Here stands another day in the Miley Cyrus/Liam Hemsworth/January Jones “did they, or didn’t they?” saga. To recap, Liam and January were spotted suspiciously sharing a car ride home after a pre-Oscars party at the Chateau Marmont on Saturday evening. Miley was not in attendance at this event, and she didn’t take Liam with her when she went to Elton John’s Oscar party the following evening. So for whatever reason, Liam ended up alone inside a car with January, and early previews of this week’s issue of Star revealed allegations that Liam and January were pawing each other at the party and even locked lips. A lot of people also thought that Liam was the guy in Lainey’s blind item who just happened to be too young to be engaged and stepping out on his betrothed.
Now the full story has appeared in Star. In addition to the details about Liam and January’s supposed behavior before they were photographed droving off together into the night, we’re getting word of Miley’s alleged “single” behavior at Elton’s party. Further, Star claims that “friends say Liam hates Miley’s punky new look,” which honestly wouldn’t surprise me. I think Miley looks fine, but Liam did get with her when she looked very different from how she does now. Here are the details:
“Where’s Miley Cyrus?” That’s what onlookers were whispering on Feb. 23, when Liam Hemsworth spent the evening flirting up a storm with “Mad Men” actress January Jones at a pre-Oscars party at West Hollywood’s Chateau Marmont. “It looked like they had some hot chemistry,” reports an eyewitness at the event. “They were all over each other — and they even kissed!”
After steaming up the soiree, the pair left together. “Liam got January’s coat and helped her put it on, then they headed outside,” adds the source. “They made sure to leave a few seconds apart, so they wouldn’t attract too much attention. Theyn they jumped into a waiting car and took off.”
Of course, Liam, 23, is engaged to Miley — and their top-secret wedding is rumored to be happening in Palm Springs, Calif., in June. But lately, there have been rumblings that the couple are on the rocks and after Liam’s lusty outing with January, 35, friends are wondering if the wedding is still on!
While Miley, 20, skipped the party with Liam, she did attend another Oscars bash the next night, thrown by Elton John’s AIDS Foundation. “Miley was all over the place,” a party guest tells Star. “She certainly gave off the impression that she’s single. Someone even asked her how Liam was doing, and she said she doesn’t care how he’s doing!”
That’s obviously a strange response from someone about to be married. But strange behavior is nothing new for Miley. While at New York Fashion Week in mid-February, sources say Miley partied nonstop. “She was fliring with every guy and girl in sight,” an insider says, “Especially the models!”
January, meanwhile, has a reputation for romancing unavailable men. In addition to high-profile exes Ashton Kutcher, Josh Groban and Jason Sudeikis, she has reportedly been linked to married celebrity chef Bobby Flay and supermodel Claudia Schiffer’s husband, producer Matthew Vaughn. But regardless of her history, January can’t take full blame for the hookup. “Miley is not the girl Liam fell in love with,” says a friend. “She’s turned into an embarrassment.”
[From Star, print edition, March 11, 2013]
Just to point out a glaring error in this story, January wasn’t wearing a coat that evening, but that erroneous detail might just be filler and doesn’t mean that the rest of the story isn’t true. For what it’s worth though, a Miley source has contacted E! News and to say that Liam and Miley are still “totally together,” and there’s “no drama” because they attended separate events over the weekend. Whatever. Miley would have Liam doing a photo op with her if they were still together, right?
No matter what we believe about Miley’s alleged antics in this Star story, the fact still remains that Miley’s Twitter remains dark and has been inactive since Monday, which is unheard of since Miley loves to tweet, and she regularly takes to the site to debunk gossip. There’s also an unsubtantiated rumor floating around out there that claims Miley tweeted, “Not to worry, I won’t break,” on Monday and then deleted it, so who knows.
Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet and WENN
ha I knew Liam would find someone less crazy and more hot :/
I’m going to disagree that January Jones is less crazy.
and who’s that? Because i’m not seeing less craziness in January Jones, just a very sketchy woman…hotness is subjective.
January Jones strikes me as a woman of few morals and less class. Pretty…will never get why anyone finds her pretty.
Miley, you are young and can do so much better.
And she is pretty devoid if talent. I’ve never liked her. I think she is cold, but probably well suited to play Betty.
And guess what – she was once with Ashton Kutcher 😉
So K-Stew is a Trampire, but he is “finding someone less crazy and more hot”?
Cheating is cheating is cheating. It’s not okay. That doesn’t make the cheater the spawn of Satan, but it does make their behaviour crappy. Nobody held a gun to his head and told him to date the girl and then propose. He chose to. And even if they had had a huge fight right before, what he did here is utterly humiliating and disrespectful. Nobody deserves this. Not R-Patz, not Liberty Ross and not Miley Cyrus.
But Kristen is a woman and therefore needs to be held accountable by different standards because … [insert misogynist statement(s) here].
Also don’t forget that she doesn’t do the “smile at me, baby” thing and is therefore just an ungrateful brat. How dare she! When she appears on red carpets and isn’t all flawless cuteness, when she doesn’t assure us with her teeth that she is thrilled to be reduced to her body and a dress, when she doesn’t make us believe that to be looked at gives all the meaning to her life, when she basically doesn’t fulfill her holy duties as a woman, she deserves to be judged, bullied and harassed.
Liam on the other hand … Oh well, “boys will be boys”, you know? Also did you notice that Miley cut her hair? Probably without Liam’s permission! So it’s totally her fault!
*sarcasm off*
Good point. I don’t like her but the affair is really not the reason. She acts like an miserable brat.
THANK YOU! Liam publicly humiliated a woman he supposedly loves (loved). That is a real dick move. He knew the tabs would pick it up, he knew it would hurt Miley and that’s why he did it. I’m not a Miley fan nor even know much more than what I read here about her. But she is a freakin’ human being and she deserved better. The guy’s an ass. And we are not much better if we demonize Kristen and give Liam a pass. As you said, “Cheating is cheating.” And getting a hair cut is an excuse??? Ok. New grounds for cheating, divorce, etc.: Hair cuts, gaining weight, illness, anything that makes you not EXACTLY who you were when you met. Yeah, they were too young to get engaged in my opinion but they DID and they owed each other something. Break up, make an announcement and then get laid all you want.
