FBI Director James Comey ‘misstated’ some facts under oath last week

When Sally Yates testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee yesterday, she used phrases like “compromised by Russians” repeatedly. And it’s really got me thinking: has FBI Director James Comey also been compromised? Or is he just a political hack? Comey used his position as FBI Director to interfere in the presidential election just days before most Americans voted. He did so because he believed it was Congress’s right to know that the FBI was looking at emails Huma Abedin sent or forwarded to her husband Anthony Weiner, who was under FBI investigation. But Comey never sent any letter or made any statements before the election about the ongoing FBI investigation into Donald Trump’s campaign. So I ask again: is Comey somehow compromised? Or is he just a political hack?

Anyway, Comey testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee last week. He was supposed to testify about Trump-Russia. But of course he got a million questions about Hillary Clinton, Huma and Weiner. Comey actually testified UNDER OATH that Huma had forwarded “hundreds of thousands” of Clinton emails to Anthony Weiner and that many of those thousands of emails contained classified material. I’m sure you heard about that part of Comey’s testimony, because it was a big story on the Alt-Right Twittersphere, with @MAGADeplorableBrosef tweeting sh-t about how Huma and Hillary should be in jail.

Here’s the thing though… Comey was lying. He lied under oath. He lied to the Senate. ProPublica had the scoop:

FBI director James Comey generated national headlines last week with his dramatic testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee, explaining his “incredibly painful” decision to go public about the Hillary Clinton emails found on Anthony Weiner’s laptop.

Perhaps Comey’s most surprising revelation was that Huma Abedin — Weiner’s wife and a top Clinton deputy — had made “a regular practice” of forwarding “hundreds and thousands” of Clinton messages to her husband, “some of which contain classified information.” Comey testified that Abedin had done this so that the disgraced former congressman could print them out for her boss. (Weiner’s laptop was seized after he came under criminal investigation for sex crimes, following a media report about his online relationship with a teenager.)

The problem: Much of what Comey said about this was inaccurate. Now the FBI is trying to figure out what to do about it. FBI officials have privately acknowledged that Comey misstated what Abedin did and what the FBI investigators found. On Monday, the FBI was said to be preparing to correct the record by sending a letter to Congress later this week. But that plan now appears on hold, with the bureau undecided about what to do.

ProPublica is reporting a story on the FBI’s handling of the Clinton emails and raised questions with government officials last week about possible inaccuracies in Comey’s statements about Abedin. It could not be learned how the mistake occurred. The FBI and Abedin declined ProPublica’s requests for comment on the director’s misstatements.

According to two sources familiar with the matter — including one in law enforcement — Abedin forwarded only a handful of Clinton emails to her husband for printing — not the “hundreds and thousands” cited by Comey. It does not appear Abedin made “a regular practice” of doing so. Other officials said it was likely that most of the emails got onto the computer as a result of backups of her Blackberry.

[From ProPublica]

Oh, Comey “misstated” the facts? What he said was “inaccurate”? Well, golly gee whiz, my goodness. Why is no one saying that Comey lied under oath? Why isn’t anyone asking why he lied?

Photos courtesy of Getty.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

77 Responses to “FBI Director James Comey ‘misstated’ some facts under oath last week”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Nicole says:

    Honestly it’s fascinating to watch such corruption in action. This seems way worse than watergate. So many people complicit in active coverups and selling the Us to china and Russia. Amazing. We aren’t safe at all.

    • original kay says:

      It’s like a Richard North Patterson novel.

      Only it really is real and I am scared for you guys 🙁

      • Nicole says:

        I’m scared too don’t get me wrong. My anxiety levels have overall been higher than normal and this is a major reason why

    • cindy says:

      I get what you are saying. Like watching a car accident and we are all in the car. It is fascinating and terrifying at the same time. I feel like I am watching the end of our democracy.

