Mel Gibson’s ex-wife Robyn is on his side, says he never abused her or their kids

90419m6_gibson_b_gr_22

You know how the Mel Gibson tapes are just horrible, and each new day brings another hate-filled audio that just ruins your whole day? Except for yesterday’s tape which, while still disturbing, was actually pretty funny with the whole ““I deserve to be blown first before the F-CKING JUCUZZI! Okay, I’ll burn the f-cking house down!!! HOW DARE YOU?!!” and “Oh and earlier today – you said ‘Oh, nevermind’. WHAT THE F-CK WERE YOU GOING TO SAY?” Well, a lot of us were wondering “Gee, I wonder if Mel ever pulled that sh-t with Robyn?” Robyn, his first and only wife. Robyn, who he pretty much left for Oksana. Robyn, who stuck by him for 28 years and had seven of his children and could walk away with some kind of insane $400 million divorce settlement. That Robyn. Well, TMZ reports that Robyn has submitted a written declaration to the court on behalf of Mel – she says that he never hit her or the kids, and Mel was “a wonderful and loving father.”

Mel Gibson’s soon-to-be ex-wife, Robyn, has written a sworn declaration on behalf of Mel, saying he has never physically abused her or any of their children in the 28 years they were married … TMZ has learned.

We’ve learned in the declaration, Robyn writes, “Mel never engaged in any physical abuse of any kind toward me before, during or after our marriage.” Robyn also says there was never any domestic violence perpetrated by Mel against any of their children.

We’ve learned the declaration was filed with the court this morning. We’re told Robyn’s declaration will also be submitted to the L.A. County Sheriff’s Department when Mel’s lawyers present their evidence to deputies next week.

In the 1-page declaration, Robyn acknowledges that she is divorcing Mel but says, “Mel was a wonderful and loving father.”

Robyn — who is widely respected in Hollywood — could ultimately be very powerful ammo for Mel.

[From TMZ]

I’m here to nitpick. Okay, so Mel was never physically violent towards Robyn or the kids. I’ll buy that claim at face value, although I do think Robyn’s settlement money might have soothed any marital problems they once had. But sure, okay, Mel “never engaged in any physical abuse of any kind toward me before, during or after our marriage”. I will accept the idea that Mel never abused her or their kids, but I don’t think that means he DID NOT abuse Oksana. Plus, what about other kinds of abuse? Did he ever scream and yell and act insane and threaten people with guns? Oh, that’s right – he did yell and verbally abuse people when he was married to Robyn. “Sugartits” anyone? Furthermore – Mel was the one to leave Robyn for Oksana. If Robyn had left Mel, it might have been a different story. Because I think that’s what Oksana’s tapes show – Mel is like a baby, and he wants all of the attention all of the time, and when he doesn’t get it, he turns into a total freak.

MALIBU, CA - JUNE 10:  Actor Mel Gibson (R) and wife Robin (L) drink in a coffee shop after shopping on June 10, 2002 in Malibu, California. (Photo by Mel Bouzad/Getty Images)

90419m6_gibson_b_gr_02

Header: Mel and Robyn, circa 1986. Also, on April 19, 2009. Credit: Bauer-Griffin.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

119 Responses to “Mel Gibson’s ex-wife Robyn is on his side, says he never abused her or their kids”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Lem says:

    why is Robyn respected in Hollywood?

  2. Lee says:

    Yeah, she says no “physical” abuse. Sounds like splitting hairs to me. There are all kinds of abuse, and Mel seems to have perfected a few of them.

    Also, it’s possible his alcohol abuse has damaged his brain in a progressive way, and Robyn didn’t experience what Oksana has.

  3. MissyA says:

    I don’t buy this at all. She got paid off by his people.

    I don’t know whether to feel sad for Robyn or disgusted by her. A little of both.

  4. Kiska says:

    Maybe Robyn blew him on a regular basis. *sarcasm*

  5. greatgal says:

    I believe that Robyn is very clear with her statement…”saying he has never physically abused her or any of their children in the 28 years they were married”

    She never mentions any verbal abuse, does she? I am reading what she said, and more important what she did not say…

  6. Mistral says:

    Maybe he only physically abuses “whores”? That’s OK, then, right? Because sluts aren’t people and deserve everything they get! They are in an industry where they should expect to be disrespected and physically degraded/used/harmed. Gold diggers are glorified whores/prostitutes, so it is OK. And women who have stolen the husband of another of course bring this on themselves, because if the man is horrible to them, it is because he realizes what she has done to him—how she tricked him/seduced him away from his family and ruined his life. Demons need to be destroyed.

    This is what some looney tunes will be saying.

    I’m sure what Robyn says is true—he never PHYSICALLY abused any of them. She didn’t say anything about mental/emotional abuse, though. I doubt that Mel has been a peach to live with, since his alcoholism is well-documented. She probably wants people to know she wasn’t a battered woman. Obviously she’ll still have feelings for the man—he is the dad of her kids, and she must have loved him to put up with years of infidelity and drug/alcohol problems (looking at how ridiculously hot he was back in the day, and probably charming, it’s no wonder she would have fallen for him).

    It is really sad, this whole thing. And while gold digging/stealing husbands isn’t cool or good, and famewhores need to go away and stop talking shit and trying to foist their mediocre-looking, untalented selves on the wider public, and celeb mistresses need to stop making bank from selling their tales to tabs (these apply to any of the parade of women we’ve been reading about on this site recently), no one deserves domestic abuse. Mel needs to save himself. For his own sake, and the sake of his family.

  7. jane16 says:

    I’m not buying it, and I’m disappointed in Robyn. She should have just butted out. Maybe she’s pissed at Oksana, I don’t know, but its generally accepted throughout the people who work in H’wood (I have a husband, friends, neighbors & family members who work for various studios) that Mel is a total a**hole who has treated everyone in his orb terribly, Robyn included. People were happy for her when she finally escaped, but maybe for her, she put a higher value on being married to an A lister or staying married for the kids. Also, there’s the line of thought that abused people will often stay with their abusers, and not blame them for anything. Ted C. wrote on his column yesterday that everyone in H’wood knew that MG is a beast.

  8. Sudini says:

    I’m sorry, but this is also coming from a woman who put up with ALOT of Mel’s sh*t for many, many years. She seems to have an unhealthy habit of just giving him a ton of leeway and excusing him way too much.

    The tapes show (as does his history with the cops, etc.) that he is (at the VERY least) controlling, and verbally and emotionally abusive. And he also basically admits to hitting Oksana (ie. “you deserved it!”).

    Robyn, girl, stop protecting this turd.

  9. Maddie says:

    I read on another board and believe it or not, sometimes this does happen, the wayward husband also known as the cheater ,has never hit his wife, him leaving the marriage and hooking up with the other woman there sometimes seems to be a hidden underlying anger in the choices that were made by him and who else is he going to blame for shi*tting on his marriage, his ex is no longer there, and he is not going to blame himself for his misery, (narcissist never do) so it must be the one who made him leave his marriage, the other woman.

