Shonda Rhimes: Black folks are not a monolith, ‘My Black Is Not Your Black’

ELLE_October 15_Shonda Rhimes

I might get crap for this, but I never really engaged with Shonda Rhimes’ shows. I like her as a person, I’m happy that a woman of color is dominating prime time network TV, and I will gladly defend Shonda on almost anything. But Thank God It’s Thursday and the whole Shondaland lineup isn’t my jam. So, if you want to talk about that stuff, God bless. Personally, I’d rather talk about Shonda’s new interview in Elle Magazine. Shonda sat down with the October issue of Elle (the one with Selena Gomez on the cover) to discuss race, politics, the writer’s room and more. You can read the full piece here. Some highlights:

The Scandal episode of ‘The Lawn Chair’, whether African-Americans are a monolithic community: “That episode was very interesting for us because Zahir McGhee, whose name is on the episode, [and] I basically wrote it together. He really did a good job with it, but [we] couldn’t be from more different worlds: He wanted Marcus to have attended a black college, and I didn’t want him to—I thought it meant something different. It was just a giant battle that we waged about every detail because [McGhee] was a young black man from Baltimore, and I grew up a lot like Olivia Pope. I was trying to explain to him, There is this weird belief from people on the outside and from people in black communities that there is only one way to be black. And I say it in the writers’ room all the time: My Black Is Not Your Black. What’s terrifying is that, just the same way we’ve all accepted that normal is white, everybody seems to buy into the idea that there’s only one way to be black or one way to be Hispanic. That’s as damaging as anything else.”

The resonance of telling stories about police violence: “That’s what was both heartbreaking and ironically, sadly, fortuitous. I woke up knowing that we were going to go write “The Lawn Chair” after Ferguson. I watched that coverage and was horrified. I woke up the next morning with this image of this man, of a lawn chair and a shotgun and a child underneath him. The episode came out of that. We shot that episode in October or November. I remember thinking, This is going to feel dated when it comes out. And then the police just kept killing black men. Literally the [day before] it aired, they released the Ferguson Report, and it was worse than the press had ever thought.”

Olivia Pope’s love life: “She is in love with the white, Republican president. She is in love with the man her father could not be more unlike. And that is what Rowan has been railing against. If you take it to its bare bones, metaphor scrubbed away, she is in love with the thing that her black father, who grew up in the 1950s and ’60s, could not be more disgusted by.”

Understanding power: “I think power is useless unless you know you have it. I’ve seen that a million times. And I feel like it happened with me for a while. I was always like, Why are people behaving this way? And now I know they were trying to treat me as if I were powerful. But because I was not ready to be powerful, I was like, What’s happening? The minute you realize or accept the concept that, Yes, I am a powerful person—guess what? The people who need to treat you that way to get things done—the business guys, and the money guys, and the finance people—they fall in line.”

[From Elle Magazine]

The whole piece is definitely worth a read. Shonda discusses the disagreements in the Scandal writers’ room and how those disagreements make the show better. She says Olivia’s relationship with her father is Shakespearean. She talks about power and love and owning her own boss-ness. I admire her so much. Just don’t ask me to watch the shows!

wenn22476102

Photos courtesy of Jean Francois Campos/Elle Magazine & WENN.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

45 Responses to “Shonda Rhimes: Black folks are not a monolith, ‘My Black Is Not Your Black’”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Jen says:

    The fact that it’s such a big deal that a black woman has become such a powerhouse in that industry just goes to show you it’s a conversation we still have to have.
    She’s always seemed like she would be tough to work for to me-but in a good way. When your boss expects that much out of themselves, they expect a lot out of you, too.

    • ninal says:

      yeah, it’s like the same dynamic written about in that lincoln book team of rivals, where the having counterpoints and diversity of opinion creates a good sort of tension where ideas can be shaped, honed, and fortified.

  2. Tiffany says:

    I am not into Grey’s or Scandal, but Murder is my jam.

    Signed,

    A unhealthy love for anything Viola Davis.

    • wolfie says:

      I just love Viola. I believe that she is one of the best actresses of all time – I love the way she lets you be intimate with her character. I love her.

      • I Choose Me says:

        I love the way she lets you be intimate with her character. I love her.

        That’s one of the most apt descriptions of Viola Davis as an actor that I’ve ever heard. And I couldn’t agree with you more. When she’s onscreen I can’t take my eyes off her.

  3. Mispronounced Name Dropper says:

    “black folks are not a monolith”

    True.

    • evermore says:

      Preach!

