Princess Catharina-Amalia vs. Queen Maxima: who had the better tiara?

Here are some photos from The Netherlands – King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima are hosting a state visit for Germany’s President Frank-Walter Steinmeier and his wife, and they had a state dinner in Amsterdam last night. We haven’t talked about the Dutch royals in a minute, but they’re still doing their thing and doing it well. The heiress to the Dutch throne is Princess Catharina-Amalia, who is now 22 years old. Amalia was included in the state dinner and the official portraits. Yet another reminder that Europe’s royal houses are actually raising their heirs and heiresses to know the job from an early age. Compare this to Prince William’s lack of preparation even now, just weeks before his 44th birthday. Anyway, here’s some info about the Dutch tiaras:

To welcome German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier during his three-day state visit to the Netherlands, King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima hosted a state banquet at the Royal Palace in Amsterdam. In line with the white-tie event, where the dress code calls for statement gowns and glittering tiaras, their daughter Princess Catharina-Amalia pulled out all the stops in a fairytale blue gown and her mother’s wedding tiara.

Posing for a photo ahead of the banquet, the 22-year-old stood behind her parents in a cool blue column dress by Rachel Gilbert with a corseted, embellished bodice and draped straps that were reminiscent of Disney Princess Cinderella’s ball gown.

With her long blonde hair styled in tumbling curls in a half-updo, she proudly showed off her sparkling diamond tiara, which was a sentimental piece from her family’s jewellery collection. The starry design known as the Dutch Star tiara was made up of the base of the Pearl Button tiara, topped with five diamond star brooches that were given to Queen Emma when she married King Willem III in 1879.

Not to be outshone, Máxima also made a style statement on Tuesday night in a sapphire and diamond tiara largely considered to be one of the most spectacular pieces of Dutch jewellery. Created in 1881 by King Willem III as a gift for his second wife, Queen Emma, the towering tiara is made up of 33 large Ceylon sapphires and more than 600 diamonds and came as part of a set including two bracelets and a brooch.

Maxima wore the headpiece alongside matching drop earrings and a recycled cream dress by Jan Taminiau with flowers and birds adorning the fabric.

[From Hello]

I know that the whole point of having a royal family is to gawk at all of the jewelry, but can I just say? Maxima’s tiara looks so gaudy to me. Sure, the jewels are spectacular, but the actual design of the tiara is offensively bad. I love Catharina-Amalia’s tiara though – so elegant and simple. It suits her, and she has the face for tiaras.

Photos courtesy of Avalon Red.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

32 Responses to “Princess Catharina-Amalia vs. Queen Maxima: who had the better tiara?”

  1. YankeeDoodles says:

    Maxima is proof that a gorgeous personality can carry any hideous bauble. I don’t mean that as shade, I mean it as a compliment. She wears the stuff, it doesn’t wear her.

    • Tiny says:

      Nobody but Nobody wears big hats and big tiaras better than Maxima.

    • ArtHistorian says:

      Maxima has worn the Stuart Tiara in its biggest and tallest setting, which features the enormous historical Stuart Diamond. The tiaras in absolutely hideous IMO but she kinda pulls it off.

  2. Anne says:

    Maxima’s tiara is beautiful but it looks awful with that hairstyle. The side part clashed with the peak of the tiara, which is in the center. It out throws the whole oil off. Catharina-Amalia’s tiara is perfect for young woman.

    • Kaye says:

      I agree about Maxima’s tiara clashing with the part in her hair. I don’t necessarily think a center part would have helped, either. Maybe just all pulled back in a modified “pouf” held by the tiara?

      On the other hand, the tiara is splendid. Go big or go home.

  3. MC_TO says:

    I scrolled in for the dress, never mind that tiara. Maxima’s dress is stunning! Tiara doesn’t suit it.

    • Chaine says:

      I didn’t even notice the tiaras because my gaze was immediately drawn to the dress! The design with the tree and the birds is incredible.

    • Lauren says:

      The pattern on the dress is actually inspired by a wallpaper at the Dutch palace and the craftsmanship of the dress is stunning

    • irisrose says:

      Is this the same dress she wore for the opening of Parliament a few years ago?

  4. gaffney says:

    These two are my fav for Royal Watching.

  5. Becks1 says:

    Catharine-Amalia’s is perfect for her IMO. It’s elegant and goes well with the dress, without overwhelming her.

    I love Maxima’s though. I know its huge but she pulls it off. and it really works with that dress. The only thing I wish is that her hair was parted in the middle and not on the side. But otherwise I love it. That’s what we mean when we saw we want to see the bling!!!

    • irisrose says:

      iirc this sapphire tiara can be dismantled and the large diamonds used on a smaller tiara. Mabel wore the smaller tiara with borrowed diamonds for her wedding.

  6. M says:

    Go look at photos of Maxima during her husband’s coronation. You’ll understand that tiara better. I love it but not with this dress. The tiara Amalia has on is what Maxima wore for her wedding. It’s lovely on her.

  7. Josephine says:

    To me, the best dressed woman there was Elke Büdenbender, no tiara needed. Tiaras have a tainted history to me and they belong in museums. As does the idea of royalty.

