As I said yesterday, I despise the idiotic reflex of “blaming Democrats for every single thing that happens in America.” The people who screamed, cried and threw up over everything Joe Biden and Kamala Harris did and said are the same people who have blamed Democrats and screamed “where’s Kamala?” this year, as Republicans control every lever of government. All of which to say, when you’re in the business of hating Democrats no matter what, then you have zero credibility when the sh-t hits the fan and a handful of Democrats completely screw us over. Which is where we are now. Seven Democratic senators “defected” to give the Republicans a 60-40 vote to end the government shutdown. They needed to get to 60 to avoid a filibuster, the threat of which was literally the only power Democrats had in the shutdown/continuing resolution negotiations. So what did those Dems get after a 41-day shutdown? Absolutely nothing. Worse than nothing.
The Senate passed legislation on Monday night to end the nation’s longest government shutdown, after a critical splinter group of Democrats joined with Republicans and backed a spending package that omitted the chief concession their party had spent weeks demanding.
The 60-to-40 vote, on Day 41 of the shutdown, signaled a break in the gridlock that has shuttered the government for weeks, leaving hundreds of thousands of federal workers furloughed, millions of Americans at risk of losing food assistance and millions more facing air-travel disruptions.
The measure goes next to the House, which is expected to take it up no sooner than Wednesday and where the small Republican margin of control and intense Democratic opposition could make for a close vote. President Trump has indicated that he will sign it.
The breakthrough came after eight senators in the Democratic caucus broke their own party’s blockade of spending legislation Republicans have been trying to pass for weeks to reopen the government, prompting a bitter backlash in their ranks.
They said they had done so after concluding that Republicans were never going to accede to Democrats’ central demand in the shutdown fight — the extension of federal health care subsidies set to expire at the end of the year — while millions of Americans continued to suffer amid the federal closure.
“We had no path forward on health care because the Republicans said, ‘We will not talk about health care with the government shut down,’” said Senator Tim Kaine, Democrat of Virginia. “And we had SNAP beneficiaries and those relying on other important services who were losing benefits because of the shutdown.”
It will still take days to reopen the government. Speaker Mike Johnson on Monday urged House members — who have not held a vote in nearly two months as they took an extended recess during the shutdown — to begin the process of returning to Washington “right now.” At the White House, Mr. Trump said that he approved of the plan. “We’ll be opening up our country very quickly,” he said, calling the package “very good.”
While the legislation omits any mention of the tax credits, Democrats said they would accept an offer by Senator John Thune, Republican of South Dakota and the majority leader, to hold a vote on the issue later this year, when the subsidies are set to expire. But that measure, which would require 60 votes to pass, faces long odds in the Republican-controlled Senate and even less chance of advancing in the House, where Mr. Johnson would be unlikely to bring it up amid widespread opposition in his party.
I’m absolutely disgusted with Tim Kaine, who is one of my senators here in Virginia. “We had no path forward on health care because the Republicans said, ‘We will not talk about health care with the government shut down.’” Did he learn how to negotiate in a clown college?? Weak, stupid, short-sighted, utter cowardice. Tens of millions of Americans voted to reinstall Donald Trump and give him a Republican majority in both chambers of Congress. The Democratic position should have been: “We’re going to watch as Americans get exactly what they voted for.” But, but, but the Republicans wouldn’t talk to us about healthcare! Maybe they would have been more open to negotiations if all of the airports were shut down over Thanksgiving. Instead, Kaine and these defectors capitulated with absolutely NOTHING to show for it.
Photos courtesy of Cover Images.