  10. Annie says:

    And the beat goes on.

  11. jane16 says:

    I don’t know that I would say Robyn is “respected” in Hollywood. I’ve heard a lot of people say they felt sorry for her, being married to MG, but never heard anyone talk about her as though they respected her.

    Another point, in a lot of pix of the two of them, Robyn looks like Mel. Maybe he’s not just a psycho, but a narcissist as well.

  12. K-MAC says:

    not buying a word of it….not one word.

  13. audrey says:

    no wonder he’s so aggro.. his looks are shot.

  14. RobN says:

    I tend to believe her. I think there’s a good chance that Mel finally woke up to the fact that he threw away his family for a golddigger jumping on the baby gravytrain. He just isn’t capable of handling it and there’s no going back. I think it’s a combination of alcohol, panic and frustration that didn’t exist when he and Robyn were married.

  15. lucy2 says:

    I think it’s telling that it repeatedly specifies “physical”. That’s what’s being investigated, but the letter would have been an opportunity to try to discredit the verbal abuse as well.
    Robyn’s probably looking out for her own kids mental well being, which I can’t blame her for – but I hope she’s not lying to protect MG.

    And I totally agree that what happened with one woman could be totally different than what happened with the other. Some people bring out the worst in each other, and especially so if there’s alcohol or other stuff going on too.

  16. Kiska says:

    Notice how Robyn worded her statement:
    “Mel WAS a wonderful and loving father.” Past tense. He IS still a father, albeit, a crappy one.

    Also, she made no mention of verbal/emotional abuse.

    She’s covering her ass.

  17. lrm says:

    Why did she word it ‘Mel WAS a wonderful loving father’?
    WAS? Isn’t he still their father, and aren’t some of them still young-ish?
    How odd.

  18. aenflex says:

    I’m sorry, I don’t buy it. I have heard the tapes. Someone with the anger, insecurity and control issues like Mel, they don’t just turn that way overnight. Now maybe Robyn was a softer, more patient, more subservient and non-opinionated woman than Oksana. Maybe Robyn never crossed him, and blew him BEFORE the jaccuzi every time, I don’t know. But someone as angry and vile as Mel has certainly behaved this way in the past, and I bet Robyn’s seen that from him as well as her kids…

  19. tiki says:

    this is going to blow (no pun intended) wide open. people will be stunned when the court issues its findings.

  20. mary says:

    Robyn may be fearful of retaliation from Mel if she doesn’t do what he and his people tell her to do. What do you think would happen if she refused to release a statement appearing to support Mel? She would be a recipient of the same kinds of harassment, abuse and threats that Oksana is being subjected to. If Robyn were to tell the truth about living in “Mel-Hell” it would only help Oksana, anyway, whom I am sure Robyn has no love for. Robyn is probably relieved to be rid of Mel, and doesn’t want his sick, twisted attentions turned back on her again, so she gave the statement to keep him off her back. I do not find Robyn’s statement credible – I think she felt pressured to make it.

  21. The_Porscha says:

    Even taken at the most optimistic, which reads Robyn’s statement at face value and assumes it all to be true, it still has no bearing on Oksana’s relationship with Gibson, as Kaiser points out. Even if Robyn is being 100% accurate (as some, I’m sure, are hesitant to believe), it means nothing on the question of whether or not Mel Gibson hit or otherwised abused Oksana Gregorieva. Period.

  22. popcorny says:

    The more I hear and the more this is drawn out, the more I feel bad for Mel.
    Not blaming Ox, not absolving Mel or relieving his responsibility, but he’s in (and has been) in crisis -and as much as some would like to deny it, he’s a human being.
    Imprint my name on your toilet paper or insist I must be a fellow abuser, whatever you feel … but I cannot hate him or persecute him, I’d sooner give him a hug and/or try to help him get better.
    I don’t think he’s a racist, I think he’s rabidly saying the most hateful and ugly things he can (for effect) think of to compensate for his intense anger and is deliberately eschewing holding back.
    Basicly, if it were to be taken literally -he hates everything. And in those moments (that he spews off like a volcano) he no doubt does hate everything and he becomes self destructive as a form of self loathing.
    Ox is fine, she will get paid.
    Mel isn’t fine, he needs help, he’s in crisis.
    His exhibited situation/behavior is, by far, not unique -and it is most certainly able to be helped and/or treatable.
    He’s not done for, or written off, by me.
    I’d like to see him get better and become a better person.

  23. leo says:

    i think every one just wants to sound righteous ! clearly no woman should go near mel now, he has been on a downward spiral for few yrs

    oksana does, has a baby, at the very first instance of abuse she doesnt walk away or report him to police, she coolly talks back to him and records the whole thing for months

    he was a once decent husband/father/actor who is facing tough times and this woman is exploiting that

  24. di butler says:

    I take it a different way. I’m sure he was an asshole at times during his marriage to Robyn, but I think he realized he threw his life and rep away when he hooked up w/ Oksana then realized she was a golddigging ho, and that pushed his normal nuttiness into full blown creep.It’s like she was fuel for his fire. He sounds like he is having a complete mental breakdown on those tapes. Dayum.

    He was good looking back in the day, though.

  25. carrie says:

    she had a different relationship with him and he was a loving dad…now he has/had a nasty relationship with his ex-girlfriend

  26. Crash2GO2 says:

    “Notice how Robyn worded her statement:
    “Mel WAS a wonderful and loving father.” Past tense. He IS still a father, albeit, a crappy one.

    Also, she made no mention of verbal/emotional abuse.

    She’s covering her ass.”

    I agree. That letter buries him without her saying anything, to anyone who reads carefully…

  27. Ron says:

    I have an exboyfriend from years ago and if he was being tried in the press like this for abuse, I would not hesitate to make an immediate public statement to the contrary, even though we are not close at this point. This is a very carefully worded “declaration” and would not label her a liar under oath. She also has a 400 million dollar settlement on the line here.

  28. ,,,, says:

    Personally, I never let Mel Gibson ruin my whole day. While I would never support what he has done and thus will no longer support his career, his actions certainly don’t have the power to ruin my day.

    Also, someone above mentioned that people don’t just become this way (abusive, crazy, threatening) and I would sort of beg to differ. If you watch the show Intervention you can see people who were very kind and loving morph into monsters because of addiction.

    Of course that addiction never justifies their actions but I think it is possible that Mel’s alcoholism has changed him. Again that’s not an excuse by any means but it is a possibility.

  29. Kitten says:

    I doubt he would pull any crap with Robyn ! She was his wife not some whore he knocked up ! I doubt Mel beat his girlfriend ! I think she set him up .

  30. Zelda says:

    @kiska

    ahahahahahhahahahahahah.

