Pyrex, especially with rare patterns, could be worth a lot of money


My parents loved taking me to antique malls and thrift stores as a child. We just enjoyed walking around and seeing what struck our fancy. All three of us were gluttons for art and kitsch. Over the years I picked up some great pieces of vintage costume jewelry, a few porcelain figures of my hero Bugs Bunny, and a homemade quilt made for the 1976 Bicentennial that was embroidered with all 50 state flowers–which I still use to this day! I also developed, through my mother, a love of mid-century cookware, including the classic Pyrex–and mind you this was long before Pyrex had cameos in Mad Men or was a plot device in the pilot for Mrs. Maisel. With cheerful colors and quirky designs, Pyrex bowls and dishes always made us smile. But now I’ve learned that apparently my mother and I are pikers, because there’s a whole community out there who avidly collect Pyrex sets, with Yahoo! Life reporting that some very rare designs sell for thousands of dollars:

Three reasons why people still love Pyrex: First, there’s the increasing rarity of what used to be ubiquitous: Pyrex ceased production of its color ware in the mid-1980s. Then, there’s a huge variety of styles, over 150 patterns that provide a visual catalog of American design over four decades. Collectors tend to feel a pull to certain designs, whether it’s whimsical daisies, blades of wheat, constellations, floral borders, or the earthy mushrooms that were among the last of the patterns Pyrex put out before the end of color ware. Finally, there’s the nostalgia. “Pyrex continues to hold its value because most of us associate it with memories of family and holiday gatherings and memories from their childhood,” says Willow Wright, owner of Urban Redeux Vintage in Alexandria, Virginia.

This is insane: Some of the most elusive Pyrex pieces go for hundreds of dollars and there’s even anecdotes of collectors bidding thousands for rare pieces. A rare Lucky in Love Pyrex casserole dish from 1959–what might have been only a test pattern, made of shamrocks and hearts–sold for $5,995 in a 2017 Goodwill auction. Someone bid more than $22,000 for the same pattern in 2022, but the bid was rescinded and the rare promotional piece sold for an undisclosed amount in a private auction.

A little history: Pyrex was developed by Corning Glass Works in the early 1900’s and began as clear glassware, Wright says. The company went on to produce a milky white glass and eventually added an exterior color to their bowls. By 1945, Pyrex Color Ware was introduced with a primary color four-piece nesting set, and, over the next 40 years more than 150 patterns would be released, she says… The glass could withstand extreme temperature changes without shattering, which added to its practicality and made it ideal for baking and cooking, she adds.

Patterns and prices and shapes, oh my: Other patterns considered rare would be the Turquoise Diamond, Pink Daisy, Snowflake, Black (or Atomic) Starburst and New Dots to name a few, Wright says. The most popular shapes are by far the mixing bowls which can simply be round or have a spout on one end and a handle on the other, known as Cinderella mixing bowls. Bowls in fair to poor condition may go for a few dollars at a thrift store or yard sale, but a highly sought-after pattern in excellent condition may reach as high as a few hundred dollars, she says. Complete nesting sets in almost any pattern can fetch over $100 on the low end and often into the several hundred range or more.

[From Yahoo! Life]

For the record, I have never paid over a hundred dollars for a Pyrex dish, let alone thousands! Where my mother and I were shopping we never really saw nesting bowl sets, only a stray bowl, or what some collectors call an orphan piece. And we use them for eating all the time! I guess maybe we should stop? This article had a link to an online pattern museum where I learned the main designs we have are Spring Blossom in white/olive and Butterprint in white/turquoise. I also discovered that Pyrex did a Zodiac print, which I adore, but of course I found one on Etsy–a 1961 casserole dish with lid and warming cradle–and it’s $700, sigh. For those of us with a slightly smaller budget, there are vendors on Etsy who make everything from earrings to magnets to keychains using Pyrex patterns, even the $22,000 Lucky in Love.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

24 Responses to “Pyrex, especially with rare patterns, could be worth a lot of money”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. mellie says:

    I love Pyrex, but I use mine….frequently. Even the old stuff. I also love Fiestaware, all the colorful things. I’m big into the MCM style of decorating, so I like funky old things anyway. It’s all getting so expensive. You just about have to find someone who doesn’t know what they have or happen upon a yard sale where people just want rid of stuff.

  2. NotCathy says:

    Pyrex collecting has become insane! It’s rare to find sets at antique malls or flea markets for under $200. I splurged on a large teal balloon print bowl not realizing it had a smaller nesting bowl and spent years on the hunt for that ‘lil guy. I love that design so much and wish I had space to display my collection. Even got Pyrex themed wallpaper for my kitchen much to the chagrin of all of my friends. It’s peel & stick and it’s adorable, calm down people!

