Justin Theroux vs. Brad Pitt: who’s the better, cooler dude?

gq1

I just got finished writing about that incredibly stupid OK! Magazine “Bride Wars” cover story, which pitted Angelina Jolie and Jennifer Aniston against each other because SEVEN YEARS LATER it’s still happening every damn week. So I thought I would take one for the team and pit the boys against each other. Justin Theroux and Brad Pitt have dueling interviews/photo shoots today. First, Justin Theroux appears in a GQ feature in which his chest hair is rippling in the wind because he’s channeling Al Pacino in Serpico. Er… thoughts? I know some of you like Theroux, and he’s definitely better than many of Jennifer’s boyfriends, but DO NOT date a guy who would ever channel Al Pacino in a photo shoot unless you are actually dating Al Pacino. I don’t care if it’s for GQ. I don’t care if the guy is totally super-cool. It’s really UNcool, okay? You can read Justin’s GQ interview here and an excerpt is below.

Justin Theroux on European roads: “it’s great, it’s like riding on carpet… Asphalt carpet.”

He has a “dork voice”: He drops words like “funnily” and “oomph” and “beeswax figurines.” He talks about his personal soundtrack—”If I’m in scenic country, a little Nouvelle Vague on the iPod.”

On his beard: “You establish all sorts of mannerisms with [a beard]. Like when you’re bored, you can feather your mustache.” And how did women respond to it? Women such as Aniston? “Certain chicks dig it; certain chicks don’t.” A few days after our photo shoot, the beard is gone.

[From GQ]

Hipster douche. That’s what he seems like to me. Like he’s trying too hard, like he’s desperate to keep his hipster cred while dating tabloid-darling and publicist-maintained Jennifer Aniston. Now I’m also starting to wonder if he’s dating Jennifer for some kind of ironic, hipster reason. Like, this relationship might be a James Franco-esque art project for Theroux.

gq3

gq2

On to Brad Pitt – he covers the new issue of Entertainment Weekly, and here are some highlights:

ew1

On producers wanting him to start in TV: “You know, when I first started, they were trying to get me into sitcoms — I think because I had that kind of Wonder Bread look and my hair always went into place. I kept saying, ‘I’m not good at sitcoms. I don’t know how to do that. . . . But that [his Friends cameo] was a little bit later, and I like those guys. They’re a great bunch of guys. The movies I loved were a complete 180 from situation comedy, and that’s what I wanted to head towards.”

On winning Sexiest Man Alive: “Well, they’re not saying you’re the Biggest A–hole, you know? When you get older, you realize it’s just for fun. Clooney and I were able to have fun with it later. But in some ways, I’m still a kid from Missouri and Oklahoma, and I’m trying to find my way. By the way, we’re only talking about a blip. I didn’t spend much time thinking about it.”

On Mr. & Mrs. Smith: “A husband and wife who actually want to kill each other — I thought that was a launching pad for something really fun and vibrant. Again, that was something we were developing as we were going along, and Angie’s a great partner in that. We work really well together. We had some good workshops beforehand. Had some good laughs and ideas. That was just a great collaboration that turned into a greater collaboration.”

On his and Angelina’s rule not to work while the other is: “We should be doing them together — that’s what we should be doing. We should be doing everything together, and then we could work less. We could have more time off.”

[From EW/Pop Sugar]

Now, there’s some douche in this one too, trust me. But I think Brad has come a long way, and during most interviews, I get the feeling that Brad just flips on his “Brad the Professional” switch and does his shtick. Basically, I find Brad WAY hotter. His hair, though… it’s grown out from the “hot” phase and now he just reminds me of Tom Brady.

Oh, and I can’t find Brad’s Parade interview anywhere. It’s possible Wonderwall just jumped the gun and released their excerpts too early. I’ll post it when the story comes out.

wenn5717187

wenn3503314

Photos courtesy of GQ, Just Jared, WENN.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

151 Responses to “Justin Theroux vs. Brad Pitt: who’s the better, cooler dude?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. bite me says:

    patiently wait for the parade interview 🙂

  2. Eve says:

    Answer:

    Pitt — hotter, better and cooler by association (with The Jolie).

    P.S.: That first picture (of Theroux) is f*cking ridiculous.

  3. Ell says:

    If you going to pit two people against each other make it fair, don’t put 3 pics of one in character and the other not.

    I’m not going to vote, it’s obvious where this is all leading to.

  4. original kate says:

    well now, let me see…the brangeloonies will say brad’s better and jen is a whiner, and the jen-hens will say justin’s better and angelina’s a slut.

    there. can we move on now?

  5. ladybert62 says:

    I dont like either one of them.

    At least, Justin doesn’t look like a homeless drunk living on the streets which is what Pitt usually looks like.

    Other than that, I cant think of anything positive to say about Justin –

    I get strange vibrations from him (as we used to say in the 60’s)!!

  6. olala says:

    Pitt is trying so hard to come across as cool, always has. The guy has no personality and is nothing but product of Hollywood agents and publicists. Don’t care about that other hipster dude either.He looks like he stepped out of a Village People music video.

  7. marge says:

    Brad all the way!!!!

  8. Calli Pygian says:

    I don’t think I could care any less about what celebrities say. My only interest is their physical appeal. After all, I am never going to be dating them, or even meet them, FFS.

    That said, I am natural blonde and have ALWAYS preferred dark haired/skinned men.
    I think biologically, that’s pretty standard, you know- for purposes of genetic diversity.