- United States President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump walk on the South Lawn of the White House before boarding Marine One to fly to Norfolk, Virginia. Unions representing hundreds of thousands of federal workers have asked a US judge to immediately prevent the Trump administration from carrying out mass firings during the government shutdown while they press a legal challenge. Featuring: President Donald Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 05 Oct 2025 Credit: Graeme Sloan/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com
- President Donald Trump speaks with reporters as he prepares to board Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House. The President is embarking on a three nation trip to Asia, where he hopes to sign economic and mineral agreements with US trading partners and meet President Xi Jinping of China. Featuring: President Donald Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 24 Oct 2025 Credit: Francis Chung/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com
- US President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump host a Halloween trick-or-treat event on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, USA, on Thursday, October 30, 2025. Featuring: Donald J. Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 30 Oct 2025 Credit: Aaron Schwartz/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com
- US President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump host a Halloween trick-or-treat event on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, USA, on Thursday, October 30, 2025. Featuring: Donald J. Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 30 Oct 2025 Credit: Aaron Schwartz/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com
- United States President Donald J Trump waves as he walks toward the residence after stepping off Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, USA, 09 November 2025. President Trump is returning from the weekend in Florida with a stop at the Commanders NFL game on the way home. Featuring: Donald J Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 09 Nov 2025 Credit: Shawn Thew/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com
- United States President Donald J Trump walks toward the residence after stepping off Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, USA, 09 November 2025. President Trump is returning from the weekend in Florida with a stop at the Commanders NFL game on the way home. Featuring: Donald J Trump Where: Washington, District of Columbia, United States When: 09 Nov 2025 Credit: Shawn Thew/POOL via CNP/INSTARimages.com


















Interesting perspective by Lawrence O’Donnell on the gains made by the Dems in the bill. Thy didn’t everything, but… all federal workers are to be rehired, back pay for workers. And an increase in SNAP funding.
This aspect was not well reported and was helpful to me. Dump wants to destroy everything President Obama did, that’s why he’s doing this with healthcare marketplace. Kamala warmed up over and over again. Good job voters, you helped the republicans gut healthcare.
Link to Lawerence 👇🏾
https://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/watch/lawrence-with-trump-s-shutdown-ending-dems-are-closer-than-ever-to-forcing-epstein-files-release-251756613516
I was furious at first but like you have seen a few different takes. The republicans were NEVER going to give on healthcare and they don’t care who it hurts, so the dems did what they had to do. But before they caved the republicans are being held responsible in the public eye and many MAGA voters are having buyers remorse over their vote.
The fact that the republicans are not crowing off the rooftops at how they won gives me pause to think that maybe this was a better deal than I originally thought.
Still my 2 senators (1 retiring) from NH were responsible and I will hold them accountable until this plays out in our favor.
Thank you for posting this, it’s good to see and hear a more nuanced take on this cluster.
also not reported is that the new spending bill allows Senators to sue for $500K each over phone searches (making 8 Republican senators, including Marsha Blackburn, immediately eligible)
I am a federal worker who got a RIF notice on 10/10 and I am furious. Everyone suffered for nothing. Believe me, I know how hard it is to go without paychecks, my husband’s severance also stopped because he was a federal employee RIFed earlier this year. But the courts were taking care of us because then shutdown RIFs were especially illegal. We had a terrific case. Also, back pay was already the law, so they’re just playing into the WH narrative that back pay wasn’t guaranteed—it WAS by a law this president signed. So they’re folded for 2 things that were already happening and an empty promise. I say stay angry and let them know that they’ve failed us.
Back pay for federal workers was already the law! trump was just bullsh*tting as per usual when he said that was up for debate. No it was not. It’s been the law since 2019 (it was merely custom before that). And the RIFs were just illegal, absolutely no way those were going to stand. And there’s a contingency fund for SNAP benefits so that they can be paid during a shutdown!! trump was again breaking the law by trying to stop it, then trying to claw back what’s been paid this month.
Democrats held all the cards then folded! I am disgusted, just disgusted.
Some of us don’t have incomes right now because of this. Some of us can’t put food on the table because of the shutdown. I didn’t want those 8 senators to vote the way they did but what I’m NOT going to do as someone who’s spent the last several weeks with zero income scrambling to be able to keep a roof over my head and feed my children is act like they’re traitors for doing so. What I’m not going to do is shift the blame to them rather than where it belongs – the Republicans who drained the SNAP money that was allocated as a stopgap. They have constituents who’ve probably actually been calling them, and that would include those who voted correctly in November.
It was a choice between 20 million without healthcare and 40 million who can’t eat. It was a choice with no good option when Republicans would have been fine keeping this going indefinitely.
And what happens next is it goes back to the House and forces Johnson to open the House to vote on it, which means swearing in Grijalva. That’s not nothing.
