Did Jennifer Aniston dump Justin Theroux after he refused to commit to her?

As I mentioned yesterday, there are some rumors circulating that Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux are either on the rocks, or they’ve split up completely. I thought the rumors were just based on my easy observation that Justin was in NYC and LA for two weeks while Jennifer worked in North Carolina, and wasn’t that weird because usually they’re joined at the hip? That seemed to be the gist of the UK rumors about JustJen, but as you can see, Star Mag has decided to one-up the JustJen Breakup Rumors by adding some new layers. According to Star (via HL), Jennifer demanded a commitment, Justin was all “meh” and so Jennifer has had him followed while they’re apart!!! Epic.

After waiting two years for a proposal from her boyfriend Justin Theroux, Jennifer Aniston has finally reached her breaking point, according to a new report! Following a romantic dinner at Giorgio Baldi restaurant in Santa Monica, CA, on July 11, the 41-year-old stood her ground and allegedly demanded an ultimatum.

“The dinner did not last very long, and they left abruptly and walked out separately,” said a witness at Baldi restaurant. “In the car, they sat apart, on opposite sides. She was burying her face in her hands.”

“Jen said, ‘I need a commitment, and I need it now,’” an insider tells Star. Only, instead of a dropping down to one knee and confessing his undying love, Justin reportedly shrugged his shoulders.

“That was the moment the writing was on the wall for Jen,” adds the insider. “It crystalized in her mind that Justin isn’t the one for her.”

Devastated by the turn of events, Jen allegedly told Justin that they should go their separate ways. “Justin pleaded for a second chance, but for her the love is gone.”

If Justin’s fear of commitment was the only factor, perhaps the two could’ve found a way to reconcile, but it seems marriage wasn’t the only issue at hand. “Looking back, Jen never fully trusted Justin,” says a friend of the actress. And perhaps for good reason.

Throughout his relationship with Jen, Justin always had insisted on remaining friendly with his ex-girlfriend of 14 years, Heidi Bivens. Lately, their friendship had allegedly become closer than ever. “Heidi and Justin have been talking for months, and Jennifer had no idea,” reveals an insider. “But she started getting suspicious.”

Mere days after their reported breakup, Jen’s suspicions were allegedly confirmed. “To give her closure, Jen even had someone following Justin in New York while she was away,” explains a friend. “He got together with Heidi within days of Jen leaving. It seems like Justin couldn’t wait to be rid of Jen so he could cut loose.”

[From Hollywood Life]

Don’t you love how Jennifer’s (alleged) spying is easily explained away? “To give her closure, Jen even had someone following Justin in New York while she was away…” It was FOR CLOSURE y’all. She was just mourning the death of her relationship by having her boyfriend followed while she was out of town. If it was any other woman, that action would not be framed in that way, like OF COURSE she had him followed, it was for closure, what do you want?

As for the main part of the story – Jennifer demanding a commitment, Justin’s hipster apathy… eh. I think Justin is apathetic, for sure. He and Heidi Bivens never got engaged or married and they were together for 14 years – I would be willing to bet that Justin is simply against marriage. But I do think it’s unfair to paint the current version of Aniston as a fairy-tale-seeking, needy, “YOU NEED TO PUT A RING ON IT” type of woman. She’s not Jennifer Lopez, you know. Everything that Aniston has been saying lately leads me to believe that maybe she’s fine with not getting married too.

And it seems like Aniston’s reps took this seriously enough to respond – I love what Huvane deems important enough to deny.

Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux are over? Not so fast. A new report in Star magazine claims that Aniston broke up with Theroux after a year-and-a-half of dating, allegedly because he wasn’t ready to commit.

But the 43-year-old actress’ rep countered to Wonderwall, “It’s once again just another fabrication to sell magazines and has no relationship to reality.”

Among Star mag’s supposed bits of evidence was Theroux’s recent dinner at NYC’s ABC Kitchen with a “mystery blonde.” In fact, the unidentified woman is actually actress/comedienne Amy Sedaris, an old friend, a source tells Us Weekly. More proof that the twosome are stronger than ever? While Aniston shoots We’re the Miller in North Carolina, Theroux enjoyed a group dinner in NYC with some of her closest friends July 30, a second insider says.