    She keeps stressing “physical” abuse, and that he was a “wonderful father”.
    By that definition, he could’ve treated her exactly as we hear on the tapes and she’s still not lying.

    People do not turn into ranting emotionally abusive c*cks overnight. And one bad relationship sure as hell isn’t going to do it…

  31. JM says:

    I’m with Maddie & RobN on this one.

    It’s obvious Mel is a raging alcoholic who took a serious downward spiral in the last few years. He had a very public (and stupid) arrest, and threw away his marriage for a wierdo. Now he’s mad at himself for f’g up his life, and Oksana’s the one he took it out on.

    Not saying it’s ok – it’s not – just saying it’s a huge leap to assume he treated his wife the same way.

  32. YT says:

    It could be that Robyn is telling the truth, but she was married to him for a long time and perhaps ruled the roost at home. She knew he could be a jerk, but she could control him at home and ignore any antics he pulled in public. There are plenty of jerks in this world whose husbands or wives accept them for what they are and make things work.

    As far as “well-respected”, she is not crazy like Mel, she is not an attention-seeker like so many, probably not a diva, and she maintains a somewhat normal lifestyle even though she has access to millions of dollars.

  33. Right....? says:

    I totally agree with you Popcorny. You make complete sense. Anger, anxiety, frustration, lonliness, depression, etc. can all make a person say and do horrible things.

  34. Anti-icon says:

    Great now Robyn gets to bashed. Why should Robyn NOT be believed? She has been a class act all her life.

  35. LOVE ANGELINA says:

    I gotta agree Kaiser with what you said. 100%

  36. OC lady says:

    I call BS. I don’t believe Mel became this abusive overnight. His past drinking problems were well documented.
    I bet he became like this anytime he had too much.

    Robyn is probably protecting herself. She might have signed an agreement to not discuss the marriage. If she does tell all, it could be bye-bye $400 million. She wants to stay out of it by pulling the “I don’t know that Mel” card.

    She might get dragged into court if there’s a criminal trial, though. At that point, she will be forced to tell the truth. Either way, I feel bad for her–just when she thought she was free . . .

  37. cat5 says:

    Sounds like the “well you slept around before, so you couldn’t have been raped” mentality, just warped around. I hope she’s telling the truth and she didn’t have to live with that. Ugh. But as for him abusing Oksana it is completely irrelevant. Just shows he didn’t abuse Robyn (maybe). Lucky her.

    My own little outsider opinion forming is that Mel is upset over his divorce and blaming Oksana. Maybe he realizes losing his wife of almost 30 years was not what he wanted. But instead of accepting his own mistakes, he’s placing it all on the girlfriend who is caught in his mid life meltdown. And $400 million, holy Jesus. I thought he was ranting about being broke? God this guy is a tool in every way. He’s a 50 year old child.

  38. albeli says:

    Robyn says there was no *physical* abuse–that doesn’t preclude verbal or emotional abuse.

  39. Jeri says:

    Robyn probably wants this circus to end to protect her childrens’ dignity & privacy. I’m sure they are all being questioned about life with Mel. It put all of them in a bad light to be related to him.

    I’m sure she has no love for her temporary replacement either.

    It’s hard to quit protecting someone (from theirself) after all those years.

  40. London says:

    This is exactly why it was smart of oksana to tape Mel. If, without the tapes, she claimed that Mel was a verbally abusive lunatic, his ex-wife refutes those claims, who would believe her? Some might say, “yeah, he was drunk when he was spouting off about Jews and women with sweet breasts, but he was plastered when he said that”!

    A few years back, Oprah had a mom on her show that had been verbally and physically abused by her husband for years. This husband even went so far as to have their son VIDEO TAPE his mom being beaten and verbally assaulted (by the husband). A lawyer on the show stated that even with that video, the husband would have only gotten a simple assault charge and probably no jail time. What got him thrown in jail was the the wife’s boss. Every time the wife went in to work bruised and broken, the boss took note of it. She kept a journal for a while before finally convincing the wife to go to the police. Without continued documentation, the husband would have walked. So taping a raging lunatic isn’t a bad idea when domestic violence is involved.

  41. Cruisin Through says:

    I believe Robyn for the most part. I don’t think Mel ever respected Oksana and this rage is fueled by the fact that he’s going to get taken to the cleaners by this gold digger.

    That said, it excuses NONE of what he’s done. Lesson here: Mel, you should have kept it in your pants and none of this would have happened.

  42. Squirtle says:

    Exactly Leo!!!

  43. Madison says:

    Thankyou Robyn. This is how this whole sordid mess should have been handled from the start in the courts not through Radaronline or TMZ.

    I’m not surprised that Team Oksana don’t believe Robyn. I don’t think she would be making this statement in court if Mel was in any way abusive towards her as he has appeared to be on Oksana’s tapes.

  44. Disco says:

    @Mary…I cosign everything you said. I think she’s still scared and probably doesn’t want him to turn his attention to her when she’s this close to freedom.

  45. lucy2 says:

    ,,,, if the alcoholism was something new, if he’d never had a drinking problem until recently, I’d be more inclined to think that was the reason. But I’m pretty sure he’s been battling that demon for decades, so if that’s the root of it, I would image Robyn saw some effects of it.
    I agree with The Porscha – unless a prosecutor were to try to paint him as a repeat offender, what he did or didn’t do in the past has no bearing on what he has or has not done here.
    For the record, I don’t know if he did physically abuse her, no proof of that has come to light yet. But the tapes are enough for me to believe he was emotionally and verbally abusive towards her, and the sort of things said give insight into his character, and that’s enough for me.

  46. Uzi says:

    There is a very well-balanced article in the new PEOPLE that addresses some of the things you’re all commenting about. Some of Mel’s friends/acquaintances/business associates are quoted (anonymously, of course, and I think this is because of the ongoing legal situation). The consensus is that Robyn knew how to deal with Mel, and that his post-2006 DUI/rant downward spiral intensified after their separation and divorce filing.

    I too noticed that the statement denied physical, but not verbal abuse. Mel’s known for being hot tempered, and I’m sure Robyn and the children endured plenty of his tirades. I had a childhood friend whose father had similar bi-polar issues, and was even briefly institutionalized. Her mother was a Robyn Gibson type, the glue that held the family together. Everyone learned how to cope with the situation, and this was back in the 60’s when mental illness was swept under the rug and was not understood as well as it is today. I played with the children and was in and out of the house, and never observed any signs of physical abuse – cuts, bruises, broken bones – on the mother or any of the four children.

    My heart aches for those of you that have experienced abuse first hand, and I apologize if any of my comments have offended you. I am trying to educate myself about this horrible situation. But please, stop projecting your own experiences upon the Gibson family. It’s entirely possible that when Robyn swears that Mel never physically abused her she’s telling the truth. I would also ask you to please try to educate yourself about mental illness and alcoholism the same way I’m trying to learn about domestic abuse.

