‘War for the Planet of the Apes’ rules the box office: is it as good as critics say?

Mild spoilers for War for the Planet of the Apes
I loved Spiderman: Homecoming. It was a delightful movie full of thoughtful details, funny scenes and likable characters and had a fresh, effortless vibe. Homecoming clocked in at two hours and 13 minutes but it never dragged and kept me entertained the entire time. In contrast War for the Planet of the Apes was two hours and 22 minutes but felt at least an hour longer than Homecoming. It was like two movies in one that did not flow together. The first half was a schmaltzy mess with too many drawn out death scenes and moments which seemed emotionally manipulative. The score was overdramatic, I’ve seen less cheesy Hallmark movies, and I was sighing and rolling my eyes at several key scenes. The second half, when the apes were forced into slavery by Woody Harrelson’s band of Nazi-esque soldiers, moved quickly and provided the payoff for sitting through all the glurge that led up to it. Plus, War took itself way too seriously. There was one character who provided comic relief but it was a ham-handed attempt to lighten up the movie. (It needed it.)

Dawn of The Planet of the Apes was incredible and I was hoping for more of the same from War, but it just didn’t resonate with me like the last one. This surprised me given its very high 95% Rotten Tomatoes rating. War outperformed Homecoming at the box office this weekend, which was expected given that it just opened. However it’s not doing as well as predicted and is 22% down from Dawn’s opening weekedn. Here are a couple of articles about War’s good, but still disappointing, box office:

Euphoric reviews did not translate to blockbuster ticket sales for “War for the Planet of the Apes,” which collected $56.5 million at North American theaters over the weekend, or 22 percent less than initial results for its 2014 series predecessor…

For the weekend in North America, “Spider-Man: Homecoming” (Sony) was second, taking in an estimated $45.2 million, for a two-week domestic total of $208.3 million, according to comScore, which compiles box office data. “Despicable Me 3” (Universal) chugged away in third place, collecting $18.9 million for a three-week total of about $188 million. – NY Times

The movie in its debut played akin to a non-superhero threequel, off 21% from Dawn, and is considered OK by industry standards. If there’s any kind of sigh here, it’s just that when studios build movies this big, and War carries a $150M production cost before P&A, the expectation is to swell, and 20th Century Fox pulled out all the stops in promoting this threequel 10 months in advance at New York’s Comic-Con with a six minute unfinished scene and a teaser trailer. The gorilla’s horde of cash here will come from overseas, which is where Rise (63%) and Dawn (70%) reaped the most. Heading into the weekend, rival studios had some pretty aggressive estimates out there for War, but Fox never saw the threequel in that upper box office sphere, especially in this summer marketplace which has been severe for any title that’s not part of a superhero franchise.

While Fox was able to get the critics on board, social media guru Relish Mix felt that the love wasn’t translating in the online chatter heading into the weekend with mixed conversation, a socially disengaged cast and a “good, but not great” 265M social media universe across Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube for a sci-fi/fantasy film. – From Deadline

[From NY Times and Deadline]

I guess this means superhero movies, which I don’t mind given that Wonder Woman was awesome and we have Black Panther coming out early next year. In terms of ticket sales, word of mouth must have more clout than critics. If our friends don’t like something or seem hesitant about it we’re less likely to see it. Don’t get me wrong I enjoyed this film, I just had higher standards for it which were not met. Also, no shade if you liked all of War! My friends really did.

War for the Planet of the Apes was co-written by the director, Matt Revees, who is also directing the standalone Batman movie. Reeves’s other writing credits are scant and include the TV series Felicity, The Pallbearer (a 90s romcom with Gwyneth Paltrow and David Schwimmer) and a couple of other films you’ve probably never heard of. Reeves just announced that he’s scrapping Ben Affleck’s script for The Batman and is rewriting the whole thing. This does not bode well.

As an aside there were some references to the original Planet of The Apes in War. The Hollywood Reporter has more about that. (Spoilers)

Premiere for the War for the Planet of the Apes

Premiere for the War for the Planet of the Apes

Premiere for the War for the Planet of the Apes

photos credit: WENN

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

19 Responses to “‘War for the Planet of the Apes’ rules the box office: is it as good as critics say?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. B2C says:

    It was sooooooo good. I Loved every moment of this movie.

    • Pandy says:

      Me too! I thought it was great. So did DH.

    • Mgsota says:

      I loved it! I was on edge throughout the movie. My husband liked Dawn better but I liked this better. And I LOVED the score. I think the score will be nominated for an Oscar.

  2. Nicole says:

    Not better than Dawn but I thought it was solid. It’s a good trilogy

  3. GiBee says:

    I didn’t think it was better than Dawn, but I didn’t think it was worse.

    Maybe I was just relieved to see an action film that wasn’t just snarky one liners…. plus Serkis does such an amazing job.

  4. Aang says:

    I liked it. But I found it tough to watch. Violence disturbs me. The motivation of colonel was a mystery to me. I kept thinking, humans destroyed the world when they were in charge, give the apes a chance and see if they can do better. I’m afraid that one day they will no longer all be just apes, but chimps, gorillas, orangutans. I hope they don’t go down that road, I want to imagine them living in harmony forever. I got hints of Exodus from the film. Also I wish Maurice was my bff.

    • Radley says:

      The Colonel gave an entire monologue about his motivation. I won’t post any spoilers but he def explained.

      It was a little long for me. But it was still good. And as usual, it created so much sympathy for the apes, who are just more victims of man. And it painted man as fearful and unable to get along with each other let alone another species. That seems accurate.

      Minor spoiler, I totally got the inference of the power crazed madman hell-bent on building a wall and making sketchy decisions while not listening to reason. Something very familiar about that…

  5. Tiffany says:

    All I can write is that Andy Serkis better get some award love this season. Just spectacular in this role.

  6. Heat says:

    I thought the movie was great! This trilogy is definitely underrated in NA. Bad Ape was my fave. I recognized my beloved Steve Zahn’s voice right away. Andy Serkis is truly amazing as Caesar. I’m waiting for them to add a mo-cap category to the Oscars…or maybe name a new award after him. Lol.

  7. lower case lois says:

    If you want to see a great summer movie go see the ” Big Sick”, quite charming and script is well written.

  8. Word says:

    Horrible. I wanted to punch the screen. Bad Ape was the only entertaining thing about this.

  9. tmot says:

    So, how many girls were in this movie? Did they get any lines?


    Were there any scenes with all women? Talking? To each other?

    Why am I expected to empathize with all male movies, but they don’t want to make movies about women, because dudes are so simple that they won’t like it?!

  10. Adrien says:

    Haven’t seen it yet. I went to see Big Sick (good movie, glad to know it made money) and Baby Driver (entertaining from start to finish, made me care for Ansel Elgort).

  11. Mrs Odie says:

    I really enjoyed it. Beyond just the “get out of the heat and eat popcorn” draw of the summer blockbuster. It was a quiet, thoughtful movie with lots of room for actors to convey the complexity of the issues in the script. Two thumbs up (I didn’t see the other 2 movies).

  12. Mrs Odie says:

    Overjoyed to see all the Andy Serkis love. For me, though, Andy Serkis will never top his performance in 13 Going on 30. Who’s with me?

  13. DesertReal says:

    I love love loved it! I got choked up a few times, my husband and step-daughter were digging it pretty hard too. It was a fitting cinematic end to the trilogy.
    It was so good, I was willing to over-look/not get distracted by the dose of humor character. He sort of reminded me of Lord of the Rings’ Gollum.