The Wanderlust actor, 40, dined at Elio’s in NYC with Aniston’s BFF and Friends costar Courteney Cox plus Laura Dern. Cox, 48, brought her daughter Coco, 8, who is Aniston’s goddaughter; Dern, 45, brought her son Ellery, 10, and daughter Jaya, 7, to the cozy get-together. “Everyone seemed to be having fun,” the source adds.

[From Us Weekly]

Hm. The “source” seems to know a lot about Justin’s whereabouts, right? Aniston totally had him followed. Basically, they totally could have broken up. Why not? Let’s see if we can shame Justin into flying to North Carolina to prove his love!!!

Photos courtesy of WENN, Fame/Flynet.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

144 Responses to “Did Jennifer Aniston dump Justin Theroux after he refused to commit to her?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. RocketMerry says:

    About time. Now she can go back to her old wardrobe.

  2. really says:

    It’s hilarious when the tabloids print supposed quotes from conversations to which there’s no way they could have had access.
    I doubt they’ve broken up. Even if the “magic” is gone, they both have a lot invested in milking this for a while.

    • Aussie girl says:

      Yes what is with these made up conversations!! I doubt that it’s over, this is just like how she is knocked up every second week.

      • the original bellaluna says:

        Wouldn’t you love to be the Chief Bullshit Fictionary Writer (yes, I just made that up) for one of these tabs? How difficult a job like that must be, to just make shit up as you go, and then turn it in like it’s the real deal. You’d never even have to leave house!

    • Andrea says:

      totally agree. Jen is not going to let this one go after all the professions of love, and this is his big shot at fame…its so not over…

    • rustytrawler says:

      Yes I love that the person who overheard them at dinner also knew that they sat on opposite sides of the car (how would they sit on the same side of the car??) and that she buried her face in her hands.

    • yolo says:

      Not only that, but who on Earth proposes such demands from a relationship over dinner.

  3. tripmom says:

    That blond woman on the cover of the mag is NOT Amy Sedaris.

    • Shoes says:

      No, but Justin had dinner with a blonde in NYC and Star assumed it was Heidi and printed a picture of Heidi on its cover. star doesn’t have actual pictures of the mystery woman. Us weekly is saying the mystery blonde he dined with was Amy Sedaris.

      • Jacq says:

        Even to that end, Bivens and Sedaris look NOTHING alike.
        I seems like in the wake of trailing Kristen Stewart & that cheating scoop/scandal, all of the other gossip mags are trailing stars and their significant others. I’m not saying it will be Justin, but someone’s bound to get caught with their hand in the cookie jar.

  4. RdyfrmycloseupmrDvlle says:

    This has been brewing for awhile. Anyone with half a brain could tell this guy is not passionate about her and is “in it” for other reasons. If he goes back to Heidi, which is what Ive always thought he’d do Jen will need to do a lot to save face. Yikes.

  5. mln76 says:

    Well call me suspicious but I think Huvane issued those host of denials and clarifications yesterday to distract from this story.
    WHY make a press release that Jen is playing a stripper NOT a prostitute….or that she’s doing a photo-op with she who can’t be named?
    Also that still from her movie that no one really cares about released and then suspiciously pulled. It reeks of PR planting and denail Huvane’s calling card.
    I’m not saying that they are definitely over but there may be something to these rumors maybe they are on a ‘break’?
    Justin’s pattern in his previous relationship was off and on with a couple of dalliances in between it may be too much for him to be in a committed relationship with a darling of the tabs and possibly he wanted a hiatus.

    Just conjecture.

    • evyn says:

      Well, he has to say she is playing a stripper for the countless “Jen’s Topless, “Jen’s Nude,” & “Jen’s Sexy Striptease” stories they are going to plant in the tabs to try and sell this turkey. Wait for it…

    • mln76 says:

      *before anyone notices denial not denail…..I haven’t had coffee yet folks

      🙂

    • Eve says:

      I don’t think they’re over — though I couldn’t care less if they’re still together or not (I don’t wish them hapiness, I don’t wish them harm).