    Ergo, my opinion is that Theroux is waaaay hotter than the boy-next-door.

  9. bb3 says:

    brad of course
    justin is a douche midget

  10. John Wayne Lives says:

    The hipster douche had to date Miss Needy to get a GQ cover. Lol.
    Brad worked for his. Brad wins 🙂
    And Brad is still soooo hot. Oh man, brady hair and all. And for the record, I wish he would grow it even longer again. Like “Legends of the Fall” long. I love the long haireds 🙂

  11. bite me says:

    geez this a tough one… i like justin hat in the first picture… and bradley really knows how to wear a suit

  12. Pomona says:

    Brad Pitt as Tyler Durden is cooler than real-life Justin and any character he’ll ever play

  13. Mia says:

    Hipster Douche indeed.

    Brad is Brad. He looks good. He sounds happy and content in his life and with his career.

  14. kas says:

    It’s good to see Theroux possesses another look besides Hipster Sqiggy, but he just reeks of trying to hard.

  15. Sillyone says:

    Justin looks gross every time I see him. I do hate Brad’s “Tom Brady’s hair” it’s nasty, when I seen Brady the other night playing I yelled at the tv get a hair cut you slob. To me Brad is like a fine wine he gets better with age.

  16. jen says:

    Can I vote for neither?

  17. alex says:

    Brad Pitt

  18. Julie says:

    Brad all the way!!!

  19. Sue says:

    Pitt is hotter. Is he growing his hair out for a role? If not, then cut it, dude!

  20. Jenni says:

    Pitt is hasbeen. He will never get Oscar or any important award. His pretty face is gone. He is old and unattractive and boring as hell. He stucks with Angelina and benetton army forever.

  21. spinner says:

    They are both sexy in their own right. However, I find Justin more intriguing & he seems more intelligent.

  22. tracking says:

    They both come across as hyper-aware of image and trying too hard. But they’re celebrities, is this surprising? Justin seems like a quirky guy, so his interview is interesting in that sense. Brad’s is more predictable, but at least this time, it’s not filled with
    “You know, man”, “okay, man”s ad nauseam.

  23. sandy#1 says:

    really? are you kidding? lol you may not have heard of this guy, had he not dated brad’s left overs, the fact that he gets mention at all is because of brad, lol nothing against justin, he’s a smart opportunist, i give him credit for that, brad does not have anything to prove, we should never compare these two, it’s like comparing ja and Angelina, lol, people are still pissed at brad for dumping the wannabe, air head so….

  24. mln76 says:

    Brad Pitt is Tyler Durden and an icon in his own right he didn’t get a pictorial in a magazine because his girlfriend bought him one as part of the contract .

  25. tapioca says:

    Justin Theroux – mostly because Brad only ever had “hot” going for him and that ship has l-o-n-g sailed.

    Plus JT played the evil DJ in Zoolander – a cinematic tour de force in THE seminal male-modeling movie of the early noughties, which renders him cool forever.

  26. Munkey says:

    Holy sh*t, that first photo of Justin is too hysterical for words! As for Brad, I’ve enjoyed some of his movies, but he’s always been a little too pretty for my tastes. So, I vote for “none of the above.”

  27. Samigirl says:

    I think Brad seems way more chill…of course, that could come with age. To me, Justin seems incredibly anal. Trying too hard Hipster Douche actually kind of fits him perfectly. He’s trying to be what everyone else thinks is cool. Brad is his own person. And I love that about him.

  28. The Original Ashley says:

    I’m going to go with Theroux (love that name) on this one.

    The thing about Theroux is that he’s always been this indie, cool NYer. He didn’t just start doing it to be cool.

    Pitt on the otherhand… I’m still trying to figure out who the hell Brad Pitt is. He transforms into whatever his girlfriend/wife at the time wants him to be. It’s kind of creepy actually.

    I also think Theroux is more Angie’s type.

  29. mymy says:

    One thing is certain. Jen has not progressed. And she still has terrible taste in men. The vanity and trying to hard attraction must be a hard thing to get over. This is what she has been waiting for? Sad just sad.I so get a phony vibe.She sure has a type

  30. layla says:

    Brad – No contest.

    Justin – too much try.

  31. Canuck says:

    Pitt never did it for me, he’s a bit too “Ken doll” for my tastes. Justin is hot in a nasty possibly slightly psycho way, but only without the facial hair. Although I suspect that it might be way more fun to bed nasty, slightly psycho than a Ken doll.

  32. alili says:

    “Like, this relationship might be a James Franco-esque art project for Theroux.”

    I laughed really hard at that one !!! And I wish this was true, oh yes I do, so, so much !!!

  33. Iggles says:

    @ mln76:
    “Brad Pitt is Tyler Durden and an icon in his own right he didn’t get a pictorial in a magazine because his girlfriend bought him one as part of the contract .”

    A thousand times YES!

    That says it all 😉

  34. sassenach says:

    Brad Pitt all day everyday. PLEASE do not post the Parade interview because the comments will be INSANE! Justin is a fake hipster douche. Yeah, he wrote Iron Man 2 but it was not a good script and many felt that it had too many subplots and was discombobulated. He talks all of this crap about Tom Hanks and it looks as if he is desperately trying to follow in his footsteps.

  35. lambchops says:

    Both douches. Can you imagine being with either one of these dumb dumbs? Both are one enchilada short a deluxe dinner.

