Julia Roberts’ sister allegedly timed her suicide to hurt Julia’s Oscar bid

robertsaugust1_edited-1
If this story was some tabloid invention, or a possibly made up interview, I would have skipped it. We’re talking about someone’s death, and it’s a sensitive issue. But this interview is a legitimate one, on the record, with Nancy Motes’ fiance’s brother. Nancy, Julia Roberts’ half-sister, was found dead at the home of her pet sitting client on Sunday. The coroner confirmed that a suicide note was found and that there were prescription and illegal drugs at the scene. Additional sources claimed that Nancy’s note was five pages long and that the majority of it described her strained relationship with Julia Roberts. Nancy also allegedly apologized to her mother and to her fiance in her note.

Now Nancy’s fiance’s brother, Conner Dilbeck, has given statements to The Daily Mail saying that Nancy timed her suicide to interfere with Julia’s Oscar campaign, and that she intended to send a message to the public about Julia. Dilbeck confirmed that the suicide note implicated Julia, but said on Facebook that it was eight pages, not five. It’s all very sad and chilling. Here’s Conner’s brief interview:

Julia Roberts’ half-sister may have killed herself in a deliberate attempt to harm the actress’ career and scupper her chances of winning an Oscar at this year’s Academy Awards, her fiance’s brother claimed today.

Nancy Motes took an overdose after writing a suicide note which allegedly contained dark secrets about the Pretty Woman star that she wanted to be made public, said Conner Dilbeck in an exclusive interview with MailOnline.

Nancy’s fiance John Dilbeck, Conner’s own brother, found her dead body in the bath Sunday, the same day Julia was due to be at an Oscar nominees lunch. She is up for Best Supporting Actress for August: Osage County.

‘We are talking about people who are powerful,’ Conner told MailOnline.

‘People who have very delicate power, people who are in the limelight. Their power can be destroyed very easily if unfortunate things make them look more wicked.

‘They have to be careful, it can destroy their career or their Academy Award.’

[From The Daily Mail]

On Facebook, Conner co-signed this other Mail interview with Nancy’s friend, her apartment manager John Fraschetti. Frachetti also did an interview with Inside Edition in which he defended Nancy, and said that the story of Nancy’s death was not of an addict killing herself, but of a woman with problems who “didn’t know where to go.” Fraschetti claimed that Nancy’s mother and her half-sister, Julia Roberts, drove her to this by rejecting her for the last six months. Here’s some of what he said:

Nancy Motes, the half-sister of Julia Roberts was driven to take her own life by her uncaring family who are now ‘crying crocodile tears’ over her tragic death, a close friend claimed today.

John Fraschetti, who knows Nancy’s grieving fiancé, John Dilbeck, claims the family of the Oscar winner are now only interested in manipulating public opinion after her suicide, but during her life, ‘drove her to death.’

Making the incendiary comments today outside Nancy and Dilbeck’s home, Fraschetti said that Nancy spiraled into depression after her and Roberts’ mother, Betty Lou Motes, ‘rejected’ her six months ago – and that she ‘just couldn’t handle it anymore’.

‘And then you get the actress woman who is pretending to grieve but she didn’t want to deal with Nancy and made her f***ing miserable.’

Fraschetti, who has known Dilbeck since he was 13, said that since her death, her family have been careful to mold a favorable public reaction.

‘They are crying crocodile tears. They have taken control of this situation, but they never cared of her when she was alive,’ said Fraschetti.

Labeling them ‘a family that drove her to death’, Fraschetti said that Nancy, ‘couldn’t stand the rejection of her mom, who in the last six months had cut her off entirely.’

‘It hurt her that none of her family wanted to be with her. She had a miserable Christmas, truly awful, and I think she just couldn’t handle it anymore.’

Fraschetti admitted that Nancy’s well-documented problems with drugs and her weight had caused divisions, but claimed that to cut her off was unforgivable.

‘They didn’t care when she was alive. She was a handful, and yes she had her problems, but there’s a way to deal with your relatives,’ said an angry Fraschetti.

Nancy’s suicide note also reveals the true depths of depression that her family’s rejection had sent her to.

‘It read about how much she loved and cared for her fiancé and how happy he made her, but it also said how unhappy and depressed her family made her and how she couldn’t cope anymore,’ said Fraschetti, who said that fiancé, Dilbeck, is grief stricken by Nancy’s death and can’t face the media.

[From The Daily Mail]

Fraschetti went on to say that we shouldn’t judge Nancy by how she chose to commit suicide. “I wouldn’t read too much into where she did it, it wasn’t in some drug den. She was dog sitting, and I imagine she did this, so she didn’t have to do it at home and let John find her.

Assuming all this is true, that Nancy somehow thought that she would affect Julia’s Oscar chances, and her career, by killing herself, I just feel sad and sorry for her family. Whatever happened between Nancy, Julia and her mother, this is something that Nancy is wholly responsible for, and that she paid the ultimate price for. This isn’t going to change any Oscar votes. Julia doesn’t have a chance to win anyway, as cynical as that sounds. When an adult kills themselves, and particularly when there are drugs involved, the narrative often changes to implicate the suicide victim. I’m not saying that’s right or wrong, and I do feel for Nancy’s family, it’s just that the severity and finality of that act tends to nullify anything the person has to say.

nancymotesheader (1)

robertsaugust2_edited-1

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

123 Responses to “Julia Roberts’ sister allegedly timed her suicide to hurt Julia’s Oscar bid”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Susie says:

    yikes! I wonder if Julia will say anything?

