Evan Rachel Wood in black, beaded Elie Saab: stunning or “too old”?
Paz de la Huerta in ballerina pink w/silver lipstick: truly awful or simply Paz?
Gwyneth Paltrow in belly-baring, beaded Pucci: dated, fug or hot?
Heidi Klum in Christian Siriano: avant-garde gorgeous, or just tacky & fug?
Sofia Vergara in salmon Vera Wang: stunning, boring or fug?
Christina Hendricks in Johanna Johnson: flattering, pretty or too much?
Jon Hamm & his Botoxy girlfriend Jennifer Westfeldt: tragic or sexy?
Katie Holmes in blue Calvin Klein: simple & beautiful, or too underdone?
Julie Bowen in metallic Oscar de la Renta: hot mess or pretty decent?
