Anna Wintour fired most of Pitchfork’s staff while wearing her sunglasses indoors

The past week has been hellish with mass layoffs in the field of sports and music journalism. Sports Illustrated is not folding, but their corporate owners are firing a huge chunk of sports journalists, writers and editors, and no one knows what the future holds for one of the most important national sports-reporting brands. This week, we also learned that Pitchfork would not continue to exist as a somewhat independent site – Conde Nast is slashing Pitchfork’s staff and the music site is being folded into GQ. Anna Wintour controls a lot of what happens within Conde Nast – her official title is Global Chief Content Officer, which means she oversees content over a vast array of domestic and international media outlets, mostly print outlets. Wintour was in the meetings with Pitchfork staffers as they learned their site is being folded into GQ. Apparently, she never removed her sunglasses.

Anna Wintour, Condé Nast’s longtime fashion doyenne, is famous for a singular style trademark — her sunglasses. Indeed, Wintour didn’t take off her sunglasses the entire time she met with employees of Pitchfork this week to tell them they were losing their jobs after Condé Nast had decided to subsume the music criticism site into GQ, according to one now-former employee in attendance.

“One absolutely bizarro detail from this week is that Anna Wintour — seated indoors at a conference table — did not remove her sunglasses while she was telling us that we were about to get canned,” Allison Hussey, a former Pitchfork staff writer, wrote on X. “The indecency we’ve seen from upper management this week is appalling.”

It’s unclear whether Wintour’s reported decision to not remove her eyewear during the meeting was a deliberate fashion choice or, rather, a way to avoid having to look Pitchfork’s employees in the eye. Reps for Condé Nast did not respond to a request for comment.

Condé Nast on Wednesday told staffers that Pitchfork, the music news and criticism site the company bought in 2015, will merge with men’s magazine GQ. First launched in 1996, Pitchfork has become known for effusively praising favored artists while harshly dinging those that provoke its disapproval. The decision “was made after a careful evaluation of Pitchfork’s performance and what we believe is the best path forward for the brand so that our coverage of music can continue to thrive within the company,” Wintour, Condé Nast’s chief content officer and global editorial director of Vogue, wrote in a memo to staff.

Pitchfork staff members being let go include editor-in-chief Puja Patel and features editor Jill Mapes, who commented on X, “after nearly 8 yrs, mass layoffs got me. glad we could spend that time trying to make it a less dude-ish place just for GQ to end up at the helm.”

[From Variety]

The sunglasses detail is appalling, but am I the only one surprised that Wintour would even sit in those meetings? While I know her position gives her power over a lot within Conde Nast, it feels like Wintour would think that it was beneath her, to deal with Pitchfork music critics and such. Maybe that’s why she kept her sunglasses on – she didn’t want those peasants to see her eyes. I don’t know.

Photos courtesy of Avalon Red.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

46 Responses to “Anna Wintour fired most of Pitchfork’s staff while wearing her sunglasses indoors”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Jayne says:

    I don’t know why the detail about the sunglasses is so shocking. I’d expect nothing else from her. It 100% tracks.

    • BeanieBean says:

      Those sunglasses are her thing, much as they were/are for Jack Nicholson.

      • sophie says:

        Anna was talented and motivated.
        but the lies do not suit her…
        and I know she is wearing that wig or theses wigs for so long…
        Please Anna let see…
        no wig and no glasses!!! give us truth and a change!!!!

    • Olivia says:

      It’s shocking because it’s a clear visual representation of abuse of power, privilege and entitlement. For example, no other staff member would ever be allowed to wear sunglasses indoors while at work. Especially not in meetings or when liaising with management. Least of all when addressing Ms Wintour. Can you imagine?

    • Fabiola says:

      She’s always in sunglasses. Not surprised. Also, people need to realize that now anybody can have a YouTube channel and critique music so they need to find other jobs.

    • Elizabeth says:

      I’m hoping someone punched her and she was hiding a giant shiner.

    • StillDouchesOfCambridge says:

      Of course she would not sacrifice her own comfort to tell employees they’re fired. That would be too hard.

    • HillaryIsAlwaysRight says:

      Sunglasses indoors is what women of a certain age and position have the luxury to do after making little trips to the dermatologist and/or plastic surgeon. I live and work in Manhattan. See it all the time.

