Will Jennifer Lawrence do a ‘star vehicle’ adaptation of Steinbeck’s ‘East of Eden’?

I grabbed this before Bedhead had a chance to see it! *villainess cackle* My interest in this story is not so much about Jennifer Lawrence, but about John Steinbeck. I am an unapologetic Steinbeck fan-girl. I think he’s arguably one of the greatest American writers of all time. Many people get stuck on The Grapes of Wrath and never reach beyond it to read Steinbeck’s other works, which are for the most part much less depressing. One of my favorite Steinbeck novels, East of Eden, was already adapted into a film in the 1950s – it starred James Dean, and it was okay. Dean is wonderful in the film but I never really felt like it was a genuine adaptation of the original novel. So now Hollywood is going to try again, only it sounds like they’re trying to make it into some kind of vehicle for Jennifer Lawrence? What the what?

Universal Pictures and Imagine Entertainment’s Brian Grazer have closed a deal with the John Steinbeck estate for a new version of his seminal novel East Of Eden that will be developed as a re-team for The Hunger Games director Gary Ross and Jennifer Lawrence.

I’m told that the book is Ross’ favorite American novel and that the director plans to tell the generational story in two films. The novel previously was adapted into one picture, the 1955 Elia Kazan-directed film that starred James Dean and Richard Davalos as sons who compete for the attention of their farmer father in Salinas, CA. Ross wants Lawrence to play Cathy Ames, the cold and cruel mother of the boys and estranged wife of the farmer. The films will tell their stories, leading into the rivalry between their sons.

The studio and Imagine first acquired the 1952 novel back in 2004. This was after Steinbeck’s modern retelling of the Cain and Abel story shot back up the best-seller lists when Oprah Winfrey made it the first selection of the revived book club on her daytime talk show. I’m told that the original option lapsed, but then the studio and Grazer put together a new deal in a competitive situation, this one built around Ross and Lawrence, the latter of whom won the Academy Award in February for Silver Linings Playbook. Universal Pictures chairman Donna Langley was very involved, as was Jeffrey Kirschenbaum, Uni’s co-president of production.

Back to Steinbeck, who is hot stuff. This is the second recent seismic deal for the late author; in July, DreamWorks and Steven Spielberg made a deal to mount a new version of the Steinbeck classic The Grapes Of Wrath.

On East Of Eden, Universal, Grazer and Ross are still working out the particulars. When the studio acquired the book the first time, it got a script by Paul Attanasio. It is unclear at the moment if Ross will rewrite it himself or work with a writer. Ross will most certainly have a hand in the writing; he is a four time Oscar-nominee whose book adaptations include Seabiscuit and The Hunger Games. The intention is to get the picture into production after Ross directs Peter And The Starcatchers for Sony and Disney, which is his take on the Peter Pan legend. Lawrence will catch up with Ross and East Of Eden after she completes the final two installments of The Hunger Games series. She will next be seen in The Hunger Games: Catching Fire and the David O Russell-directed American Hustle from Sony.

[From Deadline]

Deadline also points out that Ross and Lawrence are also going to reteam for the film adaptation of the Hannah Kent novel Burial Rites. Basically, everybody wants Jennifer Lawrence for everything, even if she’s not really right for the part and even if the character is like 40 or 50 years old through much of the story. While the “Cathy Ames” character is central to the story, I worry that if the adaptation is built around Jennifer Lawrence as “the star,” you will lose a great deal of the story. The story is much more than Cathy Ames.

It’s always sort of amazed me that some of Steinbeck’s “minor” works don’t get the big Hollywood treatment – his books like Cannery Row and Sweet Thursday are much more “adaptable”. I see that someone already tried to do Cannery Row back in the 1980s, but that’s a great story and it would be interesting to see them try to do it again.

Photos courtesy of WENN.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

38 Responses to “Will Jennifer Lawrence do a ‘star vehicle’ adaptation of Steinbeck’s ‘East of Eden’?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Tessa says:

    I liked the first half better. Cathy is a great literary character. When I read it, I pictured Nelly Olsen from Little House on the Prairie. Pure Evil. I think Jen can pull it off. I am looking forward to this.

