Does Scarlett Johansson think Blake Lively is a phony & a fame monster?

I’m pretty sure we’ve discussed the meat of this Enquirer story several times before, but let’s discuss it anew. The Enquirer claims that Scarlett Johansson is having a particularly rough time these days because her ex-husband Ryan Reynolds married Blake Lively all of a sudden a few weeks ago. It’s not so much that Ryan moved on from Scarlett so quickly – it’s that Scarlett now believes that Blake was plotting to “steal” Ryan the whole time, and that Blake and Ryan even fooled around in 2010:

There’s at least one person who probably won’t be sending Ryan Reynolds and his new bride Blake Lively a wedding gift – Ryan’s ex-wife, Scarlett Johansson! Sources tell The Enquirer that Scarlett has been on the warpath since Blake and Ryan tied the knot last month because she’s convinced that two hooked up while she and Ryan were still married.

“Even though there is no evidence behind it, Scarlett has convinced herself that Ryan cheated on her with Blake,” a close source told The Enquirer. “She’s incredibly bitter about it. In a way, Scarlett feels like Blake actually stole Ryan from her, because it was when he started shooting ‘Green Lantern’ with Blake in 2010 that everything fell apart.”

Insiders says Scarlett is so angry about the marriage that she can’t even stand to look at pictures of Blake.

“Scarlett thinks that Blake is a total phony and a complete fame monster,” continued the source. “Scarlett also considers Blake to be a cheap version of herself. They’ve actually auditioned for the same roles a few times and Blake has always lost out.”

“Ryan and Blake’s wedding has brought back a lot of pain for Scarlett. She’s sure that Blake deliberately seduced Ryan, even though she knew he was attached at the time. On top of that, she feels like it’s a huge slap in the face that Ryan would remarry this fast. Scarlett is happy and dating, but she assumed he would wait a few years before he tied the knot again.”

[From The Enquirer, print edition]

If you told me that FOR SURE Blake and Ryan had some kind of affair in 2010, I would probably believe you. I don’t think it’s beyond the realm of possibility. Whatever happened between them in 2010, they both seemed to move on with ease, so I would guess that it wasn’t anything torrid or earth-shattering. More like it an emotional affair, where Blake was actively trying to ingratiate herself to Ryan and win him over, all while “showing up” Scarlett. Petty girl drama, basically, although Blake played it so well that she’s the new Mrs. Reynolds.

As for the “Scarlett thinks Blake is a fame monster, Blake is the Budget ScarJo” stuff… there might be something to it. But does Scarlett know that by referring to Blake as The Budget Scarlett, those insults will boomerang back? You know what I’m saying? ScarJo and Blake are both fame monsters to a certain extent. Neither is, like, a Real Housewife or something, but let’s not pretend that either of them is some bastion of celebrity decency and austerity. Now, is Blake a “phony”? Is Scarlett? Or are they two young women who simply outgrow certain personas?

Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

170 Responses to “Does Scarlett Johansson think Blake Lively is a phony & a fame monster?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Emma says:

    When those nudie pics of Scarlett surfaced that were sent to Ryan (Scarlett admitted this), Blake realised he was into that and texted him a pile of nudie pics too.. Hhaha

    • Annie says:

      I still suspect those nudies were for Ben Affleck. They were taken when she was filming with him, basing on the fake tattoos and Ben’s suspisciously girly black eye, and Jennifer onset 24/7 all of a sudden…

      • CL says:


        I have no reason to think this, but I like to think that J Garner found the photos and leaked them. Do not mess with Sidney Bristow’s family!

      • Emma says:

        You all should never be detectives. There were several sets of photos released. One set were photos of her back, shoulders and neck. There were no nudes in that set and she was obviously just photographing her fake tattoos. Another set was taken on The Green Lantern set which idk were probably sent to her boyfriend Penn who was filming across the country. You’re all so desperate to believe she’s some whore that you refuse to think logically. It’s quite sad.

      • Annie says:

        Or maybe we don’t know Blake’s every move, especially from two years agob

        And the set with the tattoos were definitely taken when filming with Affleck, so idk what you’re talking about.

      • Emma says:

        Annie, can you read? I said myself the set with the tattoos were taken during The Town but there were no nudes. They were photos of the fake tattoos she had done for her character. She did the same thing with her tattoos she had done for Savages. They were photos of her neck and clavicles. Tell me, why would she send Ben photos of her fake tattoos when he sees them everyday on set? Why would she send him nudes when she can just be nude in his trailer? Is common sense asking too much of you?

      • mercy says:

        Emma: “There were no nudes in that set and she was obviously just photographing her fake tattoos. Another set was taken on The Green Lantern set which idk were probably sent to her boyfriend Penn who was filming across the country.”

        “Tell me, why would she send Ben photos of her fake tattoos when he sees them everyday on set? Why would she send him nudes when she can just be nude in his trailer?”

        These are the most common sense thoughts I’ve read about the photos. I never even noticed the tattoos in some photos but not the nudes. You’d make an excellent detective. ;)

      • Tiffany says:

        “Annie, can you read? I said myself the set with the tattoos were taken during The Town but there were no nudes.”

        You must not have seen all of the photos. There was at least one with her fake Town tatoos where she was naked, showing her boobs and crotch in a mirror of a set trailer. She was naked AND Town-Tattooed.

    • Mia says:

      According to Emma’s logic, why would anyone ever take nudes and send it to someone if they could be there in the flesh? It’s a variation of sexting, I hear all the youngins are doing it lately, you should try it sometime….lol

  2. V4Real says:

    Finally it’s good to hear a celebrity say what most of us have been saying all along; Blake is a phony famewhore. Even though it’s Ryan’s ex saying it, it’s still true.