  2. Seraphina says:

    I do not know how she remains in power being such an ugly person on the inside. She needs to be knocked down off her pedestal to learn how to treat people.

    • Macky says:

      They say she was really really friends with the owner. While he was alive they tried to get rid of her dozens of times but he saved her. Went to bat for her at investor meetings. They did manage to continue to cut her personal budget and gave her more work to do. Once he died they tried to get rid of her again but kept her because they needed a transitional person. I think they also gave her more work to do.

  3. Goldenkatz says:

    The best “Anna Wintour is a diva” story I heard came from Tim Gunn. Something about an elevator being out and her bodyguard carrying her down five flights of stairs! This was almost a decade ago. The lady lives in a rarefied world of peasants and overlords.

    • Brassy Rebel says:

      Is that bodyguard available for a couple of weeks I wonder? We’re getting a new elevator in my building and I live on the third floor. Getting groceries is hell. Car is parked in basement garage. It must be nice to be Anna Wintour. It’s just not nice to be around her.

  4. Chaine says:

    Idk it’s rude to keep them on but at least she personally showed up for the bad news instead of leaving the firings to some luckless HR drone.

    • Matilda says:

      I agree, most of the layoffs these days are handled by HR or the CEO sending a message via Zoom so at least she had the grace to show up and tell them to their face. My boss has been wearing sunglasses indoors all last week because he just had upper lid surgery so that is what I first thought of when I heard this story, perhaps Anna has had her lids done again??

      • Dilettante says:

        Those sunglasses are bifocals – this way no one knows she needs them. See: The September Issue movie

  5. Ginny says:

    It is an appalling situation and I’m not a fan of Anna’s, but I don’t really get why it’s news/a surprise that she kept her sunglasses on…Doesn’t she almost always have them on, regardless of context? They’re her signature. 🤷‍♀️

  6. Brassy Rebel says:

    Maybe she was out drinking the night b4. (sarcasm). But you can count me among the ones surprised she showed up at all.

    • KeKe Swan says:

      I was imagining pink eye!

    • Anon says:

      If Anna Wintour was not taking the sunglasses off out of being disrespectful, then she probably should have and looked them in the eye.

      But here’s an opportunity for a PSA about why I’m not going to judge someone on wearing sunglasses or ask them to explain why or take them off.

      Reasons why:

      A relative of mine has a serious medical condition where they have to wear sunglasses almost all the time. Some people irrationally find it so offensive and others never skip a beat or notice-like they’re regular glasses-and treat my family member totally normally, as it should be.

      A former colleague had eye cancer(!) which was terrible and also had to wear sunglasses a lot. Same kinds of reactions from people.

      From what I’ve observed, it’s a lot of people assuming and / or projecting, including their complicated ideas about sunglasses, in these interactions. Sometimes you can tell it catches someone off guard and you can watch the wheels turn as they realize the person must be wearing the sunglasses for a reason, that may or may not be an eccentricity, probably isn’t their business, and based on how others are treating it as totally normal, may actually be a medical need. Then they just act like it’s totally normal too.

      So if you do see someone wearing them in what you think is an unusual scenario, please have some compassion. Thanks!

  7. Shawna says:

    Really upset. I’ve depended on Pitchfork since 2006. Before Pitchfork, you had to do a really deep dive into the internet or buy expensive niche magazines if you wanted to learn about new indie music. 🙁

  8. Eurydice says:

    It doesn’t look like Variety cares much for Pitchfork – according to them, it hasn’t been reviewing artists fairly.

    As for Wintour, she says she wears sunglasses so people can’t tell what she’s thinking, but she seems so vain that I wonder if she doesn’t have some kind of medical condition.

    • Yup, Me says:

      I wondered the same thing about the medical condition.

    • Dara says:

      Eyelift gone wrong. Or she can’t put on full glam eye makeup every day (it’s hard on older/thin skin) so she wears sunglasses so she won’t be seen with naked eyes.

    • Jaded says:

      She is quoted as saying “[sunglasses are] incredibly useful because you avoid people knowing what you’re thinking about.”

  9. SarahCS says:

    What a powerful way to say ‘let me show you all how little you mean to me’. The fact that leaders like this are enabled is a source of constant frustration to me.

  10. Bumblebee says:

    The lenses look pretty dark with big frames. Could be for blocking out light or covering up something visibly wrong with her eyes. It makes me wonder if there’s a medical problem.