    • Isabelle says:

      haha thought I was the only one. Just a hotter Nelly Olsen. Cathy IMO is the most evil book character I’ve encountered. It will be interesting to see Lawrence as Cathy.

  2. Cecilia says:

    East of Eden is a delicious read & one of my favs. She is perfect.

  3. neelyo says:

    Sounds like they’re just using her name to get buzz going about the movie. By the time it’s made it will probably be Chloe Grace Moretz in the lead.

    There was a miniseries adaptation in the early 80s with Jane Seymour in the role. It was campy fun, especially Seymour. I still quote some of her scenes with my friends.

    Whoever plays the role will have a hard time matching the Oscar winning performance of Jo Van Fleet in the 1956 adaptation. They only focused on the latter portion of the book so she didn’t get the backstory but you knew exactly who she was and how she got there.

    Interestingly enough, the 1980(1?) version of CANNERY ROW starred Nick Nolte and Debra Winger, but originally it was supposed to be Raquel Welch who was fired early into shooting. I think she got a pretty big settlement out of it.

    Sorry I’m babbling, I know way too much inconsequential old Hollywood trivia.

    • holly hobby says:

      Oh yeah, Dr. Quinn does creepy scary very well. It’s available on dvd and I borrowed it from the library to rewatch. Jane Seymour was a great Cathy. Didn’t care for how they portrayed Asians.

      Karen Allen played Abra. She was cast as Marion Ravenwood right after this mini-series.

      Bruce Boxleitner was hot in this too.

      Yeah I remember too much. However, I can’t see JLaw as Cathy. She can’t do evil.

      • Tig says:

        Isn’t there some scene with Jane S as the way older Cathy, crazy as a bat, rocking in a chair back and forth? That scene has haunted me ever since!

  4. brin says:

    Great news! “East of Eden” should be re-made, can’t wait to hear who else will be cast.

  5. MisJes says:

    I think Jennifer Lawrence can pull of anything. She’s EXTREMELY gifted.

    I remember being skeptical of her as a troubled widow in Silver Linings, and she knocked that s-t out of the park. I hope this happens!

  6. Naye in VA says:

    Cathy you crazy bitch lol. I don’t know, I’ve never seen Jennifer play vulnerable. I don’t doubt that she can whip up the tough evil part, but Cathy had this vulnerable childlike sexuality that drew in the men at the beginning, and even the women in the the brothel if I remember correctly.

    • Tessa says:

      Yeah, she was Steinbeck’s version of the devil, I’m pretty sure. She lured you in, and then she unleashed her evil.

    • Tig says:

      I have reservations about her being able to play evil. If she can nail Serena, then she’ll be a fine Cathy- but that remains to be seen. I did like her in SLP.

  7. bns says:

    Who else hated that book and doesn’t like Steinbeck?

  8. Hillshmill says:

    I love the Grapes of Wrath novel. Steinbeck’s writing forces me to slow down and indulge in his descriptions. The Great Depression and Dust Bowl era is such a fascinating time in American history. I’ve read just about every Steinbeck work and have to say that Tortilla Flat and Cannery Row are my favorites.

    • bns says:

      Ah, I tried reading that, but I couldn’t get into it. I love reading, so I feel like I should like Steinbeck, but I can’t.

      • Hillshmill says:

        It’s very tedious and I can understand why a lot of people can’t stand his writing. Indefinitely have to be in the right mindset before I get into it.

  9. Londerland says:

    I don’t think Steinbeck is as widely read in England (though obviously still famous) and the only thing of his I’ve ever read was The Pearl. And good god, that book was depressing as hell. I read it when I was very young, and utterly ignorant of any real-life historical context, but it destroyed me. I think that was the first thing I ever read that didn’t have a happy ending, and I just remember going, “Wait, is that it? That’s the ending? You can’t end a book like that!”

    I just had no idea it was possible to have an unhappy ending in a book, let alone THAT tragic.

    All of which has nothing to do with the actual Jennifer Lawrence story, I’m just reliving a childhood trauma. 😀 Um…I’m sure she’ll be great in this role I know nothing about…!