    • Marianne says:

      If she does, she should probably say that she’s sorry that her sister struggled with her demons…..but I dont think she should say much else.

      • springingforward says:

        Julia is a fr***king b*tch, but no one believes that she is responsible for her half sister’s suicide. Again, Julia Roberts is a massive b*tch.

    • paola says:

      I don’t think she will say anything. She would have said something already. I think she is mourning in her own way and she owes no explanations to anyone. It should be private. Actually all this should be private.

      • Kiddo says:

        I agree. Normally suicides aren’t even reported as news, it’s usually off limits. I think the only reason this getting play is because her sister is famous. But I don’t think it’s right to release the contents of a suicide note unless it somehow reveals a crime.

  2. Kiddo says:

    Sounds like someone is angling for a paid story in the NE or Radar Online.

    And this:

    “People who have very delicate power, people who are in the limelight. Their power can be destroyed very easily if unfortunate things make them look more wicked.

    ‘They have to be careful, it can destroy their career or their Academy Award”.

    ….almost sounds like a veiled threat to release some other dirty information.

    • Esmom says:

      Yeah it seems like Nancy surrounded herself with shady people who likely encouraged her to exploit her relationship with Julia for their own gain. So incredibly tragic.

    • fairy godmother says:

      I do not believe this spin at all- since Julia has already won an Oscar. It is fairly narrow minded to center sympathy for a bully who had taunted a sister. It was hurtful and taken to heart. Shame on Julia and her PR. The woman’s bf came out stating she was not a drug addict- so who knows for sure, but negative words to someone you love can sting for a lifetime.
      p.s. I saw the movie and imo the only outstanding performance was none other than the extraordinary Meryl Streep!

      • laura says:

        I so agree with you @fairy godmother. And I am shocked to read all the comments stating how julia roberts half sister is an addict, mean spirited, how she was jealous. Julia Roberts is not a nice, caring selfless woman…She is the opposite actually!

      • minime says:

        This one “friend” says something else:
        “Fraschetti admitted that Nancy’s well-documented problems with drugs and her weight had caused divisions, but claimed that to cut her off was unforgivable.”

        I think this is a seriously sad story with a horrible ending and people involved should shut the f*** up. Nancy certainly was struggling with some serious psychological condition and no one really knows what went down with her family. Family ties are complex and it’s really not fair to judge in a moment like this. I have to agree with the last sentence of Celebitchy: “it’s just that the severity and finality of that act tends to nullify anything the person has to say.” It’s extremely sad that this was the pathway she chose.

      • seven says:

        Totally agree with your assessment. My heart breaks for nancy and i dont even know her because she had to be in tremendous pain to do something so extreme. I do hold julia responsible partially in her sister’s suicide. She was crying out and she turned her back on her own flesh and blood. Its not for me or anyone to judge her but I cant help that I cannot stand julia now. So far as nancys extended friend family– they have every right to vocalize Nancy’s truth imo because they were the closest thing she had to a family while she was alive. R.I.P. sunflower

      • Kiddo says:

        If there is evidence that Julia did something malicious to her sister with the intent to drive her to suicide or to create great harm, I would need to see that before casting judgements on her. She didn’t murder her sister, so making this blame fall squarely on her shoulders is unfair. If we are to blame her for not getting adequate help for her sister in order to stop her from this desperate act, then we can also blame her friends, who seem to be blaming others, because they were the closest to this woman at the end.

        In reality, one person took her own life.

      • Sugar says:

        @Seven-

        “I do hold julia responsible partially in her sister’s suicide. She was crying out and she turned her back on her own flesh and blood.”

        How can you know if any of what you said is true? Who knows what this landlord and purported friend’s motive for saying these things is? Is what he says true? We have no way of knowing but we do know that being even tangentially connected to fame makes people do unseemly things, and this guy was probably paid for his story.

        I dislike Julia Roberts intensely. She’s superior and smug and I’m not defending her character. But she isn’t responsible for her sister’s death; her sister chose death. There’s no way to know whether the sister was “crying out ” to Julia and whether Julia turned her back on her. We should all stop speculating on something so truly tragic and quit assigning blame to anyone since we have exactly zero facts. Someone died; this isn’t an appropriate topic to bloviate about.

      • Lemon says:

        Completely ridiculous to “hold someone responsible” for another’s suicide, particularly in a case like this. The half sister seems to have had major issues herself. As a psychiatrist, and someone who works with suicidal people every single day, I feel very strongly that except in very rare and particular situations, the “responsibility” for suicide rests with the person who chose to take that path.

      • Aurie says:

        You’re disgusting, I’m sorry.

        John Dilbeck admits Julia had tried looking out for Nancy. In regards to the rehab rumors he said “she [Julia] mentioned it in passing” and then claims Nancy only used Marijuana, but considering Nancy was found with many prescription and non-prescription drugs, sounds like BS.

        He also admits Julia didn’t think much of him and thought he wasn’t good for Nancy.

        This is from JOHN HIMSELF. So basically he admits Julia was willing to pay for Nancy to go to rehab and thought Nancy deserved better than an unemployed loser like him.

        Does that sound like Julia hates Nancy and wants her to die? Geez.

        Not to mention John wants Nancy’s suicide letters addressed to Julia. What the f**k right does he have to pages/letter addressed to Julia? He already has a few pages left to him.