  3. Lizzie says:

    Scarlett>>>Blake every time. Lively can go hang with Martha Stewart and Scarjo can have the Avengers boys.

    • Amelia says:

      Scarlett’s no Meryl, but she can do a decent English accent, doesn’t mumble her way through films and she’s got a personality.
      That’s more than I can say for Blake.

    • Kate says:

      I used to think that too and then I saw the Avengers and Scarlet had NO personality at all. She was just terrible. I thought she was so cool in Lost in Translation way back when, but now…they both suck, IMO.

    • lizzi says:

      Superficial, but every time I see their pictures side by side I can’t get over how much more beautiful Scarlett is than boring ass Blake. :P

    • Ariana says:

      Agreed! You don’t have to be a fan of ScarJo to like her better than Blake. It comes really easy.

      I saw the title of this story and wondered, “uhm, does anyone NOT think that about Blake Lively?” On the cheating thing I’m not sure, but I wouldn’t doubt it went down that way.

    • Mazunte says:

      Blake could never be compared to Scarlett, physically, professionally, and I guess her personality too. Scarlett is many levels above.

      • Tommy says:

        …I don’t think Scarlett is that pretty and Blake’s body is way better. I don’t really see Scarlett’s appeal at all. Is it because she’s “curvier”?

      • mercy says:

        You can compare them, but it’s all relative and very subjective.

        Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. They both have nice features, but they couldn’t be more different. One is tall and slender with long legs. The other is petite and curvy. One has more of a Scandinavian look, the other Irish.

        Scarlett has been in the business twice as long as Blake and has had more opportunities to prove herself. Why not compare her to similar actors with similar backgrounds and see how she fares?

        Personalities are as unique as looks and we don’t know them personally. I’ve seen them both interviewed and they seem nice enough, but again as different as New York and California.

        They are only being compared because of Ryan, and because tabloids like to pit women against each other.

  4. Mira says:

    Blake bugs me but not as much as Scarlett. They both suck and so does Ryan!

  5. Lou says:

    At least Scarlett has a modicum of talent and was actually pretty awesome in Avengers Assemble. Blake is so basic. And with ALL that plastic surgery, i wonder what else she got ‘done’ that we cant see … ;-)

  6. epiphany says:

    And ScarJo is a mediocre actress and a moderately attractive woman who’s gotten where she is on the strength of unusually large breasts/breast implants. Lively may deserve criticism, but it should come from someone who is legimately superior to her, which this dime-a-dozen girl is not.
    When Cate Blanchett hacks on Lively, I’ll listen.

    • hyena says:

      Blake Lively has breast implants that definitely helped her career. I do not like Scarjo or Blake but when you put them up against each other, Scarjo has WAY more acting cred.

      • epiphany says:

        I’m not defending Blake – I don’t like her either, but an actress should be demonstratively better than another before they criticize her – ScarJo is not. And I know Blake has implants, but ScarJo’s anatomy, whether it’s real or not, is over the top huge.

      • nate says:

        epiphany you think ScarJo’s anatomy is over the top huge? um.. no it isn’t. if hers are huge then mine are gigantic. Scarlett has this slightly hour glass shaped figure. also have you seen christina hendricks’? that’s over the top huge.

      • Liv says:

        I think Scarlett is way more successful as an actress than Blake!

        Scarlett: Matchpoint + Scoop + Vicky Cristina Barcelona, with Woody Allen, The Other Boleyn Girl, The Avengers, Iron Man…

        Blake: Gossip Girl, Green Lantern (film was so bad!), Savages, The Town (she was so bad!)…

        Easy choice.

      • mercy says:

        Scarlett was a child actor with a mom for a manager. Blake was a good student who wanted to go to university. She hasn’t been in the business that long, and most of her time has been taken up filming a TV show. She’s always talked about wanting a large family, too. The women are only being compared because of Ryan.

      • CC says:

        Blake= TV actress that does movies occasionally

        Scarlett=movie actress

        The pecking order is clear. Scarlett>Blake

        As far as assets? Don’t know or care enough to look. Most actresses do have stuff done. It’s not possible to have attractive-looking bobbs is extremely skinny bodies. Boobs get bigger when everyting else is bigger, also. None of that #2oh no, fat didn’t get anywhere but my boobs”. (lol)

    • Ranunculus says:

      @ epiphany
      Absolutely agree, Scarlett is annoying in interviews, because she never says anything intelligent or even interesting. She can’t string 5 words together without saying ehmm. One of the stupidest bimbos out there – she is very unconvincing in any role she plays and she probably only gets roles because she is the bouncing boobs factor 20 year old boys like to see in movies. On top of it she always complains when she is not being taken seriously as an actress. I find her insufferable.

  7. Fudge you, I'm going to Guam! says:

    I kinda think they both suck donkey wiener as far as acting goes…look-wise, I think they’re both “meh”, but Blake pre surgery was just…not attractive, sorry.
    So Scarlett is better looking than pre surgery Blake but post surgery they’re both equally “meh”. Average.

    • marie says:

      ha! my first thought when reading was “they all suck gigantic donkey balls” however, didn’t Scarlett end the marriage. Sooo.. why would she care? I mean, no one wants to be cheated on but there’s no evidence of that-so unless she’s sucking on something bitter, I don’t get it.

      And isn’t she dating like the most handsome man or some BS?

  8. Annie says:

    Men move on incredibly fast, girls. Know this. Maybe he didn’t cheat (maybe he did). It’s like Ben Affleck shooting Daredevil with Jennifer Garner while he was with JLo, and then dating her and marrying her…

    It’s messed up how quickly men move on. It’s sad. But prepare yourselves for this, always. While we are still in the mourning process, they feel like they will heal more quickly by replacing us asap. 1) because they don’t want to feel sad all the time, 2) they think one girl will make them forget.
    For us is not always that easy to immediately move on to the next. For them (and Jlo) it’s a piece of cake. For the most part anyway.

