Did In Touch Weekly cross the line into transphobia with their Bruce Jenner cover?

bruce in touch

I didn’t even want to talk about this because I find the whole thing despicable. Not Bruce Jenner! I find the speculation and tabloid “pressure” despicable. Is Bruce Jenner wants to identify as a woman and if he wants to undergo a sex change, that’s his business. If he wants to tell us, he should be able to do it in his own time, in his own way. The tabloids have been writing about Bruce’s transformation for months now. But this is the first time that a tabloid – In Touch Weekly – used a photo of Bruce and blatantly photoshopped him so that the world could see what he would look like “as a woman.” And this is the same week that Transparent won a Golden Globe, and everyone was talking about the changing, more respectful and accepting perspective for the trans community! And this is the week that In Touch Weekly chose to Photoshop Bruce’s head onto a photo of Stephanie Beacham (seriously – go here to see the side-by-side) and add lipstick.

Kris Jenner’s friends told TMZ that she’s “outraged” about In Touch’s cover and she’s telling friends, “It’s just mean to do whether or not it’s true.” TMZ also says that Bruce is unfazed because “He doesn’t even pay attention to this stuff.”

The Daily Beast wrote a good piece about In Touch’s transphobia and how over-the-line this cover is. Speaking from just a gossip perspective, and someone who sees photos of Bruce all the time, I really don’t understand why they had to Photoshop his face and put his head on a woman’s body. The everyday Bruce has French tips, a nose job, Botox, lip injections, a laryngeal shave, and some kind of blown-out hair weave. In Touch could have literally used a candid paparazzi shot, is what I’m saying. So, is this cover transphobic?

FFN_Jenner_Blue_FF7_EXC_121914_51611178

Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

80 Responses to “Did In Touch Weekly cross the line into transphobia with their Bruce Jenner cover?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Abbott says:

    Yes. And now I have to hate InTouch doubly for making me side with Kris Jenner.

  2. David says:

    Yes very nasty!

  3. OriginalTessa says:

    YES

  4. TX says:

    It’s so mean spirited and awful. In Touch should be ashamed of themselves.

    • Brin says:

      Totally agree.

      • Sabrine says:

        A public shaming? Is that what this is? In Touch will sink to any low to sell their nasty little rag. They are truly disgusting and I hope people forego buying this trash in support of a man who does not deserve to be treated so terribly.

  5. Luca76 says:

    It’s so mean ,so ignorant, and disgusting! Especially so soon after the death of Leelah Alcorn.

  6. Kitten says:

    I’m glad you covered this. I saw the picture on some crappy entertainment show last night and I was appalled–I mean, truly disgusted.

    I wish people would just leave this man the f*ck alone. I also find people’s apparent fascination with something that is very personal and private to be extremely odd.

    I don’t care if he was on a reality tv show or that his life hasn’t ever been private-NO ONE deserves this. It’s just wrong on so many levels. If he wants to talk about it publicly, he should be allowed to do so in whatever forum he chooses, on whatever timeline he’s comfortable with.

    I didn’t read the post here and I avoid all the posts about Jenner because it feels dirty and invasive, but I just had to comment.

    • BengalCat2000 says:

      Thank you. My bff’s father was transgender and he took so much crap for it. I’m glad this issue is getting coverage, but this is insulting on SO many levels.

    • GoodNamesAllTaken says:

      I can’t imagine how much courage it takes to change your gender, knowing a part of our society will ridicule and mock. This makes me sad and angry.

      • Sabrine says:

        I know a man who is transgender and he has suffered terribly although now he’s older it’s not as bad. In high school he was tormented to the point where he contemplated suicide. He had death threats via phone calls to his parents’ home. You know, these are citizens who pay taxes like everyone else. What is going on in Russia is truly sickening, forbidding them to drive. I just don’t get this type of behavior in the 21st century.