        Finally maybe you can explain why Julia helped Nancy get her glee job (Julia is friends with Ryan Murphy) and while Nancy was going “Julia abandoned our mother” while being primary caretaker in Georgia, they lived in a house paid for by Julia + expenses paid for by Julia.

        If you wanna think Julia is a b***h because of the A Low Vera T-shirt (which I agree with you), fine.

        But Julia, with her powerful PR, legal, and media team is NOT the one attacking Nancy in public like Nancy is doing to Julia. Julia helps Nancy get a job and then Nancy thanks her by trashing her THREE TIMES IN 2013 to NYDN, The Daily Mail, and to the Sun.

        WHY SHOULD JULIA KEEP HELPING SOMEONE WHO KEEPS TRYING TO ATTACK HER?

      • Nina W says:

        It’s absurd to blame a sibling for another person’s suicide. Suicide is a choice and if this poor woman killed herself it was her own doing. None of us know the true circumstances of this family but we do know a terrible tragedy has stricken them. People need to stop making ridiculous assumptions and giving credence to people selling stories to tabloids and have some compassion for every one involved. These are people with feelings not cardboard cut-outs. There are also other successful siblings in the family why no criticism for them? Because it’s unwarranted and gross.

    • Tara says:

      Yeah it does sound like a thinly veiled threat. Who does that? Wtf?!

  3. Marty says:

    This is just a sad situation all around. We really don’t know what went on between Nancy and her family, but it’s obvious she had been struggling for a long time.

  4. V4real says:

    May she finally find the peace in death that she couldn’t find while she was alive.

    Nancy we already knew Julia was a bitch but thanks for the confirmation.

    • bluepoppy says:

      My thoughts exactly.

    • Kimbob says:

      Couldn’t agree more w/what you just stated. X 1000! I do truly hope this tortured soul is now @ peace…I truly do. And yes, the internet has been flaming about what an ugly person Roberts is for a long time. It’s a damn shame she felt there were no other alternatives. She had more going for her than she knew….a fiancé who loved her….more than a lot of people can claim. An all around tragedy.

      • Christin says:

        Agree. It’s not as if she (or these alleged friends) needed to tell the world something that was already suspected for years.

    • FLORC says:

      Julianna Margulies said when she wass a struggling actress and waitress she waited on Julia Roberts. Said how Julia was an absolute b***h to her then. Just above an beyond. Julianna said when she met her as a peer she was perfectly lovely. That Julia is fine as long as you’re not a in the service industry.

      So, yea. We already knew she was mean spirited, but so does Hollywood.

    • Nina W says:

      Ok my last comment, I guess this is hitting too close to home cause everybody is working my nerves. I have encountered numerous bitches in my life, as have we all, and still managed not to end it all. I think it is all kinds of wrong to pin this on Julia and I think it is very flip and shallow and pop-psych to write this poor lady’s death off as some kind of referendum on her sister. Suicide is a terrible choice and a tragedy for any family.

  5. tifzlan says:

    Okay, i take back everything i said about this entire situation when the story first appeared on Celebitchy. This is sad and twisted and messed up and it’s even worse that this has to play out in the media/tabloids like this.

    • Latisse says:

      This is exactly what I suspected which is why honestly feel this woman’s suicide was a vindictive and selfish act. The whole situation including the unsavory characters now coming out of the woodwork is completely gross. Hopefully the academy pays absolutely no attention to this.

      • Lily says:

        Completely agree. Suicide is tricky ppl do it for various reasons mental health. Addiction. Etc

        But some (not all) do it out of spite. Its very sad, i hope she had a good support system around her and wasn’t struggling on her own and had access to help if she wanted it.

      • TG says:

        I agree @Latisse and I know my sentiments don’t fall in line with the PC crowd around here but I have no sympathy for this woman or any of her “friends” who are now speaking out against Julia. I don’t really like Julia and she probably is a royal b*tch but unless there is documented evidence of her doing something to cause her sister to commit suicide I am not buying their story. What is this about how Julia and her mom “cut her off”? Cut her off from what? Cash? Wasn’t her sister in her 30’s at least? It is not anyone’s responsibility to support someone else even if they do happen to be wealthy and a sibling of the other. If you can’t stand your family then don’t hang out with them. It is really that simple.

      • Tara says:

        Yeah, I have to admit you called it. I formally retract any b-tchy contrariness I put out there yesterday.

      • sauvage says:

        Yes. Some people actually go so far as to kill themselves out of spite and with the little information given as of yet, I’m leaning in that direction, opinionwise.

  6. paola says:

    It is indeed an unfortunate timing, but Julia has no chances against Lupita even if I loved her in Osage County.
    I’m not a big fan of her, I think she is fake and bitchy on many occasions but nobody deserves this. Her sister blames Julia for everything but you can’t fault other people if life didn’t turn out as you wanted it. If it’s true she killed herself to punish Julia is wrong on so many levels. You can’t feel happiness for other people’s failure, that is a toxic behaviour and as we witness now, it rarely ends well.

  7. TxGal says:

    I never liked JR. Never understood why people love her and consider her a Pretty Woman or America’s Sweetheart.

    • springingforward says:

      Agree. Pretty Woman is the most lamentable movie of a hooker-with-a-heart-of-gold ever made.
      Such drivel.