  11. Mary Pester says:

    Sorry if I’m being nasty, but I can’t wait for someone to cut her down to size.

  12. Louise177 says:

    Doesn’t Anna wear sunglasses more often than not? Frankly it’s more surprising that she even showed up to do the firing. Especially when so many people are now being fired over email/zoom or just being locked out of the building.

  13. Leonsmomma says:

    Being part of Conde Nasty in the late ‘80s/early 90s my theory is then she had bags under her eyes and it was a way to hide the plastic surgery to get rid of them and she ended up liking the “mysterious” sunglass look.

  14. B says:

    Wintour is old. She wears large dark sunglasses for the same reason Karl Lagerfeld wore fingerless gloves and very high collars. To hide all the wrinkles and veins.

    She wears these big chunky necklaces in layers and they don’t show up on the high patterned collars of her dresses. It’s a shame, because these are actually famously owned, very expensive, antique (Georgian era) necklaces, and she wears them like they’re cheap resin layering necklaces.

  15. Heather says:

    As someone who wears prescription sunglasses everywhere because I’m light sensitive and also can’t see much beyond 2 ft away, they’re probably the best glasses she has to be able to function outside of home. I doubt it’s more than that.

  16. Anonymous says:

    The sunglasses thing has been going on for like half a century guys (literally). Is anyone shocked? And yeah she’s in on all those big layoff meetings.

  17. Brassy Rebel says:

    Turns out The Devil Also Wears Sunglasses.

    • Deering24 says:

      And this is why I have always regarded that movie as a poisoned apple. 🤮 It’s smartly-written, wonderfully-acted, and looks terrific. And it’s some of Hathaway’s, Streep’s, and Blunt’s best work. But it made bosses like Wintour seem funny and human–and it could be argued it paved the way for society accepting that kind of behavior in rl. We’ve had two decades of bosses/uber-billionaires grinding everyone to dust, and this movie was one of the first to grease the skids. It speaks volumes that there are still IMDB, Rotten Tomatoes, etc., folks who think Priestly is wonderful–and Runaway the perfect place to work. Ugh.

  18. Barnabus says:

    Anna Wintour has ruled Vogue for 40 years. She sits front row at any fashion show in the world and always wears her shades. Those wishing for her downfall? It will never happen. Her fashion legacy is enormous and will headline all future articles about her.

  19. Flamingo says:

    She’s 74, I am not sure if this was an in person meeting or zoom. But besides being her ‘brand’. She is hiding puffy old eyes.

    And not that 74 is old. Anna is just an evil crone that probably has a bathtub full of virgin blood somewhere in the world and a family is missing their daughter.

    • Twin Falls says:

      74 is old. There’s nothing wrong with getting older and eventually being old. The alternative is dead.

  20. laurie says:

    Holy cow that last picture in the blue really shows her age. 😳

  21. Oswin says:

    I feel rude keeping my giant sunglasses on at the doctor when I have a migraine. The nurses dgaf and tell me to keep them on, so I do, but it still feels rude. And that’s when I’m in pain! The tackiness of that woman, my goodness.

  22. Dark Brenda says:

    Many years ago when I was lowly temp at Conde Nast, Wintour got in the elevator with me and straight up looked me up and down. Even through the sunglasses, I could feel her scorn. Mind you, I was in my 20s and broke, and couldn’t afford professional wear other than Old Navy.

    • Jen Graff says:

      years ago I interviewed for an admin job to the Editor in Chief at a high end magazine. I can’t remember which one. But I knew this was a bad fit and a waste of time. It was just a parade of her underlings coming in being more and more condescending to me. I couldn’t wait to get out of there. It wasn’t Anna but someone like her from what I gleaned from the underweight women with bags under their eyes.

      I was like this isn’t for me and just left. I wouldn’t have survived 5 minutes working for Anna if that ever happened (it wouldn’t). I am not chic enough for NYC.

  23. fabulous says:

    I learnt a long time ago that rockers who wear their sunglasses inside are not cool, just old. Looking at you Bono. Anna’s glasses are certainly prescription.

  24. Lau says:

    She seems like the kind of person who likes to see others being miserable.

  25. Melissa says:

    Rolling pitchfork up into GQ just feels like old ideas of “only men like music” but whatever. The folks in charge here seem ridiculous out of touch and nasty to boot