‘The Idol’ was always meant to be a ‘limited series’ with no second season!

Originally, The Idol’s showrunner and director was Amy Seimetz. Seimetz had already shot a huge chunk of what was supposed to be the first season when she was pushed out by Abel “The Weeknd” Tesfaye and HBO. Not only had Seimetz already shot a lot of her original vision for the series, she had done so at great cost, reportedly around $8 million an episode. Still, Abel had a different vision – he wanted the show to focus more on his character Tedros, the “charismatic cult leader” who preys on Lily Rose Depp’s Joceyln. So Sam Levinson took over, reshot some of the show, focused more on Tedros and then… everyone realized that Abel can’t act for sh-t and that he comes across like a loser and a charisma-vacuum. After Abel realized that everyone was laughing at him, he tried to play it like he MEANT to do that, that everyone is supposed to think Tedros is a total loser. Sure.

Well, true story: now HBO/Max is trying to play it off like The Idol was never supposed to be a series, it’s only a limited series of six episodes and there won’t be a “second season.” That was not what everyone claimed just a few months ago, but again, sure.

The Weeknd is said to not be planning a second season of “The Idol” — amid backlash over outrageous sex scenes on the controversial series and the singer’s “egomaniacal” behavior on set. The Weeknd, whose real name is Abel Tesfaye, co-created and co-stars in the show, which has been slammed as “comically bad.” Ratings for the second episode fell by 12%, or more than 100,000 viewers, from the June 11 premiere.

But a source told Page Six: “This was never meant to be a long-running show, it was always … a limited series.” A source inside HBO, however, said that “The door is definitely still open — it’s definitely not a decision [yet]. At this point, this is normal in our process … we’re only two episodes in.”

The source added that HBO was not shocked by reaction to the graphic show, which airs on its Max streaming service.

“It’s a Sam Levinson show, and you know what you’re getting with a Sam Levinson show,” said the source of the show’s co-creator and director, who also oversees the network’s shocking series “Euphoria.”

One show source told Page Six that working with Tesfaye, 33, in character as Tedros was “not an ideal experience … and not one I am eager to repeat,” while another called him “egomaniacal.”

A first iteration of the series was scrapped and totally reworked by Tesfaye and Levinson after the departure of original director Amy Seimetz, who had already filmed the majority of six episodes. Seimetz has yet to speak out about her time on “The Idol.” Rolling Stone later reported that Tesfaye and Levinson cut out the feminist-leaning storylines, with a production member comparing the new direction to “a rape fantasy.” One highly placed industry insider estimated each episode originally cost around $8 million, before they were rewritten.

The industry insider said “The Idol” was meant to be a huge show for Max as it’s the first major series on the freshly named streamer.

“It was a big, big show for them with big talent and a lot of buzz,” the insider added. “But from what I heard, HBO knew it was a bit of a turkey as soon as they saw it. But [now] you have all the headlines — and that kind of makes up for it.” The HBO source said, “The only person who makes the decision [about a second season] is the head of HBO, Casey Bloys, and he is optimistic.”

[From Page Six]

I suspect that we’ll go from “this is a sexy exploitative show by Sam Levinson and The Weeknd” to “of course Abel knows that he’s playing a total loser” to “Abel’s vision was always to do a critically panned limited series and leave the audience wanting more!” I can’t believe they spent all of that money on this disaster. Well, at least there’s a very good chance that no one will get the chance to hate-watch a second season.

Photos courtesy of Avalon Red, Cover Images.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

31 Responses to “‘The Idol’ was always meant to be a ‘limited series’ with no second season!”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Flowerlake says:

    Reviews were terrible and people say it’s misogynist.

    I don’t always think that musicians should not be in acting but in this case…I won’t be watching.

    • Kitten says:

      This dude thought he was gonna have a debut like Will Smith in Six Degrees of Separation when really he’s debuting like Vanilla Ice in Cool As Ice.

      You tried, bro.

