Jussie Smollett found guilty on five out of six charges for 2019 hate crime hoax

Jussie Smollett's Mugshot

In January 2019, Jussie Smollett called 911 and said that he had been attacked in the early hours of the morning. This was in Chicago, and Smollett claimed two white men, men wearing ski masks, jumped him on the street, put a noose around his neck and told him “This is MAGA country.” The story grew more vivid and horrifying with each retelling, but Chicago police were always suspicious of Smollett’s tale. Within days, the Chicago PD was investigating Smollett for filing a false police report and wasting their time. Soon, police spoke to Abimbola Osundairo and Olabinjo Osundairo, who said that Smollett hired them to stage the assault. What followed was a full year of legal insanity. First, Smollett was charged with 16 felonies, then just as suddenly, the charges went away. Then a new prosecution team took over the case and charged Smollett with six counts of filing a false report and felony disorderly conduct. The trial seemed insane, with Smollett testifying on his own behalf and likely perjuring himself in a dozen ways. Predictably, the Chicago jury found him guilty on five out of the six counts on the indictment:

A jury in Chicago found the actor Jussie Smollett guilty on Thursday of falsely reporting to the police that he had been the victim of a racist and homophobic assault in 2019, an attack that investigators concluded was a hoax directed by the actor himself. With its finding, after more than nine hours of deliberation, the 12-person jury indicated it had chosen to believe the accounts of two brothers who testified that Mr. Smollett had asked them to mildly injure him as part of a publicity stunt. Mr. Smollett, wearing a dark gray suit and a blue shirt, sat upright in his chair, hands clasped, staring directly at the jury just after the verdict was read.

Daniel K. Webb, the special prosecutor who handled the case, said afterward that Mr. Smollett only made matters worse by continuing to stand by his account at trial.

“This jury worked so hard,” Mr. Webb said, “and for Mr. Smollett to come up before them and lie for hours and hours and hours — that really compounded his misconduct.”

The case was revived by Mr. Webb, who reviewed that decision and ultimately announced that a grand jury had charged Mr. Smollett with six counts of felony disorderly conduct. Mr. Smollett was convicted on five counts on Thursday, relating to conversations he had with the police just after the attack. He was acquitted on the sixth count, which related to a follow-up conversation with an investigator two weeks later.

The actor faces up to three years in prison. The judge did not set a sentencing date and released him on bond. His defense team said Mr. Smollett would appeal.

[From The New York Times]

Will he see a day in prison? I don’t know. Probably, but I doubt it will be three years. If the prosecution’s case was correct, then Smollett has huge issues. I say that as someone who made excuses for him in the beginning. The gleeful way people went after him – when there’s clearly some significant mental health issues at play – left me cold. It’s just a sad story and it’s sad it had to come to this.

Jussie Smollett causes a media frenzy as he leaves court in Chicago

Photos courtesy of Backgrid, Avalon Red.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

85 Responses to “Jussie Smollett found guilty on five out of six charges for 2019 hate crime hoax”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Enny says:

    It is sad, for sure, but he has to face penalties. Part of my job is to research hate crimes, which ones are taken seriously by police/ prosecutors, and which aren’t. There are so many real victims who never receive any meaningful justice, and then there’s this asshat taking up resources and shredding the credibility of real victims. He can’t just take an oopsie on this.

    • Erica says:

      Agreed. When the news first broke I think everyone was shocked and heartbroken. Then as more shit came out all I remember is how pissed I felt. Jussie needs help because what he did isn’t normal behavior.

      • Jan90067 says:

        Definitely not normal!! But wasn’t he trying to get a big raise on Empire at that time? A significant profile boost? I somehow remember this being brought up, And yes, some mental instability or lack of *something* hardwired to come up with this.

        By this point, I DO think he FULLY BELIEVES his lie(s) as truth. I know there’s a psychiatric term for this, but I can’t think of it right now on less than one cup of coffee!

    • whatWHAT? says:

      yeah, the DJs on the morning show I listen to were like “oh, he’s been punished enough…the embarrassment he must feel…”

      and I was like “NAH” because GD it, he wasted police resources and his BS gave ammunition to the MAGAts with the whole “cry wolf” thing and makes it harder for ACTUAL hate crimes to be taken seriously by those who already think that racism “isn’t a problem anymore”.

      I hope he is sentenced to mandatory mental health counseling with whatever other punishment he gets.