    I remember my sister breaking up with her BF of three years, a really bad break up and two weeks later he was dating someone else. That messed her up big time.

    ScarJo divorced him two years before his new marriage. She also needs to sit down. He’s not going to remarry whenever SHE is ready.

    • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

      This is true – mainly because men are physical and women are emotional, generally speaking of course. Sigh…one of the many injustices of the world.

      • Jaded says:

        @ Lowey: Every significant relationship I was in ended with me being alone for a long time afterwards, whereas the men seemed to find themselves someone new within weeks or a few months at most. One guy I’d dated for almost 2 years was actually engaged to someone when he dumped me. Sorry, guys lose it in this round.

    • Lowey says:

      So you know every type of man in this world? I’m tired of stereotyping men are like that and women are like this. A lot of guys I know have a very hard time moving on. See Aidan Shaw from Sex & City. Every man and woman are different. This expert attitude of knowing everything about every man and woman is not only impossible but annoying.

      • Steeds says:

        You’re sick of stereotypes, but you’re referencing Sex and the City… Is this a joke?

      • Annie says:

        LOLOLOL your experience with men is a fictional character from a TV show? Are you kidding me?
        All of us are speaking from experience. Personal and from our close friends. If all the reference you have of men is tv characters you need life to start happening to you already before you say something is a stereotype. Speak from your own life. Men do move on faster than us. It’s a fact. If they can, they will.

        FFS, my uncle married a new woman less than a year after his wife died of cancer. We speak from what we know.

      • Lowey says:

        Gosh. I’m so sorry that your two, three experiences with men made you an expert badge to speak in behalf of all men and women. And I also said that Sex&City example to generalize it as something that can happen, not that my only experience with men was that… I have so many guy friends and my ex boyfriends who had/have incredibly hard time moving on.

    • Palefire says:

      I’ve seen this too :( one of my best guy and girl friends broke up after 3+ years bc she wanted it to be more serious. He literally within two weeks found some random at a bar and she is like still in destroyed tattered mourning half a year later. He’s yucking it up like she never happened. Makes me sad oh :(

  9. angie says:

    “They’ve actually auditioned for the same roles a few times and Blake has always lost out.”
    Scarlett has actually lost a lot of high profile roles these days. She auditionned for the lisbeth salander role, for les miserables, great gabsy…. She was once at the top of the list with natalie portman and keira knightley but now there are new young actresses a lot more talented and likeable like carey mulligan, mila kunis, emma stone, felicity jones, emily blunt…. She got lucky that she had the black widow role (and emily blunt was the first choice).

    I don’t hate scarjo (though she sometimes sounds full of it), and I think she is a lot better than blake (I enjoyed her in several movies like lost in translation, the avengers, match point and horse whisperer whereas I just can’t stand Lively). But I don’t think she is all of that, she has always been overrated, IMHO.

    • Annie says:

      Completely agreed. Her career has stalled. Jennifer Lawrence is replacing her big time, I think. She has the same natural perfect body, but she has an Oscar nomination.

      Focus on that, ScarJo. You’re dropping to Jessica Biel level.

      • angie says:

        Yes, and Scarjo is already working with Jessical Biel in the Hitchcock biopic (and she said she wasn’t interested to play another actress like marylin monroe and then she signs on a movie which sounds like my week with marylin).

        Biel once said that Scarjo was one of the top tier girl who had all the good roles, and now they are working together… but it’s not Biel who has improved. And Scarlett dated Timberlake at one point, right? It was probably awkward on set.

        I also thought that about Jennifer Lawrence, she kinda remplaces Scarjo as the new blonde bombshell with more talent and a better personnality (especially when she wore that red dress at the oscars, which looked like Scarjo’s valentino gown several years ago).

    • normades says:

      I think Avengers saved her career by keeping her relevent. You’re right, she was once the actress that got to read all the scripts first. Not so much now.

      The young generation of JLaw/Stone/Mulligan/Mara/Mia W have tottally eclisped her. Notice Blake isn’t in that list and KStew is out now too imo.

      If the casting director wants to go “older”, they have Chastain/Amy Adams/Hathaway/Blunt.

      • Annie says:

        Kstew better be careful. She’s a narcissist trashy uneducated girl with a horrible attitude, and this scandal WILL hurt her mostly because it shows how entitled and unprofessional she can be. She screwed up big time. She lost all the projects she had for 2013: SWATH 2, Cali, Lying in Darkness. Notice how she danced around the topic of Lying in Darkness at TIFF. It’s gone. Why anyone still believes the affair was PR baffles me. A sequel to a potential new franchise: gone. Her first shot at producing: gone. Her dream role: gone.
        No way is she on the same level as Emm Stone, Jennifer Lawrence, Carey Mulligan, Mia Wasikowska…

        She needs to learn how to talk in interviews. She comes across incredibly obnoxious in them. And this goes to Scarlet too. Don’t feel too safe. There’s plenty of new girls with better attitudes and more talent.

    • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

      All of you are so right. These girls think they are all God’s gift to the film industry. Actresses are so replaceable and there will always be new/up and coming people. These people need not take their fame, money, life etc. for granted…never know when it will be over. And it can happen as quick as a flash.

      • Annie says:

        Yeah! Whoever is cool today is gone tomorrow. Look at Megan Fox. She thought she had the world at her feet and felt comfortable enough to talk crap about one of the most powerful men in hollywood (who calls their jewish boss HITLER?!), with the most powerful friends like Spielberg, and like that her career is GONE.

