, and everybody knew she was sick. It was sad. Miley looked stupid, desperate, unaware of how BAD everything was. No artistic merit whatsoever. Nobody liked it! That stupid face she kept making, replacing a choreography with freestyle vulgarity. That’s not a real performance, and it’s sad to think women still believe the only way they can show the world they’re all grown up is by being hyper sexual. Forget saying anything interesting or showing any semblance of artistic growth or maturity. Just grab your crotch and pretty much masturbate onstage with a foam finger, that’ll show the world you’re a woman. It’s sad. On the one hand nobody wants to be slut shamed, on the other, most women are terrified that they will never truly be seen as real people.

    • paige says:

      thank you annie..

    • Sandra says:

      You nailed it with the “freestyle vulgarity”. This may sound silly, but I think what bothered me the most about her “performance” was that it wasn’t a performance at all – it appeared to be completely unchoreographed (other than the twerk with Robin that was obviously choreographed). It was just her bouncing around being vulgar. Her dancing without the help of choreography is just AWFUL! It wasn’t a performance, and certainly not to the standard set by other artists. She was set loose on the stage and it was a disaster.

  33. Really! says:

    yes, it’s history because she’ll never have the chance to do it again on any awards show. That act was “has been” before it was over.

    That act is history and so is she.

  34. Jenna says:

    *sigh* Girl, stop.

  35. decorative item says:

    She doesn’t understand that Madonna and Britney, although neither has a fabulous voice, can both hold a note. But, what they really have is that remarkable ability to entertain. They are fabulous entertainers, like what they do or not. Miley on the other hand is horrid at both and doesn’t understand that she publicly embarrassed herself and looked foolish. She will have offers for a while because people will ride of the attention she creates, just like they do with Lindsay L and everyone on reality TV. But, they will be using her and will happily let her self destruct for ratings. It’s gross and sad.

    • Jayna says:

      Exactly. Madonna put out really great pop music to back up any of her antics and was very deliberate and focused in what she was doing.. Britney at least was sexy, great dance routines back in the day, not flailing all over, and could back in the day sing, maybe not great as she went to her breathy vocal style for pop, but was a great entertainer. And at least she wasn’t always in our face obnoxious.

      Miley was just stomping around with a foam finger rubbing herself and Robin and belting out an off-key song while doing her twerking, which was not even good.

  36. Shelby says:

    The pic where she’s wearing the camo pants reminds me of Justin Beiber

  37. Diana says:

    Her delusions are what’s keeping her from totaling falling apart. She is in deep with denial. It is such a shame she does not have a solid and honest support group ot family who could talk sense into her. She is a child desperate for attention and love. It’s sad.

  38. Sunny :) says:

    Every time I see a photo of Miley Cyrus, I want to take a pair of scissors and clip her tongue out. Maybe that sounds psychotic, but I am so damn tired of seeing her stick that thing out of her mouth 24/7. What does she think she is doing? Pushing the envelope? LOL!

  39. Masque says:

    Dear Miley,

    Adolf Hitler made history, too.

    Sincerely,
    Not Impressed

  40. Skins says:

    Lets see what happens when she has to sell tickets. Who the hell is going to pay money to see her perform? How about nobody

    • theoneandonly says:

      Exact point I made above. I can see that kind of performance at a pre-school musical – no offense to pre-schoolers.

  41. JudyK says:

    Shut up, Miley, just shut up.

  42. Erm says:

    She could have made history by walking out and taking a dump on the stage too. How about making history by being an awesome performer instead?

  43. Mayda says:

    I work in the music industry and I’m starting to wonder if they are purchasing her music/web hits themselves to give the illusion of her popularity.

    Make no mistake, facebook likes, twitter followers and even youtube hits can be purchased through services that utilize “bots” to create the hits.

    EVERYONE seems to hate her, yet her music is selling.

  44. Jayna says:

    She made history for me with her grating, off-tune, screeching vocals. I would have welcomed Britney’s messed-up performance any day as at least she lipsynced and didn’t subject me to grating vocals.

  45. cecilia says:

    I really admire how she seems to think that “people talking about it” means that it was a good performance. Or that “making history” is always good – Even if what we all are saying is “OMG did you see Miley Cyrus at the VMA:s?? WORST performance in the history of mankind”. But what does she care? We’ll remember it forever. Her ass in those uncomfortable plastic panties, and her off-pitch singing voice. Yeah girl, drop it like it’s hot^^

  46. Tiffany says:

    I am going to watch Madonna’s VMA performance of Vogue, Express Yourself, Bye Bye Baby, Like a Virgin. Then I going to watch Brittney VMA performance of Oops, Slave. I am not going to encourage this twit with a hit on Youtube. I blame Larry Randolph. Don’t have a real reason, just do.

