Biggest Loser contestant: it’s ‘a fat-shaming disaster’ that mistreats contestants

Back in 2010, former Biggest Loser contestant Kai Hibbard spoke out against what she claimed were unsafe, unhealthy practices on the show which jeopardized her health. Hibbard was the runner up on the third season of the show, in 2006, having lost 118 pounds. Now that more time has passed, Hibbard is getting specific about what she went through. In a new interview, she tells the NY Post that she suffered from a kind of Stockholm syndrome on the show. She says contestants are isolated from friends and family and put through a grueling process in which they’re worked to exhaustion and given demeaning feedback by trainers. Contestants work out at least four hours a day and eat less than 1,000 calories. Injuries and malnutrition issues are ignored in favor of the scale and storylines. It all sounds like what we’ve heard from other Loser contestants, but it’s still kind of shocking when someone goes on the record with this. The NY Post also got quotes from another Biggest Loser participant who spoke on condition of anonymity. Here’s some of their interview, with more at the source:

‘The whole f- -king show,” she says today, “is a fat-shaming disaster that I’m embarrassed to have participated in.”

Contestants are isolated
Once selected, Hibbard was flown to LA. When she got to her hotel, she was greeted by a production assistant, who checked her in and took away her key card. When not filming, she was to stay in her room at all times.

“The hotel will report to them if you leave your room,” Hibbard says. “They assume you’re going to talk to other contestants…”

Those who remain, Hibbard says, are not allowed to call home. “You might give away show secrets,” she says. After six weeks, contestants get to make a five-minute call, monitored by production.

“I know that one of the contestants’ children became very ill and was in the ICU,” Hibbard says. “He was allowed to talk to his family — but he didn’t want to leave, because the show would have been done with him.”

Trainers were sadistic
The trainers, [an anonymous source] says, took satisfaction in bringing their charges to physical and mental collapse. “They’d get a sick pleasure out of it,” she says. “They’d say, ‘It’s because you’re fat. Look at all the fat you have on you.’ And that was our fault, so this was our punishment.”

Hibbard had the same experience. “They would say things to contestants like, ‘You’re going die before your children grow up.’ ‘You’re going to die, just like your mother.’ ‘We’ve picked out your fat-person coffin’ — that was in a text message. One production assistant told a contestant to take up smoking because it would cut her appetite in half.”

Contestants ate less than 1,000 calories a day
Meanwhile, their calories were severely restricted. The recommended daily intake for a person of average height and weight is 1,200 to 1,600 calories per day. The contestants were ingesting far less than 1,000 per day.

Hibbard says the bulk of food on her season was provided by sponsors and had little to no nutritional value.

“Your grocery list is approved by your trainer,” she says. “My season had a lot of Franken-foods: I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter spray, Kraft fat-free cheese, Rockstar Energy Drinks, Jell-O.”

Contestants were not allowed to follow doctor’s orders
At one point, Hibbard says, production did bloodwork on all the contestants, and the show’s doctor prescribed electrolyte drinks. “And the trainer said, ‘Don’t drink that — it’ll put weight on you. You’ll lose your last chance to save your life.'”

“One contestant had a torn calf muscle and bursitis in her knees,” Hibbard says. “The doctor told her, ‘You need to rest.’ She said, ‘Production told me I can’t rest.’ At one point after that, production ordered her to run, and she said, ‘I can’t.’ She was seriously injured. But they edited her to make her look lazy and bitchy and combative.”

Hibbard’s own health declined dramatically. “My hair was falling out,” she says. “My period stopped. I was only sleeping three hours a night.” Hibbard says that to this day, her period is irregular, her hair still falls out, and her knees “sound like Saran Wrap” every time she goes up and down stairs. “My thyroid, which I never had problems with, is now crap,” she says.

“You’re brainwashed to believe that you’re super-lucky to be there,” Hibbard says. One doctor told a contestant she was exhibiting signs of Stockholm syndrome, and Hibbard herself fell prey to it.