      However, if they ever break up, I want to sit back and read her die-hard fans’s comments about him after that.

      Let’s see how they’ll spin it, and what names he’ll be called once he’s no longer Mr. Aniston.

      • Toot says:

        “I want to see how they’ll spin it, and what names he’ll be called once he’s no longer Mr. Aniston.”

        That is always interesting to watch. 🙂

      • mln76 says:

        Eh just like her fans ignore Vince, Jon Mayer and that model dude they’d ignore Justin and vent all their anger on you-know-who.

      • diana says:

        Y’all are just paid loons!
        I am an insider who knows what really went on. Your idol and Heidi got together and trapped Justin!!!
        Poor Jen, she so very very badly wants to be a mother but gave it all up for her sexy soulmate Justin.
        Everything, I repeat everything is your idol’s fault.
        Poor Jen.
        Justjen is unbroken 🙂
        (until Huvaniston happens)

  6. Toot says:

    I hope they’re still together because I prefer Aniston with someone than single because single Jen tab stories are beyond annoying.

  7. Kim says:

    Dont worry she will have him on a private jet in route to NC by noon

  8. Toot says:

    I wonder if the pics from yesterday were asked to be removed because a lot of people were calling Jennifer unattractive/homely? Makes me wonder.

  9. epiphany says:

    Can someone from Aniston’s camp knock back a couple of shots for courage, then tell her, for the love of God, to stop putting those fillers in her face?

  10. Dana M says:

    Why has her face been looking so puffy?

    • Lilac says:

      Alcohol. Shes had a problem with it for years. Probably gotten worse since she became besties with Chelsea.

  11. PHD in Gossip says:

    Don’t worry, she will force a photo op with Justin now. If it doesn’t happen, we know they are dunskee!

  12. mk yarwood says:

    That blonde woman is Heidi Bivens! With Blonde hair! Big duh. Anyone else starting to believe they’re in on something together? Let’s take the ol’ lady for a ride…

    • lafairy says:

      yeaah… except the supposed “old lady” is just a couple (just 2 with justin) years older than them so this “definition” will be ridiculous coming from them… and 43 is not really “old lady” in 2012.

      maybe if they were indeed plotting “famous lady” will be more relevant regarding THEIR age and regarding HER age.

      ps: we need to do something about this everyday more powerful ageism, because if now 43 is “old lady” I will seriously plan to shoot myself before hitting 30 ;)!LOL!

      • mk yarwood says:

        Haha, I wasn’t talking age, I was talking ol’ lady as in what cheaters call their current significant other…. No one is ever old. We are born children, we become full of ourselves and call ourselves adult/mature, and then we revert to doing stuff ‘just ‘cos’ and becoming geriatric toddlers. I can’t wait!

    • MW says:

      @mk yarwood – wouldn’t that be diabolical though? I hate to admit it, it did cross my mind before now. I figured I just watch too much Investigation Discovery Channel!!!

  13. Kevin says:

    He’s a veiny little bitch ain’t he. They are both pretty blah! They deserve each other.

  14. Brown says:

    The real tragedy here is those jeans she is wearing in the 3rd pic from the bottom. What is that look!? I don’t get it. Is this the style now? I feel like I’m taking crazy pills!

    • Lem says:

      I just read a (totally unrelated) book in which the author theorized that when someone gets stuck (emotional growth wise) their look, fashion and face also get stuck in time.
      These pictures bring that home. Jen hasn’t grown since her mid 20’s mid friends time. The 90 mid shirts, the pegged pants, the blowout . Girl is stuck. Her own pr is goodly responsible for her desperate air. Her temporary conform to new boyfriend’s make-under its doing her no favours either.
      Whilst were at it, can someone please give Courtney Cox a haircut!

      • lisa2 says:

        I don’t know the book you are talking about. But I do recall reading somewhere that some women get stuck in the time period they think they looked their best. That they keep the same hair, clothing everything. To stay in the period they found themselves the most attractive and happy.