  3. JennyB0285 says:

    They are all very cute but also test positive for lead in the paint they used back then so I definitely wouldn’t be using them anymore. Just admiring them from a hutch.

    • Southern Fried says:

      Yikes I sure didn’t know that. Not that I own any Pyrex now. I love Corningware white baking dishes. I gravitate to white dishes mostly since that means I can use any color of runners or tablecloths or placemats. Also pull in color with a big collection of right patterned pasta bowls.

    • BeanieBean says:

      That paint is on the exterior, though, and shouldn’t be a problem on the interior.

  4. Lily says:

    Fools and their money soon are parted.

  5. HeyKay says:

    Collectors and Marvelous Mrs. Mansel brought the pink back. 💕
    Not for me but it is pretty.

  6. Renae says:

    I still have a few of my old *cornflower* ones.

    • Juls says:

      I love the cornflower ones! True story: I inherited the cornflower pie plate and a small casserole dish with the lid from my great-grandmother. About 20 years ago, I broke the casserole dish in half. I was devastated! I put it in storage. When I moved 3 years ago, I went through all my storage and found the casserole dish right where I had put it. And IT WAS INTACT, NOT BROKEN, NOT EVEN A CRACK. I can’t explain it. It is now lovingly displayed in my kitchen. I use the pie plate regularly and always think of my GG when I do. I’ll think to myself, ‘Granny is having breakfast with us today’ as I bake cinnamon rolls in it.

      • Vernie says:

        Juls, I love that you channel your dear departed great-gran when using her dishes. I use my beloved pate grandma’s Pyrex sets when baking for special occasions and it makes me feel close to her. Your casserole dish story gave me the good kind of chills!

  7. olliesmom says:

    I frequent estate sales in my area and people looking for Pyrex is insane.

  8. k.tate says:

    the internet has ruined thrift shopping forever

  9. JanetDR says:

    I still have some baking ware pieces with a harvest design and a storage set is mostly intact. Pyrex is great until it shatters!
    When I was growing up we used the big yellow bowl for throwing up as well as mixing cakes. Seems strange, but I have learned that it wasn’t just us.

  10. Blithe says:

    I have a set of bowls and a few other pieces that were wedding presents given to my parents. Hmmm. Maybe I should see what they’re going for these days.

  11. BeanieBean says:

    I grew up with the primary color nesting set. My mom used those principally for storing leftovers. I still have the smallest of that set, the red one. I use it as a butter dish. My mom also had a mixing bowl set, which I remember using for various baking projects. I only have the largest now & I use it for popcorn. I’ve also seen plenty of full mixing bowl sets in thrift shops. I guess it depends on what part of the country you live in. Have any of y’all been to Snohomish, WA? That place has the most wonderful antique shops!
    A friend is Pyrex crazy & has two full sets of dishes, one in pink & one in blue. I find them too heavy, but she likes them.

  12. Jc says:

    New Pyrex is also just trash since they changed the glass formula, I assume to save money. I hope to never break my old glass measuring cups as some new ones broke before we learned the formula change in lab.

    • Willow says:

      You’re exactly right! Soda-lime doesn’t seem to be as tough as the borosilicate. Look for the upper case PYREX for a replacement if yours breaks. That’s the older stuff!

  13. Midnightatthemuseum says:

    So weird, I had an elderly neighbour round for tea yesterday afternoon and served it on the Pyrex plates I inherited from my mother. Turns out she used to work for Pyrex in the North of England, a company called JAJ made Pyrex under licence from Cornings from 1921. After getting excited about a possible windfall it turns out the pattern I have was called Chelsea and seems to have been made in the U.K. from the 1960s to the 80s. It’s as common as common can be, if you want to buy it online the postage is more than the items themselves. I love it and use it every day because it’s dishwasher and microwave safe, and pretty robust. Yay! And now I’ve done the research I can complete my collection!

  14. LaDeeDah says:

    Theirs is truly a ton of drama that goes down within the Pyrex collecting community. I think the community and some of its members would be perfect for a Best In Show type of mockumentary.

  15. Heather H says:

    I have a set shown in one of the photos. I have had it for years, purchased it for $45 in a thrift shop but know it is worth much more now. I need to get around to selling it!

  16. SammiB says:

    I freaking LOVE Pyrex!!! I started collecting a few years back – I try to find it ‘in the wild’ (iykyk lol!) & if buying online not spend over $50. That said, I’ve been looking longingly at a JAJ Pyrex ‘lobster’ casserole on Etsy for $150…

    Straight up I’m even in Pyrex Facebook groups – those guys are SERIOUS haha! Pyrex is the geekiest thing I’ve ever done!