  36. mln76 says:

    Oh and what exactly is Justin promoting? Seems like Huvane is getting Aniston some Clooney like powers in pushing the boyfriend out there. I can’t wait to see what’ll happen if Brad gets nominated.

  37. what says:

    Brad Pitt aged very badly and he needs to bring up OLD stuff to get attention for his Oscar Campaign.
    http://www.joliepittstop.com/gallery/2011/0910-b-mb-portrait-tiff/10.jpg

  38. bite me says:

    actually Justin is in GQ to promote wanderlust which has been pushed back to February… u know the movie that brought him and aniston together 🙂

  39. Hmmmm says:

    Brad’s still got it! Hot, hot, hot! He is so sexy! Angelina Jolie is a lucky woman.

    As for Justin …. Ewww He is so unattractive in looks and his personality seems dull, moody, and boring. Jennifer must be desperate is all I can say about that relationship.

  40. Cleo says:

    Justin Theroux is at his best when he is really skinny and sleek like an EEL as he was in American Psycho. I’m no fan of the beard!

  41. Toe says:

    Brad Pitt!!
    Actually there no comparing these 2.
    I just saw Legends of the Fall yesterday. Watching A River runs through it now…

  42. Julia says:

    Brad Pitt is Brad Pitt. No offence but when you reach that level of iconic status it’s difficult for anyone to measure up. Just like marlon Brando was still Brando at 80 with his fat self.

    Plus I am sorry but if Brad is criticised for aging badly (he is 8 years his senior), what can we say about justin, 40, baldy with an aging neck and his weird midget like body proportions ?

    Justin is 40, the age of Pitt during Mr & Mrs Smith. I know who is aging more badly and it ain’t Pitt when you compare them at the same age…

    I personally like Justin face but not his body at all and I despise his clothes, all of them. A great part of his appeal and rise in the attractive factor is all related to his betterhalf and will go down immidiately if they ever stop dating.

    The only guy that Aniston dated after Brad that was handsome body and face wise was the model Paul Sculffor.

  43. lolas says:

    If the pictures of Justin were just of some guy who didn’t give off a vibe of dating an A lister purely in the hopes of becoming one himself (and I’m not saying he is doing that, he just has that vibe about him at least on the gossip sites), I would say Justin is TOTALLY hotter. I never saw the big deal with Brad Pitt, he’s so vanilla. I’d sooner date Angelina.

  44. Thea says:

    I like Justin physically as I like dark haired men. Brad ia a hottie but..like someone said he always transforms into the woman he is with. I would like to see the real Brad not the “brand” Brad.

  45. RobN says:

    I don’t think that JT is a douche but whomever did the writing for that article is trying way too hard. I think that JT is getting blamed for some pretty wonky writing.

    I’ve never gotten the Brad thing. He went from too pretty to too unwashed with nothing inbetween.

  46. mln76 says:

    @bite me Paul Rudd is the lead of Wanderlust. Please lets not kid ourselves about why he’s on the cover.

  47. Joanna says:

    Brad all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111

  48. bite me says:

    but thats the thing justin in not on the cover, he is featured inside..Leonardo is the coverboy for the october issue of GQ

  49. sassenach says:

    @mln JT is NOT on the cover!! If Chris was still the West Coast editor he would be on the cover but it looks like Chris could only use his contacts to get him a small article inside.

  50. sharylmj says:

    Justin = gross…. Brad = H. O. T. !!!

  51. CaramelKiss says:

    Clearly, the question wasn’t asked without a predisposed point of view. Can you shove Brad down our throats any further? Damn, Justin doesn’t a chance with all of your judgemental comments. IJS. I really don’t give two shits either way.

  52. Happy21 says:

    I’m on the fence. Brad is hot – pure & simple but Justin has got something real sexy about him. Can’t fault Justin for how GQ wanted to shoot him.

    Hotness all around if you ask me!

  53. mln76 says:

    @sassenach thanks for the clarification.

  54. loveyourwork says:

    THEROUX FOR THE WIN!

  55. miss_bhaven says:

    Ang and Justin would make a better, bad ass couple.

  56. lola says:

    Brad never did it for me, he’s like a wood sprite. Who wants to do a wood sprite.

    Justin T. seems a little sketchy and dirty, but at least he’s not a wood sprite. He’s kinda hot in a douchey way even.

  57. Lili says:

    I’m with Layla..

    No contest – BRAD !!!! He’s been at the top of the list since his Thelma and Louise days. And he looks as good as ever..growing older without looking jacked up

    Justin – too much try !!! ‘Hipster douche’ just about sums it up. He may spend as much time in front of the mirror as Jen..can you imagine?

  58. lisa says:

    Brad is always for me.. always.. forever.

    I think Justin is a hot guy too. Not my type.. too short sorry.. but I think he has an unique style.

    the thing I don’t understand is why is he being compared to Brad Pitt. are they even in the same category as far as fame or what ever.. Or is it because of Jennifer. If that is the case why not John Mayer or Vince Vaughn.. those men are more current than an almost 7 year old relationship.

    This is beyond silly. Every woman is compared to Angie or guys to Brad.. to me that makes them a standard.. if that is not the case then put some other names up there.

    Brad as I said is 20+ years of always.. When Justin and others are at that point then we can talk. Until then..not a question at all.