    • MarcelMarcel says:

      @Kitten I completely agree with you! This is invasive and rude- if Jenner identifies as a man in public & private that’s his business, if he identifies as a man in public & gender fluid or a woman in private that’s his business and it’s not mine or a gossips rag or the general public right to know. All he has done is dress in a way that slightly deviates from the norm of masculinity.
      Furthermore, I worry about how this affects trans woman & girls since Jenner is being treated with no respect and as an object of mockery. Trans woman experience higher rates of suicide and assault- this discourse continues the dehumanisation of trans woman & would only encourage transphobic attitudes in cis people.
      This kind of bullcrap shows inTouch is run by trans misogynistic editors since they would rather cruelly speculate about Bruce Jenner than devote the front cover to celebrating the achievements of Laverne Cox, Janet Mock, Candis Cayne or the many other amazing American trans woman who are currently achieving so much in a transphobic world.

  7. maeliz says:

    That’s crossing the line. Leave the guy alone!!

    • RussianBlue says:

      Totally agree. There was no need for that. I cantvbelievevit got by an entire mag team! Bruce seems like a kind person. So mean of them.

  8. Jenna says:

    Yup.

    Next question?

  9. Charlotte says:

    I don’t buy that kris is outraged. Well, if she is it’s only because she’s not getting a cut of the profits.
    Magazines alter pretty much every image they ever use, but this is… Not right. With teenagers still killing themselves over crises with being transgender, turning M-F or F-M transition into a punch line is not okay. It’s going to take a long time before we can brush off a ‘transgender watch’ like we can a ‘bump watch’. And hopefully by the time we won’t have to do either as they’ll have been retired to the Bad Old Days.
    Google Leelah Alcorn.

  10. Talie says:

    It creates a feeling that he’s some kind of freak and that is wrong.

    On the other hand, I think the photos of him crying yesterday were staged…so I don’t quite know what to think of his head space.

    • Ani says:

      Those crying pictures kind of broke my heart. Though I did find it strange that bruce would react so publicly.

    • chaine says:

      According to various sites, he has been shopping his own reality show, so I also felt a little dubious about the shots of him supposedly crying alone in his car.

  11. littlemissnaughty says:

    Lord help us all, what is this f*ckery??? I don’t know if it’s necessarily transphobic but goddamn, it is absolutely over the line and they should be ashamed of themselves. Well done, InTouch, this sends such a lovely message to young people – trans or not. WHO thought this was a good idea? Fire someone. Now. And apologize.

  12. Franny Days says:

    I think it is just cruel and I don’t believe that this doesn’t bother Bruce at all. Shame on intouch magazine.

  13. aims says:

    Really rude. Nobody knows what’s going on with Bruce accept Bruce. This is his life and nobody should ever bully him to make money.

  14. PunkyMomma says:

    Oh it’s just cruel and awful. This isn’t about PR or the usual celebrity circus. This is a person who is probably changing genders, a person who would probably prefer to be out of the public eye. While realizing his ex- wife and his former participation in a reality show make him fair game to some, I wish Bruce peace and quiet.

    Can he sue?

  15. kri says:

    Um. The National Enquirer now officially has more class than ITW. I get that there is speculation. I don’t know what Bruce is doing, but if he is transitioning in any way, that’s his business and he will talk if and when he wants. I can’t believe they did this photo thing. Beyond the pale, even for a gossip rag.

  16. Rhiley says:

    I never thought of I’d write this before, but I agree with Kris Jenner. It is just mean and bullying whether or not it is true.

  17. Gracie says:

    Let the man do what he want! He’s just escaped from under the devil’s claw!

  18. scout says:

    That is despicable! Freedom of speech doesn’t include twisting the facts and humiliating anybody on any grounds, using their race, color, religion, gender preferences and so on. These magazines should have some restraints about what they print, specially it’s made up by them.

  19. sighhhh says:

    Sad to think of how many people worked to put this together and approved this issue before it hit the shelves.

  20. OhDear says:

    Wow, that’s a new low.

  21. snowflake says:

    if i was bruce, i’d sue the f*ck outta them. shame that people treat a former Olympian this way. He was a great athlete, seems like a nice guy and should not be treated this way. disgusting

  22. Dani2 says:

    Yeah, they definitely crossed the line with this one. It left me feeling really bad for him. This is too much.