    • Jayna says:

      Her Express Yourself appearance on MTV is still fantastic. I saw it the other day when trying to look at past VMA appearances after the Miley debacle. Madonna and her two fantastic backup singers doing a wonderful, choreographed performance with Madonna singing live and on key. Her Vogue, where she made no attempt to sing it or even pretend to, no mic to her face or headset. It was all about the brilliant and precise choreography, so never hid the fact that she was lipsyncing to the song. Loved it.

      Miley, this is a performance – Madonna VMA’s 1989 Express Yourself with Donna and Nicky as the opening to the show. I miss her with Nicky and Donna.

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4okAer1HvU

      • TheyPromisedMeBeer says:

        Man, I miss the days where Madonna could perform FULLY CLOTHED and be the sexiest thing in the house.

  47. hillbillyinthecorner says:

    This is one brat who is begging for someone to take over their knee and her butt turned red….Just want to smack that snaky tongue of her back in her mouth and say “Grow UP” So full of herself she can see her her reputation and career going down the drain …Another young person who after associating with Terry Richardson loses their soul….That man is a soul eater….

  48. jojo says:

    To me, history is when it first occurs (like Madonna) or like Whitney Houston belting out the Anthem years ago, which was spontaneous and absolutely brilliant.

    But many of these kids nowadays have little-to-no real talent, so they have to be vulgar, have to contrive controversy, and show alot of skin to get people to notice.

    • Lisa says:

      It’s really the fact that it’s so contrived that bothers me. Madonna is calculating, but I think less so in 1984. Everything now is done purely for a big reaction. All it is, is a big yawn.

  49. Lake Mom says:

    I just hope she and Justin Bieber never get together…oh, the humanity!

  50. Square Bologna says:

    She wouldn’t have gotten within ten miles of even the OPPORTUNITY to “build an empire” if not for her father. She owes everything to Daddy’s mullet and “Achy Breaky Heart.”

  51. GeeMoney says:

    I don’t know about Miley, but if I made “history” for being a no-talent butter faced skank on TV, I’d be in the studio (dance studio, singing studio, talent studio, all studios) trying to repair the damage that I did. I mean, my eyes are still trying to recover from the horror show that I watched that was called her performance. Those images forever feel like they are burned into my head.

    The sad thing is that nowadays, you don’t have to be talented in order to be famous and talked about, and Miley sure as hell proved that at the VMAs. Pretty sad.

    • Jayna says:

      The VMAs have become an embarrassment. When did it become that only pop acts and rap are the music indusry? Where are great bands performing on the show? It used to be that the Grammys didn’t even award pop singers many awards, not that that was right, but now it’s almost all you see on there. But the VMAs is all pop and some rap, absolutely no bands.

  52. Jaded says:

    You’re actually right Miley, you made history as one of the worst, most cringingly horrible and distasteful performances ever.

    Now go away, shut up and reinvent yourself as a decent human being who isn’t self-obsessed to the point of obnoxiousness.

  53. Mandy says:

    NEXT.

  54. babythestarsshinebrite says:

    Miley, it’s “Robin Thicke and I…” – Learn how to talk right.

    • JudyK says:

      You mean you wouldn’t BEGIN a sentence with “Me said”–yeah, she’s about as bright as she is talented. Scores a ZERO on both counts.

      Miley, you couldn’t pass English 101 or even gradeschool English for that matter. As I said earlier, just SHUT UP.

  55. MissNostalgia says:

    Are people still talking about this? Why?

  56. hannah* says:

    Yes Miley, but you see for that argument Britney Spears also made VMA history in 2007 when she went on stage with a pot belly, disoriented, hair extensions exposed and lip-syncing. That was also in the news for weeks and people still remember it today, just not for the right reasons.

    • Bijlee says:

      Am I the only one who thought Britney actually looked fine? Like yeah her performance was awful but I thought she looked pretty good. Everyone was screaming about how fat she was but I didn’t see that.

  57. decorative item says:

    The best thing about her performance was the wake-up call Riri got.

  58. Lisa says:

    Re: Dr. Laura, it’s rich coming from a woman who built a career out of giving people advice, when she’s a racist, xenophobic piece of shit.

