Is Benjamin Millepied disrespecting Natalie Portman’s dance skills?

bm1

Benjamin Millepied has a new interview with the Los Angeles Times. Ostensibly, Benjamin is promoting the upcoming DVD release of Black Swan. But really he’s just promoting himself and maybe giving a side-swipe to his knocked-up baby-mama? I’m of two minds on some of these quotes. I feel like Benjamin is honestly trying to defend Natalie’s dance performance in Black Swan by using his own frame of reference as a dancer/choreographer speaking about someone who is untrained. Basically, he comes across as rather haughty and snotty and almost like he’s basically saying “That’s Natalie dancing in most of the scenes, and the reason Natalie could dance so much in the film was because I made the choreography really simple. LOOK AT ME.” The full LAT piece is here, and here are the highlights:

Benjamin Millepied’s international background (born in Bordeaux, France, and raised in Dakar, Senegal, by a mother who taught dance and a father who trained Olympic decathletes) along with his precocious creative nobility (he was tapped by Jerome Robbins to dance with New York City Ballet at age 16) suggests something of Portman’s own ambitious, multicultural vibe. Listening to the resident of New York City (since his teens), it’s possible to hear a wisp of New Yawk mixed with Millepied’s soft French accent, such as when he talks about the dancing strengths of his wife-to-be.

When asked to name his favorite dance moment in “Black Swan,” he immediately answers: “What came off best to me was Natalie.”

“It was so believable, it was fantastic, that beautiful movement quality, ” he says. “There are articles now talking about her dance double [American Ballet Theatre dancer Sarah Lane] that are making it sound like [Lane] did a lot of the work, but really, she just did the footwork, and the fouettés, and one diagonal [phrase] in the studio. Honestly, 85% of that movie is Natalie.”

Although close-ups and CGI were used in “Black Swan,” the film was able to feature long unbroken shots of dance because of Millepied’s choreographic sophistication. How did those dance scenes evoke a classical idiom in steps Portman could achieve? “By making things fluid and not too complicated,” he explains. “By getting more movement going, which in turn added to the camera movement — that is basically what I did. If we had kept things more classical, more restrained, less fluid, it would have been harder to trick the eye.”

And would they ever think of collaborating again on a dance project? “No!” Millepied says, laughing. “I mean I think this was a phenomenal, unforgettable experience. But there are no plans to collaborate again in the future.”

Initially the critics embraced the elegance and velocity of his work, yet recently there’s rankling about his ratio of charm to substance and questions of whether he’s delivering on his promise. He remains busy as a choreographer, with a lineup of commissions over the next few years including works for New York City Ballet, Lyon Opera Ballet, Paris Opera Ballet and the Mariinsky Ballet in St. Petersburg, Russia.

After Millepied’s most recent creation, “Plainspoken,” premiered at New York City Ballet in February, New York Times critic Alastair Macaulay described a frustrated longing to like Millepied, yet ultimately called his work “irrelevant” and said he didn’t “feel the least curiosity or desire to see another Millepied premiere, no matter how much more deftly he makes a ballet than most other choreographers today.”

Millepied says that some people get his work, and some don’t. “When ABT did ‘Everything Doesn’t Happen at Once’ in London there was a standing ovation at every performance,” he says. “You have to go with your gut.”

At present he’s got the film bug, bad. Since “Black Swan,” Millepied has co-directed a short film with director Asa Mader (“Time Doesn’t Stand Still”), shot one commercial (unnamed at the moment), recorded two dances for film and is using three live cameras onstage in his work for Pennsylvania Ballet.

“I think directing and choreographing have such a similarity: how to work with movement and motion and narration and emotion and creating images…. And I think having the ability to control the viewer’s perspective on the movement… it’s heaven.”

It’s almost hard to remember that Millepied is still on the roster of principal dancers at New York City Ballet. (“I haven’t been much of a dancer lately,” he says.) He does plan “to do a little more dancing,” he says, though he says that he is mulling over retirement as a performer. His hope is to dance onstage for one or two more years before he stops for good.

Those retirement-concert tickets will surely move fast in New York, just as “Swan Lake” ticket sales have been amped worldwide by “Black Swan.” But before that, he has the challenge of fatherhood this year. Is he excited? “Yes,” he says. “I’m very much looking forward to it. It’s a new life, as everyone who is around me who is a parent tells me. So I’m getting ready.”