        I’m afraid kstew will piss off the wrong person one day and she’ll be gone too. She has a terrible attitude and thinks she can get away with anything.

        Actresses are very replaceable. There’s always someone younger, hotter, more talented. I feel like Jennifer Lawrence took everyone by storm as did Emma Stone. All the Biels and Johansons should be afraid. Their moment is over. Amanda Seyfred basically took away the career Lindsay Lohan could’ve had.

        Scarlet knows this. She should be worried. All of them should.

      • Carolyn says:

        cosign, EmmaStone & Annie.

    • Tommy says:

      And Emily Blunt would have been a way better Black Widow, IMO.

  10. dooliloo says:

    Hmmmm.. I think Scarlett tried the marriage thing with Ryan because she wanted to see what it feels like to be a married girl.. Unfortunately she went back to being herself realising”wth am I doing here? This is not me!” and it was the end. Ryan Reynolds is a guy who seems to want to have a wifey and Scarlett wasn’t one of those even though she tried. Now he might have hooked up fast with Blake so it raised eyebrows but oh well… Ryan wants to be married doesn’t he?
    As for acting range, Scarlett is a tad better but she’s still very much overrated. She was surprisingly good in Avengers but that’s just about it.
    And well when you hear your ex got married in the blink of an eye, I too would go on a fashion high spree shopping in Paris and forget about it all… If I had the money :-D

    • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

      Yeah I remember in an interview when they were married, she was often saying how much she liked to cook, bake, keep house…pshh more like play house! Then along comes Blake with the same speech, “Im such a homemaker, obsessed with baking.” That sound byte just comes across as try hard now..who knows..maybe Blake will be into it. Just hope Ryan doesnt strike out again for marrying a variation of the same thing.

  11. Mia 4S says:

    No kidding Blake’s a total phony and a complete fame monster. This is a shocking opinion? However Scarlett should tread carefully, she’s had her moments.

    Somehow I don’t think Scarlet is all that upset at losing Ryan. I think she grew up and matured, and he has a type. Blake will either outgrow him or we won’t see her acting much anymore…wow that would be a shame. ;-)

  12. kingkayski says:

    I think they both suck and meh as an actress,but ,but,atleast Lively dressed better,i think.

  13. Annie says:

    Oh, one thing for which Blake has all my respect forever is for dumping DiCaprio like she did. Leo was an a-hole to women all his life, I saw this as a fan who witnessed this play out in the media. Dumping them, cheating on them, being generally awful. If he ever dated a woman of color, he would hide her, only flaunting the blonde super models. It’s pathetic that at his age he still dates very young women. Did you know he has never dated anyone over the age of 25? It’s creepy how he’s all over a 20 year old model, like Blake is going to feel bad because she’s 25. He ran the young Hollywood scene when he was at his peak, age and fame wise. He thought it would always be like this, when his friends all grew up and started families. I’m guessing Blake realized he would never grow up while he saw a 23 year old in the mirror. And he had never been dumped. Massive ego blow. I was glad.

    I still think Giselle Bundchen is the love of his life, but he was horrible to her. So there you have it. Refuse to settle down, you’ll lose what you loved the most and you’ll end up alone.

    • Suzy (from Ontario, Canada) says:

      Annie, I agree! I read somewhere that Leo was shocked and devastated (probably more from the fact that she dumped him than because he really wanted her). Frankly, if she was the big famewhore everyone accuses her of being, then staying with Leo would’ve been her game…he’s a much bigger star than Ryan is!

      Plus I agree that Giselle was the big love of Leo’s life and I think he blew it by putting her off when she clearly wanted to settle down and start a family. I suspect he might regret that a little bit. Giselle was smart – she moved on with her life and seems super happy now. I think Leo is past his peak and will not age well. He seems intent on trying to prove something to himself and everyone else with all his young super-model girlfriends, but since Gisele they all just seem like cardboard cutouts that are inter-changeable. I respect Blake for recognizing that he wasn’t what she wanted, leaving and moving on.

    • Jegede says:

      Ooooooh!!!!! What did you see?
      I’ve heard about Leo in his ‘relationships’(a public girlfriend but scrweing around in private with naything that has a pulse) but never seen anything. Do tell!!!!!!!!

      • Annie says:

        After his first serious girlfriend and he broke up, post Romeo and Juliet, he became a very messed up guy. He took drinking, partying and drugs and became a notorious party beast, a-hole hooking up with every model and starlet you can think of (and a few older women like Demi Moore when she was still with Bruce!) There’s this infamous story on how he was being a drunk brat making his friends leave a house party, they wouldn’t listen and he started turning the lights off and on. Kate Hudson went up to him and made him stop, calling him out in front of everyone. It was like Entourage but with a-holes. His posse was insuferable.
        After Titanic, he was evwn worse. Google the NY Mag article “Leo, Prince of the city” so you see the kind of a-hole we’re talking about. While Kate Winslet loves him, Claire Danes says he was a pain to work with.

        He has dated women of color before but he hides them. He only goes out publicly with girls when they “fit the bill”: blonde, tall, supermodel.

        He’s superficial and he moves on fast. If there’s any talk of settling down he breaks up with them. He prefers them push overs and simple minded. He’s like intimidated by independent, strong women. That’s why he goes for the easily manipulated young girls. Creep.
        He cheats on everyone too. With Gisele, he was crazy about her like he has not been with anyone before. He was even very close with her family, and his folks met her folks. He really messed up big time but it was never meant to work because she’s of very strong character and cannot be pushed around. Though he did forbid her from talking about him when they were dating. And not just to the media, to anyone. Don’t talk about us, don’t talk about me.

