Spike Lee: Beyonce losing Album of the Year is ‘straight up bulls–t’

Spike Lee has not gotten softer with age, but he has become more diplomatic. His interviews used to have much more pointed comments and I would have even called him judgmental. Nowadays, he takes the longer view and that makes him more interesting, I think. Spike is the recipient of this year’s BFI Fellowship, the highest honor from the British Film Institute. To celebrate, Spike agreed to a wonderful interview with the Guardian. He spoke about awards shows, the Oscars, Malcolm X and Beyonce. Enjoy:

He believes his film ‘Malcolm X’ is still relevant: “Very relevant. Did you see what happened in Memphis recently?” says Lee, referring to the killing of Tyre Nichols, a shocking reminder that history has a habit of repeating itself. “Malcolm X will stand the test of time. And that performance by Denzel still amazes me. It’s one of the greatest I’ve ever seen.” As for the fight against racism, he adds: “It’s always two steps forward, one step back. But I’ll never say there’s been no progress. The struggle continues.”

When EEAAO’s director Daniel Scheinert called ‘Malcolm X’ a “crime movie”. “I’d never heard that description before. But look, I’m not going to kill the guy. I’ve misspoken many times in my life, too. So I’m calling on Black Twitter to give the guy a break – because when Black Twitter gets on your ass, they get on your ass.”

His relationship with film critics: “People forget that when Do the Right Thing came out, critics with loud voices said: ‘This film will incite African Americans to riot all across the country.’ It sounds crazy now, but that was written by prominent film critics, that my film would cause black folks to run amok. They’ve still never said they f–ked up. It was a very racist take on a film that dealt with the legacy of racism in the US.”

On Viola Davis and Danielle Deadwyler being snubbed for Oscar noms: “You know, I’ve really got nothing to say about it. I’m happy Angela Bassett got nominated. I’m happy Ruth Carter – who for a long time was my costume designer – got nominated… It gets tricky when you get these award things. And the Academy has a history with … The Academy has a history, let’s leave it at that. But the whole #OscarsSoWhite hashtag definitely made an impact. The Academy, to their credit, made changes to bring diversity to the voting body.”

Beyonce losing Album of the Year again at the Grammys: “I’m not the male president of the Bey Hive [Beyoncé’s fanbase], but I love and support Beyoncé. Her album is amazing. I know she’s won multiple Grammys, but four times nominated for album of the year and she’s lost every time? No disrespect to those artists like Adele or Harry Styles who won. It’s not their fault, but that’s some straight-up bullsh-t. There’s a history of great black artists who come up for these awards and don’t win. We all know their work is great, because art speaks for itself. But then it always comes down to this tricky territory of validation. Do black artists say: ‘F–k it’ – or seek white validation and chase awards? I just want to give a shoutout to my sister Beyoncé. We know what the deal is. It’s straight-up shenanigans, skulduggery, subterfuge. Or as the British say: it’s some poppycock!”

Speak your truth to power: “I’ve learned that you have to speak truth to power. When I take my last breath, which won’t be soon by the way, it’ll be written that I was on the right side of history. But it’s an individual choice. There’s certain times when you know there’ll be repercussions and you’ve got to make a choice to speak out or clam up.” But speaking truth to power, he adds, has never felt like a burden. “Because I’ve never tried to position myself as speaking for 45 million African Americans. I always say, ‘This is my opinion’. Fairly early on, my late mother said: ‘Spike, we as black people are not one monolithic group. We don’t look alike, talk alike, think alike. We’re very diverse, from many different backgrounds.’ And I took that to heart.”

[From The Guardian]

Everything Everywhere All At Once’s co-director Daniel Scheinert really did call Malcolm X a “crime movie” and it caused a lot of debate on Film Twitter and Black Twitter. It’s funny that Spike is kind of giving him a pass on that, maybe because Scheinert’s comments, in context, were complimentary towards the film. I love what he says about Beyonce and the history of Black artists not getting any validation from predominantly white industries. And Spike is talking about himself there too – you know he’s debated whether or not he should take the Oscars seriously, whether he should seek validation from his industry peers, whether he should even go to the Oscars when he’s nominated. Those are questions without answers, and every artist has to figure it out for themselves. I kind of wish Beyonce would just stop going to the Grammys though.