  23. wolfpup says:

    Whenever a person tries to shame another – it is an attempt to create a phobia (by bullying), for many real, live, human beings. We need to respect other identities – that is the nature of true humanity.

  24. swack says:

    I have said from the very beginning when all this talk of transgendering and Bruce began – that they need to leave him alone. It’s nobody’s business but his. Saw this on another site and refused to read the article.

  25. Jayna says:

    It’s the tackiest thing I’ve ever seen.

  26. Jan Harf says:

    Bruce should sue the pants off of In Touch Weekly.

  27. Kayla says:

    This is bullying. It is so sad that In Touch Magazine is promoting bullying. Your magazine is a disgrace and I will never buy it again . Is the magazines staff so stupid and ignorant that they don’t see how big of an issue this is in our country today. People are ending their lives over this and your magazine is basically promoting that to happen. Absolutely disgusting. You should all be ashamed of yourselves.

  28. Judyk says:

    Totally offensive…the magazine, not Bruce.

  29. littlestar says:

    OMG. It’s one thing to use an actual picture of him on the cover, but to friggin’ PHOTOSHOP his picture to make him look more feminine?! How on earth did anyone at In Touch think this was okay to do???

  30. Dawn says:

    Well I think this magazine pretty much goes over the line always and really doesn’t tell the truth ever. I maybe the only person in the world who does NOT think that Bruce is going to become a woman but I don’t. I think he just lost his mind being with Kris Jenner for all those years and is now just trying to regain his brain. So his hair is long and he gets his nails done just like lots of other men. I’ll believe this when I hear it from Bruce’s mouth that he is going to become a woman and no one else. That said I do believe that Bruce needs to man up and stop this ridiculous relationship between that 25 year old and his youngest daughter. There is something really creepy about a dude who will date a teenager when he is 25 and the father of one and don’t get me started on him taking her to the clubs and drinking and drugging with him because we all know she is. Poor Kylie will be all used up by 25 if she doesn’t stop this nonsense. Time for Bruce to become a parent.

  31. Brandii says:

    Hmmm. I actually thought this was a parody magazine pic, as in somebody was mocking In Touch.

    Honest to God question, is this headline any more intrusive than those on its side bar speculating about teenage pregnancies, failing marriages and plastic surgery? The line seems very arbitary to me. Like surrogate pregnancy? Sure lets talk. Possible lesbian? Bring on the pics. Drug use? Video please. But male to female transitioning or male homosexual? Absolutely not, get outta here. Thats private.

    • Steamin' Sam says:

      You’ve got a point but I think because the trans issue has become more center-stage recently, especially combating phobia, that it’s seen as especially mean-spirited or inappropriate to speculate that Bruce is actually transitioning. We pry into celebs’ private lives all the time, as you noted, but this seems to be taking us all a huge step backward to when everyone thought trans issues were something to be made fun of. I agree it’s hard to draw a line between observing (or poking fun) at Bruce’s hairdo or manicure, and doing the same with the latest plastic surgery debacle (more Botox, fillers, implants) seen on female celebs. It kind of feels like they’re all subject to ridicule, especially in the case of Bruce since he willingly put himself and his family out there for public consumption with the ridiculous reality shows, but if he truly has walked away from that limelight and is trying to live his life and transition, it’s unfair to criticize him with the same harsh standards commonly reserved for speculating on much more minor issues like who got butt implants. And in this case, it feels like this is something out of his control (if he is indeed transitioning) – one can blame things like teen pregnancies, failed marriages, plastic surgery, drug use, etc. to poor decisions or generally lifestyle decisions, but transitioning doesn’t fall under the same category of some nitwit snorting coke on camera.

    • Kitten says:

      Uh yes, it is very VERY different from the things you mentioned. Not that I don’t think the other issues are private, because I certainly do.

      People who use surrogates aren’t at a greater risk for being murdered simply because they use a surrogate. People who use drugs aren’t at risk for being targeted for a hate crime just because they shoot up. A divorcee isn’t going to get fired from their job just because he/she got divorced*.