    Thank you.

  47. Crash2GO2 says:

    I sort of know what you mean popcorny. Believe me, I struggle with not letting pity overwhelm my survival instincts when it comes to my abusers. That is part of what makes me such an easy target. Knowing that THEY are sick, that theoretically, THEY cannot help themselves, and when they fall apart you see what a mess they really are on the inside and a kind hearted person wants to help.

    But trust me. You don’t want to feel sorry for someone like Mel, or try to help him, because he is absolutely not trustworthy and would sooner gouge your eyes out after you pull him from the ravin, than to thank you and change his ways. In fact, all of his problems would now be all YOUR fault and be a direct result of everything you have done to him even if it was something as insignificant as liking his acting (yes these people really are this screwed up).

    If he truly is at the end of his rope, he can get his own damn help if he really wants it. Or thinks he needs it, which most of these abusers will never admit to.

    Don’t fall for his ‘poor pitiful Mel’ cr*p. My ex used to cry on the phone to the guy I was dating after I left him. I told my new boyfriend not to fall for it. He was amazed at how quickly the tears dried up when he wouldn’t show sympathy, but rather remained neutral. My ex changed tactics in a heartbeat right in the middle of a phone call! It’s all about manipulation. It’s the only way they know how to survive and it is deeply ingrained. Fortunately you are probably safe, since I assume you aren’t going to be going on dates with Mel any time soon.

    If you are, then we will have to stage a pocorny intervention!

  48. katyalia says:

    You guys have already said everything here… the specific term ‘physical’ is quite telling, etc.

    So, has anybody ever noticed how much Robyn looks like Brenda from Six Feet Under?
    Kiska is probably right – BJ, then off to the jacuzzi with a bottle of whiskey and Robyn had a quiet night. (Sorry, that was in really bad taste, I know. But after 5 days of Gibson’s revelations I feel as if my brain has been soiled.)

  49. margaret says:

    people change. my ex does stuff I never would have believed when we were married or directly after we separated. but now it is like he is a different person. even more different than the person I divorced. and if mel is a drinker (as my ex is) then I can easily believe that he has changed since his marriage to his first wife.

  50. onyx says:

    wow, could you have found any more unflattering photos of her?

  51. Sudini says:

    @Madison & Leo (and all of the “she’s just a gold digger/I don’t condone abuse, but..” people):

    The people supporting Oksana throughout this aren’t as much “Team Oksana” as they are more Team “Go f*ck yourself, Mel, for being an abusive POS!!”

    It’s so disconcerting when people can be handed this kind of taped evidence, and STILL find a way to side with the abusive person/man.

    The same kind of divide happened with the Tiger cheating scandal, and with the Jesse/Sandra Bullock scandal. Some people insisted on trying to blame the wife for having been cheated on and lied to!

    There are just some people (men and women alike) who love to blame women and excuse the man no matter what they do.

    And to reiterate the point made above, whether Mel was abusive in his previous marriage should have NO bearing on the present abuse case. However it’s already working to serve as a diversion from the current reality unfortunately.

  52. guesty says:

    was hoping she would add her 2 cents however this isn’t about her relationship.

  53. irishserra says:

    Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Mel cheat on his wife throughout their entire marriage, even to Robyn’s knowledge? I thought I remembered hearing such throughout the ’90s. That eliminates my respect for her right there. Her defense of him is worthless.

  54. angelika says:

    Robin sure saying the truth ..Mel is abuser,but he is smart abuser..Why would he do it to his wife during their life together? It would trigger a divorce,loss of his fortune, this woman is not long suffering wife,she is very shroud business woman who controls most of his assets..They are a team..They are partners..And who is Oksana? Russian immigrant without connections or resources..Mel’s male chauvinism dream come true..This says a lot about him as a person, he is not only an abuser,but he is a coward.. And how cruel of him to mention her son name in such a way?To say she is an excuse for a mother,Oksana i bet is a very good mother,and she has much more class then this two strange hypocrits

  55. Bec says:

    So, what is she saying? This must be Oksana’s fault? The chick may be a gold-digger, but no one deserves to be abused.

  56. OC lady says:

    “I’m not surprised that Team Oksana don’t believe Robyn.”
    __________________________________________
    Excuse me, I’m not Team Oksana as much as Team “I don’t condone the verbal or physical abuse of others” and Team “I don’t make excuses for abusive people,” thank you very much. 🙂

  57. Linda says:

    Apparently Robyn blew him before the jacuzzi and shut up.

  58. KsGirl says:

    [quote]Imprint my name on your toilet paper or insist I must be a fellow abuser, whatever you feel … but I cannot hate him or persecute him, I’d sooner give him a hug and/or try to help him get better.
    I don’t think he’s a racist, I think he’s rabidly saying the most hateful and ugly things he can (for effect) think of to compensate for his intense anger and is deliberately eschewing holding back.[/quote]

    You know, Popcorny, this is a pretty close description of my ex when he would get this way. He would deliberately say the most destructive things he could about me, my life and our relationship. It wasn’t an accident, it was on purpose, and in my quieter moments with him I would feel something like you describe here – a kind of pity for him, a sorrow that a human being could be so destructive to others and to themselves (because ultimately, the ex’s behaviour hurts him more than it hurts anyone else who ends up leaving him – i.e. he can’t leave himself).

    But at the same time, he wasn’t behaving that way to an inanimate object. He was saying those things to a human being, just as sensitive and worthy of respect as any human being. I don’t fully understand compassion for Mel without compassion for Oksana. Nobody ‘deserves’ to be on the receiving end of these insane, destructive rages.

    Would you feel differently if someone spoke that way to your sister, or your mother? Would that be OK? People who think Oksana ‘deserves’ this, I’d just like to know why she deserves it. How does that work? What abour personal responsibility? At what point does someone become not-responsible for what they say or do? Would you buy “but she provoked me” from someone who treated someone you loved this way?

  59. mary says:

    I think the only blowing Robyn (and Oksana, for that matter) want to do now is to blow out of Mel’s life!

  60. Cheyenne says:

    Oh, right. So Oksana is the villain in this mess?

    Sorry, Robin, but you’re FOS.

  61. juliana says:

    I was an abused wife for several years. I did divorce him and carry on with my life.

    But something about this whole situation just doesn’t feel RIGHT to me.
    I’m not saying Mel was a perfect gentleman or Oksana a perfect angel, but the way she sounds on those tapes just makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up.

    Something stinks here, and I think it’s coming from Oksana.