      A actress friend of mine, had to tell a white gentleman in LA something similar one day. He actually worked in the industry… He would run at the beach and chat with her sometimes in what he felt was a nice way and he was harmless, but she said all is questions were about black this, African Americans that, eating habits of African Americans, how he was surprised she grew up in the middleclass suburbs and spent weekends at Harvard ,,,, but she got tired of all his talk being about just being black. One day she said they were running and he started with his questions and she told him she can’t speak for every African American person in America. He got all bothered and said she was being hostile. She gave up on chating w him. She said he just never would understand, what she meant.

      • Anna says:

        I have taken to calling that kind of hostility to a black woman speaking truth a “NickiMinaj-ification” situation.

      • sauvage says:

        This reeks of racism. To me, it sounds like this guy was trying to feel good about himself because he’s so open and tolerant, look at him talking to the black woman at the beach, in such a friendly manner! – Just, please, don’t dare being an individual, black woman. It ruins the whole purpose of “I am one of the good ones, I am so tolerant because I talk to BLAAACK people; I am interested in THEIR culture.” – Just not interested in actually learning something, something new, something that might challenge your preconceived notion of what BLAAACKS are like.

    • Nev says:

      Word.

      Love Scandal and HTGAWM.

    • I Choose Me says:

      Yas!! I get so annoyed for instance when people expect me to like Tyler Perry films because they star black people and are aimed towards black audiences. I get wanting to support your own but I just can’t with his style of directing and his derivative, repetitive plots.

      Much respect and admiration for Shonda Rimes but the only show of hers I’ve loved is Grey’s Anatomy and HTGAWM. The latter which is only good sometimes.

      • sauvage says:

        Please don’t yell at me if I’m getting this wrong (white, middle-class Middle-European here), but isn’t this just about as racist as it gets, to make assumptions like that? To be EXPECTED, as a person of colour, to be a certain way, for example to like a certain director, because he happens to be a POC, too? To me this sounds like, again, the monolith. YOU BLACKS are like this or that, YOU BLACKS love this or that because YOU BLACK! Because all of YOU BLACK! I find that offensive. People are individuals. ALL people are idividuals, regardless of skin colour, background, or favourite chewing gum brand.

        Curiously enough, the fact that people are indeed individuals seems to be regarded as common sense AS SOON AS IT IS BEING APPLIED TO WHITE PEOPLE . “We” get to be diverse, to be individuals, because – BECAUSE WHAT? Because WE WHITE. This way of thinking is wrong on every human level. It defies common sense, in my mind.

  4. kri says:

    This is the thing that I think is so important-that we have women of color in positions of power in Hollywood. She writes fully-fledged HUMANS and they are complex and faceted. She doesn’t write jokey stereotypes or one-dimensional people. I can’t speak for people of color, but I think it must surely be frustrating to see either no representation of someone who looks like you, or maybe even worse-a stereotype flat character. There isn’t one kind of black, hispanic, gay, female etc. The more that people get to see dimensional humans of all colors, shapes, etc the better off we are . go Shonda! We need more!

    • DesertReal says:

      Right on.
      As a black American woman who grew up lower middle class diverse neighborhoods and people, I’ve been exposed to all kinds. I was born in the north, raised in the south, and even though I currently live back up north- I still got the “you’re not black because you don’t act like it/don’t be offended because I meant it as a compliment/I even refer to you as a white black person whenever I talk about you to my family” from a coworker last year. Yeah.
      Really.
      So although I don’t jam with S.R. shows I definitely think there’s a need for people to see everywhere that “Black people are people just like you!” and there are more than one type, unlike what traditional shows portray on tv.

  5. Kiki says:

    @keiser. Neither would I watch Shandra Rimes shows either. I am just fed up with her over the top soap opera crap prime time shows. I would say this though. She does have a point with the “lawn chair ” episode. Even though, I think it is ridiculous and so cliche, it was a very moving in a little way, but what does she mean with “my black is not, her black.” My black is the same as your black, missy. We have growth, struggles and strengh.

    • Toot says:

      I’m black also, and I think she means all black people don’t have the same experiences in this life and therefore the same point of view. So my black isn’t the same as your black.

    • LAK says:

      This is my interpretation of that statement, ‘my black is not your black’, because i’ve actually lived it and I recognise what she is saying and thank goodness someone actually said it publicly.

      People assume that if you are black then you have to dress, act, speak, live a certain way and if you do not, then you aren’t black/you aren’t black enough/ your are an uncle Tom/uppity and at worse race deniar, take your pick.