    • Tessa says:

      A huge theme in his novels is the struggle of the American family, the American farmer, the search for the American dream, etc. It’s all very American, but obviously can and should be enjoyed by the rest of the world. I have learned a lot about my own country by reading his books. He packs a lot of history into his family dramas.

    • j.eyre says:

      Actually, I think yours is a good point as to why more of his novels aren’t adapted to film successfully in latter years.

    • Sixer says:

      Although, Of Mice and Men is one of the most commonly-studied texts at GSCE (the exams you take at 16) in the UK.

      When I was at school, I remember doing a cross discipline term topic when I was 13 or 14 – Steinbeck, Woodie Guthrie, and tramp art.

  10. ots says:

    Yeah but isn’t Cathy in her early twenties in the first half of the book? Or am I not remembering correctly? And since they are making it into movies, the first movie will be focused on her so I don’t think there is a problem with her age.

  11. Wally Vincenty says:

    She is a perfect cast. For those who doubt I suggest you watch her in The Poker House.

  12. MollyB says:

    Steinbeck is my all time favorite American writer and East of Eden is one of my favorite books. Cathy might not be the entire story but she is certainly the most memorable character in the book. I think it would be almost impossible to fit the entire story into a 2 hour film, so focusing more on her character doesn’t seem out of line.

  13. ZoZo says:

    @OTS: You are correct!….the role of Cathy Ames (which Jennifer Lawrence will be playing) takes place in the first half of the novel—when Cathy is a young woman, early twenties. Lawrence will only be playing Cathy as a young woman…and she’ll nail it. A very EVIIIL woman, Cathy is (she would be pals with Serena!) (LOL!).

  14. Jegede says:

    What on earth happened to her ‘SERENA’ movie with Bradley Cooper?

    • ZoZo says:

      @Jegede: Susanne Bier tweeted a message two days ago that Serena will hit theaters in spring 2014, and that we can expect a trailer “soon…very soon!”.

  15. Algernon says:

    Cannery Row! I’m so glad someone else thinks as much of that book as I do. But my favorite Steinbeck is The Red Pony. I know it’s a kids’ book but I challenge anyone to read it and not be deeply moved.

    It’s hard to tell because there’s a lot of “maybe this or that” in this report, but it sounds like either the movie will just be about Young Cathy, or else JLaw will play her young and they’ll have someone else play her older. If that’s the case, can we have Cate Blanchett play the older version of Cathy? I would believe them as two versions of the same person.

  16. Samigirl says:

    Adam Trask is one of my all time favorite protagonists. I would LOOOOOVE a remake of this movie. And I do think she would be a fabulous Cathy. Of course, I’m biased and a huge J-Law fan. She was in my town a week ago, and I may have done some little mini stalking, but I never saw her. 🙁 I did see Charlize Theron though, so that almost made up for it.

  17. Eden75 says:

    Oh please tell me they are not going to ruin one of my fav movies with a remake. Why can’t they just leave s**t alone? The 1956 movie is amazing, Jo Van Fleet was untouchable, James Dean was epic, Raymond Massey was phenomenal.

    I am now going to go off and mutter and swear in a corner. And yes, if anyone wonders, that is where my handle came from. Bloody hell…….

  18. Anna says:

    No no no no no no noooooo

    Hollywood ruins everything.

  19. Arjuna says:

    Jennifer Lawrence as young Cathy is fantastic (she’ll be teriffic….she’s very talented) and either Charlize or Cate B. as older Cathy would suit me just fine. I’m just thrilled another adaptation is coming. I’m a Steinbeck girl.

  20. Isabelle says:

    I have ‘hero’ worship for Steinbeck. Witty, intelligent and bold. Encourage everyone to read his letters and news articles. He didn’t just write about the poor and oppressed, he often advocated for them.

  21. Bridget says:

    I hate Steinbeck. Ugh.

  22. Melissa says:

    She is sooo overrated and overexposed

  23. Jordan4 says:

    Yes!…I’m excited for this (love Steinbeck and Lawrence). Jennifer Lawrence is an incredibly talented actress, can’t wait to see her take on this role!.