“I was thinking, ‘Dear God, don’t let anybody down. You will appear ungrateful if you don’t lose more weight before the season finale.’ ”

[From The NY Post]

First season winner Ryan C. Benson has also spoken out against the Biggest Loser. Like Hibbard, he says he was dehydrated from the show. He also suffered kidney damage and was peeing blood after the show wrapped. Countless doctors and nutrition and fitness experts have spoken out against the dangers of the kind of rapid weight loss portrayed on Biggest Loser.

Hibbard was 26 when she participated on Biggest Loser, she’s now 35. She recently posted to Facebook that she refuses to “be be reduced to a number.” Hibbard previously admitted to gaining 70 pounds back after the show, but she says now that she doesn’t want to be reduced “to something as meaningless as my weight or clothing size.” Good for her. She also recently shaved her head to help raise awareness and funding to combat childhood cancers.

Many people will make the argument that Hibbard knew what she was getting into when she signed up for Biggest Loser. She claims that she hadn’t seen the show prior to 2006, which was just the third season, and that her best friend convinced her to send in an audition tape. I suspect that more potential contestants know what Biggest Loser entails now, and that Biggest Loser contracts have become air tight to avoid contestants speaking out like this. I know it makes for good television to have people lose weight so quickly and it’s surely cheaper than doing it the more healthy way, but I wish they would strive for a realistic balance.

10552462_10152690401212437_7996890327201925083_n

373813_10151422832907437_744474315_n

hibbardba

Photo credit: Getty Images, NBC and Facebook

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

70 Responses to “Biggest Loser contestant: it’s ‘a fat-shaming disaster’ that mistreats contestants”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. kri says:

    SO now we know what it takes to get that Hollywood body. Um, I’m all about being healthy, fit and happy. But when you sign up for this kind of show, you have to be ready for the stuff that goes along with it.

    • Brittney B says:

      I don’t think anyone should “have to be ready” for emotional and physical abuse. Both of which largely take place off-camera… so how *could* they know?

      Most people don’t read gossip mags or seek out stories about the realities of “reality TV”, and I imagine most contestants are probably so desperate to change their lives that they want to believe the TV version. It wouldn’t be such a wildly successful show if the average American knew exactly what happened to these people behind the scenes, or the long-term consequences they face long after the seasons wrap.

    • Jag says:

      I was going to sign up because I thought that contestants would be given the best organic food, the most nutritious diet, and then also access to good personal trainers and wonderful workout equipment. I’m very glad that a knee and back injury kept me from sending in a tape!

      Those trainers and producers better be happy they never met me, because if they had tried to put me through all of that, they would’ve seen my Jagrage!

      • pikny says:

        i knew bob harper a long time ago.he used to live in a vw van.he was a cool guy.sickening to hear what biggest loser is really like

    • Bridget says:

      The people that go on that show are desperate amd feel like The Biggest Loser is their last chance – does that mean that they deserve to be treated so badly? We’re talking about vulnerable individuals who apply to be a part of an experience that is at least billed as being about health and wellness. The show is terrible, but that blame lies squarely on the folks that put it on and who choose the format and the tone.

    • Zwella Ingrid says:

      I have zero sympathy for any of these people. You know what you are getting into when you get involved with a show like this. Cry me a freaking river. This is all a bid for either attention or to grab some kind of compensation from the show. It just makes me mad.

      • A~ says:

        Seriously? It’s cool with you that the show risks their LIVES? For entertainment purposes? I guess exploitation is all the fault of the victim, regardless, as far as your concerned?

      • Sooloo says:

        Zwella does have a point, A. You’re way off the mark. The show didn’t risk their lives – these contestants decided to proceed, knowing that what the producers were telling them was counter to doctors’ orders! It doesn’t take a health freak to know that processed Frankenstein foods aren’t healthy or that working out 4 hours a day isn’t either (and honestly, what person in their right mind begins peeing blood or stops menstruating yet STILL does not call it quits??). Maybe these people had no clue what they were getting into when they first signed on, but come on! Nobody held a gun to their heads and forced them to restrict their calories or exercise even with severe injuries. If someone has a child in the ICU and still refuses to either leave the show or break the rules about not having more than 5 minutes of phone contact, then it’s clear where his priorities are. This is not exploitation when people willingly ignore sensible medical advice all in the interest of winning a stupid TV show. When does personal responsibility come into play?

