Susan Faludi thinks ‘Barbie’ is about abortion & the horror of the Trump years

Spoilers for Barbie.

New York Times columnist Jessica Bennett organized a special outing and wrote about it in a column this week. The outing? Taking noted feminist author Susan Faludi to a matinee of Barbie and asking Faludi what she thought about it. Faludi seemed to enjoy it, and she even has some theories about the feminism and backlash politics contained within the film. As I read through the (overwritten and overwrought) column, I sort of agreed with her? Faludi thinks that the film is about abortion and the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, which overturned Roe v. Wade. I agree that I think it was really pointed that much of the third act of the film hinged on voting, the Barbieland constitution, patriarchal overreach and, in the final moment, a trip to the gynecologist. Some highlights from this NYT column:

Faludi’s immediate reaction: “I mean, you couldn’t write the script without 30 years of women’s studies,” Ms. Faludi said as the lights came up. “It seems to me that a big theme underlying the movie is shock and horror over what happened to us — what happened to women — from 2016 on, with the double whammy of Trump and then Dobbs. And in particular, I thought abortion was the subtext to a lot.”

Ms. Faludi explains. “I mean, it begins with little girls playing with dolls learning the origin story of Barbie — and the rejection of the idea that women can just be mothers. It ends with her going to the gynecologist.”

Ms. Faludi went on to outline a series of other allusions to our present moment: In an early montage introducing viewers to Barbieland, lawyer Barbie speaks before the Supreme Court about the idea of personhood — “which immediately made me think of attempts to create the unborn as ‘persons,’” Ms. Faludi said. Later, the Kens attempt to change the Constitution, amid Barbie lamenting how hard they had worked to create Barbieland, and “You can’t just undo it in a day.” (To which Ken responds, “Literally — and figuratively — watch me.”) Ms. Faludi’s take? “I mean, that’s what happened on Election Day of 2016.”

The Midge problem: And then there’s Midge, the doll once marketed as Barbie’s best friend, and the one pregnant doll in the Barbie universe, before she was discontinued. (You could remove Midge’s belly and baby intact from her body and then magnetically reattach it. It was weird.) Midge and her bump are in the film, too, repeatedly — a ghost that the fictional Mattel executives, and everyone else, just wish would go away. She’s there for laughs, but squint hard enough, Ms. Faludi suggested, and you could also see her as “the specter of Dobbs.”

Barbie ofers genuine catharsis. “Perhaps what’s going on,” Ms. Faludi wrote me in an email a few days after the screening, “is that women are finding a way to explore their anger about recent history without feeling like they have to drown themselves in the bathtub (in real water)….Only Barbie could say, ‘By giving voice to the cognitive dissonance required to be a woman under the patriarchy, you robbed it of its power!’ and turn it into a laugh line.”

[From The NY Times]

Yeah… as I said, I think Faludi makes a very good case. Is every part of the movie about abortion and feminism? No, but there’s tons of subtext (and just plain upfront text) about personhood, feminism, bodily autonomy, women’s right to “choose” and the political realities of being a woman in a modern society. I also noted, as I watched the film, that Ken’s line of “Literally — and figuratively — watch me” was actually frightening. They play it off later on, but making Ken drunk on his own patriarchal power and hellbent on achieving a completely male autocracy, a Kenocracy, was a huge f–king choice.

Photos and posters courtesy of Warner Bros/Barbie.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

16 Responses to “Susan Faludi thinks ‘Barbie’ is about abortion & the horror of the Trump years”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Bettyrose says:

    I read Backlash about 20 years ago, and sometimes I wish I hadn’t. I’ve always been a feminist, but life was easier when I could just watch a movie and not analyze it to death. I’ve guess that’s the gender version of being woke, and dayum if that book didn’t wake me. I haven’t seen Barbie yet. But why would Gerwig even have bothered if not for this message?

    • Bee says:

      I read it in women’s studies back at uni. (In a different class, I read Brighter than a Thousand Suns – about the Manhattan Project.)

      I think Faludi makes a lot of good points. And I’m usually one to analyze the hell out of everything. But I just flat out enjoyed Barbie.

      I do want to see it again – but for my first viewing, it was enough to get to see a movie that gets me, you know? Especially a fun movie. I know all the depressing stuff already. Seeing the patriarchy get clowned on while eating popcorn in a theater full of happy people wearing pink was such a treat. Once it starts streaming I’m going to watch the hell out of it. I can analyze it then. For now I can be happy that nothing in it made me cringe.

      I woke up to feminism as a girl reading my aunt’s Ms magazines, and going to church. I figured out pretty early on that being told that women should obey men – as church doctrine, no less – was messed up, and that I wanted no part of it. I’ve been a royal pain about it ever since. (Unfortunately just about all of the things I was out protesting back in the ’80s are STILL issues, sigh.)

      We need more movies like this.

      • dj says:

        💯 to everything Bee said here. I just enjoyed it at the movies. It was fun and I will also analyse the hell out of it once I see it a few times at home. I too have been a feminist since high school in 1978. It is sad and exhausting to have to keep protesting and relitigating these issues we thought we had earned. But I will keep on doing it til I can’t anymore. That’s one of the reasons I wanted to see Barbie is to put my money into female led projects. I hope others will put there money where there passions lie.