    • DystopianDance says:

      Why didn’t Comey state that the trump admin was under investigation for russian collusion into their win! We all could -plainly see- the deluge of “fake news” that denigrated Hillary, and no one understood where it was coming from. Plus the Julian Assange wiki leaks that literally hacked into the DNC. This IS Watergate, yet NO ONE is doing ANYTHING substantive. I know this is a “fashion web page”, but in the words of Trevor Noah- “we have eyes and ears”- we see and hear the treason. Make it stop.

    • Tiffany :) says:

      Comey was just fired, per CNN.

      • Olenna says:

        Dayum. Didn’t see that coming. I’d commented earlier that Obama should have done the deed when he was under his watch.

      • hunter says:

        WOAH – wow wow wow, now I have to go search this, thanks for posting!

        Assuming this is true, it’s a relief – at least something works properly.

  2. Snowflake says:

    I hate this guy so much. I feel like he deliberately threw information out there to prevent Hillary from being elected. And he’s getting away with it!

    • NtSoSclBtrfly says:

      He did. He is compromised. There are unbelievably deep and tangled roots of corruption in this entire administration, and I am fearful that justice will be denied.

      LOCK HIM UP!

      • vaultdweller101 says:

        He committed a crime and deserves to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. He won’t be, though. Who watches the watchmen? Absolutely no one, it seems.

    • sendepause says:

      Well he´s been fired. Although I don’t think it means that is not “getting away” with his shit, it’s rather the White House trying to fuck with the investigation into Trump/Russia. It also helps to distract from Sally Yates’ testimony *smoke screen*

  3. Shambles says:

    … Lock him up

    And yes I do believe he’s compromised

    • Tiffany :) says:

      I didn’t think it was a strong possibility…until now. Overstating it by “hundreds of thousands” is such an incredible exaggeration, I don’t see how it was just a slip up. This seems intentional, which makes me wonder about his motivations in a way I hadn’t before.

  4. OriginallyBlue says:

    How do you misstate something like that. It’s either hundreds of thousands or a handful. That is a huge discrepancy and he needs to be brought back to explain himself AND they need to publicly apologize and set the record straight.

    • original kay says:

      I agree 100%, however, just like his letter last year, the damage is done. People will say he was forced to apologize, and that his original statements were correct.

      I gave him the benefit of the doubt, but now, no. He is compromised, completely.

    • NtSoSclBtrfly says:

      I am so sick of the lack of clear labeling on all of these behaviors from tRump on down through his administration to Comey and beyond.

      Call them what they are. LIES. From LYING LIARS who LIE.

    • Tiffany :) says:

      I agree. This is too far to be a simple slip up.

  5. Giulia says:

    I’m less worried about Russia than about this:
    http://hedgeclippers.org/out-of-town-billionaires-trump-backers-attempt-to-hijack-local-school-board-election/
    Multiply tampering by 100s of local elections across the country. F**king Citizens United.

    • Kimble says:

      We had Koch, Bush and other money pour into our school district from 2009 and reformers have decimated our school district. It’s a real threat that most people are not aware of.

  6. krAkken says:

    I have long thought that the Russians had dirt on Comey that motivated him to interfere ahead of the election.

    • Tate says:

      That wouldn’t surprise me

    • RussianBlueCat says:

      I thought the same thing. I also think Wikileaks is sitting on a lot of damaging information. Just waiting for the right time for it to be released

      • comeonnow says:

        They aren’t waiting for the right time, they are waiting for Daddy Putin to tell them to.

    • Lucy2 says:

      I’m thinking it has to be something like that. There is no logical reason he announced the info on Clinton but then stayed silent on the fact that the FBI had been investigating Trump since June.

      • comeonnow says:

        The Clinton stuff is complicated. The FBI NYFO is compromised. The letter is in response to feared, untrue leaks from that office to the media re: emails.

  7. grabbyhands says:

    Well, Bigly and his cadre can’t go screaming about how he lied because ultimately it will make Hilary look like she was being unfairly targeted (which she was) because Comey “misstated” (also known as lied about) the facts.