  59. loveyourwork says:

    He’s totally channelling Indiana Jones – Raider’s of the Found Hipster

    he looks like you’d hear his voice, all cigarette-rasp and rum, in your ear as he takes you from behind. I LOVE IT!

  60. Now if there was a *look at me I’m finally famous,because of my girlfriend’award,Well that would be Justin ALL the way…

  61. truthSF says:

    I’d take Tyler Durden any day, anytime, anywhere. If a man can make me c.u.m just playing a character onscreen, it’s a WWWIIIIIINNNNNNN for me.

  62. curleque says:

    Pitt is the original hipster douche.

  63. olivia says:

    according to imdb:
    Justin – 5’10” (1.78 m)
    Brad – 5’11” (1.80 m)

  64. SLM says:

    I wonder if Theroux is not a pretty decent guy – or at least fairly likable & moderately talented. He has been around for years, popping up in pretty different circles (he is the only non-regular guy I can recall being in TWO Sex and the City episodes), memorable bit characters in cult movies like Romy and Michelle’s, an arc of Parks and Rec episodes, writing Tropic Thunder and Iron Man 2. I don’t know if you get to work so widely if you are {not A level and} too much of a douche.

    I’ve always thought Brad was very pretty, but both are too petite for my taste. Tiny fellas.

  65. Also,I just can’t find a man who *bitched slapped* Tom Hanks attractive.Oops,almost forgot the biggest turnoff for me: Man hugging terry richardson.

  66. Chloe says:

    sidenote: Actually, roads in many European countries are pretty bad, unless you’re lucky to live and drive in Germany (and, possibly, Scandinavia). So I’m calling bs on the asphalt carpet, Justin

  67. Susan O. says:

    Brad Pitt by far…no contest

  68. sassenach says:

    @ Olivia: IMDB is just as bad as wiki for having wrong info. There is no way that Justin is 5′10″. He is barely taller than Aniston and has incredibly short legs.

  69. Goofpuff says:

    Brad Pitt is sexier, hotter, more bad ass. Justin is still trying too hard and Brad has been there/done that and doesn’t care anymore. Justin seems like he still needs to grow up.

  70. jb says:

    Justin alllll the waaayyyyy!!! Super hot!

  71. layla says:

    If a guy says he’s 5-10/5-11 guaranteed his closer to 5-8/5-9.

    Anyone who’s dated knows this! 😉

  72. Freya says:

    Brad!

  73. say what says:

    If Justin wasn’t dating Jen, there would be no contest. Period. Brad is old, wrinkly, and has no personality.
    “Thelma and Louise” happened 1000 years ago so it’s time to put it to rest as a testament of his good looks.
    If Justin hooked up with Jen to get his ratings up, then we should say Jolie hooked up with Pitt fot the same thing

  74. Cheyenne says:

    @Kaiser: I think Theroux hooked up with Aniston to kick-start his stalled career. She may be totally into him but I have a feeling he’s totally using her.

  75. Gossip-ho says:

    Justin for me. He has always been artsy and no he is not pretentious like James Franco as u say.

  76. Cheyenne says:

    @say what: You’re completely off the mark, as per usual. Jolie was already an Oscar-winning actor before she ever met Brad. She didn’t need him to boost her career. Theroux, OTOH, was Justin Who? before he became Aniston’s boy-toy.

  77. mzjask says:

    still. Justin. in my book. brad is hott and all but its like; ok, enough already you have like 10 kids.. kinda ruins the fantasy for me.
    always loved me a bad boy and drunk irish gingers arent the only hotties in the world, ladies 😉

  78. Chloe says:

    @say what

    there is so much wrong with your comment that I don’t know where to start. I guess we’ll just have to politely disagree 🙂

  79. Phoenix says:

    Brad of course. Justin is very unattractive and gross and looks skeevy and dirty and just….um, I don’t quite know how to word it, but someone who would be preying on women in parking lots very late at night. He even looks a bit evil and untrustworthy. I much prefer Brad shaven but at least he doesn’t look like a serial killer and he has a kind face.

  80. 4Real says:

    Brad FTW!

  81. Esmom says:

    @Miss Bhaven (great name btw), ITA. From an image point of view, Angie and JT seem like a better match. It’s almost like Jen tried to find an equivalent to Angie.

  82. Canuck says:

    @Chloe: the toll highways in France are also like asphalt carpets. The “Route National” ones, not so much.

    @Cheyenne: His career isn’t stalled. Seems to me that Tom Cruise is currently filming something he wrote. Just because his career doesn’t consist solely of being in front of the camera, doesn’t mean that he doesn’t have one.

  83. say what says:

    Why are we even comparing these two? Let’s compare Pitt to an actor his age, similar financial status and acomplishments. Then, let’s compare Justin to someone his age etc.
    Makes more sense, doesn’t it?

  84. nan says:

    Bobblehead with the massive head??? Are you serious? LOL

  85. Cheyenne says:

    @Canuck: If his career was where he wanted it to be, he wouldn’t have hooked up with Aniston. He needed the exposure and she provided it.

  86. JaneWonderfalls says:

    Brad is a pompous a-hole since he’s courting Jolie! Him and Jolie look like my grand parents old and haggered looking.

  87. Toe says:

    Pitt’s spotlight is so bright that even an A-lister like buddy and Ocean’s co-star George Clooney says he stands in his shadow.