      Do you see where I’m going with this?
      The difference between the examples you listed and a transgendered person is public fear, discrimination, hate, and violence.

      To out someone as a transgendered person in a sensationalistic and mocking way is at best cruel, and at worst dangerously irresponsible.

      Sure, Bruce might decide that he wants to come forward, and maybe he’s not even transitioning, but either way, it should be on his own terms, however he’s feels comfortable and safe doing so.

      *see Vandy Beth Glenn fired from her job as legislative editor by her department head for coming out as transgendered.

    • chick binewski says:

      Brandii, I have to agree. This rag is trash and has no regard for anyone or any subject. They will use any celebrity’s circumstances or choices and paint it in an dramatic, unflattering light. All of their headlines are offensive. And poorly written.

      That being said I think the trans issue is something that many people still have many questions about. If this story is true, it would be great if it was told addressing the significant issues that come along with transitioning, not what color nail polish one is using or giving more time to a family who has used gossip rags for years with no regard for dignity, self-respect or the truth.

  32. FingerBinger says:

    Intouch went too far. It’s obvious they were trying to mislead people with the cover. They tried to make it seem like they got the exclusive of Bruce ‘coming out’.

  33. maeliz says:

    I don’t know if I believe all the sex change stuff I read about Bruce. If he wants to, let him, it’s his life. The media talks about it all the time, but this is awful. Time to stop picking on Bruce. I’d be so upset to see someone in my family treated like this

  34. Joy says:

    That’s horrid. And I don’t even think he’s transitioning. I think he just likes plastic surgery and the like.

  35. Susan says:

    The cover is beyond offensive. We have no idea what the story is with Bruce, it’s his business! Kris Kardashian has promoted and instilled in her children ‘any news is good news’ as a marketing tool giving tabloids free reign for any storyline. And this is one of the ugly results.

  36. Kim1 says:

    I think this is awful but I don’t think it is a new low.I think putting celebrities’ young kids on cover is low.I think posting stories about miscarriages and abortions is low.I think posting pics of dead celebs is low.
    If Bruce is transitioning it takes years of living as a woman,seeing a therapist,hormones,surgeries,etc
    I hope he is happy and at peace.

    • Sassy says:

      If he is truly transitioning (which I doubt) he had better get on with it due to his age. I read an article recently about a man who got Medicare to pay for his transition surgery. Guess it is never too late. I think this is all a carefully orchestrated bid for publicity for a new show with Bruce and his boys. Same as Kim’s rear end. it is a gimmick. I am saddened if that is the case, because it means that Bruce is as shallow and greedy as the rest of the sorry bunch. I hope that Kendall, the model truly escapes from the madness.

  37. Ginger says:

    My first thought…WTH?!! That is so outrageously disrespectful. I didn’t think that tabloid could sink any lower. I guess I was wrong.

  38. Citresse says:

    For a second I thought it was Khloe Kardashian.

  39. Hautie says:

    I did not realize until last night… when it made the news… that it was a genuine cover for In Touch. I really thought it was just some photo-shop mess that some jackass had made.

    To now realize that it is actually on the news stands, at the grocery store, just p*sses me off.

    I have a great deal of sympathy for Bruce Jenner for getting bullied so hatefully. No matter even if it is lies or the truth. No one (In Touch) has earned the right to bully a public figure like this… for their own amusement.

  40. Embee says:

    The magazine is clearly playing to transphobia if not transphobic itself/the editors. Which is worse, because it is perpetuating an easy and ignorant but dangerous attitude in our culture.

    But I love Bruce’s attitude. You do you, Bruce!

  41. Mrs. Wellen Melon says:

    Bruce is shopping a reality series now, right? It would feature Bruce and his sons’ bro lifestyle – which isn’t interesting tv. Could this cover be testing the waters to see if the reality tv fans want a show about Bruce’s coming to terms/coming out/whatever is going on in this part of his life?

    • Kim1 says:

      Making him look like a clown is not going to draw viewers to a show about him and his sons playing golf and racing cars IMO

      • Mrs. Wellen-Mellon says:

        It’s the clown part that’s making my PMK antennae raise up and receive signals. Most things in Kris’ universe are clown-like: Kim’s butt and the fit of her clothes, Khloe’s butt, Kylie’s lips, their repeating story lines which are getting stale.