        If you look at a lot of women you can see that is the case. Diane Keaton, Goldie Hawn (If I think on it I could come up with loads more)

        but Jennifer does not change and has not changed. Her fans like it so I guess it works. They go on and and on about her “style” which is not really a style. Jeans and a tank top, scarf, hat.. are not really a “style”. It brings to mind Johnny Depp.. stuck in a time warp..

  15. Guest says:

    so justin supposeldy had dinner with Courtney and laura dern but we are just now hearing about it 2 weeks after the fact and there were no pictures, sightings, or “cauight in the act” of this event, someone is trying a little too hard to deny this story..does anybody remember what she did when her n Vince broke up, i think they denied it too, anyways we shall see how this plays out

  16. NM6804 says:

    I wouldn’t believe the Star cover because:

    1. It’s Star! You can’t pick and choose about their credibility according to the star you happen to like/dislike.
    2. They claim she want to be a mother. Yeah right.

    And she chooses guys who can’t commit and who don’t want babies. Theroux dated for 14 year without marriage or children. Maybe he changed his mind but why would a woman who wants to have children choose a man who didn’t start a family with his long loooong term partner?

    I see nothing suspicious about Huvane’s denial. Aniston and Theroux ARE together and are repped by the same management so I can see him “collabarating” in these statements. He knew what he did/wanted when hooking up with Aniston and I don’t think he would be foolish to ruin it.

    Most couples in Hollywood spend a lot of time apart due to their busy schedules. It’s a given. Why anybody would think that would imply that these two should split the second that happens baffles me.

    • lisa2 says:

      hmmmmm

      I don’t..maybe because when other couples are not seen together the same people upset about the assumption that jen and justin are over say that about other couples.

      I guess they picked up on the way things go and are applying those standards to this couple as well.

  17. Carolyn says:

    Zzz….all articles which quote “a source” or “a pal” are pure PR pieces written by the celebrity’s agent. Don’t believe a word of it.

  18. Lem says:

    Denial= he totally hearts her. Duh! That’s why he went to dinner with Courtney, coco, Laura, and her kids. Commitment phobe 40 yo men love dinner out with their girlfriends freshly divorced ‘bff’s’ and their kids

  19. Audrey says:

    I call BS on Huvane’s reply. What grown man enjoys dinner with two middle aged women and their 8-10 year old daughters???

    I was just out with dinner with two friends of mine and their daughters…BORING…

    The faux-mance is over.

  20. Sassy says:

    hope her new movie is better than Wanderlust – it sucked….so NOT funny

  21. Dorothy says:

    If Justin truly wants a commitment, he would be committed! There would be NO hesitations, insecurities, demands and the like. Men know whether to wife her or not, most are not as shallow as some women think.

    As for Jennifer, take a break dear and figure out why you are attracting these guys that don’t want no more of a commitment than a dog wants a bone! 🙁

    • Audrey says:

      Absolutely. When a man wants to get married, he’ll get married. Justin obviously is not that kind of guy.

      IF the relationship was real, and that’s a BIG “IF”, Jen is one of those “I’ll change him” kind of women. It never works.

    • videli says:

      Agree with you, as one that was on the shallow side of relationships for a while. Most guys I dated wanted to settle down, and get married. AND babies! Yeah, that’s my image of men, they crave commitment, stability, and they want to reproduce.

    • skuddles says:

      Absolutely right. If he’s fudging around on the issue of marriage now, chances are he’ll never be ready (with you anyway). And same, of course, applies to women. I knew within a week I was going to marry my husband… but spent years with former partners and just wasn’t able to commit, so the relationships fizzled out. Or blew up.

    • MW says:

      On the other hand, Brad Pitt was committed, married her, and wanted kids. That didn’t make her happy either.

  22. DenG says:

    Hey, he can’t treat the Hottest Woman of All Time (CHOKE) like that!

  23. spinner says:

    They’re done. Looks like this was a stunt from the beginning & everybody was in on it, including Heidi. If that is the case…I am disgusted.

    • Lilac says:

      Whats with this smearing of Heidi? What does she have to do with this? Heidi was completely betrayed, blindsided and hurt. She had nothing to do with this.