@*unf* Joan Jett
*claps*
But, how do you know yet if he was cheating. Just because there hasn’t been a public statement doesn’t mean they hadn’t already broken up. It says she was also flirting with guys and girls at the party she was at. They may both have already been single!
January is way less hot than Miley and definitely more crazy.
I think Miley looks great! I love her hair. Good if they cancel the wedding, she’s in her 20’s she should be living a single life and having fun. Wait until your thirty before getting married.
When I saw the pictures I assumed they had broken up already. Even if they hasn’t, January and Liam shared a car. There’s still the possibility that they didn’t cheat. It’s small, but it’s not like he was going down on her in the photos.
Sadsies! I liked these 2 together 🙁
ditto! I just like Miley in general. she’s a cutie and I love her new look! Liam should smarten up.
+2 hopefully a bad rumour.
‘….January can’t take full blame for the hookup. “Miley is not the girl Liam fell in love with,” says a friend. “She’s turned into an embarrassment.”….’
Dafuq? So it’s Miley’s fault instead? Look, I don’t like the girl that much and I’m not a fan of her new look either, but changing your style (however drastically) is not a legitimate reason to blame her for Liam straying (if in fact, he did.)
Same here. I can’t stand her and her awful voice, but I do feel sorry for her. It has become really messy.
thought the same thing, the fault is not with Miley but with Liam and January.
I think Miley looks great here by the way, like the hairstyle she’s rockin.
Seriously. But this is why people kept telling them they were too young to commit like this. A man like Liam wouldn’t be able to handle baby weight gain or to not be the center of attention all of a sudden, if a simple hair cut bothers him so much. He’s very green still. Bad idea to get engaged.
I wondered how he would cope with her “phase”.
I don’t dislike her short hair, but she styles it weirdly. Though I really don’t like her new punk style. It looks forced and dishonest too. While I think it’s just a phase I also think she shouldn’t change for him. If that’s how she wants to be seen, fine.
…but seems like she was flirting with guys and girls and apparently acting a fool too so… I doubt if it’s just her look that’s changed, maybe it’s the attitude too. …If any of this is true.
That’s what I was thinking too..Not just her hair that changed, but her lifestyle. I would say that’s enough of a change to break it off.
If he’s gonna get cold feet just because of a haircut then I’d say she’s probably better off without him.
I’m not a fain of hers either but I think she looks amazing in these photos. The dress is flattering and she seems less self-conscious and try-hard than when she first chopped it all off.
+1
She looks awesome in these pics… hair is adorable and edgy and her body looks great and sexy in the dress. In fact, she might look the most grown-up and sophisticated I’ve ever seen her. Much more comfortable in her own skin. Rock on Miley!
I agree, how ridiculous is that statement? In what way is she an embarassment? She is 20 and she can mess about with her style as much as she likes. When I think about some of the hair disasters I had at that age she is coming out way ahead of me. So glad I am not famous and have people nit picking over my appearance in such detail.
However, I actually love her look at the moment. I think she really suits it and can pull it off. More power to her for having the bravery to stick to it in the face of so much criticism.
If Liam is dumping her because of it, or acting so childishly over a haircut she can do so so much better.
Yes. All of it.
Agreed! I like her look now too…get so bored with the cookie cutter Hollywood styles…thankfully someone had the courage to break the mold
Liam looks like so many other guys out there…meh
In what way is she an embarrassment ? The penis birthday cake, fondling a strippers boobs, need I go on ? I love her new look but, she did go a little off the rails.
@ JuneBug:
Oh come on, she is young and allowed to have some silly fun.
she’s pretty and her new hairdo isn’t embarrassing at all. what would he do if she got a green and purple mohawk instead of just short hair?
it’s not like she’s become a cracken who walks around in her underwear and slippers.
well,well. at least this taught me it’s okay to stop being into someone if they change their hair or how they dress.
I don’t think anyone said her ‘hair’ is an embarrassment. Yes, she changed her hair/style…. but there might be more going on, if the embarrassment comment is even true.
I’m sure the haircut was not it. Those of you who believe that are gullible. We didn’t live with them, only they know the reason. I’m sure her “change” has nothing to do with her outer appearance, although what one has inside is reflected on the outside.
Whatever the reason I doubt this is a happy time for either. They seemed very in love at one time.
Perhaps the style change isn’t the reason behind the feelings of embarrassment. Other than some guest spots on TV, Miley really hasn’t done anything with her career in two years. It would be a bit embarrassing for a guy if his fiance suddenly took a turn into a weed-addled celebutante.
I didn’t get the impression that the embarrassment comment was limited to her new look. I thought it meant she was an embarrassment in general – i.e. behavior. Which I thought was weird because I feel like she’s been much more together since she started dating Liam.
The real question is whether she was still wearing her engagement ring at Elton John’s party. That would tell the story right there. I’d think if there were any truth to the story, that’s not a fact they’d leave out.
Agree. Like she has changed as a person and the hair is just a side effect to her new personality/behavior.
She was an embarrassment when he hooked up with her. She looks different but her behavior is the same… no undies on a bike… ewww!
JJ is a predator.
Liam has very bad taste in women. I agree JJ is hotter than Miley but I think most women are – at least around the face, but I think JJ is just as trashy and crazy – Liam has a type.
Her hair isn’t the only thing that’s changed. She’s also been photographed getting high, getting into her car with a short dress and no underwear, wearing cut-off shirts with her boobs hanging out, etc, etc, etc. Maybe he’s not down with his future wife behaving like that. This is why you don’t make huge life choices with a 19 yr old.
has everyone missed out on the addendum in Lainey’s blind?it said “NOT January Jones”.
Apparently, it was Emma Watson, who also attended several parties but refused to be photographed.
Interesting that Emma keeps getting tossed in this story. Makes me wonder in what stage her hair is in growing out becuase a cute blonde girl with a shag/bob can look pretty similar in the dark. Is it possible that a shared car ride just a car ride and instead of good girll Emma the hollywood lolita JanuAry takes the hit. Maybe Lainey did know that those pictures of the ride were being released and therefore gave the addedum. Seems like something she could have heard about while being there for the Oscars and maybe just maybe Miley lets him cheat.
