How will Benedict Cumberbatch’s Victorian ‘Sherlock’ garb be explained?

FFN_Sherlock_FFUK_exc_013015_51641950

These are not the first photos I’ve seen from the set of Sherlock, but they are the first we’ve been able to publish. Perhaps that’s because the production has moved to the city of Bath, England, and suddenly there are more paparazzi around, and they’re able to get clearer shots. Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman have been filming the new episode(s) of Sherlock for weeks now – they started in the new year, and I think there’s been a lot of start-stops because Benedict keeps having to fly to LA for his Oscar campaign.

Allegedly, they are only filming one episode right now, which will be the “Christmas Special” airing (hopefully) in December of this year. When other sites have published other set photos, the Sherlook-loonies were freaking out over Benedict and Martin’s seemingly Victorian wardrobes. I guess there’s the theory that the Christmas special will actually be set in the original canon’s time period, which was the late 19th century. While I have no problem with that, or with the idea of Martin and Benedict in Victorian garb, solving old-fashioned cases, I do think that it seems profoundly WEIRD for the modern world Moffat and Gatiss have created for their vision of Sherlock. I mean, how are they really going to explain it?

Meanwhile, I finally got the chance to see The Imitation Game. I’ve been covering it for so long and I actually did lose touch a bit with the whole “Oh, there’s a movie at the center of all of this” thing. I have to say, it was a really well-done film and Benedict IS great in it. TIG probably won’t win much of anything at the Oscars, but over the weekend, it did pick up the Ally for Equality Award from the Human Rights Campaign.

FFN_Sherlock_FFUK_exc_013015_51641936

FFN_Sherlock_FFUK_exc_013015_51641932

Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

113 Responses to “How will Benedict Cumberbatch’s Victorian ‘Sherlock’ garb be explained?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Sixer says:

    I think the Comet hijacked the TARDIS from Moffat’s spare bedroom and took Bendy on a spin back to Victorianaland.

    • Kiddo says:

      WRONG! Hot tub time machine, lol.

    • Sixer says:

      The TARDIS is going out with a WASHING MACHINE?

    • 'P'enny says:

      Don’t joke. That could be true. With Gatiss’s Dr Who writing style she may have been cast as Rani and we get a crossover on Christmas Day schedules. It will be the best way to get me hiding behind the sofa.

      • vauvert says:

        As long as the Master stays away and no Daleks, I am OK with it…

      • icerose says:

        Sherlock should win a Bafta for the most obvious nepotism fuelled casting, Can you imagine what would happen if they had children-mini Cumbies and comet Sophies running side by side the Watson gang.

      • 'P'enny says:

        nooo! Mary’s baby will be ‘acted’ by cometbendy-baby 🙁

      • Lilacflowers says:

        @’p’enny, the fake baby from American Sniper thought she had that role

      • 'P'enny says:

        LMAO @lilacflowers

        not seen it, but read all about plastic-baby nightmare.

    • LAK says:

      Don’t watch Sherlock, have no intention of doing so, but i’m puzzled. This version isn’t a costume drama?

    • Lilacflowers says:

      The TARDIS and the Hot Tub Time Machine have married and are busy producing little dishwashers. While the Christmas Special will bring us back to Victorian times, the next season will be one time-traveling, planet visiting extravaganza with Sherlock appearing dressed as Julius Caesar, Ghengis Kahn, Pontius Pilate, and King of Asteroid B612. Watson will choose to be Tom Brady, because Tom Brady.

      • Sixer says:

        I think it should include a visit to Woodstock. Then we could tie up with the trippy laudanum below.

      • Lilacflowers says:

        Yes, definitely a trip to Woodstock. Gatiss could be Timothy Leary.

      • icerose says:

        Comet Sophie could guest as Joan Baez ,Benny can use his Richard 111 wig to play Neil Young and he can grope the Comet in the finale.The Freemans can groove to Jefferson Airplane and Gatiss can sing the Who’s “Tommy’s Holiday Camp ” with a mysterious guest artist,

      • 'P'enny says:

        do the little dishwashers have time-bending abilities too? can I have one?

      • icerose says:

        speaking of Sherlock’s mysterious guest artist he won a Falstaff award for playing a roman general in a garment of humility with a lion’s roar.

      • Lilacflowers says:

        Yes, ‘p’enny, the little time-bending dishwashers are magical and they fly too

      • 'P'enny says:

        @icerose LOL!

        i don’t think he is a guest artist for the Christmas special or S4 i still think thats all fan-twitter. Still it brings a smile.