    Fans “step over you to get to him,” Clooney says. While in Turkey for the opening of Ocean’s Eleven, Clooney walked in first, and “everyone starts screaming, ‘George!’ I said, ‘Hey, Brad Pitt!’ ” The crowd turned and swarmed his friend. “I was his bodyguard at that point,” Clooney says.

    Clooney has only one bone to pick, namely Pitt’s height: “He’s tall. He’s like 6-1. It’s irritating.” At 5-foot-11, Clooney says, he looks like “the little guy.”

    Then there’s his lantern-jawed, lifeguard-cum-military-man looks, including those eyes that are as blue as the Aegean Sea.

    “He’s a little ugly,” Clooney deadpans. “He got hit with an ugly stick.” Pitt, who’s a couple of years younger than Clooney, “looks a decade younger than me. He’s sort of a genetic freak.”

    http://www.usatoday.com/life/movies/news/2004-05-03-pitt_x.htm

    Again, Justin who??

  88. Mrs.Krabapple says:

    Pitt raised Anniston’s exposure, and Anniston raises Theroux’s. So Theroux is riding on Pitt’s coat-tails too, once removed. So my vote goes to Pitt.

    I find very few actors to be truly “cool” — they are ALL products of publicists and all try TOO hard to be cool. Which makes them un-cool. The last actor who I thought was truly cool was Paul Newman, so you know how long that’s been.

  89. LOVE ANGELINA says:

    I don’t think either one is a douche…well Brad is apologetically who he is, that can come off as douche. However I think Brad is a really nice guy with a no nonsense demeanor sometimes.

    No body really knows Justin and I feel super bad for him. No one was calling him all these horrible names several months ago. Now all of a sudden he is a douche bag or a hipster douche and all this bullsh*t. I don’t know Justin either, I just liked him in Six Feet Under and Romi and Michele’s High School Reunion. He is a great supporting actor and really good writer, even though I wasn’t the hugest fan of Iron Man 2. I like the guy and I hate that he is gonna get called all these horrible names just for dating Jen Aniston.

  90. Minx2 says:

    Brad is real, he’s famous, he’s happy – he’s got nothing to prove.
    The other guy is trying too hard to be hip and coming across as a douche. And he’s in GQ because he’s dating JA. Kind of pathetic.

  91. Ramona Q says:

    Justin and Jennifer are perfect for each other: both are self-absorbed, eh, self-obsessed – how many mirrors do you think are in their house?

    I’m not crazy about Brad, but he’s a legend and a good actor, and obviously a good and thoughtful person.

  92. Playlist says:

    There is a weird Charles Manson vibe/look that Justin gives off. Like something creepy lies just under the surface with him. Brad isn’t aging well and watching any of his interviews is almost painful because he struggles so hard to sound intelligent and witty. With Justin I get the feeling he is hiding something from everyone. With Brad I get the feeling he is bullshitting everyone because he finds it entertaining.

    My vote is neither of these guys are cool, but Brad is a great dad. We wouldn’t even be discussing Justin if it weren’t for him dating Jennifer. I agree with The Original Ashley (#28). Justin and Angie would be a perfect combo. Brad is Angie’s doormat and Jennifer is Justin’s groupie.

  93. Josephina says:

    Theroux…hotter than Brad Pitt? … Seriously?

    What are you up to

    It would make more sense to compare Theroux with Jason Sudeikis…they are more equally-yoked.

    Someone earlier posted that Theroux looks like Squiggy from LaVerne and Shirley….(chuckles) He DOES!!!!

    His hair, too small T-shirts, long torso and stumpy legs remind me of Beavis and Butthead. (They wear hipster, skinny leg jeans.) That, plus the fact that he hangs out with that creepy photographer pervert friend (Terry Anderson or Richardson?).

    Aniston and Theroux should double date- Aniston brings Chelsea Handler and Theroux brings the horny famous photographer friend.

  94. whitedaisy says:

    I tend to prefer a brown-eyed, little boy quality in my men.
    That being said, Brad Pitt is muy bueno and Justin Theroux is a poser wanna-be.
    Pitt is a family man. Theroux is buddies with Terry Richardson and shares the same agent as Jennifer Aniston.
    End of story.

  95. Canuck says:

    @Cheyenne: Well, that’s your totally uninformed opinion, unless you know the guy personally? It’s not as if the woman isn’t attractive, successful, by all acounts a genuinely nice person and independantly wealthy. I know you wish her nothing but misery and loneliness for the rest of her life so that the Brange fans can continue to believe that she’ll pine away forever for Pitt, but the truth is that most guys would give their right arm to be dating someone like Jen and this one looks to be very into her.

  96. mandyfan says:

    I’ve been in love with Justin Theroux since the second Charlie’s Angels. And the I found out that he wrote Tropic Thunder and Iron Man 2…and I love him more. HGF!!!!

  97. DetRiotgirl says:

    Eh… Neither. But, I think I might like Brad’s personality on Justin’s face. I would call this hybrid man Brastin Piroux.

    *gently puts down afternoon cocktail, wanders out of thread*

  98. anonymous says:

    No comparison,they shouldn’t even be mentioned in the same sentence let alone the same article articles such as these is an insult to the personna of Brad Pitt. No one knew who Justin Theroux was or is before he dated Jennifer Aniston,most people have to ask Justin who, never heard of him. I swear I have seen Justin Theroux on a reinactment of a crime scene on TV which is for d and F listers,seems to me they are both living off of Brad Pitt’s fame, JA got her fame only because she dated and was married to Brad Pitt. Brad Pitt is rich, handsome,famous and an A-list star. Right now Jennifer Aniston and her beau is living in a rental home cost 27,000 per month if Justin pays half of her rent for a year he is going to be broke by next year, stop insulting Brad Pitt, with cmparing him to Aniston broke down bum!