If they did split, shouldn’t Lainey had already known that? Liam isn’t cheating if single.
BTW-A man can flirt with more than one woman during a night of partying.
Has it been confirmed that they’ve split? I think they’re still together.
Her blind item was really kind of a fail and not salacious at all.
Most of hers are. Lainey isn’t as connected as she says she is
She looks really good in these pictures — love the way she styled her hair.
I agree. She looks adorable…her eyes look huge. At least now she has a “style”, and has set herself apart from the rest of the Disney princesses. Can’t see any of them being able to carry this look. I love it.
I agree…this is the best she has ever looked, and my favorite dress of the night.
I agree.
She looks better than she has in ages.
Her makeup is PERFECT.
Yep. Great figure. Beautiful skin.
Agreed. I don’t think she looks or acts any differently than many 19 year-olds. And she was a product of the disgusting Disney factory machine which has f’ed up the lives of many a young girl. She’s doing great and I feel badly if he has hurt her.
Have to agree as well. In the photos with this article she looks the absolute best I’ve ever seen her look. She appears a lot less chipmunk-y.
She looks really pretty here.
if you look at the first photo, her left wrist it’s covered with brecelets but you still can see some marks of cutting, I think she’s cutting herself again ansd she tried to covered it with the bracelets. this poor girl!
Awww man, I just noticed that :/
How happy van you really be with someone if you cut yourself? Liam has always been a douche.
I scrolled back up to take a look after reading your comment and you are right. There are cut marks up her arm, and that honestly makes me really sad. I am in no way a Miley Cyrus fan, but it’s pretty obvious that there are underlying issues we know nothing about, and Liam is just one of it. I hope, for her sake, that his little rendezvous with January was not him cheating on her but that the two had broken off their engagement and ended their relationship prior to this incident.
Wow, I didn’t know that about her. But you are right, looks like there are scars on her arm.
If she cuts, it is not his fault. If she cuts the issues are her own, even if he is a douche he is not gabbing a knife and cutting her.
When a person hurts him/herself or commits suicide, the blame is not on oter people, but that ill person. If she cuts, she should need help for her own sake.
I’m not blaming him for her own cutting, but he’s definitely not helping. If you know you’re dating a fragile/unstable girl, you don’t push her over the edge with your antics. You’re either there for her, or you leave, but you don’t intentionally hurt someone who already hurts herself.
But maybe he did leave her – I mean we don’t know if they broke up or have an open relationship or are pretty much together and he actually cheated. It’s all so twisted.
I mean there’s Lainey, saying he flirted very much with Watson, but not January. And then there are photos of him with January in a car. Miley tweets that she won’t break, deletes it, but cuts herself again. And there’s a “source” telling us they are still together. Very weird.
And I agree, it’s not his fault if she’s actually cutting herself. I doubt that he’s a douche and cheated, but what do I know – maybe he did. Time will show 😉
I love Miley so I’m biased here but they are TOO young for an engament. Just break it off and live a little more, find out what you like in yourself, in others, go to college, travel alone. Just live.
Agree 100% with you, she’s too young to be engaged…break up and live a little before you get married, no shame in that.
Totally. Better they figure this out now and call off the wedding than going through a divorce.
i guess they broke and she looks pretty here
Seriously? It’s also Miley’s fault because she’s not the girl he fell in love with? Give me a break.
That’s a perfectly valid reason to break up!
I get the feeling that they already did and Miley is pushing him to keep the official announcement under wraps.
Cheating is not ok, but hanging on when the other person wants to leave is desperate. She may be mad at Liam, but she knows his career is going up while hers in going down and she doesn’t want to end her association with him.
No, but wouldn’t it be understandable if he wanted to leave her because she changed extremely? I mean that’s why you shouldn’t get engaged with 20! You just change so much in this time of your life and many couples can’t cope with it!
People divorce all the time for this reason… It’s better for them to break an engagement than a marriage.
Unsurprising.
Compared to Miley he seemed a bit more private, a tad smarter and a hell of a lot more talented.
So a 19 year old super famous girl with tons of cash, no job, and a messed up family getting engaged WASN’T the best idea?
Liam sounds like a douche, whether or not they broke up. Going home with notorious man stealing ice queen January Jones of all people to humiliate Miley after they [maybe] broke up and doing so in a very obvious way? Screw him. As far as I can tell, Miley never did anything to him to deserve that kind of douchery, all she did was lavish praise and love on him like all young girls do when they are madly in love, and this is what she gets for it. They either did or didn’t break up and either way, Liam looks like a tool for having so little class or discretion [or taste…Miley is no prize really but January Jones is horrible, what a horrible seeming woman].
Ditto!!
Yeah he has cheated on her a lot, and Miley is the typical girl who worships the bf :/
But she has issues. All that cutting and everything else we don’t know. Douches like him take advantage of girls like that.
I’m a cutter [well, less so now] with a lot of those same issues and I’ve only been taken for a ride once and never, ever put up with cheating [I found out he was cheating after we broke up]. I feel like Miley…I don’t know, I feel like she seems stronger than to let someone do her like that, it befuddles me. It almost makes me think their relationship was open to a degree, that she’s bisexual, and that the party girl rep she has received from a lot of blind items is accurate. But she could also just have major self-worth issues. Whatever the case, Liam is a twat. I always felt he was a twat, he never gushed about her the way she gushed about him, I feel like he used her for exposure and took advantage of her puppy dog heart. Hopefully the fact that he did this with January Jones will help Miley get over him…that’s how I’d handle it. If a guy did something like that to me right after we [maybe] split, I wouldn’t miss him for a second.
so true!
Janhoeuary!!!
Hahahaha…couldn’t have said it better myself
Miley looks super adorbs!
This is a pity. Miley seems like a bit of a mess, but she’s a kid with a hell of a lot of responsibility and I was pulling for her to find her way. I find it very hard to hate her as much as some people seem to.
