Lady Gaga’s Testino/Vogue photo shoot: ridiculous or strangely beautiful?

gaga3

Last week, we had a preview of Lady Gaga’s Vogue cover, and now we have the full Mario Testino photoshoot. In every shot, Gaga is wearing some variation of this stupid wig! I hate the tiny bangs trauma, and… well, it’s Gaga, so I can’t make the argument for Gaga needing to know what flatters her face. She doesn’t care what flatters her face. She only cares about Being High Art. The full Gaga interview is here, in Vogue. First, I wanted to put up the beginning of the piece, in which Gaga makes her entrance:

She is an hour late. Suddenly the curtains part and Lady Gaga makes her entrance, mincing into the room holding a porcelain teacup and saucer in one hand and a wineglass for me in the other. (Like fainting on command or dropping a glove, the long-lost art of making an entrance, which Gaga seems to have single-handedly revived, is a remarkably effective way to shift the conversation.) “I don’t like the idea of you having to drink wine out of a plastic cup,” she says as she makes her way toward me, one tiny step at a time. She proffers her powdered cheeks for a kiss-kiss as a bottle of Sancerre is opened, which she insists on serving to me herself. “Pouring your own wine is bad luck,” she says.

She is still in her day look: a slinky black-and-white striped dress—a gown, really—with a four-foot train and shoes that—do I even need mention?—make her feet look as if they are screwed on backward. The heels bring her nearly up to my height of six feet. (She is five feet one.) She has a Bride of Frankenstein updo, with a brooch perched on top. Gaga glances down at the bowl of candy on the coffee table in front of us, shoots me a look over the top of her granny glasses, and deadpans, “What, the Mars bars aren’t doing it for you?” I have eaten three of them, I tell her, and she apologizes profusely for making me wait. She then asks an assistant to bring us a proper spread, which arrives moments later and consists of enough filet mignon to feed twelve people.

Lady Gaga may be behaving as if she were a member of Marie Antoinette’s coterie—the powdered wig, the binding costume, the impeccable courtliness—but it’s a far cry from what I witnessed the night before. After catching her performance, I was ushered backstage to her dressing room and found a scene that seemed entirely unhinged. Gaga herself looked like a lunatic: Barefoot, still covered in fake blood, mascara running down her face, she was careening around the room in a robe made of red feathers like a cross between Alice Cooper and Big Bird. There were dancers running in and out, mixing and spilling drinks, and a peanut gallery of strangely bedazzled gay men sitting on the sofas singing “Adelaide’s Lament,” from Guys and Dolls, which Gaga joined in on when she wasn’t bouncing off the walls.

Gaga stumbled up to me to say hello and then introduced me to the guy she was hanging all over: a tall, boyishly cute heavy metal–looking dude with a mullet, wearing a sleeveless black leather vest. “This is Luc,” she said proudly. “He’s my boyfriend.” He looked down at her for a moment, and a knowing grin crossed his face. “OK, Bette Midler,” he said. Moments later I was ushered out of the room by Wendi Morris, Gaga’s road manager—in an effort, it seemed to me, to protect Gaga from herself. As I was walking through the curtains I looked back, and Gaga was in Luc’s lap. “Jonathan, wait,” she whined like a teenage girl in need of attention. “Don’t you want to stay and ask me some questions?” Obvious to everyone but herself: not the time for an interview.

[From Vogue]

She’s completely deranged. I love her. Here are more highlights:

Gaga on being exhausted: “Let’s call a spade a spade here,” she says. “I am really f-cking tired. I am at that last mile of the marathon when your fingers and your toes are numb and you can’t feel your body, and I am just going on adrenaline. But in the overarching objective of my life, I am really only at mile two. I try to keep that in mind.”

Gaga on being self-confident: “I was a strange, loud little kid who could sit at the piano and kill a Beethoven piece.” Still showing no false modesty, Lady Gaga says of herself now, “Speaking purely from a musical standpoint, I think I am a great performer. I am a talented entertainer. I consider myself to have one of the greatest voices in the industry. I consider myself to be one of the greatest songwriters. I wouldn’t say that I am one of the greatest dancers, but I am really quite good at what I do.” Big words from someone who’s only been around for three years. “I think it’s OK to be confident in yourself,” she says.