  8. Sandy says:

    The whole thing is a sad situation. The sister was not well mentally, and clearly needed help. Is Julia Roberts a “nice” person, or even nice to her blood relations? Probably not, and probably would not have been such a great sister, even if the facts were different. Julia Roberts is also not a good actress, but she is campaigning for an Oscar. And THIS story is part of her campaign for sympathy votes, the “don’t vote against me because my mentally ill sister was out to get me.” Jesus, shut the hell up. A human being is dead. Who cares about your Oscars!

    • Kimbob says:

      Yep…good point indeed! A life is lost…and the big talk is how it’s ruining Roberts’ chances of winning an Oscar? Ugh.

    • MrsB says:

      What makes you think these stories are coming from Julia to make her look sympathetic? There is absolutely no evidence of that. I don’t know how you connect interviews with Nancy’s friends to coming from Julia Roberts camp.

    • Aurie says:

      @Sandy, you tell Julia to shut up because no one cares about her Oscar chances? Maybe you should shut up about things you know nothing about.

      All this crap is coming from John Dilbeck + his brother, not Julia.

      Sorry if I come off forcefully but I’ve been in a similar situation to Julia and it pisses me off how you’re trying to blame Julia for things that there’s evidence against and evidence showing Nancy was one bitter, messed up person that Julia tried to help but ultimately decided she wanted to hurt Julia with her last evil act.

  9. MrsBPitt says:

    My heart breaks for all involved…I have a close family member who is a drug addict and counselors have suggested to the family that we try “tough love” and tell this person that we won’t be in their life until they give up the drugs…but, honestly, I can’t do it…I have too much fear that the person would kill themselves, either accidentally or on purpose, and then I would feel like I hadn’t tried enough. Maybe, Julia and her mother were told this same thing by counselors…they must feel horrible…

    • sputnik says:

      i’m sorry for your situation. it’s a tough thing to deal with an addict. you love them and want the best but it’s knowing what to do. we had similar issues with a family member many years ago, cutting off or institutionalising were both recommended but in the end we couldn’t bring ourselves to do it. it was a hard road for a few years but it did all work out. counselling helped us all.

      but i understand when people do try the tough love option. they don’t do it because they don’t care. obviously we don’t know about julia roberts or her family, but i don’t think you can automatically blame them. i feel horrible for them all.

    • Gia says:

      Cutting off a family member who is an addict is intervention 101. I in no way hold JR responsible. This woman was clearly ill and placed her sister onto some messed up pedestal. It’s sad she allowed her fame to effect her own life so much. And I in no way think a wealthy relative is obligated to shell out for a family members wedding. You’re a gown woman and man. Pay for your own damn wedding or keep it small. God that annoys me.

  10. dorothy says:

    This sounds like something Julia’s people put out to garner sympathy and votes.

    • Mel says:

      She doesn’t need added sympathy its more likely coming from her sisters friends who have been leaking all this info

    • Jayna says:

      It was the fiance’s brother, who lived with them, who gave the interview, with his photo and all. He was bashing Julia. How is that someone from Julia’s side?

    • Latisse says:

      Julia’s “people” did not put this out. The fiance’s brother and neighbor are giving interviews, what you read above are direct quotes.

    • JojoAnn says:

      Julia already has the public sympathy without having to spin this. People just dont expect survivors of a suicide to be responsible for another persons choices.

    • Megan says:

      OMG. I am no fan of Julia Roberts but that is crazy. First of all it is extremely obvious that Julia knows she isn’t going to win and is genuinely excited and happy for Lupita as she marches towards her win. I mean you can tell with Julia when she is fake gracious and genuine and she is genuine with Lupita.

      Honestly these so called “friends” of Nancy are losers, they are twisted opportunist and are using a death to get attention. Its been confirmed she was an addict, and honestly them turning their back on her might have been a last resort. Or they might be hateful people however, until we all deal with addicts, trying to help them and not being able to we have no room to judge.

      If these “friends’ loved Nancy they’d just mourn her quietly they wouldn’t be selling stories or going to the press.

    • GByeGirl says:

      Ummmm…no.

  11. Rick Stevens says:

    Julia Roberts is way overrated and full of herself.

    • laura says:

      Agreed 100/100. She is very jealous of other actresses who can ‘shade’ her…and try to seduce all the male actors.

  12. Renee28 says:

    It seems like Nancy and her fiancé blamed everyone for her problems but herself. Your family isn’t responsible for all your issues.

    • Delta Juliet says:

      I know lots of people like that. Nothing is their responsibility, everything is someone else’s fault. It’s exhausting.

      • littlestar says:

        I have several family members like that too, always crying that “no one helps me, no does anything for me” You’re an adult, help yourself already! I’m likely a terrible person, because I’m finding it really hard to have any empathy for Nancy.

    • laura says:

      How can you judge her? you were not there when she died, or witness what she went through. We do not know what drove her to this ultimate act of extreme desesperation…we do not know the relationship with her family and if she was truly an addict.

      • Renee28 says:

        Did you read the article? It clearly says the suicide note implicated Julia. Whatever her issues were she obviously blamed Julia and her mom for them.

      • laura says:

        Yes, I read the article! Do you truly believe everything you read? Media do manipulate the truth sometimes….

      • Aurie says:

        @Laura you obviously lack reading comprehension abilities then. The media used direct quotes from John Dilbeck, the fiancé. This isn’t a case of “according to a close source”. Also yes we know Nancy being a total b***h to Julia. After Julia helped her get a job on Glee (Julia is friends with Ryan Murphy) Nancy gave 3 interviews in 2013 to NYDN, The Sun, and The Daily Mail trashing Julia to high heavens blaming Julia for all her problems.