  99. Jordan says:

    Why do you guys have to be so negative, and assert that JT is only with JA to boost his career? Damn, the guy is a very good writer, he doesn’t need to do that. if you guys worship Brad and Angie, fine, it is your choice, but stop slamming people just to create this fantasy line between whoever-dates-JA-douch and the god and goddess of Hollywood.

  100. Tara says:

    If I can’t vote for Clive Owen it’s not a real contest. That said, Brad Pitt is an icon and a surprisingly good actor. Theroux definitely reeks of confused tryhard. But, anyway CLIVE OWEN!!

  101. Wresa says:

    Brad is starting to look like The Dude in The Big Lewbowski.

    I was reading JT’s and thinking, “Lord, what a puerile douche,” and then I scrolled down to Brad and thought, “Now THAT’S a man!”

  102. PeekaBooICU says:

    LOVE me some Brad Pitt! His association with Angelina Jolie made him an even better person. He went from a seemingly typical shallow Hollywood actor to a more mature humanitarian.
    Although there are times when he takes on a “Benicio Del Toro” look, ugh!

  103. N.D. says:

    Brad Pitt! Forever and ever.

    Personally I find Justin ugly as hell and not ugly hot but just ugly. And all his past interviews I read were awfull – he comes off as a desperate poser and douche.

    But I’ve just seen him in that weird comedy with Portman – Your Highness I think it was named – and he stole the show as evil scorcerer. Now I think he might be charming and/or interesting in real life after all.

    Still, he’s no match to Brad, they ain’t in the same league.

  104. Jilli says:

    Hmmm. Two completely different men. Why put them up one against the other? It’s ridiculous.

  105. Memphis says:

    Saying JT is dating JA to “boost” his career, has to be a joke. Right? This guy has been around forever. Be it acting, producing, directing or writing. He’s been known in HW for a very long time.

    Aside from that both men are looking haggard here, so I would go with none of the above.

  106. fizXgirl314 says:

    just based on looks Theroux is way hotter and more masculine and I dig dark features and piercing dark eyes. Bland Pitt is MEH…

  107. Sol says:

    Justin Theroux all the way! He has personality not as Brad Pitt that metamorphosed in every relationship he had. Just look at pictures and you will see how with every girlfriend he changed his looks.Oh and after reading what he said of his previous marriage he is a douche!

  108. mln76 says:

    @Memphis you’ve got to be kidding. He’s done a few cult movies & TV shows in the far past and has a couple of screenwriting creds . He has been around forever and 6 months ago no one really knew his name (face yes name no) and at 40 was hitting a wall in how much further his acting prospects would go. Now he well-known simply on the basis of who he is schtupping. He’s getting mentioned in the same sentence as Brad Pitt who is one of the most iconic actors of the last two decades and he has a full pictoral in GQ for a small role in a movie that’s so bad that it’s released date is getting pushed back.

  109. Camille says:

    I agree with you completely Kaiser.

    Theroux is a fugly, wannabe, Try Hard if ever there was one.
    Brad Pitt is a gorgeous and sexy A-List Mega Star, who doesn’t even have to try at this point.

    Team Brad all the way with this one.

  110. CIdee says:

    I think Justin is SMOKIN’, There, I said it.

  111. Judy says:

    Personally I hope that JA has finally found someone ,too bad they have to bring Pitt into it again. The man is probably sick of this shit. I think it would be nice if JA told the truth about her and Pitt’s break up and then all these morons could get on with their lives. What would they possible do if they didnt have AJ and Brad to go after and call names? If JA would speak out and tell the absolute truth she would say that Brad had had enough of thier marriage and had already asked her for a divorce and that she too wanted out but she wanted to be an A lister for the rest of her life and if Brad left her she would still be a B lister because her movies were not and never will be A list. She was A list at parties only because of her marriage to Brad. SO when he left she decided to ride the pity wagon and cut him down with lies. I really really pray that this is going to be her next husband,even if she did break up his 14 yr relationship lol How does it feel to hear that she was no better then AJ?? EVEN if AJ had nothing to do with Pitt leaving lol I think Pitt is a hell of a lot cleaner looking then this guy, and has much more talent.
    But to be fair they need to stop this crap comparing Brad to every man that JA sleeps with. She sleeps with them she doesn’t have a relationship with any of them. They never last more then a month or 2 lol So far Brad has been compared to half of the men in LA. But I do wish she would get remarried so she can have those kids she talks about having roflmao.

  112. Phoenix says:

    Completely agree with everything you said Judy! Right on!

  113. Phoenix says:

    I don’t think a woman who tears apart a relationship of 14 years, and who schemes, manipulates the public and the press out of malicious spite to cast herself as the victim, who constantly bad-mouths her ex-husband, the mother of his children AND the children, and who is friends with Chelsea Handler who she conspired with to attack Angelina and who walked onto the stage on cue with a malicious grin, TWICE, as Handler attacked Angelina and made racist comments about her children and clearly supports it, is a ‘nice’ person, Canuck. You clearly have a fantasy image of Aniston in your head, when the EVIDENCE *clearly shows* she is anything *but* a nice person. She is an evil, conniving, scheming malicious bitch. There is nothing ‘nice’ about her at all, and the *facts and reality* prove this without any reasonable doubt.