  62. popcorny says:

    *waves a yellow and red flag before Crash* … lol, thanks for the concern and possibility of an intervention (as I do like parties and social gatherings of most any kind) but being a heterosexual man I can assure you that if I were to hug Mel there would be no cause for concern -or condoms (let alone an intervention to save me from being his next “sugar-tits” or “sugar-moobs”).
    My concern (for Mel, as a person) is genuine and not of a latent lustful nature. When I am done laughing, I am going to crawl under my desk and blush for a while … please excuse me …
    ;^)

  63. Well said Uzi.

    —-

    She “should have butted out”… are you kidding? This is the father of her seven children and husband of over 25 years. Of course Robyn worded things carefully, but people, don’t bash her for choosing to protect her children from all these allegations about their household. Sheesh!

  64. flourpot says:

    Tho I don’t think Osk is a textbook case of “Golddigger”, I do think that @RobN completely nailed it. Well said.

  65. mimi says:

    I kind of know someone sorta similar to Mel. My take is his wife was the kind of woman who would do anything to keep the family together. (It was only when the mistress was knocked up that she filed for divorce.) She was not career oriented…totally 100% family. She deferred to him, had a strong moral compass that he respected even tho he didn’t always honor it. This was the only relationship he knew. Then they got older and he wanted to trade in his wife for a younger, hotter model. But, younger hotter model was *nothing* like what he was used to being treated like in his previous 28 yr relationship. The reality of his choice hits him like a brick..can’t take it – plus new younger model doesn’t know how or care to manage/deal with his alcoholism/bipolar disorder. Losing his looks as well as his security (wife,kids)..perfect storm.

    Paul McCartney had a similar experience. Had an adoring wife for 20+ years. Thinks that’s normal or because of *him* and marries a much younger babe…surprise!! These men are so stupid

  66. GatsbyGal says:

    No one a perfect gentlemen with one partner and then a crazed, abusive asshole with the next. It simply doesn’t happen. He was like this before and I do not believe Robyn at all.

  67. Morgs says:

    Popcorny you’re a guy? I love that guys comment here!

  68. Lucinda says:

    I knew a woman once who was married to a man for years and he was a wonderful husband. Then he had some sort of trauma (physical but I can’t recall what it was) and he had a complete personality change. He became abusive and violent and she filed for divorce and feared for her life and the lives of her children. She mourned the man she loved but feared the man she was now married to. It was really weird. I wonder if something like that happened to Mel?

  69. Whatev says:

    –But something about this whole situation just doesn’t feel RIGHT to me.
    I’m not saying Mel was a perfect gentleman or Oksana a perfect angel, but the way she sounds on those tapes just makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up.–juliana

    I concur. The tapes seem VERY selective as if she knew how to pull his strings and get him to a point where he would lose it. This is a man whose star has fallen and never recovered. This is a man who lost the woman he was married to for his entire professional life. This is probably a man who associated his self-worth as a person with his career.

    Yes, he is not a perfect person. No one is. Ask the average American how they feel about Islam and they would likely respond similarily to how Mel referred to Jews a few years back. Not all, of course, but there are some Americans who dislike people simply because they have a different skintone.

    Mel has issues and they probably started with the release of his tirade a few years back that pretty much destroyed his career. In the process, it contributed to destroying the person.

    Take any person from any walk of life and take away what is most important to them and how they see their placement in the world. Take away the child of a woman who only associated her self-worth as a mother. Take away the job of a workaholic man who defines himself with his job. Take away the clothes of a teenager and watch the temper tantrum start.

    Mel Gibson is a man on the edge. The one who is pushing him off the cliff is Oksana. And, until I see physical proof of abuse (and not only verbal tirades) I will not believe anything the woman says. I think it is an excuse to cash in. Another mistress wannabe.

  70. JM says:

    Why say Robyn is butting in? I’d bet my bottom dollar she didn’t just decide one morning to up and write a letter. She was probably served with an affadavit or something, and responded accordingly.

  71. Crash2GO2 says:

    Hahahaha!!! popcorny, I love it that you’re a dude! Crawl on out from under that desk!

    Seriously though, as pitiful a person as Mel is, pity is wasted on such as he, and in fact would incite his rage. He might start asking you if you were a Jew. Gack

  72. Shy says:

    Well… There are two kinds of abused women. The ones like Robyn who tolerate and when he hits her – she covers him up and thinks that it is her fault. And the ones like Oksana who won’t stand it and leave. There is no way that Gibson didn’t treat his wife like that. She has kids with him, business, she doesn’t want to be labeled as “beaten and abused woman”. She is religious wright? What they should do call her up in the court. Not the silly letter. She should raise her hand and put another on the bible and say it before God. If she is religious then i don’t think she would be able to lie.

    And many people say that Mel is a serial cheater… Well should we then expect his mistresses to come out any day? Like they did with Tiger and Jesse James. Wouldn’t it be fun if they would come out and say he beat and abused them too.

  73. Ruffian9 says:

    Well said Sudini…a voice of reason & sanity.

    Whether or not she’s a so-called ‘gold digger’ (if he really thought so, maybe he should have kept it in his pants) is IRRELEVANT to the abuse (be it verbal or otherwise). IRRELEVANT. This constant blaming of the victim/removing blame from the perpetrator (the ‘poor Mel’ approach) pisses me off to no end. There are NO excuses for this behavior. Seriously people.

    Popcorny, you’re a FAR better person than I. I might consider hugging Mel (shudder), if only to better position myself to knee him in the groin. Hard. Repeatedly.

  74. Whatever says:

    How did he leave his wife for Oksana? From what I understood, she had enough of the drinking and embarrassment four years ago and left him. Even if you go with Oksana’s 3 years, they were still split for a year before he hooked up with Oksana.

    I think her testimony will help in the custody part, but not in the domestic violence issue.

  75. Cheyenne says:

    Robin reminds me of the wife who tells everybody she got her black eye from walking into a wall.

  76. Sincerity says:

    @Uzi

    I hear you. Consider it done! The question has been asked and Mrs. Gibson answered. At this point, Oksana is all by her little lonesome. If she actually has a case, it will have to be proven in a “court of law” not the public arena. Oksana started this ball rolling and she’ll have to live with the consequences.

  77. Anti-icon says:

    #72 Shy: How can you possibly maintain that you have compassion for victims of abuse; and then you turn around and call Robyn Gibson a liar. She said Mel never abused her. In plain English. It is really offensive to me that you call her a victim of abuse. It seems to further your agenda, whatever that is.

  78. Carey says:

    I just realized how like King Henry the 8th this all is. Robyn is like Queen Katherine, who called the king husband when he was young, sexy, and virile; and he sets her aside for Anne Bolyn…the seductress. He grows fat and piggish, and we all know Ann’s fate, do we not?? (she was beheaded, for all those who aren’t as geeky about history as I)

  79. Marsh says:

    It doesn’t matter if he physically abused the ex-wife or not. It only matters that he abused his girlfriend. It’s irrelevant. He admitted to knocking out her teeth and said she deserved it. Doesn’t get any clearer than that. The ex-wife is not credible. She has a motivation to help him because it could affect her settlement, she might be entitled to a percentage of future earnings, she might’ve simply been paid off to do that declaration, or maybe their kids asked her to do it. She also might enjoy sticking it to the girlfriend. It’s pretty disgusting that she would do this declaration. Even if it mattered, she could be lying or parsing words, maybe he made threats and psychological abuse

  80. ERM says:

    Wow, I’m surprised at how many people are claiming that Robyn is doing this for the money or is mad at Oksana. Why does she have to attacked for Oksana’s story to be true? Why all of the snide comments and second guessing? Maybe Mel didn’t abuse her (in any form) during their relationship – end of story. It’s a different picture with Oksana and she has the tapes as proof. Why can’t they both be right?