  24. ILLNana says:

    i hope it’s true but i know it’s not. she is way too towny for him. he is way to indie for her. he should just be with me. we make so much more sense. she’s boring. she can’t keep a man. she needs to learn some p***** skills! for real. we should pitch in and buy her some Lil Kim records.

  25. Lindsey says:

    That chick on the cover is NOT Amy Sedaris! How dare they drag her into this…

    • Minimi says:

      Yes, not really!! As someone already wrote, my first thought was that “this woman” from the cover is Heidi Bivens…totally looks like her…I really think it’s her…Then again, why to publish something like this and instead of saying her name (or ex-girlfriend for years) just state “this woman”…

      On a side note, I don’t think there’s any story there and it’s starting to be a bit annoying that the press is always after Aniston’s relationship or mommy to be desires. She seems quite happy with her life and with her relationship and I’m pretty sure that with the life that she has she could also be happy without a man or babies. I’m really not a fan of her but I also don’t understand all the evil obsession. Leave Jenni alone!! 😉

  26. Lem says:

    JA should date JLove

  27. mar says:

    Does he color his hair with shoe polish? EEGADS that is bad hair color.

  28. Bite me aka aniston says:

    JustJen 4 ever… Someone hold me, am scared

  29. Mac says:

    It seems foolish to trust someone who has proven themself to be untrustworthy.

    In 2011 after determining that he’d locked things down with Jenn, Justin returned to NYC and threw a few more ****s into Heidi.

    Shortly thereafter he said “c’ya wouldn’t want to be ya” and deliberately left her with as little dignity as possible.

  30. DANDILION says:

    The horrible helmets, that ick smile, slick talking ‘hey baby’ voice.. ..shaped odd.. result.. not presentably dressed next to her comparison.. stupid helmets and the motorcycle.. he emotes a hiss worthy, sleazy, slippery-slimey libertine soap opera gigalo aura, and..SHE knows.. that he would cheat on her…

  31. Ally says:

    I wonder what it would feel like to have lies made up about you so often. I suppose it was envitable with JA working away. I love the ‘she’s having him followed’ bit, it feeds in to the clingy Jen fantasy.

  32. diana says:

    Why are y’all horrible to poor Jen?
    What has she ever done to you apart from being a bland blonde?
    The only people she manipulated were her fans
    *sob sob*
    LEAVE JEN ALONEEEEE (with Huvane of course)

  33. Roma says:

    The tabloids (and some women on this site) are only happy with a sad, pitiful and alone Jennifer. Always chasing love and marriage, never happy.

    I don’t think it’s a PR scene, I just think people like her better in that role.

  34. Suzie says:

    Don’t worry Jen. Tom C. is single and you two famewhores were kinda meant for each other.

    • Mitch Buchanan Rocks! says:

      That pairing would create a tabloid frenzy 🙂 left by their spouses and finding passion in eachothers arms they can shack up in one of their mansions & have various “sightings” leanne rimes style.

    • Go Figure! says:

      She’s too old for Tom C. He really likes them younger.

  35. serena says:

    “Jen never fully trusted Justin ..and perhaps for good reason.”

    LOL isn’t that hilarious?

    Of course you wouldn’t trust a man who cheats his 14 YEARS girlfriend for a Hollywood bland blonde actress. Of course, Jen, but you’re forgetting that the bland blonde is you.

    LOL this is what you get.

  36. Maritza says:

    He is definitely back with Heidi, I bet he got tired of Jennifer’s high maintenance ways. Justin loves NY and he knows he was better off with the woman who put up with him for 14 yrs.This time around Heidi should change the rules and demand they get married before this year is over.

    • hoya_chick says:

      I would hope Heidi has enough self awareness/respect to not take that douchey hipster back after the way he publicly humiliated her and flaunted his holly wood showmance!

    • RobN says:

      “Definitely” must mean something different in your world than it does in mine.

    • skuddles says:

      I agree he’ll probably try to get back with Heidi. Especially if it’s true about them having stayed in touch since they split. I had a strong feeling right from the beginning of his relationship with Aniston that he’d end up with Heidi again. Maybe he even planned it this way… take up with the A lister for a career boost (and money), then head right back to the long-term girlfriend?