On her fans: “I am quite literally chest open, exposed, open-heart surgery every night on that stage, bleeding for my fans and my music. It’s so funny when people say, ‘It’s amazing to see how hard you work.’ We’re supposed to work hard! I have the world at my fingertips. I am not going to saunter around the stage doing pelvic thrusts and lip-synching. That’s not at all why I am in this. I don’t feel spiritually connected to anyone in Hollywood makeup and a gown with diamond earrings on. I am just a different breed. I want to be your cool older sister who you feel really connected with, who you feel understands you and refuses to judge anything about you because she’s been there.”

On expectations: “Because as an artist and as a performer, the person that they look up to to create this space of freedom and escapism, I want to give my fans nothing less than the greatest album of the decade. I don’t want to give them something trendy. I want to give them the future.”

On influences: Gaga herself is very open about her influences. “It’s not a secret that I have been inspired by tons of people,” she says, “David Bowie and Prince being the most paramount in terms of live performance.” She also seems to have made peace with the fact that she is compared to—or, less charitably, accused of ripping off—nearly every artist of the last 50 years. “I could go on and on about all of the people I have been compared to—from Madonna to Grace Jones to Debbie Harry to Elton John to Marilyn Manson to Yoko Ono—but at a certain point you have to realize that what they are saying is that I am cut from the cloth of performer, that I am like all of those people in spirit.” She takes a bite of filet mignon and says with her mouth full, “She was born this way.”

[From Vogue]

Okay, I was going to try to excerpt the best parts, but I just realized the whole article is really, really long and I need to move on to other stuff! So, you know, if you love Gaga, feel free to read the whole thing. If you don’t feel like it, just know that she talks a lot about her new album and gay rights and immigration and that kind of stuff. I guess. I stopped reading halfway through. I love some Gaga, but only in small, bite-sized pieces.

gaga2

gaga4

gaga5

gaga11

Photos courtesy of Mario Testino/Vogue. Slideshow here.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

87 Responses to “Lady Gaga’s Testino/Vogue photo shoot: ridiculous or strangely beautiful?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Jane says:

    These pictures are just not very pleasant to look at.

  2. Cheyenne says:

    She’s nuttier than a fruitcake but you can’t help but like her.

  3. liz says:

    I like it.

  4. Rasputina says:

    Still tired of her.

  5. Delta Juliet says:

    She is just.so.fug.

    I can’t stand looking at her.

  6. Quest says:

    Very tame considering we are looking at Gaga….she seems to be channeling some kinda “Mad Hatter/Alice in Wonderland characters” in these pics.

    It is looking sorta drag-queeny

  7. Micah says:

    I love the photos. She looks great, Oddly glamourous or Glamorously odd….either way it’s fabulous.

  8. Cherry Rose says:

    Why the hell does Gaga have a Vogue cover? She’s not high fashion. She just steals other people’s ideas, and calls them her own.

    Anna Wintour sucks!

  9. Marjalane says:

    Co-sign Julia. Blech.

  10. Rita says:

    It’s “out there” but I like it simply because there is real artistic effort in it IMO. Even the first pic of Rumor Willis getting ready for her bull fight is interesting (by the way Rumor, your bubble gum is stuck in your hair).

  11. annie says:

    She chopped up Brit’s pink wig!!!

  12. Genevieve says:

    Lame. NEXT!

  13. Tess says:

    I see a prolonged stay at McLean’s in her future.

  14. wendy says:

    In these photos she reminds me of Yolandi from Die Antwoord for some reason.

  15. Jayna says:

    Bland, ugly photos.

    I really like Gaga and will buy this album straightaway, but when someone calls themselves one of the best voices and best songwriters out there after putting out an album and a half of pop fluff, like I want to take a ride on your disco stick, that turns me off. Let your music do the talking and let others say that. What a turn off someone saying their album will be the best of a decade. Get off the coke, Gaga, and all your yes people telling you you’re the second coming.

  16. jackie says:

    I wish that she really was this amazing artist she claims to be, talking about her classic taste and abilities, yet putting out the MOST generic pop music in the world.

    I hate that she doesn’t just stay true to that, and has to put on this air of superiority. It really is overreaching and compensation for the things she thinks she lacks.

    Oh, and I am sick of her.

  17. RHONYC says:

    BRAVA!!!!!!!
    LOVE IT!!!!!
    STRANGELY!
    BEAUTIFUL!!
    FOR SURE!!!
    🙂

  18. aa says:

    She needs way more photoshop.

  19. RHONYC says:

    “I love some Gaga, but only in small, bite-sized pieces.”

    you said it Kaiser! sometimes my head starts to implode if i read to much about her at once. lol. thought i was the only one. 😆

  20. macey says:

    she sure does have an unfortunate face.