      ETA: to be clear, I don’t think any jail time is necessary…but give him a HEFTY fine and community service with victims of actual violent hate crimes.

    • Otaku fairy says:

      It is sad. It’s shocking that someone would do all of this. I did initially defend him and think he was telling the truth at first.

    • Ctgirl says:

      This.

    • Missskitttin says:

      Why did he due is when he was at the apex?

    • Sally says:

      Absolutely. There was a case of a woman falsely accusing a weatherman of sexual assault like ten years ago or so around here, so long before MeToo, but people kept.bringing.it.up during all the legit accusations and it’s so incredibly frustrating what one unstable (narcissistic ?) person can do to the fates of so many others.

    • coolspray says:

      Well said Enny – his conduct makes me so, so mad. Even if he had mental health issues, he shouldn’t have doubled down by lying in court and stringing everyone along. He had so many chances to come clean, and didn’t take them.

  2. LightPurple says:

    Right-wing Twitter is having a field day with this and using it to distract from other court actions that happened yesterday (Trump lost his “executive privilege” appeal; NY subpoened Trump; MI school shooting victim families sued the school; Josh Duggar convicted.) and to pretend that racism is just fiction.

    • Otaku fairy says:

      Of course. People don’t get that gleefully looking at this situation with the priority of, “how can I use this uncommon situation to mock and discredit other poc and weaponize it in my lib-owning rants about the pendulum swinging too far” IS being racist. There really isn’t much of a difference between reacting like that, and making the actions of one violent criminal about how a whole racial or ethnic group is dangerous.
      It’s not about feuds. It’s not a game. The concern should be for real victims who may be harmed by this in the future.

  3. Red Snapper says:

    He wanted to be Donald Glover, alas. More like Donald Trump.

  4. Chloe says:

    What exactly were the 5 accounts he was found guilty of? And why would he want to stage an attack on himself? What was the thought process behind this? And what was he trying to accomplish here?

    • Erica says:

      Speculation is he wanted attention. Like he hoped this would give him a lot of attention meaning more jobs for him, that sort of thing. I didn’t follow the trial much but he should not have went on the stand himself and honestly, if they offered him a plea, he should have taken it. The whole trial was a mess just from the articles I read about it. A ‘dry run’ attack, Jussie and one of the ‘attackers’ masturbating together and doing cocaine together. This was just….a LOT.

      • Bryn says:

        Its pretty much never a good idea to testify in your own defense. Jussie did himself no favors and came across as pretty unlikable from what I’ve read.

      • minx says:

        He was taken apart on cross examination. It wasn’t pretty.

      • Dutch says:

        At the time it was speculated that he did this because he was in a salary dispute with the show he was on and he hopes the attention and sympathy being a victim of a hate crime would get him the raise he was seeking.

    • Erica says:

      @Bryn, it was sooo bad. My wife was reading some of the articles to me while I made dinner and he should have sat in his chair and said nothing. His testimony is probably what did him in, honestly.

  5. Mac says:

    This prosecution is a ridiculous. It was a stupid stunt. Write him a ticket and move on.

    • ThatsNotOkay says:

      Chicago police and prosecutors most likely MAGA. They finally found a case that proves black people exaggerate racism and are the real racists. I read up on what happened in the case and, quite frankly, don’t know whom to believe. It was bonkers. But beyond that, felony disorderly conduct is an insane charge to levy against him, since it should require someone getting badly hurt or expensive property getting damaged. None of that happened here. Will/should probably be overturned on appeal. But with Trump having installed all the judges Mitch McConnell refused to allow Obama to hire, our judicial branch will be right winged at the lower levels for the next 50 years and injustices will abound. And we’re all gonna suffer for it. Nonwhites, that is.

    • Alissa says:

      honestly, given the damage this caused in terms of making people doubt hate crimes and racial issues, I’m not sad at all they’re prosecuting him. false claims make it that much harder for real victims to be taken seriously.

    • Smile says:

      This stunt cost the city millions of dollars. They were never going to be easy on this.

      • AppleCart says:

        Kim Foxx was, which brought a lot of this down on Jussie. 16 hours working a cash register at the Rainbow Coalition and forfeiting bond was a slap on the wrist. And the charges he was convicted of where new charges. I don’t know how she thought she could sweep this under the rug like she did. If a better plea deal was made maybe this circus could have been averted. But don’t blame “MAGA” politicians for her bungling of it. And how dare you make me defend MAGA, eww.