  59. Leigh says:

    “I made history”. Ah, the braggadocio of youth. It’s unlikely anyone will even remember this “history” making performance in a decade.

  60. Nic1214 says:

    Bedhead, I’m confused about your comment regarding Dr. Laura. She’s not allowed to have an opinion because she allowed her then-boyfriend to take topless photos of her in private when she was in her twenties? How does that make her a hypocrite?? If that is the criteria for being allowed to have an opinion on Miley’s disgusting performance then the comments section here where people have been saying pretty much the same thing would be much smaller, I’m just sayin’. In my opinion, Miley is a pig. Let the bashing begin!!

  61. Itwillrain says:

    You know you’ve got a problem when even Harry Styles has made a statement saying he thought it was obscene and inappropriate!!

  62. alex says:

    She annoying. I still don’t see what the big deal is with the twerking, she thinks she invented it or something.

    I have seen twerking for years in clubs. I mean, it’s just common. I noticed it back a few years ago with that song ‘Get Low’. Lil Jon and the Eastside Boyz they rap
    ‘Then I like to see the female twerking’
    ‘Twerk something baby work something baby’ ‘Bend over to the front touch toes…’
    and so on and so forth..I edited that a bit cuz its classic Lil Jon which means dirty haha

    But yea!! And then I saw it in all the clubs, but it must’ve been a move before that song to be mentioned in the song.
    I live in a university party town and my friends and I are that age, so maybe for other people (i.e. non clubbers) twerking is shocking but really it’s been going on for years.

  63. dahlianoir says:

    Where’s Liam 🙂 ?

  64. d says:

    I didn’t find the performance shocking at all. I just found it stupid and unprofessional. not sexy, provocative or historic. i would think miley would have been a bit kore of a performer since ahe grew up on stange. Madonna and Britney are not great singers, but excellent dancers and put on a performance and have a charisma. . plus they were sexy performances. hate to say it, but if you are going to try to put on a sexualized performance, you should have the looks to back it up or else you will just be criticized. I

  65. NerdMomma says:

    Regarding the racism/cultural appropriation aspect of this performance… does anyone else remember when Gwen Stefani had her Harajuku girls and went through that phase of either worshipping or appropriating Japanese culture? Did anyone call her out on that racism? I just don’t remember.

    • Bijlee says:

      Yeah people did but I don’t think it was made as big a deal as this. I know Margaret cho got super pissed and called it an Asian minstrel show. I mean…it was weird. She treated then like pets and gave them names. It was just weird.

  66. skuddles says:

    No lizard tongue girl, you’re under thinking it. Being the grossest skank in the room and everyone laughing at you hardly constitutes making “history”.

  67. G says:

    Uh Miley honey Michael Jackson’s Billie Jean performance or Madonna kissing Britt & Christina made history. You looked like a “turnt out” hood rat.

    Since you’re so hood you should know what that means.

  68. dorothy says:

    What a fool.

  69. Anon73 says:

    yack – there is something just completely wretched about her tongue. it’s not cute, sexy. it’s as another poster said – lizard-like.

  70. Anon73 says:

    PS does anyone thing she is trying a bit to look Gwen Stefani ? IE, with the funky hair / boyish twist on fashion ? only thing is Gwen worked her look – managed to come across as sexy / stylish. Miley is… not.

  71. Sara says:

    Twerking isn’t gross. I read this really interesting article on xojane about the African origins of twerking. Anyway, yes she was shocking, yes having her tongue always hanging out of her month is kind of gross and annoying BUT a part of me is kind of like good, at least we have a young woman being as gross as Robin Thicke. If gross is what’s selling in music right now let women jump on the wagon too. I think people are so offended because she’s a young woman. Robin Thicke is just as gross and there is %1 the outrage.

  72. Original Me says:

    I don’t know what’s worse, her performance, or that MTV didn’t censor any of it. Yes, I said censor, everyone can call me a pearl clutching prude but I don’t care, and yes I know it’s “cable”, even though there is pretty much no diff between network tv and cable anymore.I don’t believe in “pushing the envelope” when it comes to tv. There is so much garbage on tv, why do we need more? . I just don’t see why so much degrading sex, violence, nudity,profanity, and everything else is considered “entertainment”. If you want to be entertained watch Fred Astaire tap dance. You will marvel at his skill and have a smile on your face. That’s flippin’ real talent.

  73. G says:

    I guess if its part of an actual cultrual dance it’s not gross. But like Sherry Sheppard said “back in the day they just called that a HO move.”

    True dat!