  21. lucy2 says:

    The wig kind of ruins it for me. I don’t think she has a very attractive face, and the wig sort of draws attention to that.
    I think some of her music is fun, and some of her costumes are interesting, but I don’t think it’s the high art she seems to project it to be.

  22. teehee says:

    Ugly!! I dont care who it is, the poses/colors/spaghetti dress/blue lipstick/cat-with-an-orange-peel-helmet-hair-cut does not look good

    edit yeah she pushes borderline absurdity as high art because it is ‘outside the mold’– well sometimes there is a reason for it being there.

  23. Erandyn says:

    Eugh.

  24. Cheyenne says:

    Anna Wintour has all but destroyed Vogue so it doesn’t matter any more who she puts on the cover.

    God, when I think what she has done to that magazine… at least the foreign editions are still classy. British Vogue is excellent, and Vogue España is great — if you can ever find it. (A magazine store near my office has copies once in a while.)

  25. Maud says:

    How about strangely ridiculous?

  26. Ron says:

    I HATE the no eyebrow thing. It’s like a sentence with no punctuation. And it’s all starting to seem so hokey now too. One of the things with other artists that were wild in their day ie Madonna, Cyndi Lauper, Bowie, Prince, Cobain etc was there was something that was attainable about their look. Some kid in Iowa could dye their hair or wear a shit ton of bracelets. Gaga is so out there, that there is nothing to emulate and after the meat dress, where is there to go really? Pete Burns? And there is no level of appropriateness ever with her, she went to her sisters graduation wearing no pants and a lampshade hat. Her sisters graduation is her sister’s day, not hers. This album better be fantastic, because she is getting old. She needs to morph.

  27. gabs says:

    I dont take anything she says seriously. Its GAGA ya’ll. lol She is insane but I love it. Of course she isnt the greatest songwriter or talent in the world though. Kanye West much? Talk about ego. I will buy the new album. The Fame was really good for what it was..POP.

    The eyebrow thing needs to be fixed. Why does she keep styling herself as an ugly tranny when she can look cute? I remember when she first started like in Just Dance she looked hot. So its not impossible

  28. Stubbylove says:

    I think if she went away for awhile – say 6 months – we would appreciate her more. It just seems like she tries too hard.

  29. JenJen says:

    I just saw on a show she took a camera crew to her old apartment and palmed the pad, ringing every apartment’s door bell at the same time. Not sure if it was just meant to be obnoxious or if it was the heavy drugs she seems to be on. The new tenant didn’t want to let her in but let the crew in.

  30. spinner says:

    She is strangely pretentious.
    She is strangely unattractive.
    She is strangely egotistical.
    She is strangely attention starved.
    She is strangely overinflated.
    She is strangely…need I go on??

  31. huh says:

    i like her music…but physically? uh, not pretty (literally)

  32. samihami says:

    She looks like Marilyn Manson in drag.

  33. im awful says:

    everything she does is to distract from her face.

  34. K-MAC says:

    stunning and beautiful! Vogue knows how to grab your attention!

  35. Lynda says:

    YIKES…what IS that????

  36. K-MAC says:

    I love that she has the confidence that she does; she has the chops to back it up, and why should she have false modesty?

  37. Dr_Venkman says:

    I said it when the shoot was announced and I will say it again: Testino is not a great photographer.

    He relies heavily on styling and tries too hard to be Annie in his arrangements.

  38. ann says:

    I just don’t see anything attractive about this woman physically.

  39. Mimi says:

    I loved her at first but am kind of over her now. She is way too over-exposed. And I appreciate her individuality but her “image” is starting to overshadow her music. Most of the time I just laugh when I see her lol. See…

  40. JustBe says:

    I think that these are some of the best photos of her that I’ve seen.

    I don’t think that entertainers have to feign a high level of modesty, but I think that to put out statements like, best current singer/songwriter, best album of the decade, etc. is a bit much. I think her ego exploded with the sales of her previous album. But, we all know that sales/popularity of a record cannot be the primary measure of the quality of the music (or else the world would’ve never known of the Spice Girls).

    I think that she has some talent, she has a good voice, writes music and is a trained pianist. But even those qualities don’t guarantee the output of a great record.

  41. Kitty_Cal says:

    Wow… Emo Phillips, is that you?

  42. Eleonor says:

    I can hear Victoria Beckham screams, Lady Gaga on American Vogue and she hasn’t got yet HER cover.