      • Lyds says:

        All this. I lived in Chicago up until June this year and Kim Foxx missed the point and was incredibly egregious in the way that she tried to make this go away. She did a huge disservice to justice and the credibility of the Black community while providing plenty of ammo for her detractors. The punishment should not be prison time but her community service suggestion/comments about how he served enough already was just completely bonkers.

        I am with those who say impose a hefty fine. Chicago’s real crime has escalated exponentially (main reason why we left) and there is a police shortage now. It’s disgraceful how much attention has been given and wasted on the Smollett case.

    • Bunny says:

      Nah. People are caught and prosecuted based on lies and false testimony. His crime had the potential to hurt lots of people. He gave descriptions, even an arrest can ruin someone’s life. He deserves punishment.

    • loras says:

      A stupid stunt that cost alot of money!

  6. Jezz says:

    Is there any chance he is telling the truth?

  7. minx says:

    “This is MAGA country” was never a believable claim about downtown Chicago, FFS.

    • AppleCart says:

      and the audacity of the defense lawyer claiming that was never said. When he literally said it during the Robin Roberts interview really bothered me. Clearly Jussie needs help and not the first time he lied to LE. I don’t think he should spend time in prison but get the mental health help he needs and finanial reimbursment to Chicago for all the money spent investigating and taking time and resources away from actual cases.

    • Audrey says:

      There were SO MANY things wrong with his story and I posted right here on this blog when it happened. There was a polar vortex and the temperature was sub-zero in the middle of a Sunday night downtown. And, if they were Trump supporters, how would they know about Emptire?

    • Emma says:

      The Chicago police are infamously racist and viciously abused and sometimes murdered the black and brown population. That’s just fact.

      Chicago is diverse but there are a lot of racist ignorant white people here too and many neighborhoods are not at all diverse. I’m white and I live near (not in) Chicago and have been here for nearly 30 years. I wouldn’t call it MAGA country but we have MAGAts represented for sure.

  8. Am says:

    When will I see a prosecuted Karen who calls the cops for things like bird watching or being in a fancy building?

    • shabs says:

      Whilst I get what you’re saying, this is quite different. He didn’t just call the police on something not warranting a call. He designed and then implemented a whole hate crime scenario to get himself attention. He deserves some punishment for wasting resources, though 3 years seems really excessive, but the real shame here is that he has undermined the credibility and experiences of real victims.

      • Erica says:

        Him staging a hate crime pisses me off so much. But I don’t think he needs prison, I think he needs therapy. To do what he did-he clearly needs help and prison won’t be what helps him.

      • Kitten says:

        Agree with you, Erica. Prison is not the answer FFS.

    • ThatsNotOkay says:

      Never. Amy Cooper has doubled down on her self righteousness, sued her former employer for firing her, and will probably sue the city. Claims she’s afraid to walk her dog because someone might see her and follow her to her house. Everything is all about her. Bish, no one lookin’ for you! You’re NOBODY! But leave it to her to make her racist white woman tears about she herself being persecuted.

      • Echo says:

        Dude admitted he threatened her before he started filming.

      • Echo says:

        The guy was so “gracious” in not wanting Amy Cooper prosecuted because it turns out he threatened her and had a bad habit of threatening people in Central Park. Media was mum about it. Media has also been mum about dozens of other hate crimes hoaxes like the chick who claimed Boogaloo boos set her on fire.

      • whatWHAT? says:

        “threatened” how, exactly? I haven’t hear this aspect of the story – can you provide a source for this part? I’ve looked and cannot find anything.

        the woman who called 911 on him claims he threatened her, but I’ve heard nothing like that from him.

    • Echo says:

      Remember the Central Park “Karen”? When it came down to charging her, the guy admitted he threatened her before he started filming. Didn’t get much media attention. 🤔

      • ThatsNotOkay says:

        Because that didn’t happen. He said what she did was “unmistakably racist,” but do go on. You’re not going to find what you’re claiming on anything but conspiracy-theory-laden and/or rot-wing (typo stands), biased “opinion” Web sites.

      • a reader says:

        @ThatsNotOkay: I’m sorry to tell you that you are misinformed. Please give a listen to the Bari Weiss podcast about the central park Karen. It is a deep dive into the entire incident and features an investigative reporter who followed and heavily researched it from start to finish. The birdwatcher had a history of provoking dog owners in that part of the park and openly bragged about it on a zoom call (there is video online of this zoom call). Christian Cooper isn’t the innocent bird watcher he appeared to be. He contributed to destroying that woman’s life and reputation because he was clout chasing.