  81. Cheyenne says:

    @Sincerity: are you saying the tape is fake? He’s on tape not only admitting, but bragging he beat Oksana up because “she f*cking asked for it.” Oksana isn’t in this alone by a long shot. You can stick a fork in Mel, he is done.

  82. Paula says:

    “I will accept the idea that Mel never abused her or their kids, but I don’t think that means he DID NOT abuse Oksana.”

    Yup. Robyn is highly qualified to testify as a character witness, but her testimony does not trump other evidence. People do sometimes treat one partner differently from another.

    “Wow, I’m surprised at how many people are claiming that Robyn is doing this for the money or is mad at Oksana. Why does she have to attacked for Oksana’s story to be true? Why all of the snide comments and second guessing? “

    Hear, hear. Robyn and Mel were married for decades. I’ve not heard of any rumors much less seen any evidence like pap photos to suggest that Robyn was physically abused. Claims that Robyn might have endured abuse and is keeping quiet for the money are pure speculation.

  83. Kim says:

    She says Mel didnt physically abuse her or ths kids she says nothing about verbal abuse. You know darn well that violent, alcoholic verbally abused her MANY times.

    She hates Oksana – do you think even if she was abused she would give the other woman any leverage. I doubt it but he may not have abused Robin- still doesnt mean he didnt abuse Oksana.

  84. Maritza says:

    Robyn is not lying he never physically abused her, he only abused her verbally and emotionally that’s all.

  85. Anti-icon says:

    “Claims that Robyn might have endured abuse and is keeping quiet for the money are pure speculation.”

    Not just speculation, but a form of ABUSE, to be calling her a liar amidst all these REAL abusers and liars and extortionists, I just can’t understand why now a lot of people on this board are calling Robyn an abused wife AND a liar.

    Get a grip people. The inability to see beyond black and white is a form of mental disintegration. It’s called splitting. Based on many of the posts, I’d say there’s a lot of mental disintegration going on up in here.

  86. ZBB says:

    perhaps to sort of understand a tiny bit of the mentality and conduct of Mel would be to understand how it is that an Alcoholic behaves. In fact, AA literature talks about this one factor a lot..even for kids who grew up in an Alcoholic or abusive home..whether physical or verbal.

    Anyhow, Alcoholic types can be really sweet and happy go lucky and affectionate and charming at times, and then when drinking, can turn into absolute monsters who can and do flip out with a hair trigger temper of which, a lot of times, there is not something there that would reasonably rationalize the level of rage that bursts forth. People in these types of situations are just constantly walking on eggshells. Then you have a spouse and kids who love the sweet guy side of their husband or father, and make excuses for the abuse by blaming themselves for not being good or “perfect” enough. Really, as if any person can possibly do absolute every single thing perfectly as some mega tyrant expects them to. Perhaps one also has to factor in that his former wife, a catholic, has some traditional values and thought that when wedding vows were made, they were ’till death do us part’.

    I can appreciate that some people want to look at both sides of this total mess, but to make excuses for an abuser does not help anyone. No matter what is going on, or whom we interact with, ultimately we are responsible for our own words and actions, and Mel is responsible for his. period.

  87. cringe-worthy says:

    I totally believe Robyn. People who are evil enough, manipulative enough, can drive anyone to rant and curse. I think that’s what’s happened here. I think Oksana is evil and manipulative, and Mel has woken up to what she really is. I don’t think Mel is a saint by any means, but I do think Oksana has goaded him and is the worse of the two.

  88. a says:

    ever since she and mel broke up she stopped looking perpetually high.

  89. Anti-icon says:

    But I don’t think anyone is looking to excuse Mel Gibson here or anywhere on the net, and believe me, this story has me hooked. People are really reacting in a (dare I say it…..) hysterical way over this Hollywood Man and His Mistress. He has become a political issue now. He is no longer a man with an individual story. Nor is she. She has become The Victim in this hysteria, which isn’t solidly grounded in the facts or justice at all yet. It’s interesting for sure, in its Shakesperian themes. But the individual comments are filled with emotion, and also, not solid logic. Logic based on knee jerk reactions to their own personal life experience. The internet is really not a place in which I would ever like to be tried for a crime, or a medical condition, or anything at all.

  90. Kelly says:

    As someone who lives down this end of the woods, I can tell you that MG was widely regarded as a fundamentalist-yet-stinking-hypocrite butmunch for a long time before he lost his shit in the States and was outed for it. Bad drinker, whoremonger (not that I have anything against whores or whoremongers, just the ones that pretend to be catholic on the side) general all round douchebag and egomaniac.

    Personally, I’ve wanted to kick him down the stairs since Mad Max (look at his back catalogue now in the context of his recent outbursts and theres a spooky theme developing). As for his exwife- does it surprise me that someone who squirted out an untold number of children at the behest of this kind of partner, pipes up to defend his arse? Em, no. She remained the mute doormat while he famously gave it to pretty much anything he fell onto while drunk and at large. What a woman! But hey, we probably have her to thank for Mel falling for and believing his secrets were safe with Oxana.
    Cheers!

  91. Debbie says:

    Whatever, sincerity and Uzi totally agree with you guys.

    Robyn is a classy woman, for those of to to tell and say she is lying, what proof do you have!

    She would never ever have stayed in a relationship if physically abused.

    To classy for that,

    This whole thing makes me sick, Robyn and his closest friends have done things by the book through the correct channels.

    This is a man who has been on sadly a downward spiral for several months.

    This relationship is to blame a “Toxic one”. Oksana is the red flag Mel is the Bull.
    As said previously This is a man with bipolar a MENTAL DISORDER, These tapes were sealed for a reason by a supreme court Judge, They would have been heard by the appropriate people in private and not leaked by Oksana and her pals to the trashy Media.

    I think it is disusing that these media outlets are releasing little by little daily to prolong this.

    I still maintain if abused as she claims why leave it for so long, yesterday her Dentist sent a letter to her lawyers stating NO DAMAGE to her teeth, You can read what was said on TMZ, He offered her a bed for the night at his place, and did not inform the appropriate people in the time.
    No major busing, cuts, abrasions nor black eyes as she and her friends have claimed. She begged for a photograph NOT TO BE TAKEN.
    As people have said he has Broken several laws.
    I do feel sorry for Mel because No one should have had these aired in public.This is a case of a man whom has problems with booze , anger and bipolar.

