Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop published medical advice from a ghost-whisperer

The Game Plan: Strategies for Entrepreneurs

I often wonder who Gwyneth Paltrow’s ideal Goop-consumer really is? The ideal Goop-consumer is obviously a white woman, probably in her 30s or 40s, possibly married, possibly divorced. I picture this ideal consumer as a blonde, obviously. Someone who either has family money or someone who is nouveau riche but wears it well. She will be no bigger than a size 6, preferably a size 2. Some plastic surgery alterations, but not too many. Someone who went to college, maybe, but would never really use her degree. There should be an air of gullible neediness about the consumer, because otherwise, the consumer wouldn’t be looking at Goop for medical advice.

I was trying to picture this ideal Goop consumer – who probably looks and acts a lot like Gwyneth – because who is buying Gwyneth’s horses–t at this point? You know there probably is someone out there with a jade egg stuck up her vajayjay as she burns her bras to rid herself of bad boyfriend vibes. Well, that consumer is about to have a new thing to do: consume more iodine. Goop published an article about “medical medium” Anthony William and his quest to get people to consume more iodine. You know why? Because he’s a MEDICAL MEDIUM. He talks to ghosts, and the ghosts are like “you guys should consume more iodine.” You can read the whole Goop post here – I feel like it would be irresponsible to actually quote from it.

This “don’t dismiss iodine, so says a ghost whisperer” story is just one of many bizarre pieces on Goop, obviously. Gwyneth’s whole thing is that she loves to embrace weird pseudo-science, as if following the advice of actual medical doctors is for mere peasants. Why speak to someone who went to medical school when you could get diet advice from a medium? Huffington Post got an actual doctor to write a scathing takedown of the Goop piece too – you can read the full piece here. It’s a very effective, informative and educational piece about why the body really does need iodine to function, but not in some weird pseudo-science, it-will-help-with-good-vibes way.

The TL; DR version is that while iodine deficiency is a real thing, almost everybody in the developed world gets enough iodine from food anyway, and if you’re eating food seasoned with half a teaspoon of iodized salt each day, you’re getting enough iodine in your diet. There’s also iodine in dairy, eggs, fish and meat. So medical doctors would have you believe! Then again, I get all of my dietary advice from ghosts.

The Game Plan: Strategies for Entrepreneurs

Photos courtesy of WENN.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

38 Responses to “Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop published medical advice from a ghost-whisperer”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Shambles says:

    She’s a snake oil saleswoman, and Donald Trump should probably just go ahead and adopt her.

    (Not saying she’s a Trump supporter. Just that she’s just as much of a crackpot con artist as he and his spawn are)

    • Slowsnow says:

      For sure. She swims in a pool of #alternativefacts, apparently earns money from it, seems thoroughly convinced she is a businesswoman and there isn’t an ounce of shame about it.

    • PaulY says:

      The legal disclaimer at the bottom of the page tells me everything I need to know:

      “The views expressed in this article intend to highlight alternative studies and induce conversation. They are the views of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of goop, and are for informational purposes only, even if and to the extent that this article features the advice of physicians and medical practitioners. This article is not, nor is it intended to be, a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment, and should never be relied upon for specific medical advice.”

      If only everything #45 does and says came with such belated honesty. 😀

  2. Slowsnow says:

    Maybe the ghost was a doctor who died too early and whose passion was to heal people?… 😜

    Please… I wanna know more about the ghost.

  3. smcollins says:

    Gwyneth, trying so hard to be a Revelutionary but failing on so many levels. Pretentiousness looks good on no one, no matter how you try to package it. Ugh…🙄

  4. huh says:

    She has got to be trolling.

  5. Sam says:

    Serious question. How is she still running this thing? I could have sworn I read that she was losing millions every year because of it. Does she like make money from the fact that the media reports on the bat shit crazy stuff on there?

    I’m just really confused by how it’s still a thing.

    • MrsBadBob says:

      I suspect it’s cheap enough for her to keep it going, regardless of actual profit, it’s most likely a vanity project for her.