      • mytbean says:

        Much of this reminds me of military style basic training for enlisted folks. Yes they get to eat but they are also routinely rousted out of bed at random hours mid-REM cycle to run their arses off in inclement weather. They run night and day. They so exhausted that many fall into a deep sleep standing upright. This goes on for weeks on end until many fall away due to either physical injury or psychological break. We like to think that the ones left standing are the stronger ones but often they feel as though they had no other option but to enlist and failing was equal to death. They’re also the ones that were the most impressionable and, it could be argued have a deep respect for the authorities that subjected them to that battery because – like these contestants – they suffer with a kind of Stockholm syndrome as well.

      • Belle Epoch says:

        A- I’m with you. The show is reprehensible. The people who go on it are most likely desperate for money and desperately unhappy. Then they starved, insulted, demeaned, overworked and underfed until they are filled with self-loathing believe that they deserve to be punished. It would be difficult to suddenly advocate for yourself when you are exhausted, isolated, and gave up being with your family to accomplish this “goal.” And I’m sure the show pulls out all the stops if someone wants to leave, since they could have a riot on their hands if the contestants came to their senses. You’d have to have a few screws loose to go on the show – but that only makes the abuse more outrageous.

      • Seriously serious says:

        The show did risk their lives. Thyroid conditions affect you for the rest of your life. It is like living your life at 80% while everybody else lives at 100%. “Half-Dead” or “A little bit deader” describes it quite well. Even good medication can’t quite make up for it.

    • Lucinda says:

      No you don’t. Not the kind of stuff they are putting their contestants through. If even half of what is described is true, this is nothing but physical and emotional abuse inflicted on people who are already in a fragile emotional state. You don’t get that fat because you are a happy and emotionally stable person. The network is absolutely victimizing these people for profits. It makes me all the happier that I have never been a fan of this show in anyway.

    • Seriously serious says:

      Have they been told what kind of shit was to come? This show does seriously and permanently damage the health of its participants for the sake of entertainment. Certainly that is neither morally nor legally okay?

  2. Merritt says:

    The show is a awful. So many contestants just gain the weight back because the show’s method is unsustainable. And then when someone does what they need to do to win, they get shamed for being too thin. The show needs to go away, but it won’t because people love to fat shame.

    • FLORC says:

      Ofcourse, the methods aren’t sustainable. These people have no job other than to exercise.
      It is bringing up your cardio so you can endure a workout without falling after 15 minutes.

      And that woman getting too thin. She was. And she admitted she was being unhealthy to reach that, but she just wanted to win. She has since gained some weight back and looks great. Going to extremes though shouldn’t be praised.

      • Merritt says:

        The problem is the show coerces contestants to go to extremes. Exercising for hours a day like that, is extreme.

        Of course the one wanted to win. That was why she went on the show. And due to biology, men have an advantage in weight loss, which is why the majority of the winners have been men.

  3. Bridget says:

    So it turns out that expecting people to go from complete inactivity to working out for 8 hours a day on a deprivation diet ISN’T good for you?

    It’s a terrible show that disguises itself as uplifting. I won’t watch it, nor will I sign up for their race series nor buy their products.

    • Caz says:

      My brother is a very good personal trainer. He was interviewed for the first Australian series (along with many others) to find local Trainers to replace Bob & Jillian. He declined a further interview because he didn’t agree with the show’s philosophies.

      Ratings are down…they’re still persisting with new series though.

  4. QQ says:

    Good for her for speaking out and also finding a Balance

    • Erinn says:

      I agree, though I really am not sure what people expect when they sign up for shows like this. It’s not going to be cushy, and it’s not going to be fun at all.

      I can understand being confused when it’s a new show – but this has been on for ages, and they see the dramatic difference in people from start to finish. And I don’t mean this directly related to her – she was on it a while ago I think.

      But anyone who goes on now, shouldn’t be so surprised. Doesn’t make it right, but I think a lot of people who are really inactive go on thinking they’ll ramp up to it or something, and then are caught off guard when they have super controlling trainers pushing them too hard.