  43. serena says:

    She’s ridiculous. I’m getting tired of her.

  44. Darlene says:

    LOVE IT!!!

  45. Jayna says:

    Great points, JustBe. And even if there are some deep points on this album, will I be more shallow because I love dancing to the new Britney Spears album better? Gaga loaded this album down with a lot of tracks, which can mean filler, and so many themes. It may be fantastic, or she may have taken herself too seriously and lost great melody. We will see. I’m buying both albums when they come out, Brit’s and Gaga’s. I will give my review on both in the spring and say which is my guilty pleasure. LOL

  46. no says:

    Damn she is ugly no matter what they say… and in every single way…

  47. MNGIRL76 says:

    Co-sign @ Cherry Rose

  48. jover says:

    Agree cherry rose and cheyenne – since wintour decided about a decade ago to go the pop celeb route Vogue has been ruined. Someone has to explain why she has gone this celeb route – is she bored with fashion, is she being paid off by hollywood, is she so smitten with our celeb culture she wants vogue to reflect the most pedestrian aspects of it. On another thread Niki Taylor said she wanted to see models return to fashion mags;have Vogue subscriptions and sales really increased by having Blake Lively on your cover? as for gaggles, i predict she’ll sadly end up like Lauryn Hill of the Fugees.

  49. Cherry Rose says:

    Oh, Gaga was not “Born This Way”. Way before she ever became Lady Gaga, she was trying to make it in the rock scene, but failed.

    Nor did she wear all these stupid little outfits before becoming Lady Gaga. She was pretty normal until Interscope Records discovered her and formed her into what she is now. Basically, she is in the same vein that Avril Lavigne is. The girl didn’t even really know what punk was, but called herself punk because her record label told her to do it.

    Gaga is nothing more than a creation of a record label. I wish people would understand this.

  50. k says:

    samihami, that was my first thought, that it was marilyn manson.

  51. jover says:

    Not to beat this dead horse Cherry Rose but there is an unauthorized bio of her very revealing that strangely has been overlooked with pictures of her from her high school days wearing A and E; she appeared at loolapalooza in 2007 doing some burlesque act and was ignored and you’re correct she tried and failed to make it as a rock singer – the problem is as you correctly state she is such a creation of her label that i think much of her supposedly outre behavior is to distract from how manufactured she is – she has a few good songs, average talent, visually interesting sometimes and that’s about it – there are far better non mainstream acts that will never receive her attention.

  52. AMandaM says:

    Does anyone else think she really resembles Marilyn Manson in some of those photos? Ooops – just noticed you do!!!

  53. Sandy says:

    I just wish she wouldn’t speak. Really. Really.

  54. jc126 says:

    Very ugly look. Why does she do that to herself? It’s so unflattering.

  55. Stephy2585 says:

    She’s tired of it all.
    We’re (alot of us) are tired of her.
    Why doesn’t she do herself, and us, a favour and take a little breaksie??

    After Alejandro and the mess that passed for her lyrics I really believe she’s exhausted.
    Break time, Gaga.
    Come back stronger in a wee while.

  56. Angel says:

    She looks like a man. Ugly man. 🙂

  57. Chelly says:

    I love them. I need to see outtakes of these! She’s crazy and I love it.

  58. jr says:

    I wanted to like it. Not really a fan, but I am interested…it should have been lighter, more fluid and more sexy like her new album cover…it is too posed this photo-shoot, too tight…born this way…she should’ve went for a more open, natural look…boring for Vogue.seriously.Anna should have given Joan Smalls a cover!!!

  59. dahlia1947 says:

    “Marie Antoinette’s coterie.” Yes, I love that! And that’s what the pink wing reminds me of! I liked the piece about when she makes her entrance. She sounds witty and sophisticated, but at the same time she’s like a little girl, a character in a fairytale that she has created. “Jonathan, wait,” she whined like a teenage girl in need of attention. “Don’t you want to stay and ask me some questions?” Obvious to everyone but herself: not the time for an interview.

  60. RHONYC says:

    @ Kitty_Cal:

    Wow… Emo Phillips, is that you?

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    hahahhahahahaha! ahhhh, that was funny as hell. lol 😆

  61. HotPockets says:

    I co sign with almost every commenter. If lady gaga disappeared tomorrow and never took another photograph, put out a cd, or strutted around in her “LOOK AT ME DESPERATE GET UPS..” I don’t think I would miss her or even notice she was gone.