      • Flowerlake says:

        Don’t know why musicians so often have to use misogyny.

        If he had made a show about some issue in society that is alive and well, then, even if he was as bad at acting as they say, he would still be respected for his effort.

        Now he just looks foolish.

      • nisa says:

        It would be nice if this were a cautionary tale for producers about nepo and vanity actors (LRD and this guy, respectively). Maybe seasoned, talented actors could have elevated the material? Maybe not, but bad material + bad acting = this mess.

  2. Tanesha86 says:

    I’m kinda curious about the footage Seimetz already finished. I bet it’s a helluva lot better than the final product

    • Turtledove says:

      Agreed. The idea of a cult leader and pop star could have been interesting, but it’s just NOT. I would love to see what Seimetz did, especially as it has been said it had a female perspective.

      Euphoria is great. It definitely had a LOT of problematic aspects, but I can’t lie, I enjoyed it. There was definitely so much gratuitous sex/nudity, and the show had a lot of shock value, but I was still invested. Zendaya was incredible, and even the terrible characters were interesting.

      But The Idol has all the shock and gratuity with no substance at all. The supporting cast is really good but are underutilized. LRD is beautiful, but it’s hard for me to say if she can act because all they have her do is shimmy, pop out a nipple and smoke. I suspect that she does have talent, and the camera loves her, but they aren’t giving her anything to work with.

    • Nic919 says:

      The parts without the Weeknd are noticeably much better than whenever he shows up. It would have been interesting to see that version of the show.

    • Kirsten says:

      Same. I love Amy Seimetz.

  3. girl_ninja says:

    Abel makes good much but the theme has always been misogyny towards women. He’s shown himself to be a bore as an actor as well now. Stop looking at women as less than you Abel. Get some therapy my dude!

  4. shanaynay says:

    OMG! I watched 15 minutes of it the other day and it was god awful. Personally, I think all the actors/actresses, if I can even call them that, sucked!! It was just bad, bad, bad acting. I didn’t even get to the part with The Weekend. I just couldn’t continue watching.

  5. Spillthattea says:

    Unwatchable. I tried to finish the fiirst episode the other night and turned it off as it made me nauseous.

  6. K says:

    Can we just please drop this shat the bed show and put The Gilded Age back on ffs. Also someone needs to get Brian Cox and the pithy,mouthy Oasis guy for a modern Old Muppet Men in Balcony style review of this series I promise I will sub to HBO MAX for that.

    • TQ says:

      @K – WOW — love this idea! Cox and Liam Gallagher as the new Statler and Waldorf Muppets! LMAO!

      And yes, please more The Gilded Age!

  7. Kitten says:

    Keep the spin coming! The Idol is still at 26% on Rotten Tomatoes, you absolute f*cking clown.

    • Dierski says:

      +1 His daily shifting spin to try and save face is vastly more entertaining than the show itself…

  8. Veronica S. says:

    Anybody with a basic writing background would tell you their huge mistake was revolving the story around the cult leader. I’m not talking only from a feminist viewpoint but a basic structural one.

    Your protagonist has to be the character going through major change. Your antagonist often drives the change, though not always. If the story was about HOW the character became a cult leader, that’s different, but starting the story where he always was one means he’s not going through a change the audience can follow. This kind of basic structural understanding of storytelling is why the writing needs to be left to actual writers.

    • Nic919 says:

      I think they could base it around the leader, but they needed a better actor than the Weeknd. He doesn’t have the charisma to make it believable that he could have an already famous pop idol want to follow him. It’s written so poorly that no one buys her fascination with what seems like a dull man with issues.

  9. Steph says:

    Sounds like Abel was playing himself. It checks out with everything we’ve heard about him.

    I’ve hated the Weeknd ever since his Toronto days when he’d try to get bouncers to deny black women from entering clubs while he was there.