      So she’s in the writer’s room with someone putting together an episode of an incident that involves black people living in a poor, perhaps all black neighbourhood, and she’s having to fight the above stereotype because apparently the above stereotype is the only accepted way for a black person to present themselves or to be portrayed.

      She’s saying her colour doesn’t make her experiences the same as every black person. She’s not saying she’s better or worse, just that she’s as individual as every human being.

      I remember when Barack Obama first started to really make headway in the campaign for president back in 2008, Jesse Jackson was caught on a live feed telling somebody that Barack Obama was the wrong type of black because he wasn’t black enough or words to that effect. He was referring to Barack’s background, experiences, presentation style. That’s the sort of thing I take away from Shonda’s comment.

    • iGotNothin says:

      Everyone has different ideas of what they think black people are…who they think they are. I would be ignorant to assume that if you are I are looking at the same black man, our thoughts would be exactly the same. My black is not your black. My thoughts are not your thoughts.

    • evermore says:

      I love her over the top shows, they worked for Aaron Spelling, who I also loved all that over the top tv and even bad tv, in some ways, but I enjoy it.

    • Naya says:

      She means that “black” is depicted in one way as though we are all shaped ONLY by skin color. White people get to be depicted as individuals with varying outlooks, interests, temperaments but it sounds like her staff writer thinks of black guys as either being “street” graduates of the hard knock life or “enlightened” men who went to black colleges. Nothing in between.

      • evermore says:

        It’s really sad that she even has to say this and people need it explained,
        That in itself, says a lot

        …..Human beings are human beings, all human beings, have different life experiences and are individuals.

  6. Sixer says:

    Yip. I agree with you, Kaiser. I think her shows are generally awful and they so aren’t my cup of tea. Nothing to do with Shonda: I just don’t like soapy or procedural dramas. But very happy to see a WOC as such a powerhouse in a segment of the industry, regardless of whether or not it’s a segment that appeals to me.

  7. Mo Comments Mo Problems says:

    Last night’s episode of HTGAWM though… 😐😳

  8. Krista says:

    I like her, and though I don’t watch her shows, I’m usually interested in what she has to say.
    However, one thing I can not stop noticing right now is how different she looks. Can someone else go back into the archives and tell me I’m not crazy? She’s lost weight and her skin is much lighter right?

    • Colette says:

      Yes she has lost weight and appears she has had some chemical peels to correct skin discoloration.My cousin used to have skin discoloration and her dermatologist put her on a skincare regimen.Shonda was on Jimmy Kimmel last night.I think she looks a lot better.

      • She could’ve had skin discoloration from NAIR. My aunt is about her age, black, etc…and was very hairy. Chin, mustache, etc (same as me…UGH)…..but when Nair first came out, it was like dipping yourself in acid–according to her. She used it and it was so harsh on her skin…….she still has to wear foundation because of the discoloration.

  9. Veronica says:

    While I’m very proud of her accomplishments, I don’t like her shows either. (I felt all alone in that until now.) I hate the over the top melodramatic soap opera type nighttime shows. I watch TV and movies to escape the drama and craziness in my own life; as such I have no interest in sitting through hours someone of else’s drama. (Double that attitude for reality shows.)

    • lucy2 says:

      I feel that way as well – I really respect her for all the work she does, and for the diversity on many levels that she brings into her shows, but…I don’t think they’re very good. Some of the actors are great, but the material, not so much. But I still root for her to succeed.
      To be honest, I did watch Scandal and HTGAWM last night, because I was folding laundry and had nothing else to watch, but they are overly dramatic soap operas that occasionally touch on something important and meaningful.

  10. Jenna says:

    I’m conflicted when it comes to Shonda Rhimes. While there is no denying she has made incredible strides for diversity in television for women and African-Americans, they recently did a photoshoot with every actor on her 3 shows and it was really sad to see that for shows that proclaim themselves to be so diverse, there were only 2 or 3 latin actors combined. I love that Shonda is breaking barriers and changing how we see the world portrayed on screen, but I just can’t get too excited because in “Shondaland” it feels like diversity revolves around only African-Americans and nobody talks about it. We need more Shondas, but I’d love to see her broaden her scope of diversity.

    • Renee28 says:

      I’ve heard that complaint before about Shonda’s shows and Empire. It just seems odd that shows with predominately black casts are expected to include every minority but shows with predominately white casts are rarely held to the same standard. As long as there’s one token minority no one complains. Shonda and Co. shouldn’t be the only ones responsible for creating diversity.