      ETA – for the people that get seriously hurt and stay on the show… I just don’t get that. I know it’s a nice chunk of cash, but you’re putting your injury below a prize you have no guarantee of winning.

      • MonicaQ says:

        Totally agree on the ETA. Like I’ve played football injured because I didn’t want to let my teammates down but then realized I was hurting them by only being at 60% and my back up was at least 95% as good as I was but I’ve fractured ribs. I’m not Tony Romo. I pulled myself out of that game even though we were only losing by a thin margin. It’s not worth it.

      • Erinn says:

        It’s really not, MonicaQ. I’ve had to step out of certain activities because of injuries. I used to be super involved in 4-H and had to pull out of a competition to represent our club because I had popped a bone out of place in the wrist of my dominant hand. I couldn’t show my calf because I couldn’t get it trained up to a level I thought was appropriate because I’d injured the wrist so badly the season before while trying to load cattle onto a trailer, and I didn’t want to risk putting it out of commission again. Which – thank god – because I still have problems with it. I can’t imagine what I’d have done if I hadn’t taken the breather I took.

  5. qtip says:

    Wow that is crazy. Are these restrictions in contracts before you sign up or does this happen along the way? I’ve never watched the show so how long is the duration before they declare a winner?

    • FLORC says:

      I had to look it up. The contestants (depending on couples or singles) spend about 5 months training. Then they take 4 to 6 weeks off to train at home before the final numbers are tallied up.

      And there are restrictions in the contracts. This has been standard for years on reality tv. You know you can’t talk to family. You can risk it, but the show would be within their rights to kick you. And should you leak info there’s likely a multi million dollar penalty involved.
      I’m better the food they provide you is agreed upon in there too. On the small portion of the show i’ve seen there’s always fruit and vegetables and contestants are always eating them. They’re not surviving on kraft and jello. Once you sign you are agreeing to live like an animal for a chance at a cash payout.
      You sign over your freedom. And you can ofcourse take it back, but you’d risk being disqualified. There’s still a choice to walk away.

      • A~ says:

        Do you really think the show is letting you see everything?

      • TeaAndSympathy says:

        A~: I don’t believe so. These “reality” shows are notorious for only showing the “positives”. If they were to show the real, behind-the-scenes story, they’d last for a couple of weeks before there was an outcry and people turned off. Having spoken at length with a media lawyer friend, I also don’t believe the contracts are as clear and open as they could be, so I’m not convinced that contestants “know exactly what they’re getting into”. How could they? It’s not like they’re psychic, and these/many contracts are written in legalese, which a lot of ordinary people usually don’t fully understand. From what my lawyer friend has said, the chosen ones are pressured to sign their contracts ASAP, being told they’ll hold up production if they don’t sign quickly, and that, even then, they can be easily replaced.

        I really believe vulnerable contestants are sucked-in, with the promise of a healthy, slim body and the chance to win the big cash, which for most, would be a life-changing experience. I’ve only caught snippets of the Australian version (while at friends’ houses), but I could see that what contestants were being put through was unhealthy, unsafe and highly demeaning, but I am a cynic, after all…

        I detest these shows.

      • “On the small portion of the show i’ve seen there’s always fruit and vegetables and contestants are always eating them. They’re not surviving on kraft and jello.”

        This is not definitive, because of editing. You’re not seeing the raw footage, you know.

  6. runCMC says:

    I feel for the contestants! When you watch the show on tv, sure, it looks extreme but they pretend to care deeply about keeping the contestants healthy. There’s all these doctors appointments and sometimes people are allowed to be shown to be injured and doing their best (although like she said, sometimes injured people are edited to look lazy). They probably had no idea the extent of behind the scenes abuse they’d face.

    Honestly the first time I thought this show was more about emotional abuse than helping people was a couple of seasons ago, when an obese woman was crying to the doctor in the initial episodes about having had multiple miscarriages and difficulty conceiving. With a straight face he looked at that sobbing woman and told her it was her fault for being so fat. Ugh. Broke my heart.

    Can’t believe that show is still on. Hope contestants keep speaking out!