  2. Brassy Rebel says:

    Ever since I first heard of this film, I have been mystified. Why would anyone make a whole movie about Barbie and her world? As I have read the commentary and reviews, it’s become clearer. But only after reading this analysis do I finally and totally get it. I have to see this film!

    • BothSidesNow says:

      @ Brassy Rebel, now I have to see it too!!! I find her review uplifting, exciting and all the more reason to go see it!!! I wish I could go with my sisters as one of them is very vocal in her state with the Democratic Party. It would get her into trouble, the good kind of trouble that we woman can do!!!

      Now I understand why the snowflakes are having meltdowns of epic proportions!!! You did it, OWN it and face the consequences!!! Otherwise, STFU and sit down!! We have heard enough from ALL of you!!

  3. Feebee says:

    I just saw it today and went in with no expectations. It was great and the two hours went by faster that I thought they would. I’m not good at analyzing movies though when I stood up it was like “well, they kind of nailed life today, eh?” So in that respect I understand how Ms Faludi connected dots to abortion and MAGA backlash to progress for women. The baby doll bashing at the start made me think that’s all some of the knuckledraggers has to see in order to go off like they did. The Ken doll song/dance routine and battle scenes made me LOL several times. Didn’t make any connection with the gyno visit. In fact I thought it rather odd but I guess it did bring it all full circle.

  4. Eurydice says:

    It’s about everything. You can’t have a film that’s directed, written, produced by women – that tells a shared coming of age story that’s been experienced over generations almost exclusively by girls and women – it’s going to include elements of everything women have experienced in their lives.

  5. Emily says:

    Barbie was made so little girls would see they could be more than moms by providing an alternative to baby dolls.

    The scene at the end with the gyno … Barbie had complete reproductive freedom in Barbie land and she won’t now. That will be eye opening.

  6. Kittenmom says:

    The political messages were loud and clear throughout the movie, in a pink and candy-coated veneer. But you do have to be somewhat tuned in to the issues to get it.

  7. Amee says:

    I loved the movie and its message of Empowerment. We don’t know what we don’t have until it’s gone, and Barbie made it clear that we all need to vote and take control of our reproductive futures. F U to all the Kens.

    • BeanieBean says:

      I thought Reynold’s Ken was a sweet doofus throughout the movie until that point, until his response to Barbie’s ‘you can’t change everything in one day’ was ‘literally, and figuratively, watch me’. That gave me a chill.

  8. Nic919 says:

    The right wing are freaking out over this film because it does have obvious feminist messages. But it also points out the mistakes Barbie aka women have made over the years about what kind of progress has actually been achieved.

    That said it is also a fun and funny movie. It’s not a perfect film, but it’s getting good reviews for a reason.

  9. Shawna says:

    Dang, that’s a complete and persuasive reading. Wish I’d thought of it!

  10. bitsycs says:

    I’ve seen it twice and as an older millennial who grew up on Barbie, I felt so seen. As naive as it sounds – and I’m not proud of this – 2016 was like a year long wake up call. I truly believed we were better as a country and further along than what happened then. I distinctly remember in 2015 after Obergefell thinking ok yes, we are on the right track, progress is inevitable. I was so goddamn dumb and naive. Anyway I felt like the film really nailed two things for me: 1) the Barbie aspect. As a kid everything my Barbies did was a bonkers, involved storyline so Greta hit that vibe perfectly and 2) it felt true to a coming of age story, figuring out how it isn’t simple and how everything is more complicated than telling girls they can be anything.

    Because I do think – at least it’s true for most of the people I know – people thought it’d be enough to tell girls they can be anything. As a parent of both a boy and a girl, I went into parenting knowing the best thing for my daughter would be to raise my son to be a feminist not just telling her she can be anything. I have a lot of opinions about how we raise boys and what’s wrong with it and how that impacts girls. (I won’t bore everyone here with my screeds).

  11. Jeannine says:

    I was amazed by how deep the theme of patriarchy went in the movie and how dark it became. I would have said body autonomy was the point of the final scene, but what does that mean now if not reproductive freedom/abortion?!

  12. Jenn says:

    On our way out of Barbie on Monday, I said to my friend “I do wish the movie came with a reading list,” and then I remarked that I would put Susan Faludi’s book ‘Stiffed’ at the top, under the subheading ‘Ken’. I feel very validated that Jessica Bennett felt the same — and what fun this was to read!

    I 100% agree with Faludi that Barbie is about bodily autonomy; it was probably less oblique in a first draft, but I agree that it’s always there, even when the lines aren’t explicitly about motherhood and/or a right to choose. I also appreciated that the movie draws a straight causal line from the collective societal disenfranchisement of people, including Kens (no house, no education, no job but Beach) to the rise of “men’s rights activism,” to Kensurrection. It handles all of these themes in an economy of words, and it uses universal themes about self-actualization, independence, and agency to get there.