I am glad that the government workers are going to get paid – our house has been there and done that in previous shutdowns and I know how idiotic it all feels – and I assign the massive portion of blame to the Republicans, because this is their mess, but I am going to hold ire for the Washington Generals Democratic Party. It is like watching someone hit themselves in the face repeatedly to watch how the Democrats, the party I have voted for for the entirety of my adult life, repeatedly fold without getting anything.
We need to take our party away from the Boomers and Silent Gen who seem content to let the Republicans run the country into the ditch. “We’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas!”
THIS boomer is sure as h*ll not content! But yes, vote some of those dinosaurs out because they clearly have zero backbone.
Well said. The were negotiating with people’s lives. The greatest good for the greatest number.
About that swearing in Grijalva…Johnson’s probably waiting on swearing her in until after Tennessee’s election on December 2nd when there’s a good chance the Republican candidate will win. If that happens, Johnson will swear both in, and that will nullify the 218 needed to release the Epstein Files.
Yep. Why the Dems didn’t make a vote on the Epstein files a demand for reopening the government is beyond me.
Meanwhile, Thune secured a provision in the government funding bill to let senators sue for having their phone records collected without knowledge during Jack Smith’s investigation of Trump’s attempt to subvert the election. Republicans are ALWAYS a step ahead of the Dems and they never, EVER negotiate in good faith.
Yeah, that seat has been held by R for 40 years. And that district was gerrymandered to hell by R’s in 2022 which seems crazy considering how long they have held that district. The special election is to replace the R that retired in July. We need some hard-core stumping in TN and make it about the Epstein files. I agree Kitten, the dems should have demanded the release of the files.
Johnson is not going to do sh*t. He’s already said so.
MrsBanjo I agree with you 💯 percent. The blame should be on the republicans because you’re right it would have gone on a lot longer because they don’t care that you are not receiving a paycheck and that people would starve! I’m sorry you are going through this and I hope the government will open quickly so you and millions of others do not have to suffer!!
Counter-narrative: the Republicans wanted a clean CR; they didn’t get that. They were forced to vote to reverse the RIF’s and guarantee SNAP for a year. And Tim Kaine represents a state with a sh*t ton of federal workers who have been standing in breadlines for over a month. Am I happy with any of this? Absolutely not. But post November, 2024 there are no good options. I blame white people, not Chuck Schumer. Also, the air traffic situation was becoming extremely DANGEROUS.
This is where I’ve come out too. And I’ll admit to being relieved that air travel next week might not be disrupted too much. But I do wonder if the House and Trump will move forward—the shutdown’s not over, right?
Correct, it’s still shutdown.
the community can come together to donate food to support a breadline. what is much harder is coming together to prevent mass medical bankruptcy and preventable death because care is too expensive. there is no fight or solidarity in this country, and there won’t be so long as the GOP and their billionaire owners keeps getting to skate by the consequences of their monstrous greed and finally start facing the pitchforks they’ve earned. the democratic defectors sabotaged the country finally starting to wake up and move in that direction. imo, it was orchestrated behind the scenes when they saw the wind changing. there are too many dems who are owned by the billionaires too. it’s controlled opposition.
Exactly. Yeah it sucks going without a paycheck but you know what also sucks? Facing financial ruin because of a cancer diagnosis. It’s fucking Sophie’s Choice. This vote might be a relief for Fed workers but a whole lot of poor-to-middle class people and a lot of folks over 60 are going to suffer.
Once Dems decided to pick this fight and to make it about healthcare, they should have stayed the course. Wait till the holidays come, flights are cancelled and Republicans are getting calls from their constituents AND their corporate donors. Coming off the major win last Tuesday, Dems had all the momentum. Trump admitted that the shutdown was hurting the Republican party. Dems squandered any leverage they had.
At the very least, get your messaging in order because I have yet to hear one of the eight Dems explain why they did this is an meaningful, coherent way. FFS to quietly drop this shit on a Sunday night just so we can all wake up to a GOP victory dance and MSM headlines of “Dems in disarray”.
Yeah, I’m with Kaiser on this one.
As a 64yo that will go without healthcare, I am personally willing to die rather than children starve.