Photos courtesy of Avalon Red.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

37 Responses to “Spike Lee: Beyonce losing Album of the Year is ‘straight up bulls–t’”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. The Old Chick says:

    I love his comments. And I love that he said shenanigans and poppycock. Shenanigans is a fav word. Sticking up for Bey in that way was awesome and I suspect that is his opinion on this year’s oscars too.

  2. MSTJ says:

    I think Beyoncé went to the Grammys this year to support her husband and the Hip Hop community for the 50 years celebration. It would be interesting to see if she goes in the future. She certainly doesn’t not need to IMHO. I think her presence at the show actually gives it some credence with the current generation and a lot of people will likely watch the show if they expect her to attend.

    • MSTJ says:

      should be ….does not need to….

    • Eurydice says:

      That’s the thing – they need her more than she needs them.

      • Robert Phillips says:

        All awards shows are becoming more and more irrelavent. And no Beyonce will never win Album of the year. It is an industry award. And Beyonce demanding writing credit for changing an A to a The has pissed off to many people in the industry. And they are who vote for the awards. And no they don’t need her more than she needs them. She would get no air play or any publicity without the studios behind her. It’s still an industy run business. Social Media helps her. But it still wouldn’t be enough for her to get world tours happening. And that’s where her money and exposure comes from.

      • SophieJara says:

        I am not on board with Robert Philips saying Beyonce will never (should never?) win because she is … egotistical and demanding? As opposed to how many other Grammy winners? Beyonce is NOT unliked by her peers and anyone who is going to single her out as not deserving because of wanting more credit than they might think she is due is… part of what we know is wrong with the Grammys.

  3. Amy Bee says:

    Good interview.

  4. ThatsNotOkay says:

    I like what he says here. He’s learned to edit himself in recent years but his heart is still afire and I’m glad. And his point about seeking white validation or just turning your back and not needing it to ride high is so on point—it’s tricky and I don’t have an answer, though my gut says f ‘em.

    • Christine says:

      Yeah, that’s where I am too. I wish he would give more interviews, this one is great.

      • BothSidesNow says:

        Ditto!!!!

        I hold a deep appreciation and respect for Spike Lee. I do wish we could hear more from him but I understand him not wanting to feed the critics as they will certainly retaliate.

  5. laura says:

    i get what he’s saying and there’s def a history at all the award shows…but Renaissance was not Beyonce’s best work. her best is Lemonade.

    • BB says:

      This is up for debate. To me, her best albums are 4 and Beyoncé. But Renaissance is still an amazing album that should have won AOTY. Same for Lemonade.

    • Jais says:

      Lemonade is my fave but it is debatable about which is best. Either way, she should have won.

    • Frippery says:

      Lemonade was a huge cultural phenomenon and a watershed album. That it somehow did not get AOTY is baffling. But Renaissance is not Lemonade.

      • Cool Eye says:

        Lemonade was a full immersive experience. Who doesn’t remember where they were when they first heard, Lemonade?
        Spike Lee has always been one step ahead of the zeitgeist. He sees the world as it is, while pushing for how it should be.
        He and Beyonce were both robbed of awards they deserved.

    • Bex says:

      Meanwhile, white artists put up mediocre albums and still win AOTY.

      So, it really doesn’t matter how Renaissance compares to Beyonce’s body of work. It’s called Album of the YEAR, not Album of the Body of Work.

      This is the same undermining crap as some Grammy voters saying they didn’t vote for her because she’s “won too much”.

  6. Nicegirl says:

    Shenanigans, skulduggery, subterfuge. I wish Beyoncé would get her win.

  7. Flowerlake says:

    Stopped taking that award show seriously a long time ago.

    Seems they just award whoever some rich people want them to award.

    Same seems to go for American radio playing who some rich people want them to play.
    Then people will start ‘liking’ what they hear and call it ‘popular’, especially since Billboard counts radio play for their charts.

    • Mandy says:

      Agree flower! None of these “musicians” mentioned can play an instrument or manually tune a guitar. They are all just corporate money machines, especially Beyoncé. It’s all about money and these shows are just corporations handing out participation trophy’s. It’s all a joke. Beyoncé has dozens of writers and actual musicians working on her albums cuz she ain’t one! Either is Harry or Adele’s, they are just the face of the money machines.