She was very annoying when she was younger but she definitely has issues and I don’t see anyone helping her, or her getting help for herself, which I’m sure must hurt the relationship.
She kinda reminds me of my sister. A lot. Liam is a douche for sure, but dating a girl with issues like cutting or eating disorders is not easy. Imagine all the times she locks herself to cut. That’s not easy to witness.
Not excusing Liam’s douchery; he always cheated on her. But dating a girl with so many unresolved problems is not a piece of cake. I imagine their life together is far from perfect and him proposing was the typical way to try to fix things.
I just don’t think either one of them is a perfect angel, but I’m pulling for her because I think she needs help, and she’s not a bad person.
Of course she was annoying. She was a teenager with an outlet for her opinions. Have you seem tumblr? It’s full of the exact same girl. I would be exactly the same if I were an angsty teenager surrounded by employees willing to validate my every whim. I think she is actually doing remarkably well, considering!
Cutting is not my definition of doing well. I hope she goes to therapy or something. You let one issue grow, and sooner or later it’s going to grow like a tree, with more branches of new issues and problems as she grows older. Stuff like this doesn’t go away on its own. And engagements, marriage and babies will not make it go away.
Besides, not all teens are exactly the same. I don’t remember Emma Watson being like this at all. Heck, even Kristen Stewart was pretty chill when she was a teen. Very mature for her age. Miley was just too much, with her voice and the way she talked. Ugh. She’s growing out of it, thankfully.
I deal with clinical depression and anxiety and i can attest to how difficult it is to be in a relationship with someone who has mental issues. My boyfriend has been such a good person to me, but he is only human and sometimes, i can tell that it’s a lot for him to handle. I almost feel selfish for continuing to be in the relationship and, as horrible as it sounds, i have told him to leave me countless times because i don’t want him to burden himself. He really tries his best to give me the help that i need, and i can’t be more grateful for him, for that. I owe him so, so much.
That being said, it feels like the same can’t be said for Miley. I don’t cut myself, but i do punch myself in the face whenever i get into one of my “episodes”, and that is always a sign that i am not coping very well with myself. I don’t know if her family has tried to help her, but if they did and she is still cutting herself, more needs to be done. It also doesn’t seem like Liam knows how to handle the situation very well and is feeling a lot of pressure from being with her. They’ve been dating for a very long time, and i’m not sure if Miley’s issues started before or after they began dating, but he should know what kind of person Miley is. He chose to ask her to marry him, for God’s sake! It makes no sense that all of her issues would only come to light now and that he knew of none of it prior to their engagement.
I really, really hope that he didn’t cheat on her and that they had ended the relationship prior to this whole incident. I would be really sad for Miley if that isn’t the case, and i don’t even like her at all.
@Latifah
I have clinical depression, and anxiety as well. And my (now) fiance has been there every step of the way. I have horrible guilt with the situation. I really don’t know how he sticks around sometimes, but I am so thankful he does. I’ve told him to leave me countless times and he always laughs. Having him there makes everything so much more tolerable, even though I feel like I’m not giving him everything he deserves sometimes.
@Latifah and @Erinn – I have “issues” I call it “polar” but it’s anxiety disorder. I don’t think I’m depressed unless getting myself into crappy job situations and other things in my life due to lack of self-esteem is a form of depression.
I avoid being a in a relationship. It seems like it would be too much for me to handle, let alone the other person.
@Latifah, I’ve never heard of anyone else hitting herself. I don’t do it since I was put on SSRIs but I had a lot of “episodes” like that in my teens and 20s. I would hit myself, break inanimate objects, scratch myself, pinch myself, pull at my hair and more or less have tantrums for no reason.
It’s not a piece of cake to date a girl like me or Miley,we both have issues, but from what I can tell, Miley is like me, she gives her whole heart and that should count for something.
Besides, jumpoff January is a piece of fucking work from the deepest layer of hell, she just lacks Miley’s good nature. Miley’s good nature really makes up for her complications. I can tell in her face she’s a sweet girl. A real man would nurture a sweet, troubled girl and help her with her issues. That’s what my fiance does, and that’s what I do for him.
Ohh, I forgot about the cutting. That still doesn’t justify calling her annoying – if anything it makes people who blame Miley even worse. I still maintain that her problems aren’t crippling (as depression doesn’t need to be), but she’s in an extreme environment without a “typical” support network. As pure speculation, I would even go so far as to suggest that under “normal” circumstances, she might not have gone to such extremes. We’ve seen time and time again how damaging this environment is, and I’d be far more likely to point the finger at that than actual mental health issues.
I have never hated Miley. She is another young star that has financially supported her family for years.
Too much pressure. Too young to be engaged. I think Miley is very fragile, needy & madly in love with love. Liam is tired of being her therapist & lover.
Liam wants out, this is his cruel way of breaking up.
No, Miley didn’t support her family. Her dad is rich and hasn’t wasted his money. Miley herself said long ago that he paid for all of her normal expenses. She didn’t have to work, she was just one of those self-driven kids. She wanted to be like her dad, she was on stage with him occasionally as a youngster (pre-Mouse) and really liked the singing and performing in general. She wasn’t pushed into it by The Mouse and has real skills. She is in a transitional phase, though, too old for her previous audience but not yet ready for an older one. She just hasn’t figured out her real performance style yet and has been in the proving-I’m-grownup-now phase. Once she gets past that, she may surprise us. She doesn’t seem afflicted by the serious problems others have after success in show biz as a kid, doesn’t act like a self-absorbed narcissist and doesn’t seem at all mean.
Miley used to irritate me like crazy but I love her new look. She has become quite the lady.
Noone deserves to be cheated on in such a public and humiliating manner. Period.
I think you’re right, Miley is as much of a social media addict as LeAnn Rimes and this girl can’t resist taking to Twitter to “clear the air.” Either someone is stopping her from acting a fool or she doesn’t want to lie.
That makes her smarter than Rimes.
Am I the only one who could care less about Miley stories?
Yet you cared enough to comment about how much you don’t care. Brah-vo!
I think she looks awesome, I love that dress on her.