      • Aang says:

        @areadersays: I believe nothing that comes out of Bari Weiss’ mouth. She actually disgusts me, especially when she goes on Bill Maher and starts sucking up to his insane rants about cancel culture. Now she wants to start some scam freedumb college in Texas? She is awful. But I have no problem believing that the guy threatened/provoked. Men are men and they love to be in charge wherever they go. He could have just called the cops about an off leash dog instead of engaging with her at all. He isn’t the park police and it is not up to him to enforce the rules.

      • Pilar says:

        Bari Weiss?? For real? Weiss is pretty problematic on matters of race so I am not going to take her interpretation of the case as “ facts” . She’s literally palling around with people like Jordan Peterson and as a WOC she is definitely not someone I would listen to let alone use as a trusted source.

      • Indywom says:

        Christian Cooper didn’t do anything. His sister is the one that posted the video and he didn’t testify or anything. Sorry, but if she had followed the rules in the first place such as having your dog on a leash when you are supposed to, then she would not have found herself in this position in the first place.

      • whatWHAT? says:

        “The birdwatcher had a history of provoking dog owners in that part of the park”

        “provoking”, or “threatening”? there is a difference. and from what I understand his only issue is with OFF LEASH dogs, which are not permitted in that area of the park.

      • Kitten says:

        Bari Weiss lol.

        @whatWHAT? Right. I don’t think confronting people who are deliberately breaking the local leash laws is a provocation. Most likely, he admonished her and she didn’t like being held accountable so she went full racist. The revisionist history in this thread is gross.
        (Hi, BTW)

      • Emma says:

        Bari Weiss?!?!? Stop trolling. We know Bari Weiss functions as a right-wing rabble-rouser.

    • AppleCart says:

      Several “Karens” have been prosecuted. Try Google.

    • Jules says:

      The scope of Smollet’s crime is way above and beyond someone calling the police. He got ripped apart on the stand. He deserves what he got. As does pedo Duggar. And hopefully Maxwell will get sentenced. Can we have the ability to look at every case for what they are.

  9. Paloma says:

    Im glad it’s illegal to make a false report to the police but the punishment for that non violent crime should not be prison. (Prison should be saved for people who put society at danger.)

    • Bryn says:

      Agreed. Jail time is a bit unnecessary in this case I think. A hefty fine would be nice, mandatory counseling maybe. Obviously this guy has problems.

    • Eurydice says:

      The articles I’ve read say he’ll most likely get probation and community service.

    • AppleCart says:

      Keep in mind it was his manager that called the police. I dont’ think Jussie had any intention of filing a police report. He thought he could get some good PR saying he was the “Gay Tupac” retelling his story of his valiant street fight and leave it at that. Remember he had a swell of support. His album sales went up and did a sold out show right after.

      All in all, if it had stayed out of the legal system he would have accomplished his goals. I wish he would come clean to start his mental health recovery.

      • Lyds says:

        Sure, blame the manager. If the story he told at the time checks out, the right thing to do is to file a police report. Basically what you’re saying is if he had just told a fake story and didn’t follow up like a real victim of a hate crime, he would enjoy fake goodwill from the people and upped his level of fame and his salary at Empire. Sounds like Smollett himself thinking wistfully at how this was SUPPOSED to go.

      • Nanny to the Rescue says:

        I think AppleCart is right, tho. That IS what Jussie was thinking off. To get some good publicity out of this, but nothing more. He could have ridden the fame from this incident for years to come.

        But to his misfortune he had a GOOD manager. The manager did the right thing – of course hate crimes should be reported to the police. But it’s obvious that wasn’t Jussie’s plan.

        And then instead of taking the L and go into hiding, he doubled down. And here we are.

      • Lyds says:

        @Applecart You’re right. I apologize as I missed the point of your statement; I misread it and now understand what you’re saying/that we are agreeing. I also learned something new: I didn’t know his manager was in the dark. @Nanny to the rescue was also right: he has a GOOD manager who took his tale to heart and did the right thing.

        So if the manager filed the police report not knowing it was fraudulent and he didn’t correct the record, but instead pursued it like he did, he absolutely deserves punishment.

    • Kitten says:

      Prison is absolutely insane in this situation.