  42. MeloMelo says:

    When I saw this last night all I could think was what was going through their heads!? I mean, I know they make up stories but I didnt believe they could go this far!

  43. Ruyana says:

    Anyone who was married to Kris (the Devil’s Homegirl) for 23 years has already suffered enough and deserves to be left in peace!

  44. Happy21 says:

    Oh my GOD! I can’t even believe how awful and terrible this is. Is this for real? Pretty sure this should be the undoing of In Touch. I can’t stand anyone from the Kardashian/Jenner klan but this is despicable. Wow!

  45. OTHER RENEE says:

    THe’s are bully tactics and as such, beneath contempt. I never thought I’d use the words “Kris Jenner is right” in a sentence, but she is.

  46. MJ says:

    Whether it’s true or not, it’s certainly in bad taste and just mean. I don’t like this kind of gossip, the sole purpose of that cover is to humiliate him.

  47. mytbean says:

    I totally agree that the magazine has no class in the way they delivered that… but it’s “In-Touch” so I don’t expect high brow. I don’t think they’ve ever aimed to be classy, just attention getting. Beige covers about wall paint and the price of chic peas just don’t sell.

    I don’t agree that sex changes are nor can be private however. If a person lived in a cave with no friends, family, hobby or career, maybe. But changing ones gender and expecting no one to react is like going to church with a live chicken on your head and expecting the same thing. People are going to notice and will have an emotional response to something like this.

    In this case, in a way – I think of viewers/fans (and Bruce was on a television show so he has those whether he likes it or not) as co-workers. He televises and they view. It’s a tango that needs both parties to function. And co-workers are going to notice and probably either comment on or have a ton of questions about that.

    • Steamin' Sam says:

      I agree with the idea that it’s not a private matter…in and of itself. However, Bruce has not announced this himself so all of this is pure media speculation. Until/unless he states that he is transitioning, all of this is very mean-spirited because it’s clearly meant to poke fun and portray what’s going on as a freak show. I don’t keep up with anyone in this family so I don’t know if he’s still actually televising his life (other than what paps manage to capture as he is out and about), but if he isn’t I don’t know that it’s fair to say he’s in a position of showing viewers his life anymore, and by extension, actually offering up this aspect of his life for the public. Is it fair to expect that, if he is indeed transitioning, he serve as the mouthpiece or arbiter of what the experience is like (to all those “co-workers” commenting or questioning)? Can he not simply transition and not feel he has to represent all others who have done the same?

    • Kitten says:

      I think that people may/may not have an emotional response to a transgendered loved. Some friends and family might be understanding and embracing, some might be sad or angry, or a combination of all of the above.

      But it’s challenging enough for a transgendered person to deal with the emotions and feelings of their coworkers, friends, and family, but to have it announced to the world on a cheesy ‘Shopped tabloid cover? I don’t know…that just seems so wrong to me.

      I’m not trying to speak for the LGBT community (sorry if I seem like I am) I just feel like this cheap rag is trivializing and mocking something that must be incredibly difficult to go through, making it more difficult with the public scrutiny.

      Maybe I’m wrong..?

      Also, I’m on my moon cycle so maybe I’m just being extra-cranky today.

      • MarcelMarcel says:

        @Kitten you’re not wrong. Reading your nuanced commentary means a lot to me. As a cis woman who is dating a trans woman, it’s really refreshing to see understanding, kind hearted commentary on this topic. Especially since I assume you’re a cis gender woman? If that’s incorrect, I’m sorry. But you’re being a really amazing ally.
        With some of the trans woman I know their family were immediately accepting, other woman have to deal with complete denial and too many are kicked out of home or if they are already living out of home, they are told not to come to Christmas etc… I think misinformation & transphobia makes it harder for families to be accepting.