    She is completely overexposed and manufactured, it has become tiresome to see.

  62. I Choose Me says:

    I like Gaga’s music I do. I didn’t mind the crazy outfits when I thought she was just playing dress up and having fun but somewhere along the line she started to take herself wayyyy too seriously. These days I just wanna tell her shut up and sing.

    Edit. Was she always such a mouth-breather? Why do so many women pose with their mouths half open like that. Ugh!

  63. original kate says:

    banal & boring. just like everything she does.

  64. lola lola3 says:

    Homely woman, saggy boobs. Ick.

  65. Alexa says:

    I think she’s really beautiful . . . seriously. But I’m an American from the Northeast. Perhaps that explains it?

  66. Solveig says:

    She believes in her own hype, doesn’t she?
    I like the way she’s styled and I like the pics, that’s enough.

  67. Heather says:

    I actually could have liked the pictures if she didnt’ have that terrible wig on.

  68. Jen D says:

    I know a lot of people can’t stand her, but I think she’s kind of awesome. I mean, I don’t take her very seriously, but I appreciate the energy she puts into her entertaining. People will quote her “greatest voice in the industry” comment, but I prefer that to saccharine faux-modesty. For some reason it doesn’t come off as arrogant to me.
    I also really like the fact that she’s good to her fans. She puts herself out there for them, and that’s cool with me.

    I also think she’s batshit insane, but that’s neither here nor there.

  69. Gabriela says:

    Ridiculous. I’m tired of this bitch. I was such a big fan of her style back in 2009, when she was still the original The Fame Gaga.
    I hate this GaGa, please take this bitch back to the mental hospital.

  70. lachica says:

    She looks like Isabella Blow, sans hat.

  71. Bella says:

    I think she still represents avant-garde.

    Her cheese has slide off her cracker though.

  72. Trillion says:

    Fucking. Awesome. I’m thinking of all the little girls who have to sift through all the Disney pimped crud out there, seeking an artist from left of center to provide them with visual inspiration and a musical soundtrack to the young lives opened out before them. Brava. She’s like the Sinead/Bjork/Kate Bush of the up and coming gen. Love. Huh.

  73. Adrien says:

    Louise Brooks + Kirsten McMenamy circa 1989.
    Love the outfits.

  74. jayem says:

    I hate that wig too, but the pictures are amazing. I am a proud one of her Little Monsters. I love her! I think she’s genius crazy.

  75. Sue says:

    is there a wastepaper basket nearby? BLAHHHGGGG!

  76. GIA says:

    whilst I think these pictures are better than the crap she usually puts out there, largely because hse is actually dressed, I just don’t understand why we have to look at her flapjacks whilst walking by the newsstand. ?!

  77. Mouse says:

    I don’t see any beautiful, but I see a lot of strange.

  78. Wendy says:

    She is amazing.
    Love it all.
    Can’t wait to pick up the issue!!

  79. sammib says:

    Lady Gaga shits me to tears but these photo’s are amazing!

  80. arock says:

    if man-ray and betsy johnson had a kid, abandoned it on the streets of paris and was then adopted from a brothel by elton john and co co chanel, shed be it.
    i dig her.

  81. CeeCee says:

    omg her interview is ridiculous. Have a word with yourelf Gaga.
    She is influential to the masses for being controversial and kooky with her style, but her music is the same repetitive, prefabricated, lyrically lame pop we’ve been listening to for too long, and yet she talks about herself and her ‘art’ and ‘performances’ like she is a female reincarnate of John Lennon. Just f*ck off.

  82. cara says:

    these pictures are too tame, Mario testino’s stuff is always boring though. I was expecting something more daring with a subject like gaga.

    As for gaga, she’s more talented than a lot of her peers, and I think she just knows how to make headlines with hyperbole. But it’s all a show, I find her quite calculating and nothing she does is spontaneous or fresh, and therefore it’s not very interesting. She’s basically ripped off Grace Jones and Madonna’s playbook for success. Hardly ground breaking.

  83. crazydaisy says:

    Famous for being weird. Whatever.

  84. sweetzy says:

    Argggghh!! my eyes burn!!

  85. REALIST says:

    Very artsy. Maybe the Gaga has some regrets now about being an art student vs being Uber famous.
    Unlike most of the rest of you, I like it. It’s not all black and white blaaah..

  86. Crash2GO2 says:

    Is she allergic to smiling? I don’t think I’ve ever seen such a picture…