      • Lilacflowers says:

        @’p’enny, I think it’s all speculation too and if he did to a guest episode, it would be as a favor to Gatiss

      • Darya says:

        I’m still adamant that the ‘guest artist’ should stay far, far away from Sherlock- for so many reasons. Never, ever and nooooo sum it up nicely.

      • Alice says:

        Icerose. Nooooo!! I love Joan Baez and she is smart, funny, beautiful and principled. The Comet could never play that role. She could be one of the groupies, though.
        Maybe one of the Plaster Casters

    • LAK says:

      Sixer: Vapours!!!!!!

      • Kiddo says:

        Ooh, followed by laudanum hallucinations. Maybe he finds an old bottle, he somehow mistakenly takes it and is driven back in time IN HIS MIND. Trippy, man.

      • Sixer says:

        This one, I like.

      • icerose says:

        “Maybe he finds an old bottle, he somehow mistakenly takes it and is driven back in time IN HIS MIND. ” singing Plastic Fantastic Lover” by the by the Sophie Starship Band

    • MtnRunner says:

      I vote that Sixer (or likeminded posters) start off every Bendy thread with silliness before the serious, dissecting begins for the umpteenth time. Pleeeese???? For the good of humanity?

  2. Lindy79 says:

    Meh, they could be doing anything, we won’t know until Dec or whenever it airs, I just hope it’s not fan service like a lot of season 3. I’m liking the costuming on them both.

    Two articles/interviews popped up on my newsfeed this week
    1) interview where he says he hopes he doesnt win the BAFTA as he gets stage fright accepting at awards shows (!). So his face during Eddie’s speech was relief…..apparently.
    2) He joked that only politicians campaign and implied he is absolutely not campaigning.

    • Green Girl says:

      I didn’t realize he was a comedian, too! Because oh, sure, we believe you’re not campaigning. Suuuuure.

    • j says:

      @lindy79–he never says he hopes he doesnt win, just talks about stage fright…thats the sun for you though lol.

      i love these costumes ngl very neat!

    • An says:

      He ain’t lying about award show anxiety. I can only recall 2 times where he won something and didn’t look like he was going to crap himself on stage.

      • icerose says:

        To true but it looks good to play the shrinking violet when you are likely to loose, I dare him not to show up.

      • j says:

        he’s already confirmed for the baftas

        sherlock is on a filming crunch though, they lose freeman and gotta wrap by mid-feb

      • icerose says:

        @j I was thinking of the oscars

      • Lindy79 says:

        He’ll be at Bafta’s no doubt,. no flights or time differences to think about and unless filming has been scheduled that evening he’ll be there.
        Be shocked if he didn’t go to the Oscars but time will tell.

  3. michelle says:

    I hope they go the Victorian route – for at least one episode. I’d love to see them solving crime the “old-fashioned” way. But then, I am a huge fan of Murdoch Mysteries, so anything in this era would be great!

  4. Kiddo says:

    Daydream or dream sequence, or a case is examined that is similar to an old case and how might they have solved it back then.

    Those are common vehicles in US TV, anyway. They could make it REALLY US-like and turn the historic portion into a musical! How hilarious would that be? They could end with the cast singing Christmas carols.

    • Sixer says:

      Old time music hall! Bendy upsets someone by being supercilious, they clock him a good one, and there’s a rousing rendition of Two Lovely Black Eyes by the whole cast?

      • Kiddo says:

        Why not? (I had to look that song up.)

      • Sixer says:

        (My brother had to sing that as a solo (complete with shiner make-up) when we were at junior school.)

        They could follow up with a bit of fan service and do Hello, Hello, Who’s Your Lady Friend?

      • Lilacflowers says:

        Isn’t that a standard day on that set? I bet Gatiss is the one who clocks him.

      • icerose says:

        don’t forget ” And Baby Makes Three”

      • TotallyBiased says:

        Ooooo! I’ve got one for our favourite Comet (because for some reason I think of Anne Bolyn everytime I see a picture of her):
        “With ‘er ‘ead tucked
        underneath ‘er arm,
        She WAAAAALKSSS the bloody tower.
        With ‘er ‘ead tucked
        underneath ‘er arm,
        at the Midnight HOUR!!!”

    • michelle says:

      I could see that working (not the musical! lol) – something sort of like Cold Case (US) or Cold Squad (Canada) – flashbacks to the original case and detectives.

      Although a really horrible musical Sherlock does have its merits! 🙂

    • Lindy79 says:

      Will he step out of a shower at the end of the episode?

      It was all a dreaaaaaaaaaam
      *waves arms*

    • Jenny says:

      in what US form of entertainment is it normal to turn historical pieces into musicals?

  5. scout says:

    He IS REALLY good in that movie as Alan Turing, great actor. Sucks that “Theory of Everything” was also made in the same year, he lost out. Better luck next time.
    Love Sherlock Holmes, can’t wait.