    Unfortunately, lying under oath about Hilary isn’t going to outrage a whole lot of people-the shock value for that has passed and no one really cares anymore. When I say that, that doesn’t mean I think they SHOULDN’T care, but the grim reality is that we’ve reached a level where it simply isn’t going to motivate anyone – nothing is going to be done about Comey or how he helped contribute to the bungling of the election, and she has lost her final chance at the big prize, so people have moved on. We all keep hoping that something will stick, but apparently the saturation point has been reached and all this just seems to be screaming into the wind now.

  8. Natalie S says:

    WTF? I thought Comey’s whole thing is that he’s obnoxiously self-righteous but honest. He deliberately lied.

    • Christin says:

      Sometimes those types are the least trustworthy. I hope the truth finally comes out, though I think it’s going to take years instead of weeks or months.

    • Olenna says:

      After disclosure of the email investigation just before the 2016 election, I gave up any notion of him being trustworthy. His complicity/partisanship with the GOP was clear as day at that point. Obama should have forced him to resign.

      • Really? says:

        Why did Obama appoint this guy? To show how centrist he is as a President? Comey has never even been a Democrat. Comey is the same guy that prosecuted Martha Stewart but none of the male executives at ImClone. As Deputy AG, Comey endorsed waterboarding and sleep deprivation for 180 hours as interrogation techniques. He publicly went against Obama in stating that police officers wearing body cameras were less effective at their jobs. Now Obama’s presidential legacy is in tatters, and the Democrats look like fools for compromising with extremists.

    • Who ARE These People? says:

      Same.

  9. wheneight says:

    I really hope that Comey knows that history will either look at him in one of two ways: 1. complicit, if he continues to sit back and shrug about all of this Trump/Russia scandal or 2. a national HERO if he takes down Trump with the dirt he has (I’m sure he has enough if what’s already out there is this bad). I mean, there will be MOVIES about him. MOVIES. This is such a huge moment. Comey, save us all and clear your name!

  10. smcollins says:

    I always love the use of the term “misstated.” He LIED. Or, at the very least, exaggerated/embellished the facts to make it sound worse than it actually was. Either way, he didn’t tell the truth.

    • Lucy2 says:

      IKR? Mistated would be like accidentally saying 832 when you meant to say 823.
      This is lying.

  11. adastraperaspera says:

    I think Comey has made this whole thing impossible for himself by bending into a pretzel trying to make sure that FBI internal struggles (that helped compromise our election) aren’t exposed to the public. He’s put our entire democracy at risk to do so. He better rain indictments soon. This is way past scary.

    • NtSoSclBtrfly says:

      Sqeal like a pig, Comey. Time to squeal like a pig.

      • Char says:

        Pigs are nice, don’t bring them to this mess. Time to squeal like the coward lier he is.

    • comeonnow says:

      I agree that he is really going out of his way to cover the bureau BUT I am withholding judgment because the FBI NYFO is right in the middle of this mess.

      I’m not convinced that part of this was to keep the CI investigation compartmentalized from the NYFO.

      The truth will out and I sincerely believe that Comey’s FBI is closing in as we speak.

      • Who ARE These People? says:

        We’ll have to hope but still…why would he grossly exaggerate something like that? What a smooth liar he may be.

  12. Rhiley says:

    Oh, lordy!

  13. boredblond says:

    and we all thought the FBI investigation would at least be more thorough than the two going on in congress…we need a deep throat to get past the politics.

    • Tiffany :) says:

      Yes! The checks and balances of congress aren’t doing their job, the intelligence department seems compromised. We need a patriot to step up and stop the corruption.

  14. Dttimes2 says:

    I just read this to hubby who said you mean he hasnt already neen fired
    ..
    So why hasn’t he been fired? He influenced an election and now lying under oath..i thought y’all had a system that made getting rid of people easy???

  15. Julie says:

    We would be arrested for this.

  16. Luca76 says:

    We are so f***ed right now if Comey resigns we get someone even worse.