    He was the one whom ended the relationship because it was doing them both damage, He has been in therapy for some time.

    Also I still maintain If she was so scared as she claims Why continue to travel with him going to Dinners, award ceremony’s, have his PR people run after her every whim.

    He did verbally abuse her But some sources I have read in hollywood scoop Who have had criminal training and are specialists say the tapes sound doctored.
    I do not condone violence as everyone hear but People should be careful, I would hate anyone out there whom has suffered any illness to have it aired in the public domain.

    I am not sticking up for the actions of Mel I don’t like what he said BUT You still have to ask questions on why this woman has done what she has done.

    Debbie

  92. angelika says:

    @Carey..Didnt Anna Boleyn had a beautiful daughter Elizabeth 1 future Queen of England ?But i see your point..Robyn as plain looking as Catherine of Aragon

  93. teri says:

    Saying you deserved it could have been a variety of things. Hitting her could be one, something hit her, she fell, something swung open and hit her. Just saying Mel slugged her by that comment is rediculous. Women love to whine to others and put up with it but never leave. Hard to feel sorry for her since she kept going back. I don’t believe everything Oksana is saying, trying to save face and use his alcoholism as a way to kill him every which way. He needs rehab for himself and his kids. Alcohol makes some people very verbally mean and Mel is one of them.

  94. Rosanna says:

    Probably Mel never did this to Robyn because probably Robyn did use to blow him in front of the Jacuzzi LMAO

  95. Tracy says:

    She has been under his thumb for 28 years!! Why would she turn on him now? Even though they are no longer together, realistically she will always be strapped to him by way of seven children. I think the only time she could ever fess up to being mistreated is if Mel were dead, and she had decades of therapy. They married young and settled into a ‘Mel is in control’ kind of lifestyle. Mel became bored of her and left – only to discover his set behavior doesn’t gel with a woman also set in her ways – I wouldn’t be all that surprised if he were to go crawling back to Robyn, and no doubt, she would take him back – ugh!!

  96. Shay says:

    No physical abuse omits the verbal abuse and ‘being a good father’ refers to the money side of parenting in Hollywood.

  97. Debbie says:

    Uzi and whatever, Sincerity

    Have just read she has opened her mouth yet again, Reason why the court case today Oksana claims it was Mel who sent her the threatening phone calls yesterday!
    She wanted to stop the courts of visitation rights. But The judge has said Mel cam still see his daughter.

    Check out her mates at TMZ

    Mel is in therapy, If it was him and It was not The Judge would not allow him partial custody and the police would have already sorted this one out.

    Any way hat has now happened to her tape recorder.
    Debbie

  98. Whatever says:

    I just read on TMZ that Oksana lost in court today. Visitation will remain the same. I guess Robyn’s statement helped.

  99. original kate says:

    mel may not have abused robyn physically, but he certainly had a severe alcohol problem for a long time, cheated on her with other women before oksana, and he left her for oksana, so how is that a loving husband? a man who uses words like “cunt” and “whore” to describe the mother of his child, and telling her she deserves to be raped and beaten generally has a severe problem with women – all women. i think robyn is probably trying to save face for herself and her children. or maybe she’s scared of him – i certainly wouldn’t want to piss him off. of course, she may also be getting back at oksana for sleeping with her husband. but regardless of what robyn says mel did or did not do in their marriage it doesn’t negate the severity of his current situation.

  100. Gretchen Klingingsmith says:

    OMG….He is only a human being! Let him alone and let him go through his life! He is an awesome actor and he just has some personal issues to face. This is his deal not the United States! My gosh, these things happen daily!

  101. Sluggo says:

    I am waiting to see what the legal community (police, forensic experts, a judge, etc. — in other words, people qualified to assess the problem) have to say about this situation before deciding one way or another. In the meantime, I am not going to base any personal opinion about Mel-vs.-Oksana solely on what Mel or his attorney said, nor what Oksana or her attorney said, or what Robyn said, or what any secondhand “legal expert” said, or what any gossip writers or commenters said (not even here at Celebitchy, which is hands down my favorite site on the Internet for the fine quality of its reporting and the lively but polite quality of its commenters — it’s always, always classy here).

    Every day, the case gets more and more outrageous. Mel said this, Mel did that, Mel hit Oksana, Mel knocked her teeth out, and so forth. Today it was Mel punched his baby. Seriously, it’s getting SO out of hand.

    Meanwhile, as regularly as clockwork, Oksana’s mysterious benefactor (because it wasn’t her — she says so, right? so it must be true) releases another horrific rant.

    Before anybody starts tearing strips of skin off me for supposedly defending Mel … I am NOT defending him. First, what I’ve heard is totally reprehensible and inexcusable IF TRUE; but second, I am a survivor of many years of dreadful abuse (physical, verbal, emotional, and sexual) at the hands of an out-of-control alcoholic, so NO WAY am I condoning or defending any of these actions. I have scant patience or sympathy for a man who beats or bullies ANYBODY, nor do I have any tolerance for people who defend or mitigate his actions.

    BUT … all I’m saying is this: I want to see what the experts have to say about this. The recordings are going to be carefully checked for a lot of stuff. Everything’s being scrutinized by disinterested observers with no axe to grind on one side or the other. Mel is going to be checked thoroughly, so is Oksana. Each will have their day in court.

    And yes, as Whatever said: Oksana did lose in court today, despite the very public leaks and the very daunting evidence. Because of this, I fully expect to see, in the next few days, something along the lines of “OMG MEL ATE AN UNBORN BABY AND SCREWED HIS MOM” because everything’s going to get ramped up a notch.

    As for Oksana: somewhere out there, Timothy Dalton is probably going to church three times a day, thanking God (and every other deity in the pantheon) that he got off easy. And no matter what is happening, it is difficult to get around the fact that NONE of this was reported until demands for money were not met.

    If it is true that Oksana had a chance to report this abuse much earlier, but sat on it in order to get a lot of moolah (and it has been reported that this is exactly the case, with some evidence to back it up), then I will be almost as disgusted with her as I will be with Mel after the official report on his abuse. Why? Among other things, I feel such behavior sets a bad example for other victims of abuse, raising the question of “If you give victims lots of money, will they shut up?” and just feeds into the hands of abusive “She deserves it because…” commentators.

    No woman deserves abuse. Ever. And someone who tolerates it FOR MONEY and only steps forth when the money she demands is not forthcoming … well, it disturbs me a LOT.

    So: I’m watching and waiting for future developments.

  102. Shay says:

    The visitation will probably remain the same until Mel completely loses it, does something completely insane and then it’ll become front page news around the world.
    I wonder if he’ll have an OJ moment.