        Generally, he’s not a very nice guy. I love his movies, I think he’s a great actor, but the way he has treated women has disappointed me deeply over the years. He’s going to be like Jack Nicholson. He wishes he was George Clooney, but he’s not as likeable and his looks are starting to go.

      • normades says:

        Leo is a jerk. There was that awful story how he and his crew sexually harrassed Elizabeth Berkly and beat up her boyfriend. He didn’t like getting “no” for an answer.,,703397,00.html

        Tobey has moved on and good for him…but he still has Lukas Haas and Blaine.

        And he’s an OK actor. Overrated imo. He tends to overact imo, particularily when developitheng a character like in Edgar or the Aviator. He keeps trying for an Oscar. Ain’t happening anytime soon imo.

      • TheOriginalKitten says:

        “He has dated women of color before but he hides them.”

        If this is true, he makes me sick.

      • Annie says:

        Oh yeah!! That Elizabeth Berkley story just shows you how far he and his gang went when Leo didn’t get his way. These are awful men. Tobey wasn’t always there for his antics. Glad he grew out if that stuff but the adduction to gambling, taught by Leo, remains intact.

        Funny how he gained so many fans by playing Jack Dawson. A nice, stand-up, humble, honest, romantic guy, when if Leo had been Jack Dawson on the Titanic he would’ve slept with Rose’s mom, Rose, the 17 y/o wife of the richest man in the ship, stolen the heart of the ocean and dress as a woman to get into the boats safely.

        I have many stories from people who ran into the same circles way back when. He told a guy I know that he had “gay man eyes” or that his eyes were gay, something dumb like that, because his eyes are this weird bright blue/violet wonder.

        And yes, he has dated women of color but you will never see him give them the place they deserve. He doesn’t want to be seen with them.

  14. Erinn says:

    I don’t know. I’ve NEVER liked ScarJo… she strikes me as a mean girl. The kind that thinks they’re so far above other people. Didn’t she get with Sean Penn or whoever reallyyyy quickly after Ryan?

    I could see her being territorial just because she thinks she’s so much better than Blake.

    Neither are great actresses in my opinion, but as bland as Blake is, she doesn’t bother me the way Scarlett does.

    • Hautie says:

      “I don’t know. I’ve NEVER liked ScarJo… she strikes me as a mean girl. The kind that thinks they’re so far above other people. Didn’t she get with Sean Penn or whoever reallyyyy quickly after Ryan?

      ….Neither are great actresses in my opinion, but as bland as Blake is, she doesn’t bother me the way Scarlett does.”


      So funny. I thought the same thing. Scarlett was all over Sean Penn. With all the PDA stuff. Getting photograph with her foot in his crotch. Who is she to say squat about anyone?!

      Then she got d.u.m.p.e.d. by Penn. Most likely for being dense.

      I have always been lost as to all the hype about Scarlett. I have always found her lacking in her acting.

      Plus she has always reminded me of Gwyneth/Goop. With the behavior of believing she better than everyone else in the room.

      So I prefer Blake, in this mean girl game. And I love it, that she has p*ssed off Scarlett.

      • TheOriginalKitten says:

        +1 to everything Hautie said, *if* the story is true, which it probably isn’t.

        For the record, can I just say that I HATE these fabricated cat fights? Maybe Scarlett hates Blake for marrying her ex-I would believe that-but the insinuation that Blake was actively trying to steal “innocent” Ryan makes me crazy. The dude is a MAN and he makes his OWN decisions. His d*ck belong to HIM and at the end of the day, it’s his choice where he decides to put it.

        I get so ANGRY at these dumb-ass stories that absolve the men of any responsibility in the decision-making process, as if they’re all victims of these women and their “wiley ways”.

      • Lamont says:

        This ^^^^^^^^^ Hautie
        Sean P dumped her and she expected Ryan R to be there to pick up the pieces. Fail
        I DO think she still loves him though. The interviews she gave Cosmo and Vogue this year made her regrets clear.
        Waves @Original Kitten.
        Always love what you have to say. Already hollered for you below.

    • stellalovejoydiver says:

      I like Blake better than Scarlett too, at least she doesn´t have this “I am too sexy, to be taken seriously as an actress” shtick. She seems more likeable and doesn´t mean girl other women when she´s around guys.

  15. Micki says:

    It’s such a silly game:what if that happened THEN..and if not?
    Scarlet wanted her freedom, got a divorce and if her married life with Reinolds was so bad as to leave him WHY on Earth should she think what might have happened so long ago?
    It’s his life now, his choice(phony or ot), suck it up and move on.

  16. SunKist says:

    Never trust the girls you get a bad feeling about when it comes to your man.

    My husband and I broke up while we were dating and lo and behold, he was hooking up with the girl he swore was never a threat/unattractive/obsessed with him a few weeks later.

    that being said, Scarlett broke up with him and jumped onto sean penn pretty quick so she needs to let those feelings die down quick.

  17. Lady_Luck says:

    Pot-Kettle. That is all.

    ScarJo does herself no favours by throwing these daggers. I’m no fan of blake’s at all, but something about Scarlett suggests she is even more phony than Blake, and she has a certain arrogant smugness about her which wins her no friends.

    Agree with Annie. It’s sad, horrific and true that men move on so quickly. Whilst women have the box of kleenex out and watching sad films, most men are already onto the next thing.

  18. mln76 says:

    I think Scarlett is a bit more talented than Blake and much more attractive (although she’s awkward has wonky legs etc).. but I think the marraige failed because she isnt really the stay at her hubby’s side stroking his ego type that Ryan needs. When they were together they were barely in the same city and there were rumors of infidelity on BOTH sides (she allegedly hooked up w/ Axel Rose EEEWWWW).
    Also at the Tonys didn’t she totally ignore him I think she name checked him but didn’t hug him and left him standing awkwardly with his arms out….Plus I think Scarjo lines skeazy ‘exciting’ men and RR bored her she’s just upset he moved on first because she’s lined up douche after douche but duhhhhh.
    Blake and Ryan fit in their blandness and he looks completely gone I give them a minimum 10 years.