      • AppleCart says:

        @Lyds i’m not “blaming” the manager. I was just stating the facts. Jussie never called the police the Manager did. Which of course was the right thing to do. Jussie had this all in his head as some PR play that spun out of control faster than he could manage it. Which is what always happens in these situations.

  10. Lolo86lf says:

    I feel so bad for him. His career was over before it really began and he might end up serving up to three years in prison. If he wanted a publicity stunt to become famous he should have bought an AR-15 rifle, go to a riot somewhere in the country, shoot three or four rioters dead (to defend himself of course) and that way he would have become a national hero. Oh wait he’s black never mind, the police would have shot him dead right then and there.

    • Echo says:

      Like they shot the SUV that ran over a parade in Waukesha? Lol. You are ridiculous.

      • Indywom says:

        But she is right. Don’t forget they shot a black guy in Virginia Beach just because he had a gun that he was using to protect himself in another shooting. Yet a white boy with a rifle who just shot and killed two people still lives to tell the story. Or the black guy who was shot in the back while walking into his house with food from Subway. Or the black guy who was shot because he had a cell phone in his hand or the black guy who was shot while sitting on the couch in his own home watching TV by an officer too dumb to know which apartment she was in. So you are the ridiculous one.

    • Kviby says:

      He’s a liar so I don’t exactly feel bad but the fact that he hatched this *in order to improve his career* makes me wonder are there a bunch of Hollywood actors that are actually this stupid? I mean he does have the good looks of a bimbo. Curious if he has the net worth to pay for the costs involved. This ish should have financial penalties when rich people do it. I’m guessing he will be on reality shows to pay the bills if Hollywood keeps rejecting him. I realize he probably has the means to live privately if he invests well but I feel he loves attention so reality is my prediction

    • Dizza says:

      You feel bad for him? Why?

      • Lolo86lf says:

        I feel bad for him because he didn’t mean to hurt anyone and yes what he did was wrong in several levels but the media has demonized him for ratings ESPECIALLY right-wing media.

      • Dizza says:

        I dont feel bad for anyone who used our empathy and a social movement for his own personal gain. The media can drag him all they want, I’m fine with it because at the end of the day he did this to raise his public profile which is gross. Real crimes were put on the back burner because a rich famous man was attacked…nope not okay.

  11. Aang says:

    If he was offered a plea and didn’t take it lawyers did a bad job. If he wasn’t offered a plea then the prosecution was racially motivated and used him to show blacks lie about hate crimes.

    • equality says:

      A lawyer can only take a plea with client consent.

    • Scram says:

      No one has a constitutional right to a plea deal. He wasted an enormous amount of police resources while they investigated the crime. The prosecution was motivated by justice, not racism.

      • Bryn says:

        And honestly, does anybody believe he would take a plea? I highly doubt it. this guy is going to go to his grave telling this story

      • Aang says:

        Any lower profile case would have ended in a plea, they were making an example of him. And I think that example was racially motivated. He might spend more time in jail than those who tried to violently overthrow our government on Jan 6. Disorderly conduct is not as serious as treason/sedition/trying to find and kill the VP. I get that his lawyers can’t make him take a plea but I would hope a good lawyer could convince a client what is is in their own best interest. If they can’t convince a client what chance do they have of convincing a jury. I also think he needs mental health care, not jail. But that can probably said for a huge chunk of those that end up in the system.

    • Nanny to the Rescue says:

      There’s always the question if he even told his lawyer the truth.

  12. Tori says:

    Good. But he is so majorly deluded that I doubt he understands his circumstances. He hasnt learned anything from this.

    • Barbie1 says:

      He will lie about this til the end of time. I hate how his sister is publicly supporting him when it’s so obvious that he is guilty.

      • A n B fn says:

        Watching him dragging his mother through this charade is shameful. Looking at his mother in those videos the lady does not look well in m opinion. All the siblings should be ashamed of their selves for putting their mother through this craziness . Shame on all of them.

  13. K says:

    Obviously he needs help. For what appears to be extreme narcissist personality issues for starters. Real hate crimes happen everyday and him stunting this and trying to brazen it out just gives the right ammunition to point to him and cry wolf. Jail time…not in my opinion but fines etc yes.

  14. Deeanna says:

    Jail time is a consequence of the crimes for which he was convicted. For a reason. They (we, us, society) don’t want people pulling this kind of shyte.

    There will be a presentencing investigation. The judge will then make a decision. I have no problem if some jailtime is part of his sentence.