  103. Shy says:

    @Anti-icon – and all those women who go out with black eye every month and telling everybody that they hit the door are always telling the truth. Right? And then ambulance droves them to hospital with their faces all beat up and bloody and they still say they hit the door and that he loves them and it was their fault that they make him upset…

    Robyn has tolerate this for years. Why would she come out know and confess that she is one of those victims. How can anyone know that she didn’t walk with black eye? Did we saw her paparazzi pictures every day? Mel Gibson has so much rage inside him. There is no way he would not let it out before. He has to spit it out on somebody. On juwes, gays, Oksana… And i don’t feel sorry for Robyn. If she did stand this for years silently and HE left her. I think that she is like those victims who have every chance to escape but they still go back to their abusers again and again.

  104. jane16 says:

    @ Blessed, the “allegations” about their family have been out their for years, & many of mad max’s disgusting behaviors have been played out in the public eye. By making this public statement, she has now opened the dialogue to be about her marriage with mel; before, all the focus was on his relationship with Oksana. Besides, it made her look like she did it out of jealousy or spite. I think she & her kids would have been better served if she stayed out of it. Gibson has made his bed, let him lie in it.

  105. Shay says:

    Jane, I also think that Robyn would, as a parent, be under pressure from her own children and children tend to be biased toward their own parents. If she didn’t meet them halfway in supporting their father on some level, she would probably experience backlash from her own family as well.
    Either way, it’s a crap position to be in.

  106. H says:

    I am going to vomit if I read another post about poor Mel, his life is out of control, she tricked him,blah,blah,blah. He is 50 f@cking years old,he is responsible for his behavior. It does not matter if someone is trying to provoke you, if you can’t control yor reaction then get some help. His therapist needs to step it up if this is how he talks to people he is angry with. I guess he should stop thinking with his dick and maybe he’d be happier. And I think that the courts should monitor his visits with his daughter with the level of anger displayed on those tapes.

  107. Madison says:

    Yeah that must be it, the wife of 28 years is a liar, but the ex-girlfriend is telling the truth. I find it hard to believe that any woman who was so appalled and frightened by the raging abuse of her ex boyfriend would sign a visitation agreement letting such a violent out of control man visit his daughter and even have her overnight once a week, why didn’t Oksana present these tapes to the courts a few months ago as proof Mel is too violent to be allowed anywhere near his daughter.

  108. emv says:

    The tapes sound spliced, like i have said before. I am not condoning Mel, but Ox imo is creating this situation. There has been no physical pictures of her abuse. Yes being verbally abused is not right. However she probably drove him to say some of these things.She is minipulative. Her voice in the tapes seems off, not to mention his do as well. Abuse is awful and people who abuse need to be in jail. I think that they are abusing each other.

  109. Jazz says:

    He probably screwed around on Robyn for years and she turned a blind eye to it, like most Hollywood wives do. Then the other woman gets pregnant and she files for divorce. Mel, in his sick twisted mind, blames Oksana for getting pregnant and ruining his marriage. He realises she is only after his money and not as loyal as Robyn was and it all blows up in his drunk addled face.

  110. LindaR says:

    It’s called Stockholm Syndrome when you defend your abuser. Ask any cop that has had to go to a domestic abuse call about being attacked by the victim for trying to take the abuser away. It happens all the time. Robyn is obviously still heavily invested in some way in Mel to even bother to defend him. It might be money, but the money is going to be a given because of spousal property laws. Or she might still be in love with him which would make her the biggest sap on the planet. But I would bet the farm (and I live on one) that she is still intimidated by his past behaviour. And as someone who works in the field of abused women and children, I can say that often their relationships end when the guy “falls in love” with someone else and leaves. The wife won’t leave because he has her convinced that she would never find anyone else, that he would hurt her if she left, that he would hurt the kids if she left, that he would hunt her down and kill her if she left…the list goes on and on and if you are in an abusive relationship for even a small amount of time, your ego is so fragile and your self-esteem so eroded, that you are quite sure you would never make it without them anyway. Some of you posting here may have no idea of the courage it took for some of the other people posting here to leave their abusive relationships. I hope you never have to find that courage.

  111. denise says:

    Robyn is lying, this sort of behavior does’nt just happen.

  112. Anne de Vries says:

    Debbie: She would never ever have stayed in a relationship if physically abused.

    To classy for that

    WHAT? Did you REALLY just label battered women not classy for not being able to leave right away?

  113. Anti-icon says:

    This speculation of Robyn Gibson’s psyche is the EXACT behavior victims abhor; and yet here’s the cycle of speculation of her character. RG is a long-suffering victim of abuse; she is covering up for Mel for money; if she is not a victim of physical abuse, then surely it must have been psychological.

    Here’s a radical notion to ponder in this breaking story of shifty characters: what if Robyn Gibson is a well adjusted mother of 7 who divorced Mel because he went round the bend a few years ago with the DUI arrest: the same time he was essentially black-balled in Hollywood for his behavior.

    Robyn Gibson has never wanted to be in the spotlight. Again, another sign of solid mental health and good character.

    I don’t know why I defend her so much; but out of everything horrific in this saga—and all the children’s lives here, Robyn seems like the most Decent Parent of All.

  114. Spring says:

    I am still careful about what I say to and about my ex-husband. He has partial custody and we have been divorced 10 years. No, it’s not right and it’s not fair. But it is reality.

    He didn’t physically abuse me that often but he sounds just like Gibson when he is angry and/or drunk. He threatened me with guns and knives and threatened my life many times.

    When someone talks and behaves this crazy you tend to take them serious especially when he had many people fooled. I’m glad Gibson is being exposed for who he really is. If Gibson is crazy enough to behave like this, he’s not far from seriously hurting someone.

    I love my life and play a game with the ex to stay safe and alive. I’m sure many other survivors do the same.

  115. Ruffian9 says:

    Anne de Vries: I second your indignation.

  116. Angela Davies says:

    I understand completely why Robyn made her declaration for Mel, and it probably had little or nothing to do with Mel or his money. She has children and at least one is school aged. The shame they must be going through is awful. People forget that when a celebrity like Mel is exposed, he is not the only one to suffer. As a mum, of course she would want to say, “This didn’t happen to us!”

  117. trashaddict says:

    I have never seen Robyn looking happy in the pictures that have been posted, maybe they are selective but if not, I truly hope he was not beating her up. I would not be at all surprised if he was verbally abusive.

  118. Sandi says:

    It is clear that the man is suffering from the disease of addiction. His wife should have a share of his fortune and is a good woman for not publicly demeaning Mel despite him leaving her for a younger woman. Mel needs help, but he will never find it in women like Oksana and I believe that he knows this now. He is an alcoholic and possibly bipolar so I don’t think he can help himself right now. Let’s give the guy a break. Who among us hasn’t done some really stupid shit ourselves.

  119. It is the best time to make a few plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have learn this submit and if I could I want to recommend you few fascinating things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles relating to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!