    • Jag says:

      A doctor said that? Wow what a jerk! She could have had thyroid issues, which cause miscarriages, and also PCOS, which can cause infertility or difficulty becoming pregnant. I guess everyone is mean on that show!

      And agreed that it’s good that they’re speaking out now.

    • ataylor says:

      Are you talking about Sarah? Because if it is, then she is now a mother of two. One adopted and a biological daughter that she conceived naturally after several rounds of IVF.

      And yes, she did regain a lot of the the weight back. After the show ended, she went to work for TBL so she was able to keep the weight off for a bit. Not anymore.

  7. kpoodle says:

    As someone who has lost almost 70 Lbs and managed to keep it off for 7 years, this show makes me so angry! It does NOT depict, or promote, realistic weight loss. These people are starved and forced to do grueling workouts. Plus, more often than not, they gain most of the weight back. There is nothing healthy about that.

    • runCMC says:

      Congratulations!! That’s so hard to do! I lost 80 lbs a few years ago and put 40 back on. I’m working my way back down but you better believe it’s slow and steady- unlike the insane pace depicted in the show.

    • doofus says:

      congrats to BOTH of you. those are amazing results and I hope you both can keep it up.

      (runCMC, don’t be discouraged! slow and steady, as I’m sure you know, is GOOD.)

      Good job!

    • kcarp says:

      I took have lost 70 pounds, I have kept mine off about 5 years now. I really think this kind of show works for some without long term mental damage. Agreed that it is not healthy to lose weight this way and would make it impossible to keep off. However, some people like myself really need a kick in the a** to keep going.

      This is totally unhealthy but while I am working out I think of it is as my punishment because I have an out of control sweet tooth. I know that I am full of it, just like some of these contestants know they are just being treated this way because of the show.

  8. Francesca says:

    I only recently started watching this show and was appalled at how much weight they get these people to lose every week. There is no way that is achieved responsibly or healthfully.

    • Jules says:

      Those ‘weeks’ they speak of on the show are not 7 day weeks. Another lie from this show. Some ‘weeks’ are actually several weeks long.

  9. Jackson says:

    I agree with some of what she said – about losing weight so quickly, the frankenfoods nonsense, the not being considered a number. But I DO take issue with the fact that she signed up for the show after it had been on for a couple of seasons without investigating it more thoroughly. Who agrees to something like that without doing the research first? It is, first and foremost, a “reality show” which means she’s only going to be fodder for whatever storyline suits production purposes.

    • Happy21 says:

      I somewhat agree with you. However, I also think that a lot of these people that sign up for the show are at their wits end, are obese or close to being obese and want anything that can help them. They don’t have a clue about health or nutrition and probably even if they had researched it, wouldn’t have understood what it meant anyways. They are desperate.

      I used to watch the show but its schtick got a little old and the trainers were brutal. I’m glad that someone is speaking about what we, the viewers, do not see on the TV screen.

    • Kim1 says:

      Who signs up without doing research?
      Desperate people
      Hopeless people
      I have never watched an entire episode but the few minutes I watched showed people desperate to get help with this issue.

      • Jackson says:

        Desperate does not have to equal dumb. If I follow that same logic then those same desperate people who sign up should be happy for whatever weight they lost, however they lost it then, right? Not really. At some point people need to take some of their own responsibility back for putting themselves in the position they put themselves in – in this case, signing on to a reality TV show. Do the research and read the entire contract before you sign on the dotted line. And if something seems wrong then stop doing it and stop worrying about letting down people who aren’t important to you like a damn production assistant.

    • TrixC says:

      I don’t think you can blame the contestants. I think there should be basic ethical standards for reality TV, a bit like there are for participation in research studies.

      • Vampi says:

        @TRIXC
        ^This!

      • MarcelMarcel says:

        Agreed!
        Biggest Loser should be moviatated by a genuine respect for people and a desire to help them lose weight instead of milking their misery for ratings & pain. But then I didn’t watch it because the name sounded fatphobic. The one time I did it was because a teenage relative wanted to. My mama and I spent the entire time giving a running commentary on why the attitudes of the trainers, presenters & producers are problematic.
        I do wonder how much being cut off from
        loved ones increases the contestants pain threshold. It can be hard to see that you’re not being treated right if there’s no trusted person to validate your emotional discomfort.