    • Relli says:

      I agree with the the first paragraph of your post.

      I think the biggest demise of RR & Scarlett’s relationship was that she wasn’t willing to drop everything and just be his wife. Unlike Blake. Who according to her IMDB doesn’t have anythign coming up after GG ends AND skipped all the fashion shows this year in NYC, even though she suppose to be a fashion girl.

      For Blake marrying RR was a good move. She played it well; as the supportive friend before, wearing ALL WHITE to the premiers (so inserting that bridal look) of their movie and then getting the ring. For her this is going to be as good it gets, and when she named drop Kim Basinger as one of her Mom’s BFF’s I knew she was goign to go the same route, marry up and pop out a child for security.

      Playing by the “rules” is all good and will grab you the guy, however it doesn’t mean it make it stick…. i can think of another who played by those same rules and for years we thought they had the perfect golden-highlighted life. Until Maleficent appeared.

      Based on the recent photos of Scarlett I am sure it stings but i doubt she cares all that much.

  19. Bored suburbanhousewife says:

    I’ve only recently started following this. Could someone give me a synopsis of why Blake is regarded as famewhore, phony, etc?

    • Jegede says:

      Blake is no more guilty of things/rumor/innuendo that almost ALL of her peers are. It just ups your cool quotient to hate on her specifically. And boy does she deliver – never fewer than 60 comments of rage and you don’t have to go against the tide. Oh you get cookies and milk too.

    • mln76 says:

      She’s regarded as a famewhore because about 2 years ago Hollywood was touting her as an IT girl….she was on the cover of Vogue a couple of times and in some major movies but the girl simply can’t act and isnt that beautiful. People started wondering who she was screwing to get where she was rumors include Harvey Weinstien and Ben Affleck oh and Ryan Reynolds.
      The girl has famewhore game though.she leaked her own photos, she’s been in some high profile movies. She dated and appeared to dump Leo DiCaprio and then she landed Reynolds and is probably going to be Martha Stewart Jr.

      • TheOriginalKitten says:

        THANK YOU, Jegede!!

        Short answer: she does exactly what 90% of Hollywood actresses do-she talks about the same superficial junk (because people ask her the same redundant superficial questions), is seen as a “mediocre” actress (because HW is full of talent *eyeroll*) and dates within the industry (because she’s the FIRST actress to date a famous actor), plays the PR game like EVERY ACTRESS IN HOLLYWOOD DOES.
        But ultimately, it’s simply the “cool thing” to hate her.

      • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

        Sums it up pretty nicely. *Golf clap.*

    • Kimlee says:

      She dose have photographer Startraks take photos of her and Ryan and sells them to the media.

      Example the photo of her and Ryan kissing at her sisters Utah B&B was taken by a Startraks not the paparazzi, he also got pics os them coming back to NY. Funny how Startraks gets a lot of exclusives photos of Blake and Ryan.

  20. Madhubala says:

    I like Blake and I’ve warmed to Scarlett. I don’t think they need to be the 2nd coming of Meryl Streep in order for them to justify their existence as actresses. Scarlett used to be really good but her career has been meh of late. I don’t find Blake offensive onscreen like most seem to. She’s perfectly decent. Nothing wrong with that, in fact more power to her making a great living by being decent at something.

    Chances are Scarlett doesn’t think these things and this is just tabloids making ish up but in the event that she does, it would do her well to remember that she started dating Sean Penn (of all people) less than two months after her split with Ryan was announced. She didn’t seem broken up about it then so why cry foul now? No use crying over spilt milk.

  21. Bluedog says:

    There’s no way Scarlett still has to audition for things, so I don’t buy that part of the story at all.

  22. Chatcat says:

    The question is why does anybody care what ScarJo thinks of anybody? Here is one actress (cough cough) I’d say should be in 50 Shades…because she is about 50 shades of talentless and 100 shades of blah! Perfect casting imo.

  23. T.C. says:

    “Scarlett also considers Blake to be a cheap version of herself.”


    Ouch. Painful but true. Scarlett can act Blake mumbles. Scarlett doesn’t go out of her way for media coverage on her personal life, Blake is a big time famewhore. Nuff said total downgrade.

  24. Suzy (from Ontario, Canada) says:

    Oh please, after the way she acted? She’s just angry that Sean Penn threw her to the curb after a few weeks of fun. She humiliated Ryan and I doubt he was the one who cheated. I think if she’s bitter, it’s that he found someone that seems to suit him and he’s happy.

    Scarlet has always struck me as totally selfish and self-absorbed. I like Blake for Ryan and I think she’s much prettier than ScarJo. I know a lot of people hate her, but she seems sweet and a much better match for Reynolds.

  25. Dee Cee says:

    They both look in their mirror and say.. YESSS every time..

  26. Jegede says:

    Scarlett’s one to talk.
    Who goes on about artistic integrity and non commercialisation of her art while signing up for every house that waves a cheque in her face? Luis Vuitton, D &G, Moet, Mango
    Who is known for her pretension and cattiness towards other females?
    Who was playing footsie with Sean Penn before divorce papers were filed?
    Who was rumored to behave inappropriately with the very unavailable Liev Schriber during rehearsals?
    Then again this IS the Enquirer so its probably BS

  27. DD says:

    I don’t like either one of those girls, but, Ryan Reynolds is gross. They can both do better than him. Eww.

  28. Hmmm says:

    Ryan is not hot and he is kind of boring – Green Lantern i awfull, but I like him back in his tv-series days – he can’t carry a movie.