    • MarcelMarcel says:

      I think any human is entitled to express their gender identity and be treated with respect. A cis gender person can be curiously respectful- use correct pronouns and the right name once a transgender person comes out.
      In an age where Laverne Cox is an openly trans woman on a hit show, Janet Mock released Redefining Realness and you can find articles written by trans woman, men & gender fluid people; there’s no excuse to place the onus of explaining gender on a trans person who just came out.
      It’s exhausting to be expected to constantly explain your gender identity. For example, how would you feel dealing with these statements every day- have you always known you’re cis gender, when did you decide to be publicly cis gender, what do your private parts look like, why are you cis gender, are you sure that you’re cis gender, you’re really lucky that nowadays you can be publicly cis gender, how do you know you’re cis gender, why are you cis gender, how does it feel to be cis gender?
      These are just some of questions & statements cis gender people feel entitled to say to trans gender people when they’ve only just met each other. As a cis woman, I would find it frustrating & exhausting to explain my gender identity every day. However, I’m not expected to because by sheer chance, I fit neatly in gender binary.

  48. Lin says:

    That is cruel, they should leave him alone. He will come out when he wants to and if he wants to. These issues are too serious to play with stoopid tabloids.. SMH…

  49. G says:

    He should sue for this. That cover is deplorable and they should be ashamed.

  50. JessSaysNo says:

    This is hella weird. At what point do we start thinking Bruce is having a meltdown as opposed to transitioning into a woman at age 65? I watched him on the Kardashian shows and never really thought he seemed womanly at all. He didn’t even do women’s hobbies and seemed to love to bro-out with his sons.

    If he has always been “a woman” why didn’t he transition when he got divorced originally? Why marry a woman and have more kids and waste her life thinking she married a man when in reality he wanted to divorce and live as a woman? Seems mean.

    • Chuckles says:

      He didn’t waste that evil witch’s life. We don’t know for sure that he wants to live as a woman, and if he does, it’s possible that he didn’t make that choice until after the divorce became inevitable. He may have been fine with how things were when the marriage was good, but since it soured, he now has the choice of having a different life going forward. He can identify as transgender and still be attracted to women, and I’ve never heard any accusations of cheating on his part, so no one should jump to the conclusion that he wasn’t sincere in the marriage. He truly loved that woman or he never would have stayed married to her for as long as he did.

  51. ketjo says:

    Am I the only one who see’s Kris Jenner’s media manipulation and spotlight grabbing all over this. ???? Her Mock shock and outrage that INT could do this …. when everybody and his brother knows that that Magazine in riding her inside pocket at all times..She practically owns the durn magazine……and you can’t tell me she didn’t know it was being published…when for the last year or two its been one of her girls on the cover month after month after month…
    Nope this is pure 100% mud slinging by her part to
    A. shame Bruce and being him public trashing
    B.. give her another fat paycheck from the percent of magazine sold…..
    Only problem is ….ITS NOT WORKING OUT AS SHE EXPECTED…..People are not laughing and shaming him they are defending him and praising him ..and even if the story is true they would still back him while he is changing…..this time the shame and destroy mission failed…She did it to Kris Humphries with the planted and fake story of him having stds and other nasty things…and the mud slinging of that divorce….She did it to Lamarr with the faked drug addict stories and destroyed the man’s career and reputation, she’s doing it to her own son Rob…right now….and Kanye had better watch his back the second she can’t use him anymore she will slam the public with proof that he is gay and cheating on Kim with a man….there is nothing she will not do or say….and She will Destroy Bruce Jenner if she can ……

  52. bored_01 says:

    Yes, it’s transphobic. And just plain mean.

  53. Moo says:

    totally crossed the line. i hope the magazine goes under.
    i don’t even think he’s transitioning either.

  54. Lauraq says:

    Just wanted to throw this out about people who are saying Bruce is changing gender-We discussed this at length in all my psych classes. If Bruce is indeed transitioning, he isn’t changing gender. If Bruce identifies as a woman, then his gender is female already. He may transition so that his sex matches his gender. As they say, sex is between your legs and gender is between your ears.
    In any event, people need to back off. He’s not hurting anyone, so it’s no one’s business what he wants to do with his own body.