    • Desi says:

      Yeah, it’s a bit like that “drain the swamp” bullsh-t. Nobody thought to ask what they’d be filling it back up with. I swear to god, every single idiot who voted for this never-ending sh-tshow should have to report, Hunger Games-style, for the Face Punching.

    • Tiffany says:

      He did it to himself. He chose not to walk when # 44 left. And it was telling that Casino Tangerine asked him to stay one. This clown is no prize and it is only going to get worse for the FBI with him there. He is doing everything to make that waste of space squatting at 1600 look good right now. Why would he resign.

      • comeonnow says:

        Why would he walk away from a HUGE counterintelligence investigation involving POTUS.

        If he really wanted Trump to get away with it resigning is the first thing he’d do. He would get to walk away clean and let a new Trump appointed FBI director bury all the evidence.

    • Tiffany :) says:

      Comey was just fired.

      I think he did such terrible things (treating Clinton differently, lying about Huma emails)…but you are right. Now we will get a Trump appointee. I am TERRIFIED that will kill the intelligence community’s ability provide justice for this corrupt administration.

  17. Desi says:

    Could someone explain to me how these people KEEP F-CKING GETTING AWAY WITH THIS SH-T??!!

    • Macscore says:

      I know, @Desi, I know! My forehead is flattened and bruised from banging my head into the wall EVERY SINGLE EFFING TIME this BS keeps coming up!!!!! This is WORSE THAN WATERGATE – the complexities, corruptions, interconnected crimes of dissembling and lying – c’mon, people, do something! Argh. Out of words.

    • Tiffany says:

      Because it is more important to erase the history of a black man and keep qualified women in their place. Mediocre, white men were being victimized and they were not going to take it anymore.

  18. robyn says:

    Comey has always behaved strangely and over-explained his bad decisions like a guilty man.

    • Who ARE These People? says:

      Yes, it’s gone too far. Diane Feinstein has been openly skeptical and pointed out he had other alternatives last Fall. He doth protest too much.

  19. Lizzie says:

    A lying liar lied? Shocking! He needs to be run out of Washington with a pitch fork. I’m so sick of the characterization that he was stuck between a rock and a hard place on disclosing the Clinton stuff. He is in cahoots with republicans and it has been clear from day one. F this guy.

  20. Disco Dancer says:

    Comey’s mouth can be a cock holster for Trump’s little penis- thanks for the wonderful magery, Stephen Colbert.

  21. Rapunzel says:

    Comey lying is not surprising. And I’m hearing they want to just quietly correct the record? Um….no. What he said under oath should stand and he should retestify or get arrested for perjury.

  22. comeonnow says:

    I don’t doubt that Comey misspoke but forwarding a narrative where he’s the villain only helps Trump and moves forward the Kremlin’s talking point.

    Comey isn’t perfect but he’s handling this Trump/Russia stuff admirably. I’ll be ready to hold him to task for the Clinton stuff after the Russian plant in the White House is removed.

    “Comey is the villain” is straight up Kremlin agitprop. (Not saying celebitchy is in on it or anything like that remotely.)

    • hmmm says:

      No one knows HOW Comey is handling this Trump/Russia stuff. To assume he’s doing all the right things smacks as much of disinformation as anything else. Moreover he’s already proved more than once that he’s more than happy to deep-six the country and now this. Don’t need no stinking agitprop when the truth is staring us in the face.

      • comeonnow says:

        How does it smack of disinformation? I’m sorry but the facts speak for themselves. Why is Comey heading up an entire task force *just* for this Trump stuff?

        We will see what happens but I have full confidence in Comey regarding Trump/Russia and I find the timing on this leak to be very convenient for Trump.

        As for the other stuff wrt Comey, yeah, he made a pretty huge mistake with the emails. But honestly, at this point, what’s done is done and we need to focus on getting rid of Trump and minimizing the damage.

    • Tiffany says:

      You are giving him more credit than deserved. He is not that smart.

      • Ankhel says:

        Yet another bit of growing up – realizing even heads of intelligence can be dumb enough to lie poorly.