    • Lilacflowers says:

      Birdman, Foxcatcher, and American Sniper were also made the same year.

    • Anne tommy says:

      He was good in TIG . As one of the three people who saw the fifth estate, I quite enjoyed that in a weird way. But these pics are not flattering. To those of us who have never felt the earth move whilst looking at Benedict, there were some reasonable pics of him recently. These, not so nice. I remain resolutely Hiddlestoned. Don’t know what to make of rumours that hiddles will be playing sherlock’s other brother.

  6. FlaviA_deluce says:

    Maybe Sherlock will get a flowerpot to the head like MacGyver did… Mac woke up in King Arthur’s Court.

  7. alice says:

    I’ll have to reserve judgment until I see it. I hope I like it, but I love Sherlock for its modern take. I haven’t liked several of the Moffatt Christmas specials, much as I adore Doctor Who.

    • 'P'enny says:

      the Christmas specials are always dire, that’s why I will no doubt roll eyes at Sherlock too. I just got a feeling it’s a all a bit rushed.

  8. betsy says:

    Eddie Redcarpet is bound to win the oscar. Shame as I’d love to see any of the others win but him.

    • Lilacflowers says:

      Why, of course. There can only be one posh Brit actor who wins all the awards; the others must burn!

      • Kiddo says:

        It’s the lip gloss, so says mimif.

      • Lilacflowers says:

        Hmmm, shall we ban lip gloss? Or just posh Brit actors?

      • 'P'enny says:

        excuse me? ban posh Brit actors? only if they act like knobs.

        oh, guess that’s all of them then. Hiddles gets a free pass – for the moment.

      • icerose says:

        Ban the lip gloss and baby makers unless they are born 364 days before the current Oscar. That will let Damian Lewis, Hugh Laurie in as well as Hiddles.

    • jammypants says:

      Direct competition is hard after all.

    • An says:

      But how will Eddie impress TSA workers without a new award 🙂

      I’m rooting for Keaton but kinda meh overall on the Oscars this year. I really wanted Ralph Fiennes, I guess.

    • moodgirl says:

      If I see Eddie Redmayne one more time I am going to throw up. He is everywhere; I understand campaigning but he’s an obnoxious fool.

  9. Green Girl says:

    I think some actors look goofy in period pieces, but I think the look really suits BC.

  10. NurseDarry says:

    Prefer the modern day Sherlock: bit too much of the Victorian-love all over the ‘Net for my taste, and what made the series so fresh was that it WASN’T playing up the character’s roots.

    BUT, I’m loving the Khan-hair. *fans self*

    • hermi says:

      Don’t like the hair, don’t like the Victorian theme, was hoping for a regular Sherlock episode.
      John’s moustache is humongous. 🙂
      It feels very much like a Doctor Who special. But who knows.
      Apparently, we’ll have to wait another century for the proper new series,

  11. KT says:

    I do really like the costuming/looks/set dressing I’ve seen, but it’s hard to tell what they are doing with so much filmed on interior sets.

  12. InvaderTak says:

    I’m going with sherlock gets a case from the past to solve and the old school outfits are in his “mind palace” (can I just rave for a moment about how stupid that phrase is? I hate it irrationally). I’m betting John ans Sherlock go over the same ground where the original crime happened and theses a modern /vintage parallel story running concurrently.

    • Gracie says:

      In his mind palace in translation is a couple of writers getting paid to be fanboys. Ironically, didn’t they say they wouldn’t go there because the comparison was something?

    • Felice says:

      I never got to tell you think but I love your name and that was my favorite episode of Zim growing up.

      People think it’s something like Return of Sherlock Holmes where Watson was frozen then thawed. I like the flashback theory better. I think this can make the show bounce back.

      • InvaderTak says:

        Aww thanks! It was my fav as well. Wish it had more seasons!

        And a costume party is the easiest explaination. Wonder how they’re going to explain moriarty being back from the dead. Moffat worries me sometimes.

      • An says:

        Didn’t think about that, Felice, but wow yes they can really get back to the mystery roots with this.

  13. kri says:

    Maybe it’s a costume party? Or a dream sequence in which The Batch get to go back to simply being a great actor, and I can find myself (oddly) attracted to Mark Gatiss. He is like a human cat to me. I will watch this, as Sherlock Holmes is my perfect man. Says alot, doesn’t it.

  14. Isadora says:

    Yes to the Victorian stuff (I’ll always love anything canon Holmes) and I don’t care how they explain it. *lol* I just hope it’s somewhat clever and reasonable.