      • hmph says:

        It’s like people expect us to be mules for every minority,lgbt,disabled, white feminist etc groups, basically everyone except straight white males.
        I actually find it offensive when people not only expect us to rally for them but also demand it and if we don’t we’re somehow not worthy of respect or any human decency at all.
        I can’t remember the last time I saw any hispanic people speak up or defend black women or people….And I’ve never seen any black actors/actresses on telenovelas except for housemaids or comic relief to mock…the most racist people I’ve met in my entire life have been Mexicans.
        The only people I support now a days are other black women like myself. I don’t have the time, energy or interest to help anyone else and certainly not for free.

      • Jenna says:

        I’m not shifting the responsibility to Shonda. My point was that Shonda proudly proclaims herself to be a torchbearer of diversity in television and as part of that I would love to see her give more opportunities to Latino actors when so many doors are still closed to them in Hollywood. As many have pointed out, so many other shows only have a token latino character at best. I would love for every show runner in Hollywood to be as open to casting and focusing great storylines on non-white actors as Shonda is. The lack of this undoubtedly needs to be addressed. But since Shonda wants to spotlight this need and is obviously open to casting minorities, it would be great to see her include more Latinos. That is all I’m saying. If you want to talk about Ryan Murphy or other show runners who lack any diversity, I’ll be happy to share my support in encouraging them to cast any minority characters and feature them.

      • Anna says:

        @hmph x100000000

      • delorb says:

        @hmph,

        Well said. Well said, indeed. As soon as we get something, we’re supposed to share, but when others get something, they tell us to ‘get our own’.

        I love Shonda’s shows. What I don’t like are all the ‘fans’ who trash her for practically EVERYTHING. Why is Olivia in a bad relationship? Why can’t Olivia be strong at work and in her personal life? Because that would be BORING! Or my favorite, “Shonda said XYZ, 2 years ago and now she’s doing the opposite! She’s sold out. I hate her!” People change over 2 years or 6 months or even a day. Jeez.

    • FingerBinger says:

      Ryan Murphy only has 2 or 3 blacks and latinos in shows. I don’t hear anybody complaining about him not being diverse.

    • Ahot says:

      Sorry but you are holding Shonda Rhimes to another standard. Yes she is a champion for diversity, merely because she exists as a powerful black woman in her position. & She does her share by including latinos in her shows. I find it interesting how the number is not high enough in your eyes, whereas most white shows don´t even have that.

      It´s definitely putting all the responsability on her when you say things like: for a champion of diversity it isn´t enough inclusion for latinos, so i am on the fence with her. She does enough, more than any latino in her position would do. It´s not her responsability to uplift latinos or other minorities by including them in even higher numbers in her shows.

  11. Jenns says:

    I love Shonda. I just read that interview and the last quote about Christina on Grey’s and how she still loves her life without a husband and kids really speaks to me.

    With that being said, I don’t enjoy her shows after two seasons. lol.

  12. carol says:

    I don’t like her shows either but I love that a woman, any woman, has a position of power in Hollywood. And her statement that “my black is not your black” is so true!! I’m glad she’s talking about diversity within an ethnic group because I think that’s true of any “group”

  13. livinglavitalola says:

    I have never watched her shows, not even ga. Nothing To do with the shows quality I’m just not into those types of shows. But I love her as a person and am so happy a woc is dominating like she is.

  14. ABBESS TANSY (TEE JAY) says:

    “There is this weird belief from people on the outside and from people in black communities that there is only one way to be black. And I say it in the writers’ room all the time: My Black Is Not Your Black”

    *bows down in gratitude*

    Thank you so much for this, I wish this fact would sink into the consciousness of people. As a black American woman over 40, I can’t begin to describe the puzzlement and sometime frustration I have had over assumptions about who I am, who I should be and what my life must be like. As if I can’t love and appreciate ballet along with hip-hop dance. Or like alternative music. I am a multi-faceted individual just like other people.

    • delorb says:

      I once did an interview with the worse kind of liberal. She had put me in a box of her own making and was shocked when I didn’t fit her ‘woe with me’ stereotype.

  15. brincalhona says:

    She’s totally right that her black is not the same as someone else’s. I just wish the idea that everyone is made up of different experiences and their reaction to them would permeate the writing on her shows. All the characters have the same speech pattern and so I’m not listening to a well-crafted character but the voice of a writer or writing team.

  16. Danskins says:

    Huge fan of Shonda and especially HTGAWM! It’s sad she has to remind folks that not all black people are the same. I’ve certainly felt that way in my life since some have questioned how “black” I am over certain choices I’ve made, and even asked me to hand back over my “black card” to them on more than one occasion lol.