      • Kitten says:

        Exactly. The dude is a straight-up buffoon.

  23. Bobbysue says:

    We need a scratch sheet to keep up with all of the players and all of their games. And most of them are crooked independent contractors just working their own skewed angle on their own little corner — every man for himself oblivious to whatever the hell scheme somebody else is trying to run. It’s like a classroom full of 3rd grade boys with no teacher or supervision. They’ll be damned if all the rest of them are going to let a few hooligans get away with committing mayhem.

  24. Digital Unicorn (aka Betti) says:

    Trump just fired him – wonder which Trumpton will replace him in order to interfere with the Russian investigation. Someone was getting too close to the truth.

    Its front page news here in the UK. Knocked Theresa May and her TV interview with her husband off the news.

  25. adastraperaspera says:

    Good God, Tr*mp just fired Comey. This is terrible.

  26. robyn says:

    Trump quickly seized the opportunity to fire Comey and to use Hillary as an excuse. I’m not sure if Comey mischaracterized the Weiner emails on purpose or if he was actually set up by Trump all along to think about that finding of emails in a certain way, knowing Comey would appear to lie about it later. I wouldn’t be surprised if this FBI guy was conned by Trump.

  27. Disco Dancer says:

    Breaking News: Trump has FIRED Comey! Wow!

  28. LYla says:

    Whao. Trump just fired Comey on the recommendation of Session.

  29. Kelly says:

    I’m honestly shocked that Trump fired Comey. It could have happened to a more deserving person, though for the role he played in undermining HRC’s campaign.

    I decided wade onto Twitter to see what the reactions were and most were “this really isn’t normal”. The MAGA and deplorable trolls are out in full force, completely misinterpreting why Democrats and anyone who disagrees with them are upset by Comey’s firing. We’re not upset because we like him now that may be investigating Trump’s ties to Russia – we’re upset because it’s a blatant abuse of executive power. Imagine the outrage if Obama had done the same thing late October last year.

  30. Deeanna says:

    While legislators across D.C. are expressing their shock at Trump summarily firing FBI director Comey NOW, the Trump White House is expressing its surprise that anyone is looking at this act as an attempt at a cover up.

    This White House has to be the most tone-deaf administration in a long, long time! Trump writes a letter in which he attempts to exonerate himself by stating he had three conversations with Comey assuring him he (Trump) was not under investigation. And then Trump adds “Oh, by the way, you’re fired”.

    So Trump just fired the head of the agency that is investigating him.

    For those of you who are too young to remember Watergate – this is how it happened. It just all happened a lot more slowly due to there not being the internet and twitter in those days.
    When Gerald Ford pardoned Nixon and said “Our long national nightmare is over” this kind of thing is what he is referring to.

    Look up the “Saturday Night Massacre” when Nixon fired Archibald Cox, the Special Prosecutor who was investigating Watergate. The Attorney General resigned in protest of this and then his Deputy Attorney General immediately resigned, also in protest.

    Today echoes that. And boy does this stink to high heaven. But this will likely lead to appointment of an independent Special Prosecutor.

    • Christin says:

      Within the past hour, I looked up the Cox summary and read that the public outcry after the sudden firing was what seemed to bring momentum to the situation. Yet in the Nixon/Cox debacle, where two people resigned in protest — I’m not sure we have the same level of non-partisanship, ethics and integrity today.

      Now it’s reported that Comey (in LA, speaking to their field office) found out by looking up and seeing the news on a TV monitor. Cold!

    • mee says:

      it’s truly unbelievable how far we’ve descended under this admin. yes not sure whether others will resign in protest of trump’s firing. the repub party is ridiculously corrupt today, or maybe compromised. yet, hoping that this is the beginning of a public outcry against him and a demand for an independent prosecutor.

      and that’s the other thing, they’re so freaking inept at everything. even firing – can’t they even do that right? it looks so bad and then, they even leak to the press before they fire the guy. idiots!

  31. raincoaster says:

    If he were BETTER at lying under oath, he’d probably have kept his job.