On a daily basis, yeah she dresses quite trashy but her haircut is fine.
Anyway if Liam acted like that I don’t think Miley is to blame. It’s his own fault, he was the one acting like a douche.
This is going to end badly. If they break up I could see her having a meltdown of some kind.
Yeah, she might go off the deep end and put extensions into her hair.
This is what’s so scary about it…has seemed like her life revolves around him since they got together – not healthy. I wonder if that’s why he stayed with her for so long, didnt want to see her inflict harm on herself. That is no relationship if the case. Maybe it’s not a stretch to suggest she be on suicide watch if they are breaking it off, esp if those are really cut marks on her wrist. Sad sad.
If straying outside of your relationship is seen as a legitimate response to a change in your partner’s appearance, then it’s best to know this before marriage. Because, as a person married almost 2 decades, I’m here to tell you that you’re going to face far more severe trials together as a couple than a haircut. Best to weed out the lightweights early on. BTW, I love Miley’s haircut and that’s the cut I had when I met my husband.
I kinda saw this coming when she chopped her hair off. Yo, Miley, most dudes don’t like the short hair thing, just sayin
correction: boys care solely about physical appearance and use it to justify their shitty actions. men care about the person inside and don’t act like assholes because their significant other chooses to express themselves how they want.
i pity the women in your life.
I pity the men in yours
you do sound like a superficial person, so you might be right about this…
I wouldn’t worry about the men in Lem’s life…I’m sure she surrounds herself with people that are a bit more mature and who are not superficial fools.
Ok troll
Who is the one using Mom’s computer?
Skins, I believe you are the troll. All of these other people are regular commenters. Go back to your playpen and let the adults talk, mmkay?
Hey anon, all I said was that guys don’t like the short hair look, and these women come on insulting me? Is that what you mean by letting the adults talk? You should mind your own business
I never once lacked for male companionship when I had short hair, and I had short hair for 15 years. Try again.
Sorry you’re getting slammed for saying something true. There are a lot of guys who don’t care for short hair, take a poll and you’ll see it’s true. But there are also a lot of guys who like short hair, so there is someone for everyone.
But a guy who loves you doesn’t dump you over a haircut.
Apologies to all of you who married young, but these two are WAY too young to even consider marriage.
I feel that they got “engaged” for the simple fact that it seems inappropriate for an 18-19 year old girl to be living with her boyfriend. And now they are expected to actually get married. I hope they call this nonsense off now and go live their young lives.
I agree overall with your statement but I do think *SOME* young people who are exceptionally mature and focused can make marriage work at a young age.
Miley, however, does not fall into that category.
I still really dug these two together and I hope this is just a rumor. I’m always a big supporter of women, even when they make mistakes but it’s really hard for me to defend or like ANYTHING about January Jones. She just seems like an insecure, sketchy-ass lady. So many guys out there-why go after the ones that are taken? Is she really that desperate?
I can’t believe I have to state the obvious: a relationship consists of more than hair.
amen!
seriously. i can’t believe the # of people saying “well duh look at her hair!” as if that somehow justifies cheating or even ending a relationship.
I think a lot of those comments are coming from trolls that we ought not to feed.
Did her attitude or personality change with her hair? I’m not kidding. I don’t think she’s doing the fake wholesome thing anymore. Liam may have been dumb enough to buy the fake wholesome thing for a while. He’s pretty but he seems dumb as a brick, he’s like the Gen Y Keanu and I do love Keanu.
I think she looks good – I like her hair. She has developed a individual unique look for which I commend her.
I like the front of the dress but not the back.
I still dont like her tattoos.
Does she have her engagement ring on in that photo – I cant tell.
For some reason, I thought she looked like Ellen Degeneres in the first pic!
I think the issue is not just the hair. Her whole “punk rock rebel” attitude is very different from the girl Liam fell for. She’s giving off a hard,masculine energy these days. That’s what will push men away, unless they’re drawn to women with a butch aesthetic.
Of course you can have short hair and still be very feminine. Hair length isn’t the issue; the changing dynamic between them is.
Yes, and the fact that she’s flirting with both men AND women – maybe she’s the one who broke it off so she could date women?
Very much agree. I’m surprised so many people are bitching that Liam would ‘cheat’ on Miley for cutting her hair. Huh?? First, he might not have even cheated… they may have broken up. Second, if they broke it off, I highly doubt it is JUST because she changed her look.
I really think Miley pulled herself together when she was with him. I thought she even looked elegant in some of the photos. Maybe she was trying very hard to be something she wasn’t, and finally stopped. If that is the case, it is hardly his fault.
Believe me, Miley is nowhere near being “butch”. Not even close.
Since all signs point to them having broken up, the fact they’ve been apart for weeks now (when before she used to follow him like a puppy on his film sets) isn’t weird.
And likewise, no one here did anything wrong. They’re single and mingling. Better they do this now than after a wedding. Miley’s been off the rails for a while. No one should blame Liam if he decided she’s not the one he proposed to.
And for the record, nothing Miley is doing or wearing is “punk’. Punks never wore $3000 outfits.
Yeah, it looks like they broke up or at least stopped being so “together” weeks ago. I’m sure if someone bothered to look it up, their pap pics have been mostly solo lately.
I don’t think people should be looking to one or the other to blame right now. We all knew they were too young to be getting engaged. Which also means they’re too young to know any better and might just get back together again at some point. They’ve done it before.
“And for the record, nothing Miley is doing or wearing is “punk’.”
^ Uh huh!
Agreed. I think they broke up and he is single and mingling. I would hit it in a heartbeat.
I don’t get why so many of you all are ASSUMING that he cheated. Maybe they’re done and he’s free to pork whomever he wishes, in which case why not a gorgeous older woman who can teach him a thing or two? I have no hate for either Liam or January.
By the way, Miley not only deleted the tweet that the article references, she also deleted one in which she referred to him as “My Liam”. Wish I had taken a page pic so I could prove this.
Both just to young to be engaged. The end. Just cut it now you dopey twenty something’s.
I’m going to guess that they got engaged in that phase when you worship the ground your partner walks on, sex solves all your issues and all their idiosyncrasies seem like adorable little quirks.