    • SuOutdoors says:

      Elke Büdenbender looks like the accomplished woman (former judge) she is. Clever, hard working, very down to earth. I really like to be represented by her…

  8. Jais says:

    I’m someone that weirdly finds a lot of tiaras kind of ugly. The gems are pretty sure but sometimes I’m just like meh. So I’m gonna like Amalia’s more. Stars are fun and whimsical although it does make me think this could be worn at a 4th of July party😂. One of my favorite headpieces ever has stars, and it’s the one that hedy Lamar once wore. Although that one wasn’t exactly simple but it was so cool.

    https://www.theluminariesmagazine.com/hedy-lamarr-a-galaxy-of-stars-for-a-film-goddess-and-beautiful-mind/

    • ArtHistorian says:

      Tiaras with stones almost always kind of ugly because it when it comes to large gemstone, the ideal is to design the piece around the stone but with a tiara it is all about the overall architecture of the piece. The only tiaras that work with very large stones are the bandeau tiaras that has converted old riviere necklaces or belts to a very impressive headband.

      • irisrose says:

        IMO one of the few exceptions is the Empress Alexandra Aquamarine Kokoshnik Tiara.

  9. Tulipworthy says:

    Love Max’s tiara. Catherine’s look like the ones I’ve seen at discount stores in the mall.

  10. Interested Gawker says:

    Max is terrific with jewels and Catharina-Amalia’s tiara is lovely. Proper, old school Royal watching, thank goodness…

  11. Anita says:

    I cannot believe they released the photo with William Alexander’s eyes closed! LOL! Is he not the king and – sort of – the focal figure? (Love it! 🙂 🙂 !!!)

    • Lauren says:

      Unlike the Windsors with their tight image control the Dutch RF just has the press pool at their state dinners, including video, so all images are available like they would be for any other event.

      • irisrose says:

        post keeps disappearing. The Dutch royals have a Media Code that prevents photographers from photographing them off duty. The code isn’t binding, but if media outlets do not follow it, they can be banned from all official events.

        Republishing a facebook photo of Amalia on holiday with friends, taken/stolen from a facebook account, was considered a violation of the Media Code.

  12. Cee says:

    Amalia’s tiara is the one her mother wore when she married Willem Alexander. I thought that was the sentimental value referred to in the reporting lol
    Amalia has such an attractive face and she looks more comfortable of late. She definitely has the face for tiaras.

  13. Teagirl says:

    What a difference from the photos the UK royal family takes. Lovely dresses all round, and genuine warmth in the shots. C-A’s hair is how long hair can be worn with a tiara and evening gown. I would prefer an updo with a tiara but if you’re going to have loose hair, this is fine.

    Max’s dress is wonderful. I wonder if there is a story behind it, what the trees and flowers represent? the Dutch had (have?) significant interests overseas having colonized islands in the pacific and perhaps the dress represents something there? Anyone know anything?

    • Teagirl says:

      I’ve just seen @lauren say “The pattern on the dress is actually inspired by a wallpaper at the Dutch palace and the craftsmanship of the dress is stunning”. That’s really interesting, thanks @lauren

  14. tamsin says:

    I think all the ladies had dresses with beautiful silhouettes and wore them beautifully. Maxima’s dress is a piece of art, and CM’s dress is just classic and elegant. I think Maxima’s hair was styled too loosely for the tiara- it looked like it wasn’t pinned or sprayed enough. I think that the size of tiara needed a hair-do to balance it though, otherwise all you would see is a tiara and a head. Who is the gentleman standing behind the Steinmeiers?

  15. Lauren says:

    Love to see the far more fashionable Dutch RF get featured on the site, Maxima and the other ladies of the Dutch RF are never dowdy. Hopefully the upcoming State Banquets in Belgium and the Netherlands with Japan will also be covered. It will be the first state banquet for Princess Ariane who has made so very interesting fashion choices recently so I’m interested in what gown she will choose. In Belgium it will be the first state banquet for all 4 of the Kings children and the princesses tend to either blow it out of the park or miss with their fashion choices

  16. L4Frimaire says:

    Maxima’s tiara is very pageant queen. It’s a clunky design. Amalia’s is much better. Not the best design either, but better than that coliseum on her mon’s head. I do like Maxima’s dress however.

Commenting Guidelines

Read the article before commenting.

We aim to be a friendly, welcoming site where people can discuss entertainment stories and current events in a lighthearted, safe environment without fear of harassment, excessive negativity, or bullying. Different opinions, backgrounds, ages, and nationalities are welcome here - hatred and bigotry are not. If you make racist or bigoted remarks, comment under multiple names, or wish death on anyone you will be banned. There are no second chances if you violate one of these basic rules.

By commenting you agree to our comment policy and our privacy policy

Do not engage with trolls, contrarians or rude people. Comment "troll" and we will see it.

Please e-mail the moderators at cbcomments at gmail.com to delete a comment if it's offensive or spam. If your comment disappears, it may have been eaten by the spam filter. Please email us to get it retrieved.

You can sign up to get an image next to your name at Gravatar.com Thank you!

Leave a comment after you have read the article

Save my name and email in this browser for the next time I comment