  29. Christina says:

    I have gone back and forth about how I feel about Scarlett. I used to like her but then thought she always sounded like an idiot on interviews. With that said she is WAY better than Blake. Blake is a terrible actress. Definitely seems like a phony and famewhore. He also seems like a jackass, a hot one, but a jackass for getting divorced and remarried so quick. Or at least it seemed quick…

  30. Aria says:

    In years to come we still will hear from Scarlett while Blake will probably have faded into oblivion or into a cable tv show.

    Scarlett might not be the best actress out there but she is willing to take chances and play edgy and different roles. Blake is becoming the next Martha Stewart with bolt ons..

  31. Talie says:

    I wouldn’t call Scarlett a famewhore at all. She seems to actively avoid attention.

    Also, Lainey has said multiple times that Blake was doing everything she could on that set to get on Ryan’s good side. Making him baked goods, setting up cooking classes for them. She’s a trick.

  32. ruby says:

    It’s funny because I consider neither of them have any acting talent and both have got so far with their looks. And I’m sorry but Blake does win out in the looks department.

    Scarlett’s star is fading, it’s not surprising that’s she’s jealous of the up and coming actress who has married her ex. But don’t worry, one day Blake’s star will fade too.

  33. Jess says:

    I like Scarlett, but for Ryan, I think Blake is a better match. He seems happy, where when he was with Scarlett, it’s like they were strangers. Blake will be a good wife, and probably a good mom for his kids, and Scarlett can continue being herself, artsy New York hip, and probably settle down when she’s well into her 30′s. They weren’t right for eachother. Ryan and Blake seem more apple pie and ball games. Scarlett, not so much.

  34. Cathy says:

    It’s the Enquirer, yeah, now I know it’s true.

  35. Shelly says:

    I like Blake. I dislike Scarlett. She is so far up her own ass, I just can’t stand her. As far as I’m concerned Ryan traded up.

  36. Lamont says:

    Team Blake all the way!

    Stories probably hash though.

    Original Kitten, Original Cammille where you at ladies?

  37. Bird says:

    I absolutely cannot stand Scarjo . She’s completely insufferable – full of herself, bitchy, and I get a really mean-girl vibe from her. She’s also a terrible actress. Blake is no Meryl Streep, but I love me some Gossip Girl and the girl’s got GAME.

  38. Kimlee says:

    I think this story is yet another BS story put out by the media to put two woman against each other.

    Same story different female celebrity

    Jennifer Hudson- Jessica Simpson

    Jennifer Hudson – Adele

    Jennifer Hudson any non thin female singer

    Pink – Christina Aguilera

    This list goes on and on with other female celebrity, and the media keeps making up these stories because people keep believing them.

  39. Jezi says:

    Um didn’t ScarJo date Sean Penn like 2 seconds after her and Ryan broke up? I don’t like Blake Lively and believe that she did cheat with Ryan but I don’t exactly see how Scarlett has any rights to talk about moving quickly.

  40. Barbara says:

    Ryan has a good body…but I cannot get past his close set beady little eyes…both girls could do better.

  41. Blue says:

    Wow, everyone is just believing this story. It probably stings that he remarried so quickly, but she ended it and he filed for divorce. I doubt she really cares. It seemed like she was “over” married life as soon as it happened. It is kind of awkward that their anniversary within a couple weeks of each other. But I think everyone is happy with the decisions they made.

  42. serena says:

    You can’t compare Blake and Scarlett. I agree with her for the ‘phony, fame monster, cheap version of Scarjo’. It’s totally true.

  43. d says:

    I don’t know why, but i like Scarlett, even if she can be insufferable. I kinda want to be like her big sister and smack her upside her head and tell her to focus on her career AND dump that PR/ad man that she’s dating. I DO think Scarlett’s got a certain something in the acting dept., she just needs to recalibrate her life and her career and find small good roles in independent films, do theatre and just focus on improving her skills, even broaden them. She really impressed me in Match Point. She’s not the best actress, but she’s got something to stay in the biz.

  44. savedbykittylitter says:

    Two words = team Scarlett

  45. Guest says:

    Although Scarlett’s opinion no longer matters. I suspect she did not share her it publicly.

  46. Emma says:

    The hate Blake gets is so transparent and sad. She hardly ever goes to events, is hardly ever papped, never says anything controversial for attention, doesn’t go out partying or anything. Her PR team does exactly what they are supposed to do (get her mag covers etc) and her PR team is just like the PR team of every actor in Hollywood. Why people act like Blake is some attention whore when she’s no different than anyone else is beyond me. Jealousy and to seem cool because you’re all mindless sheep, I assume.

    Newsflash, Lainey is a proven liar and has consistently been proved wrong on her theories about Blake. She has no insider knowledge. I’m embarrassed for the people that treat her blog like the damn bible.

    Another newsflash, Anna Wintour does not answer to anyone. She gave Blake the cover of Vogue twice because she wanted to. Get over it.

  47. Relli says:

    Hmmm some of you all might want to be careful how much your jumping up and down the page antagonizing anyone who doesn’t agree with you. Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion and besides we dont want to get a subject banned or limited posts (again) because y’all cant play nice and just enjoy the gossip buffet.

  48. Carla says:

    A man is not an inanimate object. You can’t steal him. Why women always blame the other woman instead of the man. It’s Ryan the one who swore to be faithful to her, not Blake.