  13. OhDear says:

    Wow. Though I don’t see how Julia Roberts is responsible for her death? I’m not a fan of Roberts and Roberts doesn’t seem like the kindest person, but it sounds like the sister had a lot of problems and should have been getting help to deal with the problems.

  14. Kim1 says:

    Well Julia is well liked in Hollywood .Best buddies with Clooney,Hanks,Oprah,etc So if anything this family tragedy will garner her sympathy.She won’t win but it won’t her standing in Hollywood so if that was her troubled sister’s plan.Total Fail

  15. Birdie says:

    This is quite complex. It is wrong to fault others for your own suicide, as bitchy and evil Julia might have been, you can walk away and build your life the way you want it to be. You don’t have to involve toxic people in your life, but when drugs are involved everything gets worse, I guess.

  16. Neffie says:

    wow you would have to have some serious hatred for someone to kill YOURSELF just to spite them. Anyways RIP

    • Lee says:

      Yes, exactly. This is taking that expression “cutting off your own nose to spite someone else” to it’s ultimate conclusion.

  17. shelley says:

    I won’t feel pity for people who use suicide as a tool to punish people they feel have hurt them. That is vindictive and you end up being the loser.
    When dealing with addicts and destructive personalities, there comes a time for self preservation. I wouldn’t be so quick to paint Julia and her mother as evil people.

  18. dizzylucy says:

    My guess would be that Nancy’s problems/drug use were getting worse, and the mother cut her off in an attempt at tough love, which many families have to do. It’s really sad it ended this way, and the whole family seems difficult and dysfunctional, but I don’t think anyone else is to blame.
    And I have to agree, Julia isn’t in the running for that Oscar. I think she has the least chance of everyone on the list. I dislike her, but feel badly for her going through this, and all so publicly. I hope the family is able to find some peace.

  19. the original rachel says:

    I didn’t know anything about Nancy Motes before this, other than Julia Roberts had a sister and they didn’t get along. Now I know that Nancy Motes was manipulative to the point where she’d actually take her life to lash out at her sister. I have a relative who uses emotional blackmail regularly, and it’s not healthy, and it backfires because when you manipulate you lose all credibility. Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face: Nancy was probably thinking this would be the ultimate revenge on Julia: ultimately, she and her fiancé paid the price for all her bitterness. Like Carrie Fisher said: “Resentment is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.” She’s dead, Julia’s alive: what was the point of this? I’d never blame another for one person’s decision to end their own life. Your life is 100 percent your responsibility, whether you get along with your family or not, you’ve got to make it work. It will never work if you go around blaming other people for your problems. I have never been a fan of Julia Roberts, and believe that she is a bitch extraordinaire, but this actually makes her more sympathetic to me. That Nancy person now appears very sick and twisted to me: obsessed with getting something from her sister.

    • Mari says:

      Very well put, Original Rachel. Nancy’s was the ultimate act of emotional blackmail.

    • Andrea says:

      Your whole post is very well said.

      The other thing that gets me too is that she also killed herself at a client’s house? She was pet sitting and she killed herself while working to spite Julia?

    • sauvage says:

      @ the original rachel:

      A little correction: That phrase is actually attributed to Nelson Mandela. So if Carrie Fisher ever used it, she was quoting Mandela.

  20. Luca26 says:

    Yikes. The more that comes out the more I actually GULP feel bad for Julia. The people coming forward to speak on Nancy’s behalf sound like horrid opportunists. It almost sounds like they may have been aware of Nancy’s plans and carrying out revenge on her behalf.

  21. nicegirl says:

    Heartbreaking and painful. I wish them all peace.

  22. 3Katz says:

    I’ve been wondering if it was supposed to be a fake suicide attempt, left the note to get something out of JR then it went wrong.
    It might explain why she did it at someone’s house that JR knew. Whatever was in that note would get back to Julia Roberts.
    Or maybe I just can’t understand hating someone so much you take your own life.

  23. kibbles says:

    Sometimes you have to let people go who are unwilling to help themselves. This situation is quite common. Family members stop speaking to each other all the time. I don’t like to regularly see toxic family members. I’m cordial, but why would I allow that negativity to enter my life simply because we are related? Nancy wouldn’t have gone to the media about her weight problems and issues with Julia unless she craved the spotlight as well. She wanted to be famous but could never match her sister in fame, looks, or success. So, she resorted to selling negative stories about Julia to the press, attacking Julia on Twitter, and finally killing herself to derail Julia’s Oscar campaign. Whether or not Julia is a mean person isn’t the issue. Nancy was seriously troubled and bitter about Julia’s success. She became a victim or her own jealousy. At this point I don’t blame Julia or their mother for cutting off contact with Nancy. It sounds like she’d be a handful to deal with.

  24. bettyrose says:

    I’ve always thought it must be strange to be the sibling of a celeb … but plenty of every day folk have bad relationships with their families. And many people start new families and move on.

  25. LAK says:

    How does killing yourself to spite someone work? You aren’t here to enjoy the fruits of it?

    Which ever way you slice it, that is the most ridiculous reason for a suicide i’ve ever heard.

    Most suicides are at the end of their tether because life isn’t working for them, but to actively plan to kill yourself just to SPITE someone else??!!

    I’m sorry, I have no sympathy here. None.

    Suicide as an act of spite deserves none.