    But no, no and no to the real fur trimmings of those jackets (and you can tell by the fluffiness and fine hair that it’s real). It makes my stomch turn. I will never understand why people find it fashionable to wear something for which animals were skinned alive and screaming in pain. Sorry for being graphic, but sometimes one has to speak in clear terms.

    • alice says:

      Amen, Isadora.

    • Ree says:

      those are not costumes. its just a set jacket. cheap one. no fur in view.

      • Isadora says:

        Of course they are set jackets, they hardly look Victorian. 😉 Doesn’t mean it’s not fur. Quite the contrary, sometimes quite expensive faux fur that looks pretty similar to real fur is used for tv/movies, however it’s more expensive than cheap Chinese real fur. But normal jackets and everyday winter wear either look different or have the (quite cheap) real deal, which is mainly raccoon dog or sometimes even cat fur. In this case it looks like “better” fur, so I guess those are jackets of some known brand.

  15. MtnRunner says:

    Digging the Victorian garb. Hoping that art doesn’t imitate life as in season 3. They just about lost me if it wasn’t for the last episode recovery.

  16. Kay Hendricks says:

    Come on, ladies. As a long-time Whovian and Sherlock fan, it’s obvious that the Weeping Angels sent them back in time. There was a shot of Martin and Amanda in the clothes from the runway scene at the end of “His Last Vow” walking in a cemetery, which is where Amy and Rory met the Weeping Angels and went back in time. Although Moffat said he would never allow a Who and Sherlock crossover, everyone knows Moffat lies! In reality, the best theory I’ve heard is that John is writing a book or a blog about them solving a past crime, perhaps a famous one. It’s curious that Doyle never had Holmes solver the Ripper murders. Perhaps he will, now.

  17. Intro Outro says:

    Hahaha oh my goodness, I go away for like a month, I come back and we’re still in the middle of a Cumberfest. At least I OBVIOUSLY haven’t missed anything 😀

    • Lilacflowers says:

      Welcome back!

    • 'P'enny says:

      yeah! where did you get to?

    • icerose says:

      nice to have you back -it has been a Hiiddles drought and Cumberbatch overkill

      • MtnRunner says:

        waiting anxiously for THAT tide to turn…

      • smyling says:

        sydneyzibrak on Instagram has a photo of Tom and Felicity Jones in a car, that’s supposed to be for Vanity Fair Hollywood. Also, Tom’s Glamour UK’s third sexiest man (out of 100) according to Torrilla. Hope that helps you ladies out.

      • TotallyBiased says:

        Hi, Innie Outie! Nice to see you again!

        @smylin–evidently the Vanity Fair Hollywood edition is actually supposed to feature a British Invasion piece–of course, the cover is the three Americans, but whatever.
        Tom and FJ are in a vintage Jaguar, in Beverly Hills. Of course!

    • Intro Outro says:

      Awww, thanks @Lilac, ‘P’enny, icerose!! <3

      It became so cumberboring here that I retired to my music fandoms, my fav bands released new material and we had to mull it all over ^_^ Apparently, it is still kinda too early to return to my happy Hiddles family lol. I can't wait for this drought to be over!

    • Intro Outro says:

      Sorry, double post!

  18. Felice says:

    Enty revealed the blind that the engagement was pushed because of the pregnancy. He thinks it won’t get to a wedding though.

  19. maudfricker says:

    He’s been replaced on Lost City of Z by Charlie Hunnam – something to do with his Marvel contract or so I read

    • 'P'enny says:

      really? LMAO

      I love charlie, but wow, six degrees of separation hiddles-replaces Benny, hiddles stars with Hunnam and Hunnam replaces Benny.

      • icerose says:

        it is an incestuous world with a limited amount of UK actots. I am surprised he gave up Lost City he must have been thirsty for some Marvel love.

      • InvaderTak says:

        @Icerose: Lol at your typo “actots”. that should be what we call kid actors.

        That’s an interesting piece of news. Maybe Charlie will stop talking about not doing 50 shades of crap now. I wonder what losing Lost City will do to Ben’s career. I honestly don’t have high hopes for his performance in a big budget, somewhat intentionally over-the-top movie after Star Trek. I didn’t think he was good in that at all. He took it way too seriously or something. I can’t really describe it; he just didn’t get it right.

      • Ann says:

        He’ll stop talking about it when he doesn’t get asked about it.

      • An says:

        I feel like that movie is doomed. Too much back and forth.

  20. Xazi says:

    “the “Christmas Special” airing (hopefully) in December of this year” — BBC Xmas specials always air ON December 25th.

  21. unmadebed says:

    Fantasy of the day: Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock is so stylish, smart and cool, I don’t want to be WITH him; I want to BE him.