  49. halle says:

    LOL She regerated she divorced him now that he found someone younger than her and for some part hotter?. She was so over him she thought she could do better but she finds out even Penn was not in to her. Now Rayan is married she is angry? somebody slap her please. I dislike women like this. Guess what you are easily replaceable deal with it and don’t distrube people relaitonship. You have your time. Btw I don’t even care about Blake Lively

  50. TheOneAndOnlyOnly says:

    Great comments all, and can’t do better than Chatcat, the originalkitten and shitler – the only reason I dislike Scarjo more is that she is dumb as a hairbrush and acts like she’s some Oxford intellectual Scarjo read some books, newspapers subscribe to some journals of opinion, at least Boobs Lively has no intellectual pretensions; BTW, who was the actress that had the lead role in The Town, way better than boobs lively but haven’t seen much of her?

  51. DB says:

    She had him, she let him go and then screwed Sean Penn.

    She has no standing from which to talk.

    Regardless of the situation with Blake, YOU BLEW IT GIRL – shut up and move on.

  52. whateveryouwantittobe says:

    Don’t really care but I don’t think it’s normal or acceptable for some hot single woman to suddenly befriend your husband and invite him to cooking classes, just the two of them. Of all the people you could take an interest in, why the married dude? She must have been ecstatic when they divorced. We have a new Julia Roberts of man stealing.

    Also, I can never take this girl seriously after that Tom Waits monstrosity. I thought she was great when she first appeared years ago but unfortunately there talent and on screen appeal (for me) is not there.

  53. FingerBinger says:

    This is the Enquirer we’re talking about. They get more stories wrong than they do right.

  54. Anna says:

    I have always disliked Blake for getting a nose job after she filmed that magic jeans movie. She looked beautiful and then ruined her face. famewhore

  55. Anna says:

    Is it me or does Ryan Reynolds seem like a serial marryer? Dude was engaged to Alanis and then married ScarJo a year later, then married Blake a year after his marriage to ScarJo broke up. I think he’s a dude that really likes getting married but doesn’t necessarily like being married.

    Also, yeah, Blake is pretty budget.

  56. Lena says:

    Dunno why people get so weird and worked up over these things.

    Blake is so much better looking than Scarlett, it’s surprising to me it’s even a discussion.

    I liked Scarlett in “Lost in Translation” and in “Match Point,” but somewhere along the way, she seemed to get a bit full of herself or something. I feel like I’m supposed to like her because she’s supposed to be a thinking girl’s girl. But she doesn’t seem to go very deep into any topic she discusses; it all stays at the superficial layer and is pretty rote. And it bugs me that she has cellulite and is never really in shape. And yet she’s a spokesperson for high fashion labels. Is that terrible of me to think?

    I get a bit tired of Blake’s 1950s apron in a kitchen bit (please let’s not go back in time and forget about feminism), but no one can deny the girl has hustle. And game.

  57. Lena says:

    Also, I find it really odd that there’s so much venom spewed over Blake. She seems pretty unassuming to me. She doesn’t do the whole clubbing scene. She seems to keep her head down and work. And yet people get really worked up over her. It makes me want to be friends with her and defend her from the haters.

  58. lola says:

    i don’t know if we should believe this story but all i can say is that scarlett looks beautiful.

  59. Jenn Bee says:

    Meh. Who cares about a bunch on nobodies who can’t open a movie on their own? Ryan is a second lead/buddy/ensemble, Scarlett couldn’t act her way out of a paper bag and Blake is a clothes hanger.

    Scarlett needs to get that tattoo removed, it’s so but ass ugly.

  60. LucyOriginal says:

    Both are pretty. But Blake is the fame hungry one. I always thought Scarlett is gorgeous, not a generic blonde, and she is one of the few actresses that can pull off any hair color (and still looks gorgeous). But she needs to work on her acting skills again.

    How can I not be Scarlett’s team? Look how cute is her interaction with Jeremy Renner:

  61. Truth Hurts Deal says:

    Seems like what happened is Blake tried to steal Ben from Jen but failed miserably; then she tried to steal Ryan from Scarlett & succeeded. She dropped Leo DiCaprio in the process( What a fool). Bottom line she was doing a bunch of men at the same time-typical talentless Hollywood Ho.

    • Fudge you, I'm going to Guam! says:

      *Sigh* She didn’t “drop” Leo. She just realized he was never going to marry her or even have a serious relationship with her.
      I’ve even read that he only “dated” her as a favor to give her publicity and made it seem like she was the one who dumped him in order to make her look better.

  62. Jay says:

    Blake is setting herself up to be Jen Garner pt.2, minus the film roles. Men like Ryan love having a wife to do the dirty work at home while they are on location cheating (yes, they were sleeping together at the end of filming GL & during the pr tour). Like the old saying goes, you lose them how you found them. Except Blake will be more concerned with trying to keep up the appearance of the perfect H-Wood wife & mom, with the white picket fence and will turn a blind eye. That’s what Ryan expected from Scarlett, along with not wanting her to go on Broadway, but she wasn’t having it. Remember her icy comment about her “Canadian” during the Tonys? No hug, no kiss, just an arm pat before accepting her award. Anyone heard Alanis’s song Torch that she won’t play anymore that’s about him? This guy’s got serious issues. ScarJo should be ecstatic she got away.

  63. dorothy says:

    The whole thing sounds like sour grapes to me. Scarlett didn’t want him, but didn’t want anyone else to have him either.

  64. Schnikes says:

    Watch Match Point hen try and convince yourselves ScarJo has talent. She has big tits, not acting talent….

  65. coco says:

    scarjo hating on blake only makes me like blake,I wonder why?

  66. sara says:

    No me creo esta noticia, está claro que se la han inventado diferentes medios, pero a parte de esto, si creo que Scarlett sospeche que Ryan le fué infiel con Blake cuando estaban rodando Green Lanter,de echo, creo que lo pensábamos todos y cuando empezaron a salir y la posterior boda… lo dejó claro.

    Team Scarlett