  10. Mar says:

    I happened to catch tnr sex scene and it was just so bad and raunchy and unwatchable

  11. manda says:

    I’m watching it because I watch a lot of stuff and I was curious about this, and actually, the stuff that is just her and her life really is interesting and sad. Jocelyn has just gotten out of a stay in hospital for a mental breakdown, which occurred right before some gigantic concert she was supposed to have, so a lot of money was lost. Her mother had just died, and people are worried she still hasn’t recovered from that, and of course she hasn’t, she literally cries all the time in the show. But she has to get this new song out because people aren’t buying her concert tickets this time, and there’s a lot of stress that this new song might fail. (the song is so mediocre but it ‘ll get stuck in your head). She has a few people surrounding her that are interesting to listen to. I’m genuinely curious about that part of the story, but yeah, the scenes with tedros and his people are just bad and uncomfortable

  12. WiththeAmericann says:

    But they were laughing at people upset by their hate sex scenes saying they would be number one show because of it. What happened?!? Lol.

    should have kept the woman director. I’m so sick of Hollywood always replacing the woman with a man who doesn’t get the theme at all and ruins it.

  13. Diamond Rottweiler says:

    I’ll bet the financial drain of this smoking pile of shite is also to thank for getting one of the best shows HBO has ever done canceled after just two seasons. I strongly suspect they just pulled the plug on Perry Mason—after doing basically nothing to market it as the smart, beautifully-made, and sexy show for grown ups that it was—to make up for the massive financial loss of Idol. Really love to read a background piece on how the higher ups at HBO decided to turn their prestige streaming platform into this. The echo of “Skin-emax” in their new name change really doesn’t bode well. Who’s calling the shots there that led to this trashy debacle?

    • Kirsten says:

      Oh no! Why do you think they canceled Perry Mason? I love that show! Everyone in it is just fantastic.

      • Diamond Rottweiler says:

        I’m only guessing, but given how wildly over budget they went with Idol, and given that Perry Mason’s budget was ultimately the same as Idol’s, I imagine they canceled PM to claw back some of the money they burned on their trashy misogyny fest. It stings even more in that PM was finally moving toward getting the audience it deserved. People loved the 2nd season and it finally had some real audience momentum going. And, no spoilers, the way they left PM was awful. No ending at all. I think I’m canceling HBO now. I’m tired of getting attached to smart shows that get tanked mid storyline.

      • Lurker 25 says:

        Perry Mason is such a great show. Sob.

      • Hereforthegossip says:

        Came here to say that Perry Mason was cancelled a couple weeks ago via Deadline and Hollywood Reporter 😕 such a top tier quality show that was under promoted and if I remember right in a weird time slot.

  14. Coco says:

    Will he shut up it’s very obvious that Abel; thought Idol was going to be a huge hit and everyone was going to think he was amazing. Abel is better off not saying anything than this he is just losing face.

  15. Kelly says:

    HBO had to know that The Idol wasn’t going to be well received. That’s probably why they dumped it in June, and didn’t do much promotion other than the Cannes premiere, compared to other new show launches over the past year. The Idol did not get promotional blitz that House of the Dragon and The Last of Us got, and it seems that they are putting more effort into Emmy campaigns for their Emmy frontrunner shows.

  16. Kateee says:

    I watched the first episode. Both Lily and Abel have unique faces that look… not great… on camera. Her characterization is “unstable” and his is “rat tail”. There is no bottom to the lack of charisma, or sexiness, or talent* in any given scene, and in no way is it thought provoking. Is that the show’s message? About the emptiness of fame and/or celebrity worship? No, it’s just really, really awful without saying anything at all.

    *excluding the supporting cast, who must’ve signed on for the “real” version of this show and could not get out of their contracts.

    Anyway, long way of saying the HBO/Levinson/Depp PR machine will absolutely continue to throw the Weeknd under the bus. Much gross here.

  17. j.ferber says:

    Abel is such a jerk! And why would he name himself The Weekend? So stupid.

  18. allie says:

    The only good thing about the show is the music.