Sandra Hüller doesn’t even know if her ‘Anatomy of a Fall’ character is guilty

I binge-watched so many movies over the holidays and by far, one of my favorites was Anatomy of a Fall. It seems, at first, like such a simple premise: a woman stands trial, accused of murdering her husband by defenestration. But it’s a brilliant film for what we see and what we don’t see, for how the story unfolds, and for Sandra Hüller’s singular performance as the new widow accused of murder. Hüller has a second Oscar-bait film, The Zone of Interest, out right now but I haven’t seen it yet, but it’s been getting rave reviews for months. Anatomy, Zone and Hüller have all been picking up some critics awards and it feels like Hüller might actually be a contender.

So who is Sandra Hüller? She’s a 45-year-old German actress who has worked in Germany and France for much of her career, rarely even taking any kind of English-language roles. She’s now considered one of Germany’s top actresses, like Germany’s Meryl Streep or Cate Blanchett. About a month ago, Hüller spoke to Vanity Fair about Anatomy and finally “breaking through” to the American market:

Why audiences respond to Anatomy of a Fall: “It’s very much a film about the audience and what their perspective is on a successful woman, on a bisexual woman, on all these things and how the thoughts on her change with every information they get.” The actor herself felt that push and pull, asking [director Justine] Triet early on whether Sandra was guilty. Triet had no answer but asked that Hüller play her as innocent.

Hüller played her character as murky and secretive: “Actors like to do really big things sometimes, and they love emotions, and they want to show it—but in my experience, and maybe I’m the only one, normally people try to avoid that in their lives because it’s really painful. It takes a long time until somebody says, ‘Okay, this is enough, and now I’m going to scream at you.’”

Growing up in the small German town of Friedrichroda. “There was always a lot going on inside, and I didn’t really have a place to put it,” she says. It wasn’t just the ability to step into different roles, when she joined a drama club as a teenager, that felt so freeing. “I loved the way that we were talking to each other, the awareness that everybody had for each other, the kindness—the discussions we had about certain topics that I didn’t find anywhere else in my surroundings. It wasn’t common in my small town to speak about the things that were important to me, let’s put it that way.”

She doesn’t push herself to do roles that feel alien to her. “These are words that I really don’t have in my purse—I don’t use ambition, and I don’t use push—because they are really unfamiliar to me. I have colleagues that say that’s a lie: ‘You’re just lying. Everybody has it.’”

[From Vanity Fair]

Am I using this post to hype Hüller? For sure, I think she’s a big contender for an Oscar. But I also want to talk about Anatomy of a Fall – I want the discourse, because it was SO good and I still don’t know exactly what happened once the son left the house. SPOILERS!! The prosecutor was so evil and sexist, but he also failed to ask one of my first questions: if Sandra was listening to something with her earphones to drown out the sound of the “P.I.M.P” instrumental, how did she hear her son’s cries when he found the body? The other side of that is… if she killed her husband, I don’t think she would have wanted her son to discover the body. That being said, her husband was a complete douchebag and I would have been fine with it if she killed him! Sorry not sorry.

Photos courtesy of Avalon Red.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

13 Responses to “Sandra Hüller doesn’t even know if her ‘Anatomy of a Fall’ character is guilty”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Mego says:

    The first movie I saw with her was a movie about a young girl that gets exorcised by a priest somewhere in Germany. I have been following her since – she is so good. She deserves every price she will get. 🙂

  2. Lightpurple says:

    I’m so glad this film and Sandra are getting the accolades they deserve. It’s a fascinating film and all the performances are brilliant and deserving of recognition, especially the young actor playing the son and most especially, Snoop the dog

    • Twin Falls says:

      I loved this film (so much good hair), thought Sandra Hüller was phenomenal but also the little boy and, yes, the dog, too.

      The difference in a French courtroom where people just talk all over each other and sit stadium seating like was wild to me.

      That prosecutor made my blood boil.

  3. sunny says:

    Justine Triet (writer and director) has spoken pretty candidly that she wanted the death to be unclear to even the actors performing it. Though her slip up in her Globe speech pretty much gave it away. I also hadn’t realized that she wrote the film with her partner while they were in lockdown during the pandemic which I mean, a couple writing about a couple isolated and trapped and fighting. Lol.

    I think it is fascinating that almost every male critic I watch or follow interpreted it as a murder and I saw it as a suicide. I do wonder how gendered perspectives influence interpretation.

    Sandra is amazing in the film and i hope a lot of people see her work, especially Tori Erdmann.

  4. HandforthParish says:

    What was the slip up???? I find that film so fascinating.
    Guilty or not, the character’s detached callousness is chilling.

    • sunny says:

      In her Globe speech she talks about her and her partner thinking nobody would want to see this dark move about a couple fighting, a long trial, a suicide, etc.” She names it a suicide in the speech.

  5. CC says:

    Even if it wasn’t I. The courtroom itself, I’m pretty sure someone brings up the inconsistency of how she claimed to hear her son.
    Seems to be the unpopular opinion here, but I was disappointed in how dull I found this film.

  6. Lau says:

    I checked and apparently even if French officials didn’t submit the movie for “Foreign Language film” it can still get nominated for plenty of awards like Parasite was in 2020. I so hope it gets nominated just so that our governments officials have to congratulate the director and her crew through gritted teeth.

  7. Twin Falls says:

    She said in the movie that she was able to hear him because one of her ear plugs fell out while she was sleeping.

  8. Sankay says:

    I always feel that these foreign movies and their actors are overlooked because “Hollywood” is more interested in doing a U.S. version in the future. Ignore these fantastic foreign films and give them little recognition.

  9. East Villager says:

    I absolutely loved this movie. I thought the husband was such an an a-hole that he committed suicide fully aware that his wife might be charged with his murder, and not at all caring if his son found his body. Also, somebody better give Snoop an Oscar.

  10. H says:

    She is incredible in “Toni Erdmann” as was Peter Simonischek who played her father. I actually thought that I would die laughing. Or at least pee in my pants. The build up for the naked party took 2,5 hours but it was worth it.

  11. Blithe says:

    I thought Huller was great in I’m Your Man — a film that I liked enough to watch twice. Reading this post and the comments has nudged me to check out more of her work.