👏
Yes. We will be right back here soon, but without the pressure of no thanksgiving turkey, no money for Black Friday, and no 12 hour airport waits to put pressure on the GOP.
I’m disgusted with the Democratic Party and I’m a lifelong member. They don’t care about us either, at the end of the day.
It was always going to come down to the lesser of two evils! The republicans were never ever going to stop!! We got people getting their paychecks back and back pay and an increase in snap!! The democrats did what they could to get the government going again and people fed. STOP THE IN FIGHTING OF THE DEMOCRATS THAT WILL NOT HELP!! As I said they took the lesser of the two evils because those were the only choices!!!
Community cannot come together to feed OVER FORTY MILLION PEOPLE. No community has that ability to carry the number of people in their areas on that scale that we are seeing in need. Because it’s not just the 40m on SNAP. It’s also the federal workers with NO MONEY TO BUY FOOD. It’s the military who are now left with the likelihood that their commissaries – grocery stores will be shut down. This is not clean CR. Snap funds get increased. People get their goddamn paychecks.
They didn’t remove the ACA. They removed the subsidies Biden/Harris got in last year.
This conspiracy bullshit needs to fucking stop.
As someone who “got [my] goddamn paycheck,” please don’t speak for me. Every fed I know is furious about this. Don’t buy into the BS about us not getting back pay, we were all in this together for the greater good, everyone but our elected representatives. Not to mention the hard work to win back young people culminating in last week’s elections being squandered as those folks were betrayed.
Absolutely. Those who were not going to lose the roofs over their heads or stand in line hoping for a bare subsistence amount of food for their children should get off their keyboard high ground. The health care fight will continue. Starving children would just make the healthcare fight worse as the children’s health status worsen.
The DAY leading up to the dems defecting to end the shutdown, the headlines were about Trump going to court to try to force states that funded SNAP on their own into taking the money back from the people who received it while the administration was fighting in court to fight the order that they fully fund SNAP because not releasing those funds was illegal. Cartoonishly evil and unjustifiable and illegal doesn’t begin to describe the breadth of it, and the majority was finally, FINALLY waking up to reality. Then the dems flushed it all away that night. Don’t even start calling this a bullshit conspiracy.
Nobody is saying they removed the ACA but you’re either willfully ignorant, naïve or not paying attention if you don’t think people will die from the removal of these subsidies. I have a friend in VT who will go from paying *nothing* to $800 a month!!!! She makes $38K a year. She won’t be able to pay for insurance and she has any number of health issues. It’s simply cruel for the richest country in the world to force people to choose between paying a mortgage and paying for healthcare. You’re being incredibly dismissive and cavalier about something that will harm so many people like DAMN.
@Tina-People WILL loose the roof over their head if they have to choose between life-saving healthcare and paying for housing. That’s the whole point. I’m happy if you’re well off enough to not have to worry about being in that position but please understand that many people are not.
@Anonymous-thanks for fighting the good fight. Fed workers put up with a ton of shit only to have eight Dems fold like a chair in the end. Incredibly disappointing.
Agree. I am ready to go back to my job (although my work is being destroyed) and collect my goddam check(S) so I can pay my mortgage, sleep at night, take my cats to the vet and perhaps help others. I’ve just turned down a charity because I can barely feed myself.
I do not appreciate that many people did not care about airport staff not being able to feed their families until it became an inconvenience.
And this is not over yet, it is just a respite until late January.
I’m not willing to bash the Dems (and Independent) who agreed to end the shutdown. All of them saw that regular people were being badly hurt, especially with the SNAP cuts, and they knew that the Rs were not going to give in. the point being-Republicans do not care about hurting people, even their own voters. and the air traffic stuff going into Thanksgiving season would have been a total nightmare, blamed on Democrats.
but the ACA subsidies will continue to be an issue for next year. and I really can’t believe that Trump demanded that states NOT stopgap the SNAP cuts. made it clear he doesn’t care if he’s starving kids.