  74. Carolyn says:

    Dear Miley

    Pink just completely sold out 45 arena shows in Australia. 45 shows. I saw her and she was incredible. Compare her performance to your stupid twerking…well there’s just no comparison.

    The crap songs you are promoting are rubbish. Hope you’re enjoying the quick $ from single downloads. Where will you be in 3 years time? The industry and public don’t take you seriously. All the tweens & teenagers here in Aus are listening to Pink and real music. Not you.

    Your antics and lack of talent are a joke. Wake up. Liam…run!

    Signed, almost everyone.

    • Masque says:

      Awww, that makes me happy to know about the sold out shows. Love Pink!

    • MisJes says:

      +1,000,000 Carolyn!

      And agreed, Masque. Pink is very, VERY popular here in Australia. She makes the effort to come out here for us fairly often (a lot of tours don’t make it down under), and her show is just phenomenal. I can’t remember when she didn’t have a top charting song here. We love her!

  75. Str8Shooter says:

    Someone needs to duct tape her stupid mouth so we no longer have to see that ugly tongue thing she does.

    What ‘history’ did she make? Acting like a $10 whore at the VMAs? Sorry babe…that old hag Madonna beat you to it, years ago!

  76. Jane says:

    What an ego-maniacal, self-centered and self-righteous little girl. Liam—dump her and make us proud!

  77. rudy says:

    Miley looked totally unrehearsed, staring at her dancers who looked right back at her.

    She is on drugs, definitely. This girl needs rehab, now.

    Her team, her family, those in the know, are creating yet another train wreck. It is sad. it is a shame.

  78. Leslie says:

    I haven’t read all the comments and don’t know if someone already posted this or not, but it’s hilarious–Krissy Chula talking about Miley twerking. Miley needs to watch this. 🙂

    http://www.omgblog.com/2013/09/omg_she_aint_here_for_that_kri.php

  79. Lucy says:

    She’s right, you guys. We’re all thinking way too much about it. The thing is, that’s exactly what she wants. We should stop it, forever. Then she will, hopefully.

  80. emmie_a says:

    If anyone needs a laugh, watch this Daily Show sketch (I’ll paste the link but if it doesn’t show up it’s on hulu.com). About halfway through Jon Stewart does an impersonation of Miley at the VMA’s. It’s quick but funny!

    http://www.hulu.com/watch/529247?playlist_id=1031&asset_scope=all

  81. sam says:

    keep on taking whatever it is you take to get you to that place where you don’t overthink anything, Miley.

  82. Isabelle says:

    Nirvana, Rage Against the Machine, Britney, Madonna, Michale Jackson made VMA history. Miley just made us laugh, say wtf and throw up a little bit in our mouths.

  83. Jennifer12 says:

    Sit DOWN, Vanilla Ice.

  84. Norman says:

    I did make history: I stuck my tongue out, I butt thrusted and embarrassed Robin in front of his wife who is way hotter, and more sane than I am and I ignore people who don’t think I’m the baddest, twerkingest, and most foam fingeriest ass around and I put my head in the sand for everything else.

  85. Dommy Dearest says:

    Wearing shorts with your ass hanging out the bottom does not mean you have an ass, Miley. It means you have shamed your ass and it wants to escape.

    Seriously though, those shorts aren’t fooling anyone.

  86. randmanrandy says:

    “because girlfriend can’t be tamed.”? More like girlfriend can’t be shamed.

  87. RedMarine says:

    There is a video which shows the reaction of the crew of USS Enterprise (Star Trek)to Miley’s VMA performance. Hilarious. Need to watch to the end.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6Lb3kFwJRQ
    or just search for “Captain Kirk watches Miley Cyrus performance”

  88. Jaquebelle says:

    Late in the Miley Syphilis game; however, I really long for the days when great music itself created a buzz and singers actually sang well. Not impressed with using Madonna and Britney Spears as musical barometers, because neither of them can hold a tune to save their lives. Yet when compared to Miley Syphilis, both Madonna and Britney Spears appear actually talented. But this is not okay either, because these two women owe their huge successes to the studio and peroxide than sheer talent. Miley Syphilis: Entitlement. Delusion. And a distinct lack of talent. A trifecta of sad. One love.

  89. Michele says:

    Bring in the guys with the straight jacket! Delusional!

  90. anon says:

    Damn, she’s nasty! Put your freaking tongue away, little girl, you aint that hot. Did anyone see how gross her ass looked hanging out of the nude colored leather underwear? It was all saggy and…gross.