  6. Ann says:

    I picture the ideal Goop consumer as Connie Britton’s version of Faye Resnick.

  7. Tray says:

    I dislike goop immensely. However this ghost thing is not really the truth, its bad reporting to catch people’s attention. You would need to read the real story of Anthony William’s life and how many people he has helped before you make comments or decisions.

    • paranormalgirl says:

      As a medical doctor, I feel qualified to make comments. Theresa Caputo has “helped” a great many people as well. I’m sure as hell not taking medical advice from the Long Island Medium.

  8. detritus says:

    I’m happier when she sticks to superstition, it’s easier for the lay reader to discern from actual science.
    That said, unless I see credentials, her ghost is just a health practitioner, and not a doctor. So back off and try again Gwynnie.

    Second thought, doctors from centuries past did all sorts of cool stuff, like not washing their hands, believing illness came from bad humours etc. Even if you did believe, why would you trust centuries old advice?

  9. OSTONE says:

    But most importantly, is the ghost blonde, a size 2 and did it use to live in the Hamptons? We can’t trust just any ghost! It has to be a goop approved ghost.

  10. Natalia says:

    Kaiser I always love your posts but this particular piece of writing is brilliant. It made me laugh so hard. 😂

  11. Svea says:

    Nothing wrong here. I do a tremendous amount of research on supplements. There is a consensus opinion agreeing with what the “medium” says: we all need to take extra iodine and zinc. This is endorsed by medical doctors and nutritionists. Just because you don’t believe that people have extraordinary abilities to tap into some kind of higher knowledge, ie Mr Edgar Cayce, doesn’t mean the information isn’t valid. Furthermore, I most seriously doubt the editors would publish information that hasn’t been medically veted. Finally I have a friend who consults medical intuitives all the time; they have helped her far more than Big Pharma pushing traditional medical doctors.

    • Who ARE These People? says:

      Her ‘editors’ have published all kinds of medically unsupported claims. She consults and promotes quacks.

      Where is the “consensus” published?

      Happy for your friend; if she should break a bone or be diagnosed with cancer, she will probably benefit enormously from modern medicine.

      • MC2 says:

        I agree with both comments and a broken arm is great at the hospital- black & white. If I had cancer then I’d go to a hospital as well. But it’s not an either/or and you can do both at the same time. If I had low level depression mixed with family history of low thyroid, coupled with a bad diet, low exercise then the traditional hospital might not be the best fit for care. I have seen women treated with more care, time, energy & not been forced into 10-min increments billed by insurance through non-western medicine. Some health issues are good for western medicine but are getting squeezed out and I value the health care practitioners in my area like acupuncturists, nutritionists, naturopaths and the like that take the time with patients to help them in a more holistic way. And these practitioners frequently advise to use them coupled with traditional medicine.

        ETA: There have been plenty of people who are helped by supplements & that is not faith based or silly. Some need them because they have other medical issues. Many traditional medical doctors recommend supplements which is why iodine was added to our table salt- it’s a supplement added since we weren’t getting from other foods. Now people use Kosher salt (people like Goop) and don’t get enough iodine.

    • MrsBadBob says:

      That argument is BS. It is not okay to take legitimate medical advice, which this is NOT, and repackage it as superstitious psycho-babble. Science is a process, not a faith based argument, and please stop pretending that screwing around with medical science is striking it to Big Pharma. Also, name these medical doctors and nutritionists of yours who are hawking these supplements, because every legitimate source I know recommends we get our nutrition from dietary sources not supplements of questionable value and equally questionable ingredients.

      • AnneC says:

        Exactly. Vitamin and supplements are a multi billion dollar industry with no FDA accountability. It’s the natural extension of carnival barkers selling “life saving potions” to gullible people in the 1800’s. Anything that tells me it’s detoxing me is a big no. So many scams, so many people willing to be suckered. Eat healthy, exercise, use your brain and get checkups. And thank god everyday you live in a first world country in the 21st century.