Fast forward 12-18 months, the sexual haze lifts, those adorable little quirks become like bamboo splinters under your fingernails and you start musing on how easy it would be to kill them in their sleep. Multiply that by “how annoying you think Miley Cyrus is and you don’t have to live with her” and it’s no surprise that he’s trying to erase the memories with the closest available vagina.
The hair is purely incidental.
Love everything about this comment. <3 Probably closer to the truth than anything printed in Star or US Weekly.
Awesome comment Tapioca! I also think it has a lot to do with their careers. When they got together,Miley was more famous and doing various projects. Now, he is getting up there for his roles too and it can be hard on a relationship when the balance of fame is thrown off.
Also, in response to him “hating” her hair, I think people in relationships can agree that sometimes it’s not about what your significant other does with their body but how it makes them feel. Maybe she’s just not happy in the same way she was when they first got together and all her hair changing and weight loss are symptoms of her current state of mind. Maybe that’s a factor in all of this too. This is just pure spectulation on my part though.
+1
If the hair isn’t incidental, then it’s certainly symptomatic of the larger issue you have alluded to.
^^^ Truth! Plus their youth/immaturity/inexperience too.
Hi Tapioca! Love your comment – made me laugh out loud! (And I needed a LOL at work this morning! so thanks!)
If you are mature enough, you realize a person changes things up, styles change (good or bad), and looks different thru the years, just as they do. That is one of the for better or worse (for those that are vain anyway). However, if your mature enough to actually commit yourself honestly& purely to someone..you love the being, their essence not just the outer trimmings (but celebrities tend to forget that.
If he couldn’t handle her style changes his vanity clearly overshadows maturity & understanding of what loving a person means & Miley is better off w/o him. I LOVE Miley’s fun & funky look. She stands out & doesn’t look like most of the Hollywood orange skinned, hair over extentioned, and cookie cutter crowd! Just know from my nieces experience at that age going thru the same thing… It hurts & I hope that pain doesn’t spiral her back to cutting….
I seriously don’t think that’s the reason they started having problems. That’s just the tabloid version of a good celebrity break-up story.
On a style note, I’m perfectly ok with her hair, but (with the exception of this white gown) her clothing choices have been atrocious lately. Cheap dominatrix with a hint of hicktown hooker. He didn’t seem to care about that so I really don’t think the hair was an issue.
Even if it’s the clothing, it’s a phase. If that’s a reason to break up, then he didn’t love her..he loved the image. Yes, there are boys that are vain enough to leave because someone changed a hair color, style, or taste in clothing… To me that is a shallow person and loved an image of the other person, not the true person themselves. Miley is young & experimenting..bet in a year or two she will have an entirely different look. I’m just saying IF those were the reasons, she deserves someone less shallow.
But what if you learn that their essence is as crazy as a sack of cats?
^^This. I can’t believe so many people think they broke up (or he cheated) because she changed her style up. Seriously?? There are obviously bigger issues, and just because all we see is the ‘style change’ in Miley doesn’t mean that is all there is to it.
Her drastic style change shows more a lack of knowing herself yet, and a lack of maturity to me. She has no clue who she is, she’s searching for her identity, she’s not a fully formed person yet. She shouldn’t be engaged, because her fiance got together with one girl, and that girl looked and acted a whole lot different than the girl she is now. Miley has changed, we can all see it, and change is hard on some people and can be hard on relationships, especially when you’re young.
Changing ones style isn’t a lack of maturity. I’m a brunette now, look & dress totally different than the dyed blonde my spouse married 18 years ago. Granted at her age it’s more expected & she is more than likely trying to find her own identity. I have 2 sisters and a niece all mature & responsible that have just made major life changes. It’s called living. Now I agree they BOTH are too young to marry. I’m just saying if looks were a big part of it then it is kind of shallow. Example my ex has a type & heaven forbid you changed anything (though I always change up my look, hair color, style especially in my 20’s & 30’s). That’s superficial to me especially knowing one mixes things up). First
time I changed hair color w/ my spouse I asked what he thought..he said he liked both, he was not in a relationship w/ my hair or clothes. Smart man, may be why it’s been 18 strong years. I dont see a young couple like this w/ that kind of maturity yet. Especially if looks is a deal breaker. I think it’s more an age thing.. And what Tapioca said above hit the nail on the head.
Everything Green Eyes said.
I mean come on…most of us play around with and switch up our style. It’s not symptomatic of some greater concern, but simply a fun female prerogative.
Miley didn’t simply change her hair color. Hair color? Come on, she changed every single physical aspect of her appearance, including her body. She changed everything! That shows me someone who wasn’t comfortable or isn’t comfortable in her own skin and is trying to find her skin. That is something that comes with maturity. It is. Now playing with looks is something we all do, and that is not at all what I was talking about.
I actually don’t hate the idea of a Liam-January hookup. They just seem like an unexpected couple. What in the world would they even have conversations about??
That said, I really hope that the “Liam hates her short haircut” thing was made up by the tabloids. Because that’s a George Costanza-like reason to be breaking up with someone. Unless Liam was over Miley a long time ago and that’s just his quote-unquote excuse.
I don’t see anyone in this triangle as capable of conversations.
I never saw Liam and Miley together. She just seems like such a kid and he seems like a GQ kind of “man”, even though they aren’t that far apart in age. I see him with someone a little less “teen angsty” like a Jennifer Lawrence or a younger Rachel McAdams. Miley just strikes me as a kid who got a lot of money early on and isn’t quite sure where to go from here so she’s doing shlt any typical 19 year old would do. Chopping hair and piercing things and tattoos and all that…. which is fine, I just think these two seemed very different.
+1 I never got them as a couple… at all.
I love Miley’s look in these photos! She is so cute. They are so young and I believe they are probably too young to marry. They should be out having fun and flirting at their age. At 20, you should be experimenting with your looks because you can get away with it. HAVE A GOOD TIME! BUT if they are in love and want to get married so be it. Their behavior of late is so strange and leads me to believe they have broken up or are on a “break”. But why all the secrecy??