  37. Zorbitor says:

    Jen doesn’t want to get married or have kids. She told me so.

  38. Sirsnarksalot says:

    Worlds most mismatched couple splits for obvious reasons. If he doesn’t fly in in the next couple days for a photo op to dispell this then it’s true. He got his career boost, she got a little “bad girl man stealing” on her record to dispell her good girl image and everybody leaves happy! And Jen can go back to hanging out with Courtney Cox all the time…oh wait she already is doing that.

    • Midnight says:

      Ye, but you forget, Jennie was given a pass for stealing him. After all, according to everyone, he wasn’t married to Heidi, even after 14 years, so he was fair game. Not!

      • Sugar says:

        thank-you!!! it has always irked me that Jen got a free pass for her momentary indiscretion onset fling that of course makes no difference because HB&JT weren’t married with children. I bet Heidi felt differently when it all went down in May.

  39. Dusty says:

    I think Jen realized he is not that talented of a writer or actor and she’d be paying for two to keep up the lifestyle she is accustomed to.

    • Mac says:

      I heard that Jennifer had basically exhausted all of her connections attempting to find Justin suitable employment.

      Justin’s been in the industry for more than 15 years and has plenty of his own connections.

      Maybe he’s convinced himself that he’s now a leading man type who can command $10 Million per film and turns down less lucrative projects.

  40. lisa2 says:

    His birthday is coming up soon I think..

    they are still a couple. I am hoping at least. A single Jen is just tabloid triangle drama.. So I’m hoping for lasting love.

    Boy they did a number on her face on that cover.

  41. gg says:

    She needs to learn how to have a relationship under the radar.

  42. Choupette says:

    It’s been pretty hot in the South. Maybe he didn’t want to be there with her because he’s afraid all that makeup/tan would melt off.

  43. Sonia says:

    I love Jennifer. I can’t help it. I just wonder if all this drama would have ever happened if Bradski wasn’t a cheating scumbag that permanently set Jen in her victim role, and Angie in her husband stealing role. If he’d have kept it in his pants until he was divorced-or even separated, and acted like an adult, none of this would be selling magazines now.

    • Bite me aka aniston says:

      I don’t know I mean Jen was fucking Vince Vaughn before the ink the dried on her divorce papers… I don’t know I mean Jen keeps fucking all these douchebags, u know sometimes I wonder what would have happened if people just started seeing Jen as a 43 year old woman that is responsible for her life choices…

      • Lilac says:

        “if people just started seeing Jen as a 43 year old woman that is responsible for her life choices”
        Lol, that would NEVER happen. According to her fans, she is never responsible for anything she does and is given more passes than everyone in Hollywood combined. Rule number one with the Jenloons; nothing is ever Jen’s fault, she is never to be held accountable for her actions, indiscretions, infidelity or any hurt she causes. Rule number two. If in doubt, refer to rule number one.

    • diana says:

      Ikr, we are totally on the same page.
      Even I luuurve Jen, inspite of not knowing why I do.
      As you rightly said it’s all due to Pitt and Jolie. How dare he divorce Jen who is my best friend and be happy with that Jolie. Atleast for the sake of Jen, he should have waited till Jen found her real love (although it doesn’t seem to happen in this century, but we can still hope can’t we)
      And inspite of Jen saying she doesn’t think they cheated, we still know that Angie is a husband stealer, don’t we?
      Of course, Jen is so sweet that she offered to bury the hatchet now, not like that stupid Angie who offered reconciliation 6 years back.
      And the way these men always use Jen, it breaks my heart. I HATE ALL MEN FOR HURTING MY BEST FRIEND JEN(except whoever she’s currently with). They are the reason why she is not a mother inspite of desperately wishing and wanting publicly for 7 YEARS.
      If only stupid Brad stayed with Jen…
      Poor Jen. Poor poor Jen.