  114. Canuck says:

    @phoenix: and so you say in a very unbiased fashion. But please feel free to link to any negative comments ANY of her castmates have made about her. I’m quite sure I could find dozens if not hundreds where they say nothing but nice things about her.

  115. Phoenix says:

    And you’re ‘unbiased’? Fmd! Of COURSE her castmates aren’t going to say bad about her, duh. Neither have Angelina’s. OR Brads. But Aniston’s *actions* PROVE, without *any* reasonable doubt, that she is a dispicable piece of trash with no morals or decency whatsoever.

  116. smh says:

    lol i love this post and title-and if women are constantly criticized, why can’t men be also? on the other hand i have come to admire b.p. in the past few years because of all the charity and good deeds he’s done. face it he and angelina combined their fortunes and saved 1/3 of it for their causes and not everybody does that (though i hope they would).

  117. Ally says:

    I would have thought Theroux was cooler, UNTIL he hooked up with Aniston. But let’s face it, he wouldn’t be getting GQ fashion editorials without her.

    The problem with Brad & Jen is they’re both vanilla. He tends to gravitate towards strong women who’ll give excitement and direction to his life. Jen just wanted to hang around a finished house in LA.

    GQ and its ilk are sort of hilarious with this retro dude fixation. There’s also James Dean, Steve McQueen, the Rat Pack. They are so nostalgic for the days when you could relentlessly objectify women. Now you have to be slightly more polite & cautious about it, it’s hell on those poor guys!

  118. Chris says:

    “Brad Pitt as Tyler Durden is cooler than real-life Justin and any character he’ll ever play”

    +1

  119. Chloe says:

    @ LOVE ANGELINA: “I hate that he is gonna get called all these horrible names just for dating Jen Aniston.”

    Nah, he’s being called names because he dumped his girlfriend of 14 years way after he started romancing JA. Or at least that’s what both the girl’s rep and her family officially said in public.

    /chuckles about the direction the thread will develop in

  120. Canuck says:

    @Phoenix: AJ’s former castmate Gerard Butler recently said about AJ in a Howard Stern interview “I didn’t sleep with her, I’m the only guy who didn’t, i was wondering if there was something wrong with me” (sic). He also said he loved Aniston a lot, but that they didn’t date, they were only friends.

  121. Phoenix says:

    And THATs an attack??? So, like, your point is…?? Angelina is always linked with her co-stars and each and every one of them is accused of sleeping with her, which is what Gerard was jocularly referring to. It is certainly not an attack on Jolie, nor is what he said about Aniston any glowing endorsement, either. This is the guy who was intimate enough with Aniston to insert his finger up in her rear end. So, that speaks to his credibility. As I said, her ACTIONS say all there is about her, and there is no way you can counter that no matter how many paid-for references you can dig up for her.

  122. la chica says:

    Justin looks 5′ 2″. he’s a midget. no comparison with Pitt Porn (to quote Lainey). lol!

  123. Canuck says:

    Goosing, as the Brits so lovingly refer to ti, does not involve inserting fingers, despite your intense desire to beleive otherwise. Not to mention how impossible that would actually be to do to someone wearing jeans.

    Excuse me, but where did you get the idea that I was presenting Butler’s remark as an “attack”? You said no one makes unflattering remarks about AJ, I gave you an example of someone calling her the town pump. Ta da

  124. Mich says:

    Brad’s face looks busted and he has aged dramatically since hooking up with AJ. He always came across as a stoner with not a lot going on upstairs to me.
    Justin at least seems very smart, and he looks better without the beard, so Justin FTW.

  125. merry says:

    brad’s a bore

  126. Cherry Rose says:

    @Phoenix – You know, it doesn’t help the Angelina side when you come off as crazy as the Jen-hens. Saying things like “dispicable piece of trash with no morals or decency whatsoever.”

    I mean, damn, I like Angelina too, but getting this worked up over Jennifer Aniston just makes you look crazy. Chill.

    Anyway, I would only do Brad Pitt if he looked like he did as Louis in Interview with the Vampire. He was so beautiful looking in that movie.

    Justin, I would only do if he was clean-shaven, or just the slightest bit of scruffiness.

  127. Svetlana says:

    FYI – Theroux has been photographed for GQ before – well before his hooking up with Aniston.

    And I do go Team Theroux on this one. Because 1) I like dark-haired, dark-eyed men; 2) he seems rather quick-witted and funny; 3) I get the vibe that he’s a beast between the sheets; and 4) Theroux is a really awesome last name. And I figure any man that can hook a woman like JA whilst sporting a serial killer beard has to have some serious game.

    Brad Pitt is a very handsome man. But a little too blond and a little too conventional for my taste.

  128. april says:

    Yuck. Neither one.

  129. Violet says:

    Even Jen has never accused Brad of infidelity. In contrast, Justin betrayed his common-law wife of 14 years to be with Jen.

    So, no contest. This particular “chick” isn’t attracted to cheaters. Aside from lacking in integrity, Justin also strikes me as self-absorbed, pretentious and hypocritical, and I don’t find those qualities sexy.