  10. Arock says:

    The shows whole premise is to consolidate rapid weight loss from contestants who sign up, agreeing to terms and co fictions of the game. The goal is not to promote healthy life styles, it’s to take overweight people and put them through grueling physical activity (for the sake of the viewers amusement, at the compromise of their own dignity) and life restrictions to encourage the emotional element (again, cause entertainment). They sign waivers and contracts. It doesn’t absolve the ethical question of wether the show is wrong, but it clears them to do it. This show, and shows like it, are incredibly profitable and offer the contestant- after they’ve been used- a shot at fame and money as well as thinning out. You can’t fault the show, you can’t fault the contestants; at the end of the day neitherwould exist with out viewership.

    • WinterLady says:

      I know right? Basically another one of those Catch-22 reality show situations. I’m pretty sure there have been shows on that do promote healthy lifestyle changes and weight loss, but alas, they have never been as popular as sensational shows like The Biggest Loser. Says a lot about they world we are living in, really.

  11. chaine says:

    At the end of the day, you have to wonder why she did not just leave, if it was all so awful. I wonder if part of the application process for the show screens out independent thinkers and selects for doormat personalities who will be willing to stay despite the abuse.

    • MonicaQ says:

      Probably because they had an NDA? Or how they’d make you look on TV–“what a fatty fat quitter, now she’s going to die” or something?

    • canwetalk says:

      @chaine,

      I read Kai’s article a while back and she’s addressed this by stating that they brainwash you and say do realize how lucky you are to be here. There are other fat people just waiting to take your place. She says that comments like that made her feel guilty for wasting the “great opportunity”.
      Yes they pick desperate people with extremely low self esteem which makes it easy to brainwash them and force cooperation.

      Bottom line the network can make easy money without hiring actors at the expense of everyday people’s ignorance regarding the big picture behind this quick fix opportunity.

  12. Jen43 says:

    What a horrible show. I have never watched it, but would be more interested in a show that would allow these people a year to lose the weight, follow them in their real life, etc. Let it be something viewers can relate to. They should take it off the air.

  13. Ginger says:

    I’ve only watched the show once when Jillian Michaels came back to it. It did seem like they were starving the contestants with as much exercise as they were doing. Now that I know what goes on behind the scenes I won’t watch it. It’s horrible that they’ve destroyed peoples health when they are supposedly trying to help them.

  14. Irishserra says:

    You are assuming, however, that all overweight people are so because they eat too much and don’t exercise. Wrong. The people who go on that show are most likely prey to an industry that promotes GMO’d, processed, pre-packaged, nutrient-deficient foods and horrifyingly has the total support of our government. While I do hold the view that accurate information is out there in abundance and that once you know better, you’ve got the personal responsibility to take charge of your own health; the sad truth is that there are still a lot of individuals out there who still erroneously believe that their best interests are being looked after by the government agencies and the food and medical industries and it’s obvious that that wrong thinking carries over to this ridiculous show.

  15. no way says:

    Are you kidding me? Fat shaming as our society has been doing for decades really works well doesn’t it? We are now more overweight and obese than we were in the sixties and seventies.

    Also, you must not have watched the show, several people have thyroid disease- which is mostly a genetic issue, and diabetes which can be partially genetic and lifestyle. Still by the time they have the disease an intense weight loss plan is extremely unhealthy for them.

    It’s one thing to get a jump start or kick in the arse as you say, and I am not disputing that some people need a bit of a push, but way too many people are overweight in society today to think that is the reason. I guess the world is full of mostly lazy people. You must be a joy personally to be with, half empty kind of person.

  16. MonicaQ says:

    It’d be a cold day on Tatoonie before I’d get on that show and everything from My Fitness Pal to fitbit says “OMG YOU’RE GOING TO DIE”. But I bench 210lbs at 225lbs so whatever. Let me die in peace.