    • Linda says:

      How do you know he cheated? So, this is about what Jen wants. Who cares what Brad wants. As long as Jen ends up the happy one that’s all it matters, right? Who give a shit if Brad is happy or not.
      Why should he wait until the ink gets dried? If there were a slight chance that they were going to get back together, they would have done what Courtney & David did. They would’ve give each some space & a break to work things out. Why announced the divorce? It is obvious that they are not planning to reconciled. Also, why should he wait until she finds new love. If it takes 10 years, should Brad wait 10 years? I’ll bet you wouldn’t have said the same if vice versa.

    • Rhea says:

      You know, she’ll stay permanently as a victim if she chooses to stay as a victim. Look at Sandra Bullocks, or Reese W. Nobody put the label “victim” with them anymore because they choose not to be look like one forever.

      I think it’s best for her to find her luck with love outside the celebrity circle. I don’t know, like a wealthy businessman or whatever. Find someone who will not trying to get/need the benefit of press coverage. Someone who’s not interested to give an interview about their love life. Example like Tyra Banks’s ex-boyfriend. I like that they stay low profile during their relationship.

      Only one problem.
      Does she want to do that??

    • Go Figure! says:

      Everyone forgets Jen herself said there were no third parties involved. Except when she went on the Okra show, all of a sudden, she implies Brad cheated. Anything to gain sympathy as the wronged wife and to boost her career. That boat sailed a long time ago. What about what Jen did to Heidi? If Justin and Heidi’s relationship doesn’t constitute a common law marriage, what does?

    • Lilac says:

      Sonia, he DID keep it in his pants until he and Jen separated. he didn’t get involved with Angelina until May 2005, 4 months after he and Jen split in January 2005. He didn’t cheat, he DID wait. He is not a cheater and Angelina is not a homewrecker. Just because the TABLOIDS made people like you think he cheated, and therefore cast the roles, doesn’t mean its TRUE. It was proven false long ago.

  44. Gossip PHD says:

    Next chapter in this drama will be interesting. JA is a publicity hound/whore. Let’s see how she spins this.
    No Way This Goes Unchallenged. Photo evidence to follow of Justjen loved up unless he truly dumped her weeks ago and wants off the phony PR train.
    Your Move, JA. The tabloids laid down the gauntlet.

  45. tru tru says:

    I think Jen knew what she was getting into, she chose a guy that had a gf of 14yrs and he did not commit.

    I think she is fine w/o being married and just wants a lil something to ride at night.

    she could be married by now, all of these yrs, I’ve been reading how bad she wants to be married and have a kid.

    I don’t beleive any of it, she’s enjoying all those millions, that’s for sure.

  46. taxi says:

    Her nose is fattening up again. Need another rhinoplasty? Maybe Oprah told the truth & her nose thinned because she “lost weight”, not because of plastic surgery.

    • skuddles says:

      Did she really say that her nose got smaller because she lost weight?? That’s hysterical! 😀

      I actually heard a while back that a nose can grow back after a nose job. People were commenting on this because they noted that Ashley Simpson’s original nose seemed to be re-emerging. No idea, of course, if it’s true though…

  47. someone says:

    Does anyone know why she didn’t marry Vince Vaughn? Obviously he wanted to be married and have kids as evidenced by how quickly he got married and had a baby after breaking up with her. I’ve always wondered why they didn’t work out and what Jen’s issue with Vince was….

    • RobN says:

      I’d guess it had to do with him being a disgusting, unfunny slob.

    • yolo says:

      I think it’s her. I think somethings not right with her that makes all these men leave. I always thought it was weird that Vince married and had kids right after their break up. Maybe she’s super boring. lol I gotta say, Justin’s hipster style is so douchy.

    • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

      Did you not see ‘The Breakup?’ I have a feeling they did no actual acting in that one – have a feeling it was an accurate depiction of their relationship.

  48. Ravensdaughter says:

    Is this possible? If so, Ms. Aniston can turn on a dime! If he didn’t commit to her per se, he certainly made an obedient companion and escort of himself for her. Maybe the leash just got too short and Jen still wanted it shorter.
    When I found out he was Paul Theroux’s nephew, I was amused, just as I am sure Paul and his children have been. Jen is the antidote to all things intellectual, special viewing at the Vatican or not!
    Team Heidi! At least they can stay in touch now…

  49. PdxBella says:

    Off topic but I f’ng love Amy Sedaris! Her cook/craft book is one of my favorites! David Sedaris is a riot too. I’d so love to have dinner with that family.