  26. Cecilia says:

    This situation is extremely sensitive. I read the following article this morning & it puts things more into perspective.

    http://www.bohomoth.com/2014/02/12/why-blaming-julia-roberts-for-her-half-sisters-suicide-is-wrong/

    • Kimbob says:

      Thanks for that link. I think that adds a new dimension to this whole scenario, actually. Also, I didn’t realize gastric lap band patients had such problems w/depression, and for me, the pieces of the puzzle are (possibly) beginning to come together. That very well could be the case…lack of, or no follow-up/follow-through of mental issues resulting from the surgery….wow. This seems very credible.

      • Cecilia says:

        I know, right Kimbob? It added an element to this that is very plausible but hadn’t occurred to me.

  27. Pancake Bacon says:

    Where is Eric in all of this? I know he was estranged from his mother over her second husband, Nancy’s father. (This added to Eric’s complications with Julia.)

    It’s sad all around.

    Off-topic: When he’s handed a good role, Eric is a way more wonderful actor than Julia. (And in his youth, he was a more striking beauty too!)

    • Katija says:

      I don’t know, but I’d hazard to guess that Emma isn’t losing any sleep over this.

      They seem like the most troubled family in Hollywood, honestly. They make the Jolie-Voights look normal.

    • Aurie says:

      @Pancake Julia was an innocent victim of Eric. Eric got arrested for illegal drug use and for attempting to assault a police officer. Later, he physically abused his wife and Julia sided with the wife and told Eric to keep away from her.

      Who in their right mind wants to deal with a woman abusing drug addict who most likely tried to squeeze cash out of Julia. Julia wanted what was best for Emma, who has said “Julia is my role model”.

      • Sullivan says:

        @aurie: I forgot about the drama Julia went through with Eric.

        I never thought the day would come that I would sympathize with Julia Roberts.

      • QueenHoa says:

        Thank you for clarifying this. I know a lot of people don’t like Julia Roberts but I just can’t believe she is a bad person at all. Yes a bitch at times but who isn’t? I can be the biggest bitch sometimes but that doesn’t make me a bad person. I think she is misunderstood and people can take things the wrong way if they don’t understand what is happening.

  28. GoodNamesAllTaken says:

    When I die, I hope that I am thinking of love and what the people in my life have given me, even the ones with whom I didn’t get along that well. I hope I am full of love and forgiveness and gratitude. How sad, how meaningless, to end your life filled with anger, pettiness and spite.

  29. Lara Morgana says:

    One of my co-workers had to cut her son from her life after years of his drug-abuse, his lying and his manipulation. It broke her heart to do it but he was literally wearing her down – mentally, emotionally, physically and financially. She tried everything to help him and struggled for years to get him on the right path. Last October she finally said “enough” and ended all communication with him.

    I saw what she went through. She was terrified that he would overdose or do something stupid because of her “cutting the cord”. But what choice did she have?

    Julia’s sister opted for a permanent solution to a temporary problem. She committed suicide out of spite…. the woman difinitely needed help. But when help is offered and refused what next?

    I feel so bad for Julia and her family…

  30. JuJuJen says:

    Just my two cents and take it for what it’s worth but reading between the lines, I see a girl who is an addict and a manipulator and likes to play the guilt card whenever possible. The article said that the family friend indicated she was a “handful” and “had her problems” and that’s a major indicator that she’s been doing this stuff for years and the family has finally had enough of it. I know about this stuff because I have a brother who has been a drunk for years and he always had a knack for manipulating all my brothers and parents into feeling sorry for him and that he was always the victim. How vindictive this girl was to commit suicide to get back at Julia and hurt her chances at an Oscar – and to place blame all over her repeatedly for HER decision to end her life. Not that I like Julia Roberts, I really could care less, but it speaks volumes about the half sister who did this for no other reason than spite. She was not playing with a full deck. I am very sorry for this family’s pain 🙁

  31. bobbisue says:

    Aloe Julia

  32. Jayna says:

    Someone posted on Radaronline that her fiance had a molestation or sexual abuse conviction and her family did not approve of him. I don’t know if that’s true or not.

    • Aurie says:

      It’s false. There’s someone with the same name who is a pedophile, but it’s not the John Dilbeck who is Nancy’s fiancé. That said, Nancy’s fiancé is a piece of work and even knowing about the A Low Vera T-Shirt, Julia looks really good compared to that unemployed loser (who voluntarily quit his job because he was having troubles and because Julia got Nancy a job at glee).

      http://www.homefacts.com/images/offenders/california/thumb/18604219I9906.jpg

      That above is the pedophile, who isn’t Nancy’s fiancé.

  33. MSat says:

    I have a younger brother who is bipolar with extreme rage issues, also an addict whose choice poisons are alcohol and oxycontin. He has attempted suicide at least three times that I know of and has been in and out of jail for years. He beat up his wife and physically and emotionally abused his children for years. But if you heard him talk about me and my family, you’d think we were the worst human beings on the planet. But the reality is, he has lied to, stolen from and threatened every one of us through the years and has burned every bridge. We made a decision to not allow him to come to family event,s or live with family members until he gets help, which he refuses to do. He’s currently on the run from the law for a domestic abuse conviction in which he held his ex-girlfriend hostage for 48 hours and threatened to stab her and her son if she left him. But you should see the stuff he puts out on the internet and the things he tells his low-life friends about us – that we’ve never been there for him, that we don’t care if he dies, blah blah blah.

    My point is, we don’t really know what happened at all.

