Lea Michele still has no Tony nominations after being snubbed for ‘Chess’

Lea Michele at two events in 2025
Sometimes an actor ends up winning a big award for their body of work — the “it’s their time” argument — more than for a particular performance. Sometimes an actor is always a bridesmaid with nominations, but never the bride claiming an Oscar or Tony. Sometimes an actor is Lea Michele. Girl canNOT score a Tony nod! Yes, she picked up a couple Emmy and Golden Globe noms for Glee back in the day, but Lea has been acting on Broadway for 32 years (and she’s only turning 40 this summer); the Broadway heritage is a big part of her identity. Yet anytime she’s in the running for a nomination, the community rewards her costars but never her. It happened with Lea’s breakout leading role in Spring Awakening, where Jonathan Groff and John Gallagher Jr. scored noms, and Gallagher even won. (Note: Though many people thought she was snubbed for Funny Girl in 2023, Lea actually wasn’t eligible since she didn’t originate the role in that production, Julie Benko Beanie Feldstein did.) And this week it happened again: Lea was overlooked for playing Florence in the current revival of Chess. I can’t imagine the tension in the room when someone read her the nominations on Tuesday. She’s the Tracy Flick of the Tonys!!

In a surprising snub from the Tony’s nominating committee, the Glee alum — who has been performing on Broadway stages since she was eight years old — was not recognized for her role as Florence Vassy in the latest Broadway staging of Chess.

Michele’s absence was notable as the Emmy nominee has been receiving rave reviews for her performance. She’s also been campaigning hard, making the rounds to emphasize her lifelong commitment to theater by reminiscing about her prior Broadway productions, from Ragtime and Les Misérables to Fiddler on the Roof and Funny Girl.

The combined star power of Michele and her costar Aaron Tveit made Chess one of the hottest tickets of the season. It certainly helped that the musical itself is a much-loved cult favorite, which has garnered a dedicated fanbase over the years thanks to the impeccable score from EGOT-winning theater lyricist Time Rice and songwriters Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus (of ABBA fame).

But despite the box-office success and general fervor surrounding the show, neither Michele nor Tveit was recognized among the nominees. That said, Chess didn’t go entirely unnoticed.

Michele and Tveit’s costars Nicholas Christopher, Bryce Pinkham, and Hannah Cruz made the grade, earning nominations for Best Leading Actor in a Musical, Best Featured Actor in a Musical, and Best Featured Actress in a Musical, respectively. Brian Usifer was also recognized for his orchestrations.

[From Entertainment Weekly]

“Michele’s absence was notable as the Emmy nominee has been receiving rave reviews for her performance. She’s also been campaigning hard, making the rounds to emphasize her lifelong commitment to theater by reminiscing about her prior Broadway productions…” OUCH. Not only did she campaign, she campaigned HARD — the Tracy Flick vibes persist! And by the way, when EW mentions her “rave reviews,” they link to their own review from the opening… where they lamented that Lea had no chemistry with either one of her love interests. In a show where the plot centers on a love triangle, I’d call that a problem.

Though to be fair, Chess is fairly infamous for having a banging soundtrack but uneven book. Not all that surprising given Chess was first written as a concept album. Given that legacy, this production made a big deal about Emmy winner Danny Strong significantly editing the book. This was a passion project for Strong that he’s been working on for 10 years, and here’s the kicker: Strong told Playbill the key to rewriting the story “lay in giving the show’s emotional core back to Florence Vassy.” So Lea is starring in an adaptation that puts her character at the “emotional core” of the show, and it still didn’t resonate with Tony voters. That’s… something.

Some of you may recall that I’m a longtime Chess lover, though up until now I’ve only ever been able to enjoy it through collecting cast albums. Now I get to see it — at long last! I’m going with a friend, and we simultaneously said, “I’m happy to wait for Lea’s replacement,” lol. So we’re seeing it next month when Lea leaves the show. I’m obviously excited, but have to admit that this cast recording ranks lowest in my Chess collection. I understand not wanting to sound like Murray Head, but Aaron Tveit’s choices on “One Night in Bangkok” were perplexing, aurally speaking. Oh, and they took “Someone Else’s Story” from Svetlana and gave the song to Florence/Lea, yet Hannah Cruz still nabbed a nomination for playing Svetlana! That’s like taking “In America” or “A Boy Like That” away from Anita in West Side Story and the actress still getting nominated!

If you can’t make it to Broadway but still want to scratch that Hungarian woman chess player battling for recognition with a Cold War backdrop itch, Queen of Chess is a documentary on Netflix about real life Grandmaster Judit Polgár and it’s FANTASTIC.

Embed from Getty Images

Embed from Getty Images

Photos credit: Jason Howard/BauerGriffin/INSTARimages, Jennifer Graylock-Graylock.com/Avalon, Getty Images

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

9 Responses to “Lea Michele still has no Tony nominations after being snubbed for ‘Chess’”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Kittenmom says:

    I bought chess tickets as soon as they were available. The website listed in advance the days that lea Michele was not going to perform – I happy grabbed seats to one of those shows, lol! The show was quite a spectacle and I was glad to have gone, even though the plot is a bit…all over the place. Nicholas Christopher has an amazing voice, glad he was nominated. Aaron T is hot as hell and has a nice voice, but I didn’t find him particularly special in his role.

    • Lau says:

      Tveit winning his first and only Tony because there wasn’t anybody else nominated due to covid will forever remain one of the funniest things that ever happened at the Tonys. More seriously, he should have been at least nominated for Catch Me If You Can.

  2. lizzbert says:

    She’s a talented performer with a terrible reputation. If I were in her shoes, I’d be grateful that I’m still gainfully employed in high-profile projects! She has decades ahead of her.

  3. Dr. Yoko says:

    I saw Chess with Lea back in December. What a voice! However, my biggest gripe (besides the book – YIKES!), was that she cannot emote. It made it so difficult to feel a connection to her character. Hannah Cruz though, you see and feel every emotion on her face. It was visceral and raw. It was wonderful to witness.

  4. Jferber says:

    So Lea can sing, but not act. That has to be important in nominating people for the Tony award.

  5. BritChick says:

    Meanwhile an unknown British actor from low budget British play produced and commissioned by a regional theatre in a deprived part of the UK got a Tony nom with zero campaigning and without even being in the country.

  6. Jferber says:

    Britchick, so they must really hate Lea–not hard to believe.

  7. emmlo says:

    The OG concept album of Chess has been my favorite musical ever since my choir director played Pity the Child and Quartet for us back in high school. I have been dying to see it in NYC but getting there is just too expensive for me right now.

    I also don’t enjoy the newest cast recording; the emotions are very flat from both Tveit and Michele. I do love Nicholas Christopher, and hope he wins a Tony. I think the Chess in Concert production with Josh Groban, Idina Menzel, and Adam Pascal was the best marriage of book & score we’ve gotten.

  8. imaratotha219 says:

    I love this for her. Couldn’t have happened to a better person.