Yeah I’m with everyone here who says the hairstyle change isn’t the problem. He probably didn’t like the way she was behaving. Not blaming her at all, actually. He knew what he was getting himself into, as did she. Maybe they both felt they could “save” each other? It happens a lot.
And from what I heard, she’s cheated on him too. I don’t think they’re too young to be engaged. Age is just a number. I believe they are too immature, too self-absorbed, and too needy to be engaged. Get to know yourself as a person before you step into the role of husband or wife.
Hi guys…I am thinking the same thing like@Miley C. better get out of that relationship now as early,but guys remember this,it’s not in amillion years gonna happen for a simple reason…THE ARE BOUND BY DESTINY FOR LIFE,no matter what is happening now & inthe future & THEY CANNOT HELP NEITHER WE…
P.S just watch them now & inthe future to know what i’m talking about…
I know she gets a lot of love on here, and I don’t dislike her, but I think she’s a famewhore and a try-hard. I think she may be bisexual or gay; she’s trying to find her identity. Maybe not. But at any rate, wtf is she doing at Elton’s party? What are you thinkin, Elton, you had Kim K there , too! You’re sinking into pure pop culture.
If they were at separate events and both were “acting” single then perhaps the rift happened earlier?? Seems like they may have had a fight or something and both went off to do their thing alone. Perhaps Liam thought they “were on a break”. LOL!
LOL… if that was a Friends reference! If not, I’m still laughing because the ‘we were on a break’ stuff was so funny on Friends. 😉
I feel sorry for both of them though cheating is cheating. As for Miley, you’ve got to love yourself first before you can be loved. If you hate yourself, you’re just going to alienate the world and potential happiness. That’s just how it is. Sometimes you’ve got to rescue yourself first.
I feel sorry for both of them though cheating is cheating. As for Miley, you’ve got to love yourself first before you can be loved. If you hate yourself, you’re just going to alienate the world and potential happiness. That’s just how it is. Sometimes you’ve got to rescue yourself first. Having said that, it’s not easy growing up in showbiz so though I ain’t a fan, wish her the best.
Hope for the best. I actually like these two together
I had a guy break up with me over a haircut once. I acted as a hair model and they took it from below the shoulder to ear-level. I was in college and waiting tables and when I told this Russian guy I worked with about the break-up, his response was “can you blame him after you violated your hair like that?” in his really heavy accent. There was something so honest about it I barked out in laughter.
That’s a cute story-I mean cute the way that guy phrased it 🙂
Man, these stories are coming at a bad time for me-I took about 3 inches off my hair today. It’s still past my shoulders, but not halfway down my back anymore 🙁
When I was getting my hair trimmed, my hairdresser was telling me stories about the girls that she creates hairpieces for (they suffer from trichotillomania) and it just reminded me how thankful I should be just to have hair-who gives a shit about the length?
It’s just hair-it’ll grow back for most of us. These poor girls get hair pieces and extensions to fill in their bald patches and they pull THEM out. It’s really really sad…awful.
I loved that guy. I think he might have included an “I mean, I would still have you” in there or something.
But, in all of their defenses, I did kind of resemble a Q-tip when all was said and done. I had very thick, wavy hair and the stylist cut it at the bend (or break, can’t remember) – it was gone. The guy that dumped me was a summer fling so the heartbreak was minimal.
I just cut 4 inches off my hair two weeks ago. It is barely touching my shoulders now. Mr. Rochester loves it (don’t tell Kaiser – I am flat-ironing it.)
I am sure you are rocking the look. It’ll be easier for the summer.
I’m not familiar with which admin it is that hates bangs, but I keep them because I have a dent in my forehead due to a former injury. Every time I read about the fringe hate I’m glad that I’m not a celebrity being covered by this site. I also flat-iron my hair sometimes. 🙂
She hangs around with too many weirdos and has too many pets and the parents are next door.. Moses with her stripper pole, her bugged eyed mom, and Trace Cyrus stalking about the property, their old home.. gross persons or things of a nightmare and any kids they might have could look like this.. wheezin.. grinnin’ sayin’ ‘Yo.. Love me tatt’s?”. would creep me out too.
I think I have said this already on other threads, but I would highly disagree that it is “just a haircut.” There is a difference between cutting your hair and completely changing who you are. She has done the latter.
Totally agree. She has become/is becoming an entirely different person. He fell in love with a different being altogether.
I have two theories about this break-up. The cynical side of me believes that she was always just a rung on his career ladder and that he was never really into her. I say that because the disgusting annoying person she used to be could not possibly have been attractive to anyone other than a user who was seeking to make it in Hollywood. To be fair, she has toned it down a lot since SNL started making fun of her. But she is just as annoying and attention-seeking on twitter.
My other theory is that it has to do with her pot-smoking and his concern about his image. Someone looking exactly like Miley recently posted a pic of her smoking pot on Instagram. She got some heat for it and then went to twitter to say that she doesn’t have Instagram. Folks pointed out that she never denied that the pic was her. Maybe it was a last straw for Liam as he is trying to ride on the Hunger Games and build a solid career. Maybe his people told him she had to go.
i bet trashy miley gets a new tattoo to show how over him she is. you know those things are so necessary to prove in such a way.
Miley looks gorgeous!
People are suddenly saying she’s gay or bi.
Really? What changed? Oh yeah- her hair cut. So now if a chick cuts her hair short, she’s gay or bi. *eye roll*
Some people need to get out more.
I kid you not, my mom refuses to wear her hair short for fear of being labeled *whispers* a lesbian.. (I only did this because that’s how my mom says it to me, as if she will offend a gay woman by calling her a lesbian) which is sad because my mom looks really cute with a shorter do.. I’ve had mine as short as Miley’s before (shorter actually cause of the curls and had to put a relaxer in it) but anyway I really liked the hair, so quick to get ready..
Ha ha..that’s hilarious, marie. Gotta love the moms. My mom lives in a smilar bubble but she does have shortER hair.
@happymom-I kissed a girl when I was in my twenties but that doesn’t mean Dong isn’t still my religion. I mean come on..
The blurb states she was flirting with men and women.