  50. someone says:

    Ah well, that was quick. He was on set with her last night in NC. They must have been worried about the rumors and flew him down there ASAP.

  51. Mrs.Krabapple says:

    The quote says she’s 41. Isn’t she 43? Or is she pulling a Catherine Zeta-Zones? Guess she’ll be 41 for another year, then 42 for three years in a row.

  52. Mrs.Krabapple says:

    Btw, can’t she do better than this loser? I don’t think she really WANTS to marry him, because why would she? He’s a jerk who dumped his long-time girlfriend to trade up. Maybe that’s ok for a guy you only want to fool around with, but that’s not good husband material. I think she’s smarter than that.

  53. holly hobby says:

    Did she get cheek implants? She looks lumpy and bumpy. Ugh, she should not do anything to her face. She doesn’t look bad if she ages naturally.

  54. skuddles says:

    How do you go from pleading with someone to marry you one minute to deciding you don’t love them at all the next minute? Obviously what you had wasn’t all that real in the first place. Same with her spying on Justin – that speaks volumes about the kind of relationship they had.

    Of course this story could be total bs… and I actually hope it is. I like poking fun of Jen’s little pocket boyfriend 😀

  55. Fue McCormick says:

    … those blue jeans she’s wearing? What the hell? … Also, I think it’s pretty funny that Star Mag seems to have gone out of their way to find a horrible photo of Jen where she looks bloated and has funky eyes …

  56. Sugar says:

    “After waiting two years for a proposal from her boyfriend Justin Theroux…”
    Really, did i miss something here like an entire year?

    • Midnight says:

      You and me both!

    • EmmaStoneWannabe says:

      Yeah really. I was like 2 years? Yeah. Right.

    • skuddles says:

      I wondered about that too. Did someone screw up and give the actual length of time they’ve been an item (ie. when he was still very much with Heidi) instead of remembering to give the “official” version of events?

  57. lisa2 says:

    Well everyone can breath a sigh of relief.. they are together in NC

    LOVE LIVES ON.

    lol.. right on cue

    • Sugar says:

      oh man now what am i gonna do with my weekend-i was so hoping for all my free time by the pool to be taken up by the demise of JustJen. i’m not terrible like that, really…I just feel the need to be an advocate for the authentic sweet girls out there like Heidi B. there are those who support Brandi & Liberty & well I have always liked Heidi:)

    • hoya_chick says:

      I know right? It’s like her ppl has someone reading CB! I loled at the headline on People’s website because it is indeed right on cue. Good job guys! Long live JustJen.

    • Janet says:

      I bet you a dollar to a donut hole as soon as Aniston or Huvane saw that cover story, one or both of them called Theroux and told him to get his ass down there pronto.

  58. Katherine says:

    Plez. This dude is not letting this goose go. There are still many golden eggs left to lay. If Aniston wanted marriage he’d do it in a flash. Guarantee.

  59. lisa2 says:

    I JUST NOTICED THE STORIES ON THE TOP OF THE MAG..

    Sandra trashes her fans.. now if this were a few other celebs that would have been a headlines story.

    John/Katy in a pool. hmmm didn’t we see those same kind of pics with Jennifer. just curious because I didn’t see any headline stories about John takes Katy to a pool just like Jen.

    well I guess those stories only work for some and not others.

  60. Ginger says:

    The article says Jen is “41” when she’s actually 43 so how can you rely on their other so called “facts” ?

  61. JessSaysNo says:

    …theyre engaged the next day.

  62. Alex says:

    This story from Star is too detailed to NOT be true. All we’re missing is photographic proof to back it up- i’m sure something will surface soon and people will begin to unravel this story to reveal the truth behind all of it. I bet the Star story forced Justin to propose to her before all hell broke lose in the media… so sad!

  63. Altissima says:

    Didnt they just get engaged?