  12. neelyo says:

    My first thought upon seeing the header pic was ‘Ann Coulter must have done something truly hideous to rate a story here’.

    Step away from whatever it is you’re doing to your face, Ms. Paltrow.

  13. Juluho says:

    What if Gwen has no customers and the only way she makes money is as revenue from the high traffic her website gets after she goes full GOOP?

  14. S says:

    Does ANYone take ANYthing this vapid/delusional/self-important twit says OR does seriously???? Gaaaaackkk!¡!

  15. MC2 says:

    I am just going to put out there that our traditional, western medicine has not & does not pay attention to & accurately describe women’s health so only looking to other sources besides just ‘western doctors’ & that model is not a bad in itself. This article talks about the thyroid which is a subject that is not paid attention to enough in time & money but very crucial to women’s health. While I take this particular article with a boulder of salt, the idea that we should throw the baby out with the bath water & only look to a group that doesn’t proportionately research our health is dangerous….I welcome more voices in relation to women’s health then the doctors & researchers of the past- with healthy skepticism but I won’t throw it out.

    • MrsBadBob says:

      Come on, this does not help women, or anyone, at all. We do not need misinformation being spread by this delusional twit and her latest grifter prodigy. She has this amazing platform and she could do something incredible, like bring attention to the under-serviced needs of women, but no, she peddles this nonsense. It’s gross, and she’s a self-interested spoiled brat.

      • MC2 says:

        That’s great for you to say that you don’t find it helpful. That’s fine but some do & many people are finding themselves looking for more then our very limited western medicine is giving us….and less everyday. I don’t care about Goop or this particular article although I do think iodine & the thyroid should be researched more. But this automatic slap back that women should only rely on western doctors or else it’s total trash is not helpful. Supplements & looking at our diet and what we may lack and then how that influences our health is not rubbish. Kosher salt has decreased our daily iodine in certain areas or groups which could affect our thyroid so while this particular article might be crap or you hate the messenger, don’t throw out the baby with the bathwater. Or do it for you but don’t tell others they are dead wrong. This deserves a roll of our eyes but saying that all non-western medicine and supplements are crap is silly & unfounded.

      • AnneC says:

        So many low income women can’t and do not get basic medical services that most of the women on this site take for granted. Planned Parenthood, which helps millions of low income women get Pap smears, breast exams, pre and post natal care, is being used by the GOP to placate its religious right base. Write about that GOOP, not expensive self indulgent pseudo science “wellness”.

      • MC2 says:

        AnneC- I totally agree. It would be nice for her to cover more then just issues geared towards her small base (which this article covered well) and what would be good for more women but it is Goop so…..I also wish the public knew more about the history of western medicine, women’s health & demanded more.

        I don’t think an article (even if it’s from a “whisperer) about looking at possibly taking iodine & it’s correlation to women’s health is a bad thing on Goop- which does anyone take as science!? We are seeing a resurgence in certain deficiencies these days so I think an article on a lifestyle website about it is harmless. Shrug- I was more concerned at the comments saying “down with any medicine that’s not western & given to you by a doctor!” then anything that Goop covered in her sudo-science article.

        Many women today, and have throughout history, relied on other organizations for their health then western doctors & their profits. If we lose that (PP, etc) then we are screwed.

  16. poppy says:

    i take all my health advice from my gwynecologist, dr goop.
    🙄

  17. Bread and Circuses says:

    Iodine is also really hard on your stomach. DON’T take it just for the hell of it, and DO tell your doctor if you are taking it. This stuff can hurt you. (It can also help some people – my mom’s one of them – but make sure you have a conversation about it with your doctor. They should suggest your maximum dosage.)

  18. Ilana says:

    The third leading cause of death in the United States after Cancer and Heart disease is Medical mistakes in hospitals. The research shows up to 440,000 people die each year being treated even in the best Hospitals in the U.S..

  19. Sam says:

    To be fair, Gwyneth probably does not eat salt, dairy, eggs, meat, or generally food. So she probably needs lots of iodine supplements to survive.