      • Is that so? says:

        I’m unclear what tuning or playing an instrument has to do with Beyoncé’s musicianship? When last I heard her instrument is her voice and she seems able to tune and play that well enough. I’ve never seen or heard her claim to play another instrument professionally.

        Next I expect to hear that Leadbelly can’t pirouettes so he shouldn’t be considered a bluesman.

        It’s all about the money?
        What else should it be about? Starving?
        Beyoncé earns her money and her art is better than most artists without a platform.

        I’m not sure what your standards are for music to be other than” all about the money”. Beyoncé work has vision and perspective. No one has to agree with it, but saying it’s all about the money implies she puts out trash just to get paid.

        The people I hear who most talk like that are people who failed to support themselves with their art and are bitter as a result.

      • BB says:

        And those actors who get Oscars for not even directing the movie or writing their lines!! Can you believe it?

  8. April Lea says:

    I love Spike. I met him yesterday and shook his hand. I’m still star struck. He’s such an important voice. This interview is a good one. He’s a legend.

    • Glamarazzi says:

      That’s so cool that you met him! He is one of the greats.

      His tone here is so interesting – he still sees the bull but he’s a bit more forgiving of where each person is in their journey. He’s mellowed from the firebrand he was coming up in the biz, but he’s still as sharp and incisive as ever.

  9. Torttu says:

    Nope, I don’t agree with Lee at all. Renaissance is not good, and the sampling of five thousand songs was just artyfarty bs.

    • emberly says:

      If she did win AOTY, that stage would’ve look the Oscar’s Best Picture. That album was basically a “tribute”.

      • Torttu says:

        I disagree. It seemed like a desperate scramble to come up with something interesting, but it does not work, and they know it.

    • Bex says:

      No.

      And having issues with sampling is quite the take, considering how so much of early hip-hop was about sampling. But sure “artyfarty”…

  10. Fancyhat says:

    For Lemonade absolutely for Renaissance nah. She’s not entitled to album of the year and there were better albums this time around

  11. 2lazy4username says:

    No, she should not have won AOTY.

  12. SomeChick says:

    I remember when Do the Right Thing came out, and all of the absolutely bonkers things that were written about it. the wipepo were terrified, or so they said.

    then I saw it. I lived in Chicago and there was a theater where you could see two movies for the price of one – they alternated them and you didn’t have to leave the theater. the movie sharing the bill with DTRT was Lethal Weapon 2 (I think 2, it was the one with the fishtank).

    LW2 is a very violent movie. and some of the violence is played for laughs. but there was no handwringing over it for some reason. DTRT took it seriously (and was much, much less violent). it showed the aftermath. you really can’t compare the two. I have issues with misogyny in some of Spike’s films but he’s absolutely been done dirty by the establishment.

  13. Chantal says:

    Nice interview. I stopped watching the Oscars when Denzel didn’t win Best Actor for Malcolm X. It also should have won Best Picture that year. I finally decided to watch again only to see Will Smith act a fool…

    This was very magnanimous of Spike to not blast the critic but I lol’d at Black Twitter setting him straight. Its great that Spike is still receiving the recognition and accolades he deserves for his contributions to cinema.

  14. Cherbear says:

    If B didn’t win for Lemonade- an incredible, inspired album WITH widespread commercial success- they’re just never gonna give it to her.

    It’s complete cocknballs, but thankfully, she can cry into her Billions about it (and spoiler alert- she’s not doing that…)

  15. KAM says:

    Does Robert Philips just give the misogynistic hot take on every article??

  16. Hello Kitty says:

    No lies were told. Beyoncé’s albums are innovative, progressive, soulful, thoughtful, works of art. She’s in a league of her own but is not recognized for it. It makes no sense… other than that people refuse to give her credit where it’s due. My own husband didn’t get her hype until one day I sat him down and made him watch the DC’s performance at the Super Bowl, the Tina Turner tribute in Washington, and the Stevie Wonder tribute. The girl has real talent and charisma and she’s an incredible performer. If you don’t get her hype start from the beginning of her career through the present and then talk to me. If you still don’t get it… reasonable minds disagree… but you’d be wrong, not I.

  17. J. Ferber says:

    And he’s right.