[From The LA Times]

Yeah… I don’t’like Benjamin any more or less now that I’ve read this, but I have had my general impression of him completely reinforced. This whole “knocking up Natalie Portman” thing was just one step, one rung on the ladder to his own vision of his eventual superstardom. And it sounds like Benjamin know sees Natalie and the baby as a nuisance – “I’m very much looking forward to it. It’s a new life, as everyone who is around me who is a parent tells me. So I’m getting ready.” Getting ready to yell “Smell ya later!” to Natalie whenever the next project comes along.

bm3

bm2

Magazine photos of Benjamin.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

34 Responses to “Is Benjamin Millepied disrespecting Natalie Portman’s dance skills?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. brin says:

    Hope they get a good nanny cause I don’t see either one of them deigning to change a diaper.

  2. flourpot says:

    They guy may be an arrogant jackass but he’s a professional dancer, born from a professional dancing mother. I think the interview came off as pride for his ability to choreograph a non dancer to look so well and pride in Nat’s work. If anything, I’d be wondering if the stand in was pissy. He disrespected her work in a huge way.

    I don’t like either of them but I think this is just how he is. A rich, snobby, sexy, really good dancer.

    I think Nat knows exactly what he is as she’s the same kind of person. They live in their own little bubble. It’ll never last.

  3. Rita says:

    I don’t think Ben “knocked up” Natalie because of alterior motives. Benji released the hounds because that’s what Benji does (boinggggg). I believe Natalie knocked up Natalie.

  4. Valerie says:

    He is right. The reason she looked good in the movie was his choreography. Unless you have studied ballet intensely (& I’m not talking about taking a few years of lessons as a child for fun, I’m talking about pre-professional programs), you don’t really understand the hours & years it takes to dance like a professional. I was in a pre-professional program as a teen (40+ hrs a week) & before that had years of classes. You don’t “learn” ballet in a year–much less dancing en pointe. I said it the second I saw the movie-she didn’t dance. I knew the footwork was a professional’s. The majority of her “dancing” are shots of her upper body, her face, or her walking or doing a very simple move. The real dancing was her body double-a professional. The only people who are offended by this are non dancers, the dancers are thinking, “Duh.”

  5. Violet says:

    I agree with flourpot. That he was proud of choreographing something that looked complicated but that an untrained dancer could handle. i mean for all the training NP did, she’s no ballet dancer. It’d be an insult and a joke to say that her years training could compete with a real ballet principle’s years of dedication.

  6. TXCinderella says:

    He may be a tutu dancer, but he is really hot looking.

  7. GradStudentEatingHotPockets says:

    I totally agree with flourpot. I think he is very passionate about ballet and his choreography and he is very proud that he could take someone who isn’t a professional dancer and make them look good doing ballet. That has to be difficult- especially when you have professional dancers watching the film and critiquing everything.

    I also don’t really think he is trying to move up the ladder…he’s established in his career, he is good at what he does, and he was a steady worker before he ever hooked up with Natalie Portman. Obviously now he has waaaaay more attention on him since he’s with Natalie, but that kind of comes with being with a movie star.

  8. mln76 says:

    Millipied is arrogant and so is Portman. I don’t think he meant any harm by this interview he just doesn’t know how not to sound like a jerk. I can only imagine how self congratulating these two must be. They must have smug offs at home.

  9. Kaye1 says:

    I think even non-professionals know that ballet is very difficult and not something you can pick up in a year as an adult. He may well be a douche but I didn’t get that from his comments about how he helped Natalie. He seemed proud of her.

  10. Solveig says:

    You are reading too much into his words, basically he’s talking about his job in that movie, period. And for the little I understand of dance – approximately zero – he did a great job.

  11. Marjalane says:

    “Smug-offs at home”

    Says it all.

  12. OtherChris says:

    I don’t think is sounded like he was disparaging her at all, although he looks like the kind of guy who would spend 10% of his time telling you what a goddess you are and the rest of his time telling you what’s wrong with you.

    Still, he is mighty pretty.

  13. Addie says:

    @ Valarie. That’s a really interesting bit of trivia. Thanks.

    Who cares if she did’nt do ALL the dancing, the point is she ACTED like she did, which is why she won her oscar, for THE ACTING.

    Oh and Ben really seems.I don’t know, unreliable, that’s the vibe I get anyway.

  14. Brittany says:

    He totally poked holes in the condom.

  15. lucy2 says:

    I’m in agreement with flourpot too.

  16. liz says:

    Um yeah “footwork, and the fouettés, and one diagonal ” – that the dance double did was all the impressive dancing in the movie- everything else was all up-close arm work. Ha. Not saying she wasn’t an incredible actress in the movie, but c’mon.