So many comments about Miley not having a stable self-identity (or something like that). This makes me wonder: Did any of YOU out in comment land know who YOU were by 20 years old? My question is a sincere one.
Personally, I was a totally self-absorbed moron at 20 years old and no, I had NO idea who I was. I spent most of my twenties like that, actually.
That’s why I don’t get the KStew hate so much–even though I’m not particularly fond of her, she’s just a kid to me. When my mother was 22, she was married and then had me a year or so later. People today tend to wait longer about marriage and, I think, take longer to grow up. I’d hate to be judged on how I acted in my twenties. Hell, even my thirties.
I think a lot of the concern about Miley not being stable has to do with the cutting. That is serious, and not normal or okay for anyone, at any age.
I’m normally not a big fan of Miley’s but I think she looks great in these shots.
She cheated so he cheated. It won’t last because January is a skank and it’s probably just for sex but he’ll keep looking for someone faithful.
“Miley’s an embarrassment” says the source.
SO harsh. Honestly. I think she looks great with the short cut and she’s nothing close to an embarrassment. Douche quote by the “source”.
Maybe it’s not just abt the hair… If she changed the way she dressed and all so drastically we may also suppose that she also changed a bit mentally and that he “saw” in the new her something he didn’t like anymore…
After, it has nothing to do with him cheating on her. He should have broke it off if he felt so embarrassed by her. He could just have been a “cool” guy and recognized he wasn’t the guy for her!
I have honestly felt that Miley’s appearance change is no coincidence. It happened pretty much just after she got engaged. Surely we all know what this is? It’s a soul protest. Her soul isn’t comfortable with this arrangement, and is subconsciously rebelling and even trying to repel him. She is too young to be getting married – pure and simple. She isn’t the “sort” to do that. She needs to spread her wings a bit and live more before making that committment. Sad, that her repellant image change is a reaction to a catalyst of soul disapproval.
I’be thought that very thing. This really is a great look for her. Now if she would only PLEASE GOD unhunch her shoulders her new fabulous look would be complete!
Good_as_Gold that’s an interesting theory.
I have never liked Miley but I think she is looking really good lately even if he doesn’t think so.
This is more than a minor change. For somebody who used to have such a feminine look, this is a drastic change. Don’t get me wrong, there are women out there who can pull off this look: Pink, various punk rockers etc., but in all honesty, it just doesn’t seem Miley. It seems a subconscious rebellion to me, and then the image change was followed by weird tweets, insecurities, confusion and lots of self-doubt and doubt about their relationship before glossing it all over and pretending nothing was wrong. No doubt about it – it all points to alarm bells. The girl is not ready for this.
It was a huge change for her! I personally loved her short bob do! The chin length bob was adorable on her! She’s young, she’s experimenting, it’s normal! Hopefully Liam accepts her for who she is and not based on her appearance! They are or “were” a cute couple!
I agree. She is also out of control. I know she is old enough to make decisions for herself, but she is just running amuck and doing as she pleases without any thought to the consequences of her actions. I seriously do not see what Liam sees in her to begin with. Her new punk rock look is just not working for her—but against her.
gotta disagree. She probably wanted to go punk for a long time, but couldn’t bc of Hanna Montana. She’s a kid – if you’re gonna experiment – nows the time. I think she looks great. Out of control would be getting wasted and running over photographers and getting in bar fights (ahem, Cracken). Would suck to grow up in the spotlight, I think she’s handling it remarkably well.
How on earth is she “out of control and running amuck”? She seems very comfortable in her skin to me. I love the short hair.
agreed!
Really??? Have you seen any of the strange pictures of her lately? The cutting marks on her wrists???? The doped out looks on her face?? Dancing with strippers??? I’ll stop there.
Her hair looks much better grown out! You can see her natural hair color with the blonde! It looks much better! Love the look!
I’ve always hated dark brows with blonde hair! Looks tacky IMO!
They’re so young anyway and they are both in a business where it would be so much fun to play the field, especially when young. I doubt Miley is going to lose too much sleep over this–these pictures of her do not present the face of a girl who is going to cry in her bong over a guy for more than a minute or two.
From the last video I saw of Miley at the airport she really looked like she’s been doing coke.
January Jones is the embarrassment – always messing with married or taken men. She should be the one bloggers and media are shaming.
First off, her Twitter isn’t dark, and the”I won’t break” was in reference to leaking new music.
Second, Liam spoke several times about loving her haircut, even last week. Yes, he most likely cheated, but where’s mention that the rarely seen, married oldest Hemsworth, Luke, was also in the car w/ January and Liam?
It has nothing to do with her short hair cut but the truth is, Miley is gay. (I know. For a fact.)
Honestly I don’t know why people have such a hard time with that, or why anyone would care. But it’s true. And we should just let her be gay and fabulous and stop with the bearding. Same for Liam if that’s true for him.
She’s beautiful, young, and gay. Everyone needs to get over the issue altogether.
There is definitely something fishy, I read her “I won’t break” tweet as well, and 2,3 days before that, she tweeted something along the lines of “He looks like my Liam..”, with both tweets being gone now.
Wow. I’m really late for the party (no pun intended).
I personally don’t like Miley (she’s always gotten on my last nerve for some reason), But I don’t wish her any ill-will or anything.
I really don’t care for the haircut/color on her, but at least she’s out there rocking it. (It always reminds me of a longer version of what Annie Lennox’s hair used to look like xD But she totally rocked too.)
Others have mentioned cutting scars on her wrist. I truly hope they aren’t true (I can’t actually see them in these shots, maybe I’m just tired.)
Ugh, I can’t believe I’m defending Miley Cyrus, but Jeez. Lay off (not everyone here, but a few). Maybe it was even a *publicity stunt* meant to gain attention before either or both are releasing new work, or something. I have no friggin clue.
Miley is so fug
If he’s lost interest because of her changing style, fair enough. She seems to be trying on new identities, which suggests she’s still growing up – hence too young to be engaged anyway!
She’s too young to settle down and so is he they haven’t lived life single enough yet which is exactly why he “acts” single when he’s not around it is a clear indication someone is not ready to be tied down