    Brad loves to travel, gives generously to charity and makes his family priority #1. Now that’s the kind of man I want. Except I’d want one who’s still unattached, of course 😉

  130. sandy#1 says:

    as we already saw, it does not take much to hook up with ja, more guys than not already have, ta da

  131. I do pity Justin(even though,he looks like Eddie Munster to me)The day will arrive,when he and aniston are no longer a couple,and he will join the ranks of Pitt,Vaughn,Meyer,and other victims,and shit will hit the fan.It ain’t gonna be pretty.

  132. LuckyLilGem says:

    So how did Jen, very mediocre in the looks dept, get these 2 hotties?

  133. Canuck says:

    Violet: there is no such thing as “common law marriage” in NY.

  134. mamakowalska says:

    BRAD IS BEST!!!

    Justin is only a POOP-FART in a very stinky toilet.

  135. Jen D says:

    Johnny Depp! Oops, not an option? Erm, Theroux looks like he tries too hard, and Brad Pitt looks like he’s probably covered in baby vomit.

  136. Sakyiwaa says:

    BRAD PITT. BRAD PITT. BRAD PITT. BRAD PITT. BRAD PITT. BRAD PITT.

  137. N.D. says:

    @LuckyLilGem She did it by paying her mighty agent his salary for 20+ years. That’s not to say she doesn’t look good on top of that.

    @Canuck It’s beyond obvious that Batler remark is tongue in cheek, he didn’t seriously call Angelina “town pump” as you say.

  138. Phoenix says:

    Canuck, he did indeed insert a finger there. Whether in jeans or not, the FACT of the matter is, his finger went there.

    And no, Gerard did not accuse Angelina of that, at all. It was not an unflattering comment, either. Thats *your* spin on it and your attempt is a very weak and desperate one at that. As seen in the interview, he laughs off the insinuation that Angelina is with all her co-stars. The same as he did with Aniston when he denied dating her. He never insinuated what you are attempting to make it sound like and you know it. No dice.

  139. Canuck says:

    Phoenix…goosing, look it up. Butler is a Brit, it’s a stupid bit of British humour, generally designed to startle someone, and even better if their pic is being taken. No more or less…

  140. Violet says:

    @Canuck – I have no idea whether NY acknowledges common-law relationships, but you’re splitting hairs. The bottom line is that Justin cheated on his live-in partner of 14 years. Not cool.

  141. NaomiCampbellsPhone says:

    Whenever I see JT, I can’t not think of him in Charlies Angels 2 yelling “give us the rings!” in that godawful Irish accent

  142. Ez says:

    I vote for Theroux. Because of his integrity, depth, wits and obviously high and well used IQ.

    Pitt is flat, somehow. His films are not good, either.

  143. nemera says:

    Justin is not even close.

    Stop trying to make this man. Comparing him to Brad PLEASE.

    I don’t care what he as written or produced.

    Brad Pitt all the way. Not a race or even a good question. Justin who???

    Must suck for him that he is now Jennifer’s boyfriend. 40 years old and that is what you are reduced to.

  144. dg says:

    Brad’s always been too “purdy” for me to take seriously as a “guy”. The photos of him in “Interview with a vampire” actually make him LOOK LIKE Jennifer Anniston (I kid you not, google it!). As for acting, he’s always been as good as the movie around him because he’s not much of an actor, really. Kinda like Tom Cruise, he can make a movie okay (because some girls like them), but usually the movie succeeds IN SPITE of their acting ability. I like my men a little more real (and FROSTED, HI-LIGHTED HAIR ON GUYS IS JUST WEIRD!!!), and who cares who looks good in a suit? My own hubby beats em both while he’s dressed in his old overalls & cutting wood………now THAT’s sexy!

  145. ZenB!tch says:

    I can’t stand Brad Pitt. He comes across as dull as braindead as the Aniston and as opportunistic as Jolie (all his women’s bad points none of the good).

    However, I wouldn’t even know Justin Theroux existed were it not for his love life. I still don’t know what he does for a living. I’m almost impressed with Aniston for dating a “nobody” at least in my eyes.

    Why is he giving interviews? My BF should give interviews too, so should every one elses. Who the hell is Justin Theroux?

    *yes I could Google but that is not the point. The point is that if I cared enough, I would have to Google.

  146. Sakyiwaa says:

    @Canuck. Funny. I think Aniston was called a ‘sport fuck’ by some guy 😉

    Apples and oranges, people.
    Make it about Mayer and Theroux. Brad Pitt wins everything :-).

  147. Sakyiwaa says:

    Personally,
    4 making awesome movies 4 20+ years…
    4 setting up Make It Right…
    4 hooking up with AJ…
    4 being Shiloh, Zahara and Knox’s poppa…

    Brad FTW!

  148. Sheila says:

    my vote goes to JUSTIN THEROUX for keeping his mouth shut! There is a big difference between a gentleman and a scumbag!

  149. hunny says:

    Off course Brad Pitt! I just heard about Justin Theroux when he’s with Jen.

  150. Rhowen says:

    There is no sense comparing the two. Brad was there, Justin is here. Brad moved on, Justin moved in. Brad is gorgeous, Justin is mysterious.

    It is now up to Jen …. is she still pinning for love lost? or will she find true love with Justin? Brad will never come back – Justin may never leave Jen.

  151. jay says:

    This is from my personal preferences, but I think Justin is hotter. Look at that incredibly dark hair (it’s a little amusing that it’s blonde hair vs. black hair). Of course, I am gay and have a thing for bear types. Though I will say I’d prefer him with just scruff or a much much shorter trimmed beard. He was better when he was under the radar.