  34. dorita says:

    Does anyone remember when America’s Sweethearts came out how people were snickering at how similar Julia and the character Catcher Zeta Jones was playing were? How funny it was that Julia must have gotten her inspiration from the way her sister Nancy dealt with the constant nastiness from Julia? Just putting that back out there since people’s memories seem to be a lot shorter these days. Julia Roberts is awful.

    • Aurie says:

      Nancy Motes was awful and emotionally blackmailed Julia. Nancy pulled so much crap on Julia, how can we blame Julia for striking back in private, compared to Nancy always trying to publicly humiliate Julia (3 interviews in 2013 to Sun, NYDN, The Daily Mail AFTER Julia got her a job on Glee). Nancy also admitted to one time screaming at Julia in front of other people because she THOUGHT, not knew, THOUGHT Julia was making fun of her.

      Nancy called Julia b***h amongst other names to the public and in front of other people. So my point is, who cares if Julia called her an obese loser, because while that’s not the mature response, if Nancy wants to hurt Julia, expect Julia to respond back like any normal person would.

    • emma says:

      Who knows what constant nastiness, griping, whininess Nancy gave to Julia? Maybe Julia gave her some back and Nancy would never forgive her, making Julia even more annoyed/disgusted/mean to her.

  35. Naomi says:

    What gets me is her fiancée & his family are complaining about Julia Roberts cruel treatment of her sister. They need to look at the fact that Nancy Motes committed suicide at a house where she was pet sitting because she didn’t want to hurt her fiancée by having him find her body at home. Nancy clearly had some issues that ran deeper than merely vindictiveness towards Julia. This whole situation is just sad.

  36. Karolina says:

    I don’t like Julia Roberts at all, but if her sister really had such an agenda this is truly horrible and sad. You are responsible for yourself and your own happiness. You cannot blame others for you shortcomings and failures. This is selfish, ignorant, pathetic and whiny. It fills me with disgust when people act like the world and everyone around them owns them something. Okay, this sounds super cliché, but this this woman was so immensely privileged and acknowledges it not one bit. She even found someone that apparently she loved and who loved her back. So many people never find any kind of love.

  37. JuJuBee says:

    I don’t think anyone can outright blame Julia for this, but we need to remember there is a lot of history between the two and this certainly wasn’t an overnight development. Nancy was the “weaker” of the two and was probably no match for Julia’s “strong” personality. I don’t doubt for a second that Julia probably lauded this over Nancy her entire life. Julia doesn’t come off as the humble type. Ultimately the decision was Nancy’s, but this should prove just how powerful our words are and how we treat people can be.

    • Aurie says:

      You mean like Nancy calling Julia a b***h to the public and in front of other people? Nancy gave three interviews in 2013 trashing Julia after Julia got her a job on Glee and admitting to screaming at Julia in front of other people because she THOUGHT (not knew) Julia was making fun of her. Maybe Nancy should have learned how her words might have affected Julia, although Julia classily chose to ignore all the interviews Nancy gave.

      If Julia was lording it over Nancy, Nancy should have stopped getting jobs from Julia, stopped expecting Julia to foot the bill + House when she was taking care of their mother, and stopped trying to take pics of Julia’s twins to possibly sell to the paps.

      Sorry I’m so invested in this, but I have a similar situation to Julia, and it pisses me off to hear people blame my mother and my uncles/aunts for the evil actions of the person who committed suicide (note I’m not saying committing suicide is evil in itself, but I’m saying it’s evil when they use that suicide to try to hurt people).

      • emma says:

        J may not be the nicest person, but I agree, it’s absolutely ridiculous to be “blaming” J. Especially, regardless of how “mean”, “cruel”, “indifferent” her sister was, that N gave so many interviews, constantly calling her out, it’s sounds more like N was a drama queen and J had to deal with it in her own way—and maybe coming off as a b. Definitely doesn’t seem like a legitimate reason to take your life, not that most reasons are I suppose, but could her life been that much agony that she couldn’t have ignored/moved on/become independent of the situation with her family? Or specifically, her sister?
        Whatever deep dark terrible things (I want to know!) that J did, unless it’s an insane campaign Scientol-o-gy style, I don’t think warrants this.

  38. Asiyah says:

    This is one of the most f*cked up things I’ve read in a while. *shutters*

  39. Shannon1972 says:

    Are the oscars really this important? All this tragedy surrounding a superficial entertainment awards show…Dylan Farrow’s timing is to hurt Cate and Woody at the Oscars. Julia Robert’s half sister takes her life to hurt Julia’s chances at an oscar. Who really cares THAT much about an award that it has become worth life itself? I cannot buy into that narrative, because that would imply that our society has hit rock bottom in extremely shallow waters.

    It’s absolutely ludicrous.

    • sugar says:

      I was thinking when i read the headline what a dark year for the oscars like a dark clioud has decended over this stupid event and for what? An award show that people excuse me “actors” have to campaign for to win. now the dirty laundry of 2 families has entwined into this event only when the last “and the winner is…” envelope is ripped open a women is still dead leaving an aftermath of pain for family & friends and a young woman is still fighting the machine of hollywood to get people to see the true nature of dad who will go on making movies.
      Sorry i didnt mean to take away from the main point of this thread. Its just bizare and sad this year.

  40. Nima1 says:

    Just another reason to despise Julia Roberts even more.

  41. Lilacflowers says:

    Julia Roberts seems to have problems with most of her family but something as tragic as this, people should just step back and keep it private.