I want every penny back and every hour I’ve spent restored to me from trying to get these clowns elected. What a freaking waste of time and effort these people are. I place the fact that DJT is even sitting in the White House at all squarely at the feet of Joe Biden, Merrick Garland, Chuck Schumer, Nancy Pelosi, Hakeem Jeffries, and all the rest. Eff them all the way to FU-Town. They all sat there on Inauguration Day and let this murderous madman and his villainous gang of Nazis, pedophiles, and miscreants takeover this country knowing that they planned to destroy democracy, install a dictatorship, all while starving citizens and taking away access to healthcare. They didn’t then and haven’t yet publicly encouraged or supported ANY of the protests or protest organizers.
I want every single penny and hour of my life back that I wasted on these people. Anger doesn’t even begin to describe how I feel right now. The last 10 years of fighting this rise of fascism feel like a big, fat waste.
I understand your anger. For the first time in my life I have been sincerely and deeply frightened for my country. Frightened by not just this shutdown, but by the clown show that has devolved into a fascist state. I will continue to work to get every Republican possible defeated from dog catchers and sheriffs, to senators and representatives. Here in Texas we have to deal with the fact that not only do we have a Trump-induced migraine in Washington, but an Abbott-induced one here. I will work against all of them. I know you are angry, and I understand why, but we can’t afford to give up. We have to do our best to create change. We have to do our best to get rid of the monsters who don’t care about their constituents, the Constitution, and the law. Fuck ‘em.
RESIST
PERSIST
UNITE!!!
I feel this so much. It kills me because they’ll all go out there and tell us we need to fight even as they refuse to fight for us.
@ Giddy-Yeah we need to vote in EVERY. SINGLE. ELECTION. We had a terrible city council election here in my town last Tuesday where the shitty conservatives swept the whole thing. Turns out only 25% of my town of 20K voted 🙁
Vote, organize, protest, and campaign for Dems that share your vision. It’s become crystal clear that we have to do it on our own because the politicians aren’t gonna save us.
Disappointing, to say the least.
While I am extremely upset over healthcare subsidies, I also know that an overwhelming number of children were going to starve without SNAP. The 65% of the already inadequate allotment for November was a joke. You have to realize that not all areas have food banks. Those that do already help SNAP families by supplementing their end of month needs. And in my area (extreme Red State), assistance from “good Christian churches” is laughable. Anyone who was going to sit down to a typical Thanksgiving table should stop and think. I have been appalled by social media commentary over the last 2 weeks. MAGAs that post fictional stories about SNAP recipients. Other clueless people that advise them to get a flat of rice on Amazon. I have been heartbroken and trying to figure out how to have a Thanksgiving table for SNAP families in my neighborhood but on Social Security my funds are extremely limited. Everyone needs to educate themselves on the realities of life for SNAP families.
Anyone who wants to feel better (albeit temporarily but sometimes little victories are all we need to carry us), find and watch the video of Jasmine Crockett speaking in Houston before she introduces Gavin Newsom. Now, he isn’t my first choice for the 2028 race, but she has energy, fire and guts.
Does anyone else have the feeling that this is all the biggest money laundering scheme in the history of the world?
trump & his cabinet? yes.
When whispers of this first came out last week, I messaged my CA Dem senators. I pleaded with them to hold the line. Did No Kings rally with 7+million + recent election victories mean nothing to my party?
When it looked more and more possible this weekend, I messaged that we’re not fooled by the expendables actually voting Yes + that every Democrat who didn’t filibuster to avoid this vote is responsible for its outcome.
By this morning, my message just said that we feel betrayed and very angry. This does less than nothing to reassure those whose health insurance is going to skyrocket. We’re going to pay attention to who received donations from the airlines + big box stores, fast food joints dependent on SNAP money. Etc.
Midday, messaged that the least they could do now is coordinate decent messaging that didn’t make it sound like Democrats are losers and the whole shut down is our fault, etc.
I hate my Party.
They can make all the excuses they want, but there is no silver lining. We all lose. The people lose. Forty million starved because the rich see their lives as pawns in a game. Twenty million people will now likely lose their insurance, with an estimated 50K more dying per year, not to mention the countless it’ll bankrupt and force to choose between their health and being able to put food on the table. And we all get to squabble over the scraps while the rich made certain they could enjoy their Thanksgiving feasts without the inconvenience of bad flights.
And now that they now they can get away with it, they’ll do it again and again. The cruelty is normalized now.