  17. Triple Cardinal says:

    I love how, when the women are at their biggest/flabbiest, the producers make them wear “sports bras” that do not support their breasts, but which do show off rolls of fat around the midriff. T-shirts are available–the men wear them–but the women are exposed.

    Just another form of humiliation. Somebody must have stayed up late at night to dream that one up.

    • TrixC says:

      This. I watched the show once years ago and the appalling sexism of this is one of the reasons I have not watched it again.

  18. Dancinancy says:

    I’m overweight and have been trying to lose on my own for awhile. I’m not giving up but the thought of a 6 week “vacation” where I get to exercise and focus on my health sounds amazing! I have a job where I sit for 10 hours a day. The reality is there are bills to pay and in this economy you cannot just quit your job to find a more “active” one.

    Depending on the contract many people may not have realized the emotional abuse they’d be subjected to – or they were so desperate for help they didnt think they would care.

  19. XtinaDurango says:

    Fat shaming? This lady has been the least cute to me during the whole show. I’m overweight myself and lost 24 lbs with the Loaded Gun Diet, but she doesn’t bring any emotions to me.

  20. skipper says:

    I had an offer to be on Wife Swap. During the phone interview they asked about my child and I told them that she has severe medical problems and is confined to a wheelchair. They jumped on it like white on rice. I could tell that they wanted to exploit that aspect of my life to the fullest and turned it down even when they offered my family more money to sign on. That’s just how these shows work. Very icky.

  21. Frosty says:

    These shows are just vile. Even though a potential contestant might think “reality tv” and think they can handle it, I don’t think they can truly know they insanity they’ve signed on for. Most shameful are the coaches

  22. neha says:

    I think that a lot of people assume that people who speak out are just bitter and lazy. They feel like as long as they work out hard and not be oversensitive to the yelling, they will be fine. After all, all you hear on record is how TBL changed peoples’ lives. If you listen to Jillian Michael’s podcasts, it’s obvious that she also feels this way too but just isn’t able to speak so openly.

  23. MourningTheDeathOfMusic says:

    I stopped watching within the first season. I thought I’d be watching a show that maintained the group and supported better choices and a healthy lifestyle for the entire duration and then the one who was most successful out of the entire group would win.

    Once I saw it was yet another Survivor like program, I bailed. I’m not at all surprised to read about the horrible treatment behind the scenes with seeing how poorly they were treated actually on camera.

  24. Anna says:

    So I’m not saying these claims aren’t true and I’m not bashing anyone but people always complaining AFTER the show is over?? I’m not trying to be hateful I just don’t understand the mindset of “after the fact” whistle blowing. All the complaints that I have read are from contestants that were runners-up or otherwise made it significantly far in the contest from several seasons (i.e. years) ago. No one has ever signed up for Biggest Loser, blown a gasket at mistreatment, dropped out of the show immediately and made the public aware of what is happening.

  25. Lucy2 says:

    I think it’s good of her to speak out on the health and safety issues- the show is putting people at risk purely for sensationalism, which isn’t right.
    As for the other stuff…it’s a reality show. I think you need to be aware of what you’re signing up for. Unless you are on the first season of a new show and have no way of knowing what to expect, it’s incredibly foolish to go for it without doing a little research first.

  26. Beachy says:

    Is this weight loss program run by scientologists?

  27. sapphire says:

    Extreme Makeover-Weightloss edition is about as bad, even with the touchy feely Powell and wife combination. Undoubtedly the contestant needs to lose weight for health reasons-but how realistic is having the contestant put their life on hold for a year? Are they going to do that for the rest of their life AND hold a job, deal with their family and friends etc?

    I felt the worst for the young woman who developed an eating disorder during the program-after Powell ate her usual amount of food and threw up. That’s when I stopped watching.

  28. Dk310 says:

    Most of this sounds like issues that have since been worked out. For one the contestants no longer stay in a hotel. We also are constantly seeing what they eat. Does this sound awful? Sure. Did she have a choice to leave at any point? Absolutely. I find it hard to believe that the doctors who currently participate in the show would risk their reputation, medical license, and a lawsuit if the show still went against doctors orders, especially when the show now shows doctors visits throughout the season.