    • Aurie says:

      @Lilac, I said this above, but Julia has perfectly legitimate reasons for distancing herself from Eric (arrested woman abusing drug addict) and Nancy (who loves selling interviews attacking Julia despite getting jobs and help from Julia).

  42. emma says:

    Again, I have to say, this is sad, but a grown person cannot continue to blame their family for their own lives. She probably had some serious issues, not because of drugs, because she sounds fairly dependent on this family.

  43. moo says:

    How horrible for Julia….. I hope she wins anyway!!! Excellent movie!!!
    People who want to kill themselves should have that right, but taking down other people with them makes them the biggest cowards I have ever heard of! This woman was basically insane, but just had to tell everyone it was someone else’s fault she couldn’t get help. Huh??? Say whaaaat????? Wow. That’s all I can say. Wow.

  44. Jayna says:

    I’m stunned by some of the people on here with their ugliness just because they can’t stand Julia. This is a woman that sold multiple stories last year trashing her sister. You expect Julia to accept that? Selling stories about you and trashing you to the press and world? I would pass on feeling warm and fuzzy or wanting to reconicle either. Sisters have stopped speaking to each for a lot less perceived slights for months on end. And then she sends out vile tweets. I’m not talking about tweets that show hurt. I am talking about trash, vile, filthy tweets to hurt Julia, a mission. And I just found it uncouth behavior and low rent. What 37-year-old woman behaves in such a way on twitter with the words she used? Then she decides that’s not enough. She will take her life just to show her and really make her feel guilty and really destroy my mom. And, hey, I will do it during the Oscar season so I will really ruin her good times and her chances. And the letter was to Julia and her sister combined, so I guess she was going to take down both of them. Killling yourself for a vindictive reason is beyond disturbing. Her mood swings towards her family for years must have been hard to deal with. Was Julia a shitty sister at times? I bet she was. It doesn’t make her worthy of a smear campaign for the last six months by a family member. And if it does you think, then don’t whine when that sister wants nothing to do with you as far as working out differences. She sounded like a professional martyr and victim, always everyone else’s fault, and feels sorry for herself all the time. And I’m sure her mooching fiance’ and his brother made it worse, egging her on. I would have had nothing to do with my sister for the last six months if she had been selling stories about me to publications bashing me, making disparaging remarks about me, making money off of me to do that, and then I’m sure there was far more behind the scenes.

    She is living with a moocher and his moocher brother. But oh people want to believe he’s this amazing fiance’. They will be selling stories for as long as they can. I am no big fan of Julia. Young Julia, yes, but not this age Julia and am no big fan of her personality at all. But get a grip, people.

  45. Catlady says:

    What a vile and selfish woman. Her suicide drama is bad enough, but what is even worse is she was dogsitting at the time. So what happened to the poor dog with nobody to take care of it and the owner gone? How many days did the poor dog go without food or water, or being walked or even let outside? To do that to an innocent animal is beyond heinous, not to mention her choosing to off herself in her client’s home. Good riddance AFAIC.

  46. TheCountess says:

    Julia Roberts is one of my least favorite celebrities but anyone who has ever dealt with a toxic family member eventually has to make the difficult decision to cut them loose. She cannot be responsible for her sister’s decision-making, her drug addiction or her other struggles if her sister was not willing to accept responsibility for herself.

    Toxic siblings are soul-suckers. If you don’t want to get dragged down with them, you need to leave them behind.

  47. sauvage says:

    You gotta be kidding me.

    “‘‘They didn’t care when she was alive. She was a handful, and yes she had her problems, but there’s a way to deal with your relatives,’ said an angry Fraschetti.” ??

    You gotta be kidding me.

    “Fraschetti went on to say that we shouldn’t judge Nancy by how she chose to commit suicide. “I wouldn’t read too much into where she did it, it wasn’t in some drug den. She was dog sitting, and I imagine she did this, so she didn’t have to do it at home and let John find her.”

    You gotta be kidding me.

    I don’t know about this situation in particular, but I’m sorry to burst your bubble, Mr Fraschetti – sometimes there is no other to way to deal with your relatives than to cut them out of your lives if you want to keep your sanity. There just isn’t. That whole “Blood is sicker than water.” thing is a myth. Sometimes the people you are related to simply aren’t healthy for you and that is a fact.

    So she killed herself at the house of someone whose dog she was taking care of in order to spare her fiance the turmoil of finding her? Insted she imposed this on somebody she had a work relationship with? YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME. There are other ways to make sure you’re found, but not by a loved one. She could have killed herself in her own bath, but laid out a note for him to find in the hallway, stating: “I killed myself in the bath, I don’t want you to see me, please call 911.” OR she could have done it in a hotel room and left a note right in front of the door as a first thing to see for the maid when they came in.

    Sorry: No. Just no.

  48. Vilodemeanus says:

    Well her sister’s death solidifies just how awful Julia is and the stories that the academy voters have heard and maybe not thought about can’t really be ignored if a sister was willing to die in order to prove what her sister really is with her own life. You can’t pretend that didn’t happen, no one can. This whole addict thing is pretty ridiculous, the woman had friends, was engaged and worked full time, an unhappy user, possibly but this was no junkie in a shooting gallery waiting to OD, this was a woman who truly felt that her sister was trying to destroy her life, and at the end she wanted to have some control. What a dysfunctional mess, I wonder how Julia’s mother feels about all of this, aside from her obvious heartbreak. I wonder…