Libel suit against John Grisham dismissed


A few weeks ago I read John Grisham’s amazing and true account of the wrongful conviction of two men in a 1982 murder in Oklahoma. Grisham’s book The Innocent Man is so compelling, and so well told, that I didn’t go to bed until 3 or 4 the first time I opened it and pretty much read it in one sitting.

Spoilers for Grisham’s book ahead
The king of legal thrillers paints a dismal picture of the police department in Ada, Oklahoma, which systematically went after two men for the murder of a cocktail waitress who had little or no connection to the woman. Evidence was scant and focused on a “dream confession” that was elicited after hours of unrelenting questioning. One of the convicted men, a schizophrenic former minor league baseball player, spent over a decade languishing on death row while his friend, who worked as a science teacher, was in jail for life without parole. Both were freed through DNA evidence and the work of The Innocence Project under Barry Scheck and successfully sued the city and the state for an undisclosed amount, thought to be in the millions. The man who committed the crime turned out to be a local drug dealer who was supplying members of the police force. He was eventually convicted on DNA and is in jail for life without parole.

The thing is, this was the third false conviction from the Ada police department based on a coerced confession. An earlier book by journalist Robert Mayer, The Dreams of Ada, detailed the incredible wrongful convictions of three other men for two separate murder cases.

It’s not surprising that a defamation lawsuit by the county against John Grisham and two other writers of books about the gross miscarriages of justice, Robert Mayer and wrongfully convicted Dennis Fritz, were thrown out by a federal judge yesterday:

A federal judge has dismissed a libel lawsuit filed against best-selling author John Grisham and two other writers over books they wrote about the wrongful conviction of two men in a 1982 murder.

The lawsuit was filed last year by former Pontotoc County District Attorney Bill Peterson, former Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation investigator Gary Rogers and Melvin Hett, a state criminalist. All three helped win the original convictions in the slaying of cocktail waitress Debbie Sue Carter.

The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants conspired to commit libel, generate publicity for themselves by placing the plaintiffs in a false light and intentionally inflicted emotional distress.

But U.S. District Judge Ronald White rejected those claims in his ruling Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Oklahoma.

The two men initially convicted in the slaying _ Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz _ were later cleared by DNA evidence and freed after 12 years in prison.

A key witness for the prosecution, Glen Gore, was later linked to the crime by DNA, found guilty of the murder and sentenced to life in prison.

In his ruling, the judge wrote that it was important to be able to analyze and criticize the judicial system “so that past mistakes do not become future ones.”

“The wrongful convictions of Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz must be discussed openly and with great vigor,” White wrote.

[From AP as found on Huffington Post]

I’ve read most of Grisham’s books and while some of them aren’t as well told as others – The Appeal left me scratching my head – most of them are very good reads. The Innocent Man is a real page-turner, though, and you can see how a judge would side with Grisham after seeing the facts behind that amazing true story.

John Grisham is shown winning a Lifetime Achievement Award at the Galaxy British Book Awards in London on 3/28/07. Credit: Stephanie Methven / WENN

 

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

14 Responses to “Libel suit against John Grisham dismissed”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Kaiser says:

    Yeah, I read Grisham books in one sitting too – I can never remember the names of the ones I read, though. Which one is The Appeal?

    Haven’t read The Innocent Man, but I’ll read it now. Recently read The Last Juror and thought it was one of Grisham’s best.

    Also, this reminds me of the story of Rubin Carter. Blech – our legal system is screwed.

  2. Syko says:

    Here comes the story of The Hurricane…

    OK, OK, I’ll stop singing.

    I read this book and was appalled that this sort of thing happens – and apparently happens a lot in Ada, OK. It was a pitiful story of a life wasted and manipulated.

    Just finished Grisham’s “Playing for Pizza”. I am really liking his non-legal stuff more and more.

  3. Kaiser says:

    @Syko – “And it won’t be over ’til they clear his name…”

    Man, I love that whole Dylan album – “Isis” is my fave, how about you?

  4. Baholicious says:

    I recall reading some years ago that Woody Harrelson was going to be cast to play the lawyer Jake Briggance in A Time to Kill however, when Grisham saw Harrelson in Natural Born Killers he flipped and said no way was he having WH in the picture. I’m assuming he had some kind of creative control for this to fly because Harrelson didn’t happen and Matthew McConaughey got the part instead.

    When Harrelson was asked how he felt about it, he said something to the effect of “somebody should tell Mr. Grisham it’s called acting.”

  5. Baholicious says:

    Oh, P.S. is it just me or does he resemble John Lithgow?

  6. GirlyGirl says:

    Yeah he kinda looks like a mix between John Lithgow and Anthony Hopkins!

  7. kate says:

    grisham he is to writing what mc donalds is to food: fast, cheap and badly done. his books are like romance novels, just substitute legal terms for “throbbing manhood”.

  8. Lauri says:

    Please don’t compare this to Carter. Carter was most definitely guilty of triple murder. There is no question of his guilt.

  9. Syko says:

    Kaiser – love the whole thing, but lean toward “One More Cup of Coffee” and “Romance in Durango”.

    Got his new album on pre-order at Amazon, it comes out in October.

  10. Kaiser says:

    @Syko – “One More Cup of Coffee” is one of the sexiest songs ever. Didn’t know about his new album… still in love with Time Out of Mind – I listen to it all the time.

    @Lauri – You’re kidding, right? 8O

  11. Syko says:

    Oddly enough, there does seem to be a question of Rubin Carter’s guilt, since his conviction was overturned, he was retried and convicted and again the conviction overturned. Legally he is not guilty.

    I love “Time Out of Mind” too, and can listen to it for hours. He’s had another one out since then, “Love and Theft”, not as dark or depressed as TOOM and also not as good, IMHO. I’m anxious to see what the next one’s going to be. Favorites on “Time Out of Mind” – “Trying to Get to Heaven” and “Highlands”.

  12. Kaiser says:

    @Syko – I have Love & Theft, but I rarely listen to it. But TOOM is AMAZING. Love “Not Dark Yet” – one of his most beautiful songs.

  13. Dean says:

    I have read all his books. Somehow the last few books just dont have the same style as his earlier ones.

  14. I have been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or blog posts in this kind of space . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this web site. Reading this info So i’m glad to convey that I’ve a very excellent uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed. I so much surely will make sure to don’t fail to remember this website and provides it a glance a relentless basis.