  17. flourpot says:

    omg Smug Off’s. my new go-to phrase.

  18. guesty says:

    @Valerie…that was fascinating. 🙂

    His body is amazing. But on point…those two deserve each other.

  19. jill says:

    Completely off topic, but…Am I the only one that thinks that the first picture of him is a classic “glamour shots” pose? It looks like the way they have 4yo pose for pics. So I’m sure someone is about to post that its a classic ballet pose and I’m an idiot for not knowing that. Oh, well.

    And mln76 hit the nail right on the head.

  20. ordinarygirl86 says:

    Well the dancing must have been good enough because the bitch got an Oscar! I think it’s common knowledge that she obviously had a ballet dance double to do the more difficult scenes

  21. maggiegrace says:

    Valerie is on the money. And her “acting” – please – only if emoting terror and on the vergeo of tears alternatively is acting.

  22. Hollowdoll says:

    @TXCinderella: He may be a tutu dancer, but he is really hot looking.

    This made me laugh so hard. 🙂

  23. ezra says:

    Natalie hooking up with this guy=BAD BAD BAD.

  24. Sweetiedog says:

    I watched videos on youtube of him dancing. He is immensely talented and obviously a very committed dancer and hard worker.I was astounded at his abilities. I have been exposed from an early age to great ballet and modern dance and he is up there. The fact that he seems to like choreography more than dancing at this point is understandable. He is the one who gets to create the dance. He is very successful in his own right. Whatever we may project on to him, he has worked hard to get where he is and he is world-renown. He seems to be crazy about her. People are very quick to jump on the critical bandwagon particularly after there has been a lot of praise building up. The pendulum swings.

  25. Jess says:

    I myself ALSO love doing pull-ups on the floor whilst gazing intensely to my right! It’s so invigorating.

  26. Jo 'Mama' Besser says:

    Whatever. He’s better at what he does than she is at what she does, unless you thought her performance in Garden State was the artistic triumph of the ages. Whether he actively wants the attention or not, he has never *needed* her presence to act as an advertisement for his talents. If they were to separate at some point in the future, it’s not like she’ll get the arabesques in the settlement. And if a person truly, truly believes that a woman in her late 20s is capable of dancing at anything near professional level, you’ve obviously had a stroke, hell it’s over before you’re ten if you haven’t had a lesson. No, the only person who believed that such a thing could happen was Zelda Fitzgerald and that was after she went crazy. That didn’t end well, did it?

  27. Juu says:

    @Valerie: agreed. Even as an amateur I could tell when it was Natalie dancing and when it was a double. A year of ballet trainning is not enough to look like a professional, even from the waist up.

  28. Lady Satan says:

    Does anyone know what the tattoo is supposed to be? It looks like a badly drawn game of Tetris…

  29. Erika says:

    His tattoo is an Oskar Schlemmer (Bauhaus painter, & think Mondrian or Kandinsky for similar work.)

  30. Boots says:

    Oh please. Natalie didn’t look like a dancer even in STILLS.

  31. Newbie says:

    @Jess: LMAO!!!!!

  32. jenny logan says:

    How on planet earth will their two egos fit into the same household?
    Portman is not a great actress. She is mediocre. From what I hear, Centipede is a great dancer. How will Portman deal with being bland compared to his talent?
    Is she attractive with good genes? Sure. But acting — nope. Jennifer Lawrence got ripped off at the oscars!!! Lawrence was 100 times the actress that POrtman claims to be.

  33. Melanie says:

    I bet Ben was soooo embarrassed at the Golden Globes. Natalie’s speech was so childish. She obviously wanted everyone to know how wonderful she is and that her pregnancy resulted from the fact that Ben couldn’t keep himself away from her sexually any time they were in the same room together and a pregnancy would occur because he loved sleeping with her so much! I’m sure she was not on the pill because that would make it too hard for her to prevent getting a little chubby. If Nat ate more than 800 calories per day and didn’t work out like a rented mule, she would be as big as a side of a barn. It was obvious that something was going on with her body very early in her pregnancy because she looked bloated very soon after she got knocked up. I don’t think she and Ben will ever marry. He is more talented than she is, and he’ll probably get sick of her flapping her gums as if she knows everything about every subject. If she didn’t look like Audry Hepburn in the face, she would be an unknown non-model and non-actress. She definitely is not a good actress now. Some of the scenes in Black Swan were absolutely ridiculous looking. She fooled the academy into